Debian Codegraph @

docs/source/saxs/saxs_mw.rst

raw
1 Molecular weight calculation
2 ------------------------------
3 .. _saxs_mw:
4
5 This tutorial covers basic principles and best practices for calculating
6 molecular weight from SAXS data. This is not a tutorial on how to use RAW
7 for this type of analysis. For that, please see the :ref:`RAW tutorial <raw_mw>`.
8
9
10 Overview
11 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
12
13 There are a number of ways to calculate molecular weight from SAXS data. RAW
14 supports four of the most common methods natively:
15
16 #. Molecular weight from absolute scaled I(0) [1].
17 #. Molecular weight by comparing to a reference standard [1].
18 #. Molecular weight from the Porod volume [2].
19 #. Molecular weight from the volume of correlation [3].
20
21 There are two additional methods supported in the ATSAS software, which RAW
22 will show if ATSAS is installed:
23
24 #. Molecular weight estimation by comparison of scattering to known structures [4].
25 #. Molecular weight calculation by Bayesian inference from the other molecular
26 weight methods [5].
27
28 All of these methods have advantages and disadvantages, and which to use and
29 trust depends to a certain extent on the details of your data. Regardless,
30 calculating molecular weight is important to verify the oligomeric state
31 of your sample.
32
33
34 Why do we do calculate molecular weight?
35 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
36
37 SAXS molecular weight calculations are not terribly accurate, a usual rule of thumb
38 is ~10% uncertainty (or more). For this reasons, SAXS should not be used to
39 determine the molecular weight of your sample, something like multi-angle
40 light scattering (MALS) is going to be much more accurate. The main reason
41 to calculate molecular weight from SAXS data is to determine the oligomeric
42 state of the protein in solution. Particularly if you're studying a system
43 that can form homodimers or higher order oligomers, the SAXS molecular
44 weight calculations should be accurate enough to tell what oligomeric state
45 you're measuring. For this reason, the molecular weight is an important diagnostic
46 for verifying that what you think is in solution is actually what's in solution.
47
48
49 How do we do calculate molecular weight?
50 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
51
52 Because there are so many methods for calculating molecular weight from SAXS data,
53 we will only present a short summary of the methods listed above here.
54 Generally speaking the methods can be broken up into two categories:
55 concentration dependent and concentration independent. The concentration
56 dependent methods require knowing the concentration of the sample in the SAXS cell,
57 which often means they are incompatible with SEC-SAXS measurements. The concentration
58 independent methods do not require knowledge of the concentration, and so are
59 useful for SEC-SAXS measurements.
60
61 Molecular weight from absolute scaled I(0)
62 ********************************************
63
64 SAXS data is often put on an absolute scale, so that the intensity values have
65 units (by convention of cm\ :sup:`-1` ). This means that the I(0) value can be
66 directly related to the number of electrons in the sample and the concentration
67 and contrast of the sample [6]. If the concentration and contrast of the sample
68 is known, the total number of electrons can be calculated, and then that can be
69 used to determine the molecular weight of the sample. The accuracy of this
70 approach can be improved by measuring or calculating (for example, using `MULCh
71 <http://smb-research.smb.usyd.edu.au/NCVWeb/>`_) the protein partial specific
72 volume. If necessary, adjusting the electron densities of the sample and buffer
73 will also improve the accuracy. Molecular weight is calculated as:
74
75 .. math::
76
77 MW = \left(\frac{N_A I(0)}{c \Delta \rho^2_M}\right)
78
79 where *MW* is the molecular weight, *c* is the concentration, :math:`N_A`
80 is Avagadro's constant, and :math:`\Delta \rho_M` is the scattering contrast
81 per mass.
82
83 The accuracy of this method was assessed in [1] where they found it to be <~10%
84 for most proteins.
85
86 Molecular weight by comparing to a reference standard
87 ********************************************************
88
89 The scattering at zero angle, I(0) is proportional to the molecular weight of
90 the macromolecule, and the concentration and contrast of the macromolecule in
91 solution. If a reference sample of known molecular weight and concentration is
92 measured, it can be used to calibrate the molecular weight of any other
93 scattering profile with known concentration (assuming constant contrast between
94 reference and sample, and a monodisperse sample) [1]. Molecular weight is
95 calculated as:
96
97 .. math::
98
99 MW_m = \left(\frac{I(0)_m}{c_m}\right)\left(\frac{MM_{st}}{\left(\tfrac{I(0)_{st}}{c_{st}}\right)}\right)
100
101 where *MW* is the molecular weight, *c* is the concentration, and the subscripts
102 *m* and *st* designate quantities from the macromolecule of interest and the standard
103 respectively.
104
105 Molecular weight from Porod volume
106 ****************************************
107
108 The Porod volume is nominally the excluded volume of the macromolecule in
109 solution. It can be calculated directly from the scattering profile, first
110 by calculating the Porod invariant:
111
112 .. math::
113
114 Q_p = \int^\infty_0 q^2 I(q) dq
115
116 where :math:`Q_p` is the Porod invariant. The Porod volume is then calculated as:
117
118 .. math::
119
120 V_p = \frac{2\pi^2 I(0)}{Q_p}
121
122 where *I(0)* is the scattering at zero angle. Once this volume is determined,
123 the molecular weight is determined by simply multiplying by the macromolecule's
124 density.
125
126 Because :math:`Q_p` is determined by an integral from 0 to :math:`\infty`, the actual
127 integration must be approximated in some way. There are various approaches, including
128 the the 'Porod' and 'Qp' methods implemented in the ATSAS datmw program. RAW
129 uses the SAXSMoW 2 approach described in [2], which applies a correction factor
130 to the Porod volume based on the available range of data in the scattering profile.
131 Then an average protein density is used to calculate the molecular weight.
132 The accuracy of this method can be improved if a more accurate density
133 for the macromolecule is known.
134
135 In [2] they found a median uncertain of 12% for calculated molecular weight
136 from globular proteins. By contrast, in [5] they found using a large test set
137 of simulated curves that the median molecular weight of this method was 3% high,
138 and the median absolute deviation from this method was 5%. The uncertainty was higher
139 for data with simulated noise. It seems reasonable to say the uncertainty in
140 molecular weight is ~10% for most systems, though there are outliers.
141
142 Molecular weight from volume of correlation
143 **************************************************
144
145 In [3] they defined the volume of correlation as
146
147 .. math::
148
149 V_c = \frac{I(0)}{\int_0^{\infty}qI(q)dq}
150
151 They empirically found the ratio :math:`V_c^2/R_g` is logarithmically
152 proportional to molecular weight, with the following formula:
153
154 .. math::
155
156 MW = \left(\frac{V_c^2/R_g}{c}\right)^k
157
158 where *c* and *k* are empirically determined constants via fitting results from
159 theoretical scattering profiles. They found different constants for proteins
160 and RNA. For proteins, :math:`c=0.1231` and :math:`k=1` while for RNA
161 :math:`c=0.00934` and :math:`k=0.808` (note: *c* and *k* are defined slightly
162 differently in the original paper).
163
164 In [3] they found a molecular weight uncertainty of ~5% from theoretical
165 profiles and ~10% from experimental profiles. By contrast, in [5] they found
166 using a large test set of simulated curves that the median molecular weight
167 of this method was 2% low, and the median absolute deviation from this method was 7%.
168 The uncertainty was higher for data with simulated noise. It seems reasonable to say
169 the uncertainty in molecular weight from this is ~10% for most systems, though there are outliers.
170
171 Molecular weight by comparison to known structures
172 *****************************************************
173
174 In [4] they describe a machine learning method that categorizes SAXS data into
175 shape categories based on comparison with a catalog of known structures from the PDB.
176 By finding the nearest structures in shape and size (also the name of the method:
177 Shape&Size), they can obtain estimates for the molecular weight of the sample.
178
179 In [4] they found that, for the theoretical scattering profiles used for testing,
180 the method calculated molecular weights within 10% of the expected value for 90%
181 test data. In [5] they found that for the test dataset the median molecular
182 weight was correct and the median absolute deviation was 4%. Again, it seems
183 reasonable to say that the uncertainty in molecular weight from this method is
184 ~10% for most systems, though there are outliers.
185
186 Molecular weight from Bayesian inference
187 *******************************************
188 In [5] they describe a method for calculating a molecular weight using Bayesian
189 inference with the molecular weight calculations from the Porod volume, volume of
190 correlation, and comparison to known structures methods as the evidence.
191 Essentially, it takes a large test dataset of theoretical scattering profiles,
192 calculates the molecular weight for each using each method, then creates a
193 probability distribution for each method that describes the probability of obtaining
194 a particular calculated molecular weight given the true molecular weight. These
195 probabilities are combined across all the methods, and the most likely molecular
196 weight is thus estimated.
197
198 They found that for the theoretical scattering profiles used, the median molecular
199 weight from this method was accurate and the median absolute deviation was 4%.
200 Overall, they reported that it was more accurate than any individual method.
201 It may be that the uncertainty in this method is usually closer to ~5% than 10%
202 for the other methods.
203
204 What are the strengths and weaknesses of different MW methods?
205 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
206
207 Each method has distinct strengths and weaknesses, and tend to be better with
208 certain types of data. Every method requires a good determination of I(0),
209 and all of the concentration independent methods require R\ :sub:`g`, which generally
210 means a good Guinier fit is required in all cases. Also, in [5] it is reported that
211 all of the concentration independent methods struggle with flat and ring-shaped
212 proteins.
213
214 Molecular weight from absolute scaled I(0)
215 ********************************************
216
217 **Advantages:**
218
219 * Can be highly accurate when all parameters are well known.
220 * With correct parameters can be used for proteins or RNA/DNA.
221
222 **Disadvantages:**
223
224 * Requires accurate sample concentration.
225 * Requires accurate absolute calibration.
226 * Best when the scattering contrast of the macromolecule is well known.
227 * Best when partial specific volume is well known.
228
229 Molecular weight by comparing to a reference standard
230 ********************************************************
231
232 **Advantages:**
233
234 * Can be highly accurate for similar standards and samples under the same conditions.
235 * With correct standards can be used for proteins or RNA/DNA.
236
237 **Disadvantages:**
238
239 * Requires accurate sample concentration.
240 * The reference standard should have the same scattering contrast as the sample
241 (i.e.. is in a similar buffer).
242 * The standard and sample should be similar shapes (i.e. the same partial specific
243 volume).
244
245
246 Molecular weight from Porod volume
247 ****************************************
248
249 Particular to the MoW method described in [2].
250
251 **Advantages:**
252
253 * Accurate for most molecule shapes [5].
254 * More accurate than the volume of correlation method when the signal to noise
255 level of the data is reasonable [5].
256
257 **Disadvantages:**
258
259 * Should struggle when the macromolecule is flexible or extended in solution
260 (though [5] found this was not always the case).
261 * May need to have the protein density adjusted in some cases (default: 0.83
262 kDa/\ :sup:`3`)
263 * Will fail if the macromolecule is not a protein.
264 * Sensitive to subtraction errors.
265
266 Molecular weight from volume of correlation
267 **************************************************
268
269 **Advantages:**
270
271 * More accurate than other methods when signal to noise is low [5].
272 * More accurate than other methods when there are subtraction errors [5].
273 * Should be accurate for flexible or extended extended macromolecules [3]
274 (though [5] found that was not always the case).
275 * Works for both proteins and RNA/DNA.
276
277 **Disadvantages:**
278
279 * Less accurate than other methods for high signal to noise data [5].
280 * Less accurate than the Porod volume MoW method for extended macromolecules [5].
281 * Large uncertainty for macromolecules less than ~15-20 kDa (based on experience,
282 and the fact that the empirical coefficients were generated from size ranges
283 20 kDa and larger).
284 * Doesn't work for protein nucleic acid complexes.
285 * The integral of *qI(q)* needs to have converged (see figure below).
286
287 .. figure:: images/vc_convergence.png
288 :target: ../_images/vc_convergence.png
289 :width: 600 px
290
291 Both plots show the integral of *qI(q)* as a function of *q*. The plot on
292 the left shows data where the integrated value has converged, i.e. it is essentially
293 unchanging at high q as q increases. The plot on the right shows data where
294 the integrated value has not converged, i.e. it is increasing at high q
295 as q increases. The data on the right will not give an accurate molecular weight
296 by the volume of correlation method.
297
298 Molecular weight by comparison to known structures
299 *****************************************************
300
301 **Advantages:**
302
303 * Most accurate individual concentration independent method except
304 for low signal to noise data [5].
305 * Relatively accurate when there are subtraction errors.
306
307 **Disadvantages:**
308
309 * Provides no result for flexible systems.
310 * Only works for proteins.
311
312 Molecular weight from Bayesian inference
313 *******************************************
314
315 **Advantages:**
316
317 * More accurate than individual concentration independent methods in most
318 cases [5].
319
320 **Disadvantages:**
321
322 * Struggles with significant subtraction errors.
323 * Only works for proteins.
324
325 FAQ
326 ^^^^^^^^
327
328 I don't get the expected molecular weight from my SAXS data, what do I do?
329 *****************************************************************************
330
331 Molecular weight from good SAXS data has relatively large uncertainties (often
332 ~10%), and for low signal to noise data can be significantly worse. What you
333 need to do in the case where it's wrong depends on what you're trying to determine.
334
335 If you know your sample is stable in solution (not prone to aggregation/degradation),
336 or you have evidence it was all in one state (such as elution in a single sharp
337 peak in a SEC-SAXS experiment), if your MW is a bit off that's okay. In this
338 case you're just trying to determine the oligomeric state of the sample. If you
339 can clearly make the distinction, then you're fine. If not, you need to measure
340 the molecular weight with a different method.
341
342 If your sample is unstable in solution (prone to aggregation/degradation),
343 you need to measure the molecular weight of your sample with another method.
344 Good methods include multi-angle light scattering (MALS) or analytical
345 ultra centrifugation (AUC). The best approach is to do a SEC-MALS-SAXS experiment,
346 where MALS data is collected on the same elution as the SAXS data, removing any
347 question about changes in the sample between the MALS and SAXS measurements.
348
349
350 I need to determine if *<small molecule>* is bound to *<big molecule>*. Or I want to determine the binding stoichiometry. Can I do that with SAXS?
351 *******************************************************************************************************************************************************
352
353 It depends to a certain extent on the relative sizes of your molecules. However,
354 if you have something that's small, say ~20 kDa, and something much larger, say
355 ~250 kDa, SAXS data is unlikely to be reliable enough to accurately determine the difference
356 between bound and unbound (250 kDa or 270 kDa), or between 1:1 and 2:1 binding
357 (270 kDa or 290 kDa). In this case you should pursue additional characterization
358 of the molecular weight. The best approach is to do a SEC-MALS-SAXS experiment,
359 where MALS data is collected on the same elution as the SAXS data.
360
361 References
362 ^^^^^^^^^^^^
363
364 1. Mylonas, E. & Svergun, D. I. (2007). J. Appl. Crystallogr. 40, s245–s249.
365 DOI: `10.1107/S002188980700252X <https://doi.org/10.1107/S002188980700252X>`_
366
367 2. Piiadov, V., de Araújo, E. A., Oliveira Neto, M., Craievich, A. F. &
368 Polikarpov, I. (2018). Protein Sci. 2–22. DOI: `10.1002/pro.3528
369 <https://doi.org/10.1002/pro.3528>`_
370
371 3. Rambo, R. P. & Tainer, J. A. (2013). Nature. 496, 477–481. DOI:
372 `10.1038/nature12070 <https://doi.org/10.1038/nature12070>`_
373
374 4. Franke, D., Jeffries, C. M. & Svergun, D. I. (2018). Biophys. J. 114,
375 2485–2492. DOI: `10.1016/j.bpj.2018.04.018
376 <https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bpj.2018.04.018>`_
377
378 5. Hajizadeh, N. R., Franke, D., Jeffries, C. M. & Svergun, D. I. (2018).
379 Sci. Rep. 8, 7204. DOI: `10.1038/s41598-018-25355-2
380 <https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-25355-2>`_
381
382 6. Orthaber, D., Bergmann, A. & Glatter, O. (2000). J. Appl. Crystallogr.
383 33, 218–225. DOI: `10.1107/S0021889899015216
384 <https://doi.org/10.1107/S0021889899015216>`_
385
386 .. |Rg| replace:: R\ :sub:`g`
387
388 .. |qRg| replace:: qR\ :sub:`g`
389