Debian Codegraph @

texmf-dist/doc/latex/seminar/semsamp2.tex

raw
1 %%
2 %% This file may be distributed and/or modified under the conditions of
3 %% the LaTeX Project Public License, either version 1.2 of this license
4 %% or (at your option) any later version. The latest version of this
5 %% license is in:
6 %%
7 %% http://www.latex-project.org/lppl.txt
8 %%
9 %% and version 1.2 or later is part of all distributions of LaTeX version
10 %% 1999/12/01 or later.
11 %%
12
13 %% BEGIN semsamp2.tex
14 % This is a sample document for seminar.sty, v0.93 (and maybe later).
15 %
16 % This file contains both landscape and portrait mode slides.
17 % Choose one of the following to print them out:
18 % - If using PSTricks, try the semcolor style option.
19 % - If using Rokicki's dvips, try the semrot style option.
20 % - To print the landscape slides, put \landscapeonly in the preamble.
21 % To print the portrait slides, include the portrait style option and
22 % put \portraitonly in the preamble.
23 %
24 %
25 \documentclass[%
26 slidesonly,% Try notes or notesonly instead.
27 %notes,% Use instead of slidesonly to typeset the notes.
28 %notesonly,% Use instead of slidesonly to typeset notes and slides.
29 semcolor,% Try me if using PSTricks.
30 semrot,% Try me if using Rokicki's dvips.
31 %semhelv,% Try me if using a PostScript printer.
32 %article,% Try me.
33 %portrait,% Try me.
34 %sem-a4,% Try me if using A4 paper.
35 semlayer% This must be included, but you need the semcolor option to
36 ]{seminar} % actually see the overlays.
37
38 \slidesmag{5}
39 \articlemag{1}
40
41 %\twoup % Try me for twoup printing.
42
43 %\portraitonly % To print only portrait slides
44 %\landscapeonly % To print only landscape slides
45
46 %\notslides{\ref{questions}-7,1} %Try me: The slides are omitted.
47 %\onlyslides{\ref{questions}-7,1} %Try me: Only these slides are included.
48 %\onlynotestoo %Try me: For selecting notes as well.
49
50 %\colorlayers{red,blue} % Try deleting this if using the semcolor option,
51 % to get \blue and \red to use PostScript color.
52
53 %\overlaysfalse % Suppress overlays with semcolor option.
54 %\layersfalse % Suppress color layers with semcolor option.
55
56 \rotateheaderstrue % Try this out if using rotation macros.
57
58
59 \title{Example for seminar.sty}
60 \author{Policarpa Salabarrieta}
61 \date{July 21, 1991}
62
63 \newcommand\sref[1]{SLIDE \ref{#1}}
64 \newcommand\heading[1]{\begin{center}\large\bf #1\end{center}}
65
66 \newpagestyle{MH}%
67 {University of Guaduas, March 13, 1998\hfil\thepage}{}
68 \pagestyle{MH}
69
70 \begin{document}
71
72 \maketitle % This won't show up when \onlynotestoo is in effect.
73
74 \begin{slide}
75 \ifslidesonly % Title slide only for slidesonly selection.
76 \maketitle
77 \addtocounter{slide}{-1}
78 \slidepagestyle{empty}
79 \fi
80 \end{slide}
81
82 This is a lot of gobbledy-gook intended only to illustrate some of the
83 features of seminar.sty.
84
85 The phrase information overload rings a bell with just about anyone.
86 Certainly you all receive more working papers or more applications for
87 graduate school than you can readily read. Nevertheless, the term information
88 overload is ill-defined. (\sref{too_much}, top)
89
90 A message like this when you check your email conjures up the notion of
91 information overload. More generally, information overload always means too
92 much information, in some sense or another. But what does ``too much'' mean?
93 (\sref{too_much}, bottom) It might just mean that people cannot process all
94 the information they receive. That is certainly true for everyone. A claim
95 that is much stronger, and that is implicit when people complain about
96 informaton overload, is that people {\em should} receive less information, by
97 some criterion.
98
99 \begin{slide}\label{too_much}%
100 \begin{center}
101 \large\bf
102 Information overload = ``Too much'' information
103 \end{center}
104 \smallskip
105
106 \begin{verse} \bf\tt
107 You have 134 unread messages:\\
108 Do you want to read them now?
109 \end{verse}
110
111 \begin{enumerate}
112 {\overlay2
113 \item People {\overlay1 cannot process all} the information they receive.}
114 \item People {\em should} receive less information.
115 \end{enumerate}
116 \end{slide}
117
118 In this paper, I use the term ``information overload'' in both senses.
119 (\sref{overload}, bottom). Specifically, I say that an {\em individual} is
120 overloaded with information if she receives more information than she can
121 process. But I say that there is information overload in a {\em network} if
122 there is some mechanism that makes the senders and/or receivers better off by
123 restricting the flow of information. This latter notion of information
124 overload is an equilibrium property, and it depends on what we mean by
125 ``better off.''
126
127 \begin{slide*}\label{overload}
128 \ptsize{12}
129
130 \begin{itemize}{\overlay1
131 \item There is information {\overlay0 overload in a network if} there is
132 some mechanism that, compared to the {\em status quo}, makes the senders
133 and/or receivers better off by restricting the flow} of information.'
134
135 \item There is information overload in a network if there is some mechanism
136 that, compared to the {\em status quo}, makes the senders and/or receivers
137 better off by restricting the flow of information.
138 \end{itemize}
139
140 \end{slide*}
141
142 (\sref{questions})
143 The purpose of my paper is to show why there can be information overload in
144 a network and what kind of mechanisms can make the receivers and/or senders
145 better off. Since the cost of communication is one factor that restricts
146 communication, I am thus also going to look at how the welfare of the senders
147 and receivers depends on the cost of communication.
148
149 Most messages don't become jumbled and we can choose which ones to process.
150 But some of us may have a bias towards choosing to process more information
151 than we should, like the graduate student who feels compelled to read every
152 article on the usual lengthy reading list, and just ends up getting confused
153 and ruffling through the papers.
154
155
156 \begin{slide}[7.3in,5.5in] \label{questions}
157 \heading{Questions}
158
159 \begin{itemize}
160 {\overlay1 \item When could {\blue there be overload} in networks?}
161 \item What mechanims make the receivers and senders better off?
162 \item How does the welfare {\red of the senders} and receivers depend on the
163 cost of communication?
164 \end{itemize}
165 \end{slide}
166
167
168 However, experiments in consumer research and psychology have failed to find
169 that such a bias is prevalent. This is in spite of the fact that it is common
170 for stress and cognitive strain to increase with information load. We may
171 incur such stress and strain because the information we choose to process is
172 valuable to us.
173
174 More commonly, then, we can and do choose to process roughly as much
175 information as we can handle efficiently. This is called screening. But when
176 we choose which messages to begin to process, we're ignorant of their
177 contents, since otherwise there would be no reason to process them in the
178 first place. Therefore, if we receive more junk mail, then some of the
179 important mail gets crowded out, and we are effectively less informed.
180
181 \begin{slide} \label{informed}
182 \begin{center}
183 {\bf Being more informed} \par
184 \smallskip
185 is always better,\par
186 \medskip
187 \overlay1{but it's not the same as \par
188 \smallskip
189 {\bf receiving more information}}
190 \end{center}
191 \end{slide}
192
193 Why would the senders communicate too many messages in the first place? If I
194 present too much material in this seminar, you have to choose which parts to
195 ignore and I would rather make that decision myself, since I know what I most
196 want to get across. Thus, it is in my interest not to overload you with
197 information. Generally, whenever there is a single sender of messages, that
198 sender will prefer to screen rather than have the receiver screen, because the
199 sender has an interest in which messages the receiver processes.
200 But when there are more senders, one sender's messages tend to crowd out the
201 messages of the other senders, as in this example here. If the senders don't
202 take this external cost into account when sending messages, they may
203 collectively overload the receiver. (\sref{akbar})
204
205 There are several reasons that our scarcity of attention, that is, our limited
206 capacity to process information, can mean that we become less informed when we
207 receive more information. I have a cartoon here to illustrate these reasons.
208 (\sref{akbar})
209
210 \begin{slide}\label{akbar}\def\slidefuzz{15pt}
211 {\large A tax $\tau$ on communication is said to support
212 $\tilde{\cal{X}}(c)$ if $\tilde{\cal{X}}(c)$ is an equilibrium for
213 $\Gamma(c+\tau)$.}
214 \medskip
215
216 {\bf Proposition 6.} {\em Assume $\tilde{\cal{X}}(c)$ is not an equilibrium
217 for $\Gamma(c)$.\vspace{-3pt}
218 \begin{enumerate}
219 \item If $\mbox{supp}(\gamma)=[0,1]^n$, there is no tax that supports
220 $\tilde{\cal{X}}(c)$.
221 \item If $\mbox{supp}(\gamma)=S^{n-1}$, there is a tax that supports
222 $\tilde{\cal{X}}(c)$ if and only if $m=1$, $p_j>c\, \forall j$, and
223 \begin{enumerate}
224 \item $n=2$; or
225 \item $n=3$ and $p_i^{-1}+p_j^{-1}\geq p_k^{-1}$ for all distinct
226 $i,j,k$; or
227 \item $n=4$ and $p_1=p_2=p_3=p_4$.
228 \end{enumerate}
229 \end{enumerate}}
230 \end{slide}
231
232 If, by restricting communication, we eliminate the less relevant messages,
233 then we can become more informed. But how can we achieve this? Restricting the
234 flow of information shifts the task of screening messages from the receivers
235 to the senders. Unlike the receivers, the senders do know the contents of the
236 messages they originate. If the senders' interests coincide with those of the
237 receiver and if the senders have sufficient knowledge about the receivers,
238 then the senders will choose the messages which are most relevant to the
239 receivers. This may make the receivers, and even the senders, better off.
240
241 The network in Slide \ref{architectures} attains the minimal delay $c(8,24)
242 = 6$ using 8 processors. It is an example of the efficient one-shot networks
243 described by Foo. We will focus on a class of networks that are similar to the
244 Foo networks but that may differ slightly. For $q$, $c$ and $n$ such that $1
245 \leq q \leq \lfloor n/2 \rfloor$ and $c(q,n) \leq c \leq n$, let $R_{nqc}$ be
246 the class of essential networks for adding $n$ items using $q$ processors in
247 $c$ cycles that have the following properties:
248
249 \begin{slide*}\label{architectures}
250 \heading{Architecture}
251
252 \begin{center}
253 \setlength{\unitlength}{1.65in}
254 \begin{picture}(1.1,1.6)(3.5,5.0)
255 \put(4.0,6.5){\circle*{.04}}
256 \put(4.1,6.5){1}
257 \put(4.0,6.0){\circle*{.04}}
258 \put(4.1,6.0){2}
259 \put(4.0,6.1){\vector(0,1){.3}}
260 \put(3.5,6.0){\circle*{.04}}
261 \put(3.6,6.0){3}
262 \put(3.6,6.1){\vector(1,1){.3}}
263 \put(4.0,5.5){\circle*{.04}}
264 \put(4.1,5.5){4}
265 \put(4.0,5.6){\vector(0,1){.3}}
266 \put(4.5,6.0){\circle*{.04}}
267 \put(4.6,6.0){5}
268 \put(4.4,6.1){\vector(-1,1){.3}}
269 \put(4.5,5.5){\circle*{.04}}
270 \put(4.6,5.5){6}
271 \put(4.4,5.6){\vector(-1,1){.3}}
272 \put(3.5,5.5){\circle*{.04}}
273 \put(3.6,5.5){7}
274 \put(3.5,5.6){\vector(0,1){.3}}
275 \put(4.0,5.0){\circle*{.04}}
276 \put(4.1,5.0){8}
277 \put(4.0,5.1){\vector(0,1){.3}}
278 \end{picture}
279 \end{center}
280 \end{slide*}
281
282 Why would the senders communicate too many messages in the first place? If I
283 present too much material in this seminar, you have to choose which parts to
284 ignore and I would rather make that decision myself, since I know what I most
285 want to get across. Thus, it is in my interest not to overload you with
286 information.
287
288 Generally, whenever there is a single sender of messages, that sender will
289 prefer to screen rather than have the receiver screen, because the sender has
290 an interest in which messages the receiver processes. But when there are more
291 senders, one sender's messages tend to crowd out the messages of the other
292 senders, as in this example here. If the senders don't take this external cost
293 into account when sending messages, they may collectively overload the
294 receiver. (\sref{architectures})
295
296 \end{document}
297 %% END semsamp2.tex