| 1 |
% \iffalse meta-comment |
| 2 |
% |
| 3 |
% Copyright (C) 2014 by Alan Davidson <[email protected]> |
| 4 |
% --------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| 5 |
% This work may be distributed and/or modified under the |
| 6 |
% conditions of the LaTeX Project Public License, either version 1.3 |
| 7 |
% of this license or (at your option) any later version. |
| 8 |
% The latest version of this license is in |
| 9 |
% http://www.latex-project.org/lppl.txt |
| 10 |
% and version 1.3 or later is part of all distributions of LaTeX |
| 11 |
% version 2005/12/01 or later. |
| 12 |
% |
| 13 |
% This work has the LPPL maintenance status `maintained'. |
| 14 |
% |
| 15 |
% The Current Maintainer of this work is Alan Davidson. |
| 16 |
% |
| 17 |
% This work consists of the files logicproof.dtx and logicproof.ins |
| 18 |
% and the derived filebase logicproof.sty. |
| 19 |
% |
| 20 |
% \fi |
| 21 |
% |
| 22 |
% \iffalse |
| 23 |
%<*driver> |
| 24 |
\ProvidesFile{logicproof.dtx} |
| 25 |
%</driver> |
| 26 |
%<package>\NeedsTeXFormat{LaTeX2e} |
| 27 |
%<package>\ProvidesPackage{logicproof}[2014/03/20 v1.0 Box proofs for propositional logic] |
| 28 |
% |
| 29 |
%<*driver> |
| 30 |
\documentclass{ltxdoc} |
| 31 |
\usepackage{logicproof}[2014/03/20] |
| 32 |
\EnableCrossrefs |
| 33 |
\CodelineIndex |
| 34 |
\RecordChanges |
| 35 |
\begin{document} |
| 36 |
\DocInput{logicproof.dtx} |
| 37 |
\PrintChanges |
| 38 |
\PrintIndex |
| 39 |
\end{document} |
| 40 |
%</driver> |
| 41 |
% \fi |
| 42 |
% |
| 43 |
% \CheckSum{0} |
| 44 |
% |
| 45 |
% \CharacterTable |
| 46 |
% {Upper-case \A\B\C\D\E\F\G\H\I\J\K\L\M\N\O\P\Q\R\S\T\U\V\W\X\Y\Z |
| 47 |
% Lower-case \a\b\c\d\e\f\g\h\i\j\k\l\m\n\o\p\q\r\s\t\u\v\w\x\y\z |
| 48 |
% Digits \0\1\2\3\4\5\6\7\8\9 |
| 49 |
% Exclamation \! Double quote \" Hash (number) \# |
| 50 |
% Dollar \$ Percent \% Ampersand \& |
| 51 |
% Acute accent \' Left paren \( Right paren \) |
| 52 |
% Asterisk \* Plus \+ Comma \, |
| 53 |
% Minus \- Point \. Solidus \/ |
| 54 |
% Colon \: Semicolon \; Less than \< |
| 55 |
% Equals \= Greater than \> Question mark \? |
| 56 |
% Commercial at \@ Left bracket \[ Backslash \\ |
| 57 |
% Right bracket \] Circumflex \^ Underscore \_ |
| 58 |
% Grave accent \` Left brace \{ Vertical bar \| |
| 59 |
% Right brace \} Tilde \~} |
| 60 |
% |
| 61 |
% |
| 62 |
% \changes{1.0}{2014/03/20}{First version for public release} |
| 63 |
% \changes{0.1}{2004/12/05}{Initial version created} |
| 64 |
% \GetFileInfo{logicproof.dtx} |
| 65 |
% |
| 66 |
% \DoNotIndex{\newcommand,\newenvironment} |
| 67 |
% |
| 68 |
% \providecommand*{\url}{\texttt} |
| 69 |
% \title{The \textsf{logicproof} package} |
| 70 |
% \author{Alan Davidson \\ \url{[email protected]}} |
| 71 |
% \date{20 March 2014} |
| 72 |
% |
| 73 |
% \maketitle |
| 74 |
% |
| 75 |
% \section{Introduction} |
| 76 |
% |
| 77 |
% This package provides support for Fitch-style box proofs, intended to be used |
| 78 |
% for proofs in propositional logic and predicate logic. In this proof style, |
| 79 |
% each statement of the proof is accompanied by a justification, and subproofs |
| 80 |
% or lemmata within a larger proof are enclosed in boxes to separate them from |
| 81 |
% the rest of the proof. |
| 82 |
% |
| 83 |
% \section{Usage} |
| 84 |
% |
| 85 |
% \DescribeEnv{logicproof} |
| 86 |
% The |logicproof| environment takes a single argument, which should be a |
| 87 |
% nonnegative integer describing the maximum number of nested subproofs that |
| 88 |
% this proof will contain. Each line of the proof consists of two main |
| 89 |
% columns: the proof statement of the current line, followed by an ampersand |
| 90 |
% (|&|), followed by the justification for the statement. |
| 91 |
% Lines should be separated from each other by a |\\|. |
| 92 |
% The column of proof statements defaults to |
| 93 |
% math mode, while the justification column defaults to normal text. |
| 94 |
% |
| 95 |
% If you add a |\label| within a proof, the corresponding |\ref| will be the |
| 96 |
% current line number. |
| 97 |
% |
| 98 |
% \DescribeEnv{subproof} |
| 99 |
% Within these logic proofs, it is often necessary to make subproofs which begin |
| 100 |
% by making some sort of assumption that does not necessarily hold in the |
| 101 |
% broader proof. To delineate the scope of these assumptions, use the |subproof| |
| 102 |
% environment, which will draw a box around the statements of the proof for |
| 103 |
% which these assumptions should hold. Subproofs can be nested within each |
| 104 |
% other, up to the maximum level provided as an argument to the |logicproof| |
| 105 |
% environment. |
| 106 |
% |
| 107 |
% Within a subproof, the format of each line is exactly the same as in the |
| 108 |
% |logicproof| environment: a proof statement, followed by an ampersand (|&|), |
| 109 |
% followed by a justification for the statement, with |\\| at the end of every |
| 110 |
% line except the last one (which instead ends with |\end{subproof}|). |
| 111 |
% |
| 112 |
% If a statement has an empty justification, it is still important to put in the |
| 113 |
% |&| to separate out the column in which the justification would go, or else |
| 114 |
% the right sides of the subproof boxes will be misaligned for this statement. |
| 115 |
% |
| 116 |
% The previous line before a subproof begins should end in either |\\| or |
| 117 |
% |\end{subproof}|. |
| 118 |
% |
| 119 |
% A warning for advanced \LaTeX~users: although most environments make their own |
| 120 |
% groups (such that changes made within an environment go out of scope at the |
| 121 |
% end of it), the |subproof| environment does not! Any changes made within a |
| 122 |
% |subproof| |
| 123 |
% environment will not go out of scope until the enclosing |logicproof| |
| 124 |
% environment ends. This was done because groups cannot cross alignment tabs, |
| 125 |
% but the |subproof| environment needs to use the same alignment as the |
| 126 |
% enclosing |logicproof| environment does (or else they won't line up together). |
| 127 |
% An inconvenient side effect of this is that when you forget to put in a |
| 128 |
% |\end{subproof}|, the error message about mismatched environments points to |
| 129 |
% the line number where the enclosing |logicproof| environment started, rather |
| 130 |
% than the offending |subproof| environment. |
| 131 |
% |
| 132 |
% \section{Example} |
| 133 |
% |
| 134 |
% This example proves the validity of the sequent |
| 135 |
% $(p\lor q)\lor r\vdash p\lor (q\lor r)$. There are many different styles that |
| 136 |
% can be used for the justification of each step; we are using the style found |
| 137 |
% in \emph{Logic in Computer Science: Modelling and Reasoning about Systems} by |
| 138 |
% Huth and Ryan. |
| 139 |
% |
| 140 |
%\begin{verbatim} |
| 141 |
%\begin{logicproof}{2} |
| 142 |
% (p\lor q)\lor r & premise\\ |
| 143 |
% \begin{subproof} |
| 144 |
% (p\lor q) & assumption\\ |
| 145 |
% \begin{subproof} |
| 146 |
% p & assumption\\ |
| 147 |
% p\lor (q\lor r) & $\lor\mathrm{i}_1$, 3 |
| 148 |
% \end{subproof} |
| 149 |
% \begin{subproof} |
| 150 |
% q & assumption\\ |
| 151 |
% q\lor r & $\lor\mathrm{i}_1$, 5\\ |
| 152 |
% p\lor (q\lor r) & $\lor\mathrm{i}_2$, 6 |
| 153 |
% \end{subproof} |
| 154 |
% p\lor (q\lor r) & $\lor$e, 2, 3--4, 5--7 |
| 155 |
% \end{subproof} |
| 156 |
% \begin{subproof} |
| 157 |
% r & assumption\\ |
| 158 |
% q\lor r & $\lor\mathrm{i}_2$, 9\\ |
| 159 |
% p\lor (q\lor r) & $\lor\mathrm{i}_2$, 10 |
| 160 |
% \end{subproof} |
| 161 |
% p\lor (q\lor r) & $\lor$e, 1, 2--8, 9--11 |
| 162 |
%\end{logicproof} |
| 163 |
%\end{verbatim} |
| 164 |
% This compiles into the following: |
| 165 |
%\begin{logicproof}{2} |
| 166 |
% (p\lor q)\lor r & premise\\ |
| 167 |
% \begin{subproof} |
| 168 |
% (p\lor q) & assumption\\ |
| 169 |
% \begin{subproof} |
| 170 |
% p & assumption\\ |
| 171 |
% p\lor (q\lor r) & $\lor\mathrm{i}_1$, 3 |
| 172 |
% \end{subproof} |
| 173 |
% \begin{subproof} |
| 174 |
% q & assumption\\ |
| 175 |
% q\lor r & $\lor\mathrm{i}_1$, 5\\ |
| 176 |
% p\lor (q\lor r) & $\lor\mathrm{i}_2$, 6 |
| 177 |
% \end{subproof} |
| 178 |
% p\lor (q\lor r) & $\lor$e, 2, 3--4, 5--7 |
| 179 |
% \end{subproof} |
| 180 |
% \begin{subproof} |
| 181 |
% r & assumption\\ |
| 182 |
% q\lor r & $\lor\mathrm{i}_2$, 9\\ |
| 183 |
% p\lor (q\lor r) & $\lor\mathrm{i}_2$, 10 |
| 184 |
% \end{subproof} |
| 185 |
% p\lor (q\lor r) & $\lor$e, 1, 2--8, 9--11 |
| 186 |
%\end{logicproof} |
| 187 |
% |
| 188 |
% \section{Advanced Configuration} |
| 189 |
% |
| 190 |
% There are two lengths that can be configured manually if desired. |
| 191 |
% |
| 192 |
% \DescribeMacro{\subproofhorizspace} |
| 193 |
% The |
| 194 |
% horizontal distance between the sides of nested boxes is the length stored in |
| 195 |
% |\subproofhorizspace|. If you have many nested subproofs, it might be |
| 196 |
% desirable to make this space larger so that it is easier to distinguish |
| 197 |
% between them. |
| 198 |
% |
| 199 |
% \DescribeMacro{\intersubproofvertspace} |
| 200 |
% An extra vertical space of length |
| 201 |
% |\intersubproofvertspace| is added after each statement in the proof. The |
| 202 |
% intention here is to have this much space between consecutive subproofs. This |
| 203 |
% is to say, when one subproof ends |
| 204 |
% and the next subproof begins immediately, this is the distance between the |
| 205 |
% bottom edge of the ending subproof and the top edge of the beginning subproof. |
| 206 |
% This space is inserted after each line, however, so that the vertical spacing |
| 207 |
% between them is consistent regardless of whether subproofs are begun or ended. |
| 208 |
% If you want more compact proofs and you never use consecutive |
| 209 |
% subproofs, it might be useful to reduce or remove this extra space. |
| 210 |
% |
| 211 |
% \section{Constraints} |
| 212 |
% The environments in this package might not work properly if any of the |
| 213 |
% following constraints are violated. These should not be difficult burdens; |
| 214 |
% they are listed here mainly for completeness. |
| 215 |
% \begin{itemize} |
| 216 |
% \item Each proof and each subproof must be at least 1 statement long. |
| 217 |
% \item Each subproof must start with at least 1 statement before containing |
| 218 |
% another subproof inside itself. You should not have a subproof that |
| 219 |
% immediately begins with a nested subproof. |
| 220 |
% \item The end of each subproof must have at least 1 statement (or |
| 221 |
% a new subproof) following |
| 222 |
% it; a single proof statement cannot end multiple subproofs at once. |
| 223 |
% Consequently, the last |
| 224 |
% statement of the top-level proof must be outside of all subproofs. It is okay |
| 225 |
% to immediately start a new subproof after ending a previous subproof. |
| 226 |
% \end{itemize} |
| 227 |
% |
| 228 |
% \StopEventually{\PrintIndex\PrintChanges} |
| 229 |
% |
| 230 |
% \section{Summary of Implementation} |
| 231 |
% |
| 232 |
% The |logicproof| environment is built on the |tabular| environment. It has a |
| 233 |
% column for the line number, a column for each possible nested subproof, a |
| 234 |
% column for the statement, a column for the justification, and then a second |
| 235 |
% column for each possible nested subproof. |
| 236 |
% The columns corresponding to nested subproofs either contain a |\vline| if the |
| 237 |
% subproof is currently being used, or nothing if the subproof is not being |
| 238 |
% used. |
| 239 |
% When a subproof is begun or ended, a |\cline| is used to draw |
| 240 |
% horizontal lines between the columns corresponding to that subproof. In order |
| 241 |
% to prevent multiple |\cline|'s from overlapping when one subproof is ended and |
| 242 |
% another is immediately begun, each statement in the proof actually ends with |
| 243 |
% a negative vertical space backing up to the previous line, then a space down |
| 244 |
% |\intersubproofvertspace| and a redrawing of the subproof lines again to cover |
| 245 |
% the extra space. |
| 246 |
% |
| 247 |
% \section{Implementation} |
| 248 |
% |
| 249 |
% \iffalse |
| 250 |
%<*package> |
| 251 |
% \fi |
| 252 |
% |
| 253 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 254 |
\RequirePackage{array} |
| 255 |
\RequirePackage{ifthen} |
| 256 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 257 |
% \begin{macro}{\subproofhorizspace} |
| 258 |
% \begin{macro}{\intersubproofvertspace} |
| 259 |
% We allow the user to configure the horizontal and vertical distance between |
| 260 |
% the edges of the boxes. |
| 261 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 262 |
\newlength{\subproofhorizspace} |
| 263 |
\setlength{\subproofhorizspace}{0.5em} |
| 264 |
\newlength{\intersubproofvertspace} |
| 265 |
\setlength{\intersubproofvertspace}{0.333em} |
| 266 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 267 |
% \end{macro} |
| 268 |
% \end{macro} |
| 269 |
% We use a variety of counters to keep track of the state. |
| 270 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 271 |
\newcounter{lp@line}% Current line number on the proof |
| 272 |
\newcounter{lp@nested}% Number of nested subproofs we're currently in |
| 273 |
\newcounter{lp@total@nests}% Maximum number of nested subproofs allowed |
| 274 |
\newcounter{lp@cline@1}% Used to draw horizontal lines in subproofs |
| 275 |
\newcounter{lp@cline@2}% Also used to draw horizontal lines in subproofs |
| 276 |
\newcounter{lp@temp}% Temporary storage counter |
| 277 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 278 |
% |
| 279 |
% \begin{environment}{logicproof} |
| 280 |
% Use this to make a logic proof. The argument it takes is the |
| 281 |
% maximum number of nested subproofs you will use. |
| 282 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 283 |
\newenvironment{logicproof}[1]{% |
| 284 |
\setcounter{lp@line}{0}% |
| 285 |
\setcounter{lp@nested}{0}% |
| 286 |
\setcounter{lp@total@nests}{#1}% |
| 287 |
\setlength{\tabcolsep}{0mm}% |
| 288 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 289 |
% When using the array package, the tabular environment contains the statement |
| 290 |
% |\let\\\@arraycr| (note that with the array package, |\@tabularcr| is replaced |
| 291 |
% with |\@arraycr| even within the tabular environment). So, to modify the |
| 292 |
% behavior of |\\|, we're actually going to modify |\@arraycr|. Save a copy of the |
| 293 |
% original definition first, so that we can use it inside our new definition. |
| 294 |
% Remember that when the logicproof environment finishes, this redefinition |
| 295 |
% will go out of scope and revert to the previous version, so we won't ruin |
| 296 |
% any future uses of the tabular environment. |
| 297 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 298 |
\let\lp@orig@arraycr\@arraycr% |
| 299 |
\renewcommand{\@arraycr}{\lp@cr}% |
| 300 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 301 |
% Get labels to work in proofs by defining |\@currentlabel| to always be the |
| 302 |
% line number, regardless of where we are in the proof. Note that the usual |
| 303 |
% approach of using |
| 304 |
% |\refstepcounter{lp@line}| doesn't work because it goes out of scope by the |
| 305 |
% time we get to the next cell in the tabular environment. |
| 306 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 307 |
\renewcommand{\@currentlabel}{\p@lp@line\thelp@line}% |
| 308 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 309 |
% If the maximum number of nested subproofs is 0, we need a slightly different |
| 310 |
% column format, because the array environment doesn't like it when you repeat a |
| 311 |
% formatting group 0 times. |
| 312 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 313 |
\ifthenelse{% |
| 314 |
0=#1% |
| 315 |
}{% |
| 316 |
\def\lp@tab@format{{r@{~~~}>{$}l<{$}@{~~~~}l}}% |
| 317 |
}{% |
| 318 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 319 |
% Although we could use the |array| package's |>{...}| and |<{...}| features to |
| 320 |
% have automatic placement of the vertical lines on the sides of subproofs, |
| 321 |
% we would not be able to get the horizontal lines at the tops and bottoms |
| 322 |
% of the subproofs to line up properly. Consequently, we go with the ``old |
| 323 |
% school'' approach of putting subproofs in their own columns, so that we |
| 324 |
% can use |\cline| to put the horizontal lines in their proper places. |
| 325 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 326 |
\def\lp@tab@format% |
| 327 |
{{r@{~~~}*{#1}{l}@{~}>{$}l<{$}@{~~~~}l@{~}*{#1}{r}}} |
| 328 |
}% |
| 329 |
\center% |
| 330 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 331 |
% We use the |tabular| environment instead of the |array| environment because |
| 332 |
% we want |
| 333 |
% to be able to have labels on individual lines. Since the entirety of the |
| 334 |
% |array| environment is in math mode, it does not support more than one label |
| 335 |
% per array. |
| 336 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 337 |
\expandafter\tabular\lp@tab@format% |
| 338 |
\lp@start@proof@line% |
| 339 |
}{% |
| 340 |
\lp@stop@proof@line% |
| 341 |
\endtabular% |
| 342 |
\endcenter% |
| 343 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 344 |
% To ensure that no one tries using the subproof environment outside of the |
| 345 |
% logicproof environment, set the maximum number of nested subproofs to 0. |
| 346 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 347 |
\setcounter{lp@total@nests}{0}% |
| 348 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 349 |
% Finally, make sure that all open subproofs have been closed. We do this last |
| 350 |
% because if a subproof is still open, we need to set |\@currenvir| properly |
| 351 |
% for |\end| to check and throw errors on, but previous commands have |
| 352 |
% |\endgroup|'s that make it revert to previous definitions. |
| 353 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 354 |
\ifthenelse{% |
| 355 |
0=\value{lp@nested} |
| 356 |
}{% All is well. |
| 357 |
}{% There are still open subproofs. |
| 358 |
\def\@currenvir{subproof}% |
| 359 |
} |
| 360 |
} |
| 361 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 362 |
% \end{environment} |
| 363 |
% \begin{environment}{subproof} |
| 364 |
% This environment puts a box around the lines of the proof within it. It |
| 365 |
% should come right after either a |\\| or a |\end{subproof}|. |
| 366 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 367 |
\newenvironment{subproof}{% |
| 368 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 369 |
% Make sure we don't start more nested subproofs than the current logicproof |
| 370 |
% environment can handle. |
| 371 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 372 |
\ifthenelse{% |
| 373 |
\value{lp@total@nests}>\value{lp@nested}% |
| 374 |
}{% All is well; don't do anything. |
| 375 |
}{% |
| 376 |
\PackageError{logicproof}{Too many nested subproofs!}{% |
| 377 |
Increase the maximum number of nested subproofs allowed |
| 378 |
in the current logicproof environment.% |
| 379 |
}% |
| 380 |
}% |
| 381 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 382 |
% The |\begin| and |\end| parts of an environment start and end a group, so that |
| 383 |
% macros defined within them have local scope. However, a group cannot cross |
| 384 |
% alignment tabs (|&|'s), which means that this subproof environment, which must |
| 385 |
% cross them, needs to get rid of those extra groups first. So, we immediately |
| 386 |
% end the group that |\begin| created before going on with the subproof. Note |
| 387 |
% that this means any redefinitions of any macros we might have will persist |
| 388 |
% outside this subproof and will not go out of scope until the entire |
| 389 |
% logicproof environment is over. Note also that this approach is slightly |
| 390 |
% brittle: if the implementation of |\begin| and |\end| ever changes, this |
| 391 |
% subproof environment is likely to break. |
| 392 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 393 |
\endgroup% |
| 394 |
\lp@stop@proof@line% |
| 395 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 396 |
% Ideally, we'd use |\lp@extend@space| here. However, we first need to end the |
| 397 |
% current line, which means putting in |\lp@orig@arraycr| and then going up an |
| 398 |
% extra line in the tabular environment via |\lp@add@space|. |
| 399 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 400 |
\lp@orig@arraycr% |
| 401 |
\lp@add@space% |
| 402 |
\lp@go@up@a@line% |
| 403 |
\stepcounter{lp@nested}% |
| 404 |
\lp@cr@clines% |
| 405 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 406 |
% The current line number was added in before this subproof was started. Do |
| 407 |
% not add it in again now; just skip over the line number entry and go |
| 408 |
% straight on to the subproof-drawing stuff. |
| 409 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 410 |
&% |
| 411 |
\lp@continue@proof@line% |
| 412 |
}{% |
| 413 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 414 |
% If we try ending a subproof that has not yet begun, we will run into trouble |
| 415 |
% with |\cline| trying to draw a horizontal line to a column past the end of the |
| 416 |
% tabular environment. This happens before |\end| actually checks whether we're |
| 417 |
% ending the right environment. In order to get a more useful error message, |
| 418 |
% we first check that there is at least 1 open subproof. |
| 419 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 420 |
\ifthenelse{% |
| 421 |
0<\value{lp@nested}% |
| 422 |
}{% All is well; don't do anything. |
| 423 |
}{% |
| 424 |
\PackageError{logicproof}{Cannot end a subproof before it begins}{% |
| 425 |
You must have a \protect\begin{subproof} before you can use % |
| 426 |
\protect\end{subproof}.% |
| 427 |
}% |
| 428 |
}% |
| 429 |
\lp@stop@proof@line% |
| 430 |
\lp@cr@clines% |
| 431 |
\addtocounter{lp@nested}{-1}% |
| 432 |
\lp@extend@space% |
| 433 |
\lp@start@proof@line% |
| 434 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 435 |
% Now that we're done with the subproof, we need to create a group because |
| 436 |
% |\end| is expecting us to still be in the group that was started in |\begin|. We |
| 437 |
% also must redefine |\@currenvir| within that group, or the error-checking in |
| 438 |
% |\end| will think we've ended the wrong environment (its previous redefinition |
| 439 |
% went out of scope when we ended the group created by |\begin|). |
| 440 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 441 |
\begingroup% |
| 442 |
\def\@currenvir{subproof}% |
| 443 |
} |
| 444 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 445 |
% \end{environment} |
| 446 |
% \begin{macro}{\lp@cr} |
| 447 |
% This is what the |\\| will be defined as inside the logicproof environment. |
| 448 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 449 |
\newcommand{\lp@cr}{% |
| 450 |
\lp@stop@proof@line% |
| 451 |
\lp@orig@arraycr% |
| 452 |
\lp@extend@space% |
| 453 |
\lp@start@proof@line% |
| 454 |
} |
| 455 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 456 |
% \end{macro} |
| 457 |
% \begin{macro}{\lp@go@up@a@line} |
| 458 |
% This moves up one entire line in the proof. |
| 459 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 460 |
\newcommand{\lp@go@up@a@line}{% |
| 461 |
\vspace{-\ht\@arstrutbox}% |
| 462 |
\vspace{-\dp\@arstrutbox}% |
| 463 |
\vspace{-\intersubproofvertspace}% |
| 464 |
} |
| 465 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 466 |
% \end{macro} |
| 467 |
% \begin{macro}{\lp@add@space} |
| 468 |
% Extends the vertical lines at the sides of the proof down slightly, so that |
| 469 |
% the horizontal lines at the end of the previous subproof and the start of the |
| 470 |
% next one don't overlap. This basically inserts a blank row in the proof (no |
| 471 |
% line number, no statement, no justification; just the subproof lines), then |
| 472 |
% backs up part of a line. |
| 473 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 474 |
\newcommand{\lp@add@space}{% |
| 475 |
\lp@extend@space% |
| 476 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 477 |
% The |\@arstrutbox| is a box containing the minimum array height. Remember that |
| 478 |
% the height of the strut is spread between the height above the baseline and |
| 479 |
% the depth below it! |
| 480 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 481 |
\vspace{-\ht\@arstrutbox}% |
| 482 |
\vspace{-\dp\@arstrutbox}% |
| 483 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 484 |
% Uncommenting this would line things up exactly where they started. |
| 485 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 486 |
%\vspace{-\intersubproofvertspace}% |
| 487 |
} |
| 488 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 489 |
% \end{macro} |
| 490 |
% \begin{macro}{\lp@extend@space} |
| 491 |
% This extends the vertical lines at the sides of the subproofs down by |
| 492 |
% an extra |\intersubproofvertspace.| This is done so that two subproofs in a |
| 493 |
% row don't have their horizontal lines overlap each other. |
| 494 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 495 |
\newcommand{\lp@extend@space}{% |
| 496 |
\vspace{-\ht\@arstrutbox}% |
| 497 |
\vspace{-\dp\@arstrutbox}% |
| 498 |
\vspace{\intersubproofvertspace}% |
| 499 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 500 |
% Now, insert a row that has vertical lines for the subproofs but no line |
| 501 |
% number, proof statement, or justification. |
| 502 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 503 |
&% |
| 504 |
\lp@continue@proof@line% |
| 505 |
&% |
| 506 |
\lp@stop@proof@line% |
| 507 |
\lp@orig@arraycr% |
| 508 |
} |
| 509 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 510 |
% \end{macro} |
| 511 |
% \begin{macro}{\lp@amper} |
| 512 |
% You can't have a |&| in a |\whiledo| loop, but this works instead. |
| 513 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 514 |
\newcommand{\lp@amper}{&} |
| 515 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 516 |
% \end{macro} |
| 517 |
% \begin{macro}{\lp@start@proof@line} |
| 518 |
% This macro does everything on a proof line before the statement itself: it |
| 519 |
% increments and prints the line number, then calls |
| 520 |
% |\lp@continue@proof@line| to put in the vertical lines of any subproofs we're |
| 521 |
% currently in. |
| 522 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 523 |
\newcommand{\lp@start@proof@line}{% |
| 524 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 525 |
% We use |\stepcounter| instead of |\refstepcounter| here because the changes made |
| 526 |
% by |\refstepcounter| to how labels get made would go out of scope by the time |
| 527 |
% we got to the next cell of the tabular environment (i.e., 2 lines from |
| 528 |
% here). Instead, we redefined |\@currentlabel| at the beginning of the |
| 529 |
% environment to always contain the current value of the |lp@line| counter. |
| 530 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 531 |
\stepcounter{lp@line}% |
| 532 |
\arabic{lp@line}.% |
| 533 |
&% |
| 534 |
\lp@continue@proof@line% |
| 535 |
} |
| 536 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 537 |
% \end{macro} |
| 538 |
% \begin{macro}{\lp@continue@proof@line} |
| 539 |
% This macro makes the vertical lines of the subproof boxes on the left side of |
| 540 |
% the proof (i.e., the ones that come between the line numbers and the proof |
| 541 |
% statements). We use |\lp@amper| here because the raw |&| token doesn't play |
| 542 |
% well with |\whiledo| loops. |
| 543 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 544 |
\newcommand{\lp@continue@proof@line}{% |
| 545 |
\setcounter{lp@temp}{0}% |
| 546 |
\whiledo{\value{lp@temp}<\value{lp@nested}}{% |
| 547 |
\vline% |
| 548 |
\hspace*{\subproofhorizspace}% |
| 549 |
\lp@amper% |
| 550 |
\stepcounter{lp@temp}% |
| 551 |
}% |
| 552 |
\whiledo{\value{lp@temp}<\value{lp@total@nests}}{% |
| 553 |
\hspace*{\subproofhorizspace}% |
| 554 |
\lp@amper% |
| 555 |
\stepcounter{lp@temp}% |
| 556 |
}% |
| 557 |
} |
| 558 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 559 |
% \end{macro} |
| 560 |
% \begin{macro}{\lp@stop@proof@line} |
| 561 |
% This macro makes the vertical lines of the subproof boxes on the right side |
| 562 |
% of the proof (i.e., the ones that come after the justifications for each |
| 563 |
% step). It basically does the same thing as |\lp@continue@proof@line|, but in |
| 564 |
% reverse order. We use |\lp@amper| here because the raw |&| token doesn't play |
| 565 |
% well with |\whiledo| loops. |
| 566 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 567 |
\newcommand{\lp@stop@proof@line}{% |
| 568 |
\whiledo{\value{lp@temp}>\value{lp@nested}}{% |
| 569 |
\addtocounter{lp@temp}{-1}% |
| 570 |
\lp@amper% |
| 571 |
\hspace*{\subproofhorizspace}% |
| 572 |
}% |
| 573 |
\whiledo{\value{lp@temp}>0}{% |
| 574 |
\addtocounter{lp@temp}{-1}% |
| 575 |
\lp@amper% |
| 576 |
\hspace*{\subproofhorizspace}% |
| 577 |
\vline% |
| 578 |
}% |
| 579 |
} |
| 580 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 581 |
% \end{macro} |
| 582 |
% \begin{macro}{\lp@subtract@from@counter} |
| 583 |
% Subtraction by a value in another counter is annoying, but with this we can |
| 584 |
% use |\expandafter| and make it easier. |
| 585 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 586 |
\newcommand{\lp@subtract@from@counter}[2]{% |
| 587 |
\addtocounter{#2}{-#1}% |
| 588 |
} |
| 589 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 590 |
% \end{macro} |
| 591 |
% \begin{macro}{\lp@set@clines} |
| 592 |
% This macro sets up where the horizontal bars go for subproofs. |
| 593 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 594 |
\newcommand{\lp@set@clines}{% |
| 595 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 596 |
% |lp@cline@1 = lp@nested + 1| |
| 597 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 598 |
\setcounter{lp@cline@1}{\value{lp@nested}}% |
| 599 |
\stepcounter{lp@cline@1}% |
| 600 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 601 |
% |lp@cline@2 = 2 * lp@total@nests + 4 - lp@nested| |
| 602 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 603 |
\setcounter{lp@cline@2}{\value{lp@total@nests}}% |
| 604 |
\addtocounter{lp@cline@2}{\value{lp@total@nests}}% |
| 605 |
\addtocounter{lp@cline@2}{4}% |
| 606 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 607 |
% Subtracting one counter from another is tricky. We need to expand the value |
| 608 |
% of the counter being subtracted first. |
| 609 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 610 |
\expandafter\lp@subtract@from@counter\expandafter{% |
| 611 |
\value{lp@nested}}{lp@cline@2}% |
| 612 |
} |
| 613 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 614 |
% \end{macro} |
| 615 |
% \begin{macro}{\lp@cr@clines} |
| 616 |
% This macro goes to the next line of the tabular environment and puts in a |
| 617 |
% horizontal line for the beginning or end of the current subproof. |
| 618 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 619 |
\newcommand{\lp@cr@clines}{% |
| 620 |
\lp@set@clines% |
| 621 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 622 |
% We put the |\lp@orig@arraycr| here instead of in |\lp@stop@proof@line| because |
| 623 |
% |\cline| doesn't seem to work properly unless it's right after the carriage |
| 624 |
% return. Even moving it up above |\lp@set@clines| on the previous line messes |
| 625 |
% it up. |
| 626 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 627 |
\lp@orig@arraycr% |
| 628 |
\cline{\value{lp@cline@1}-\value{lp@cline@2}}% |
| 629 |
} |
| 630 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 631 |
% \end{macro} |
| 632 |
% |
| 633 |
% \iffalse |
| 634 |
%</package> |
| 635 |
% \fi |
| 636 |
% |
| 637 |
% \Finale |
| 638 |
\endinput |