| 1 |
% \iffalse meta-comment |
| 2 |
%<*internal> |
| 3 |
\iffalse |
| 4 |
%</internal> |
| 5 |
%<*readme> |
| 6 |
The kantlipsum package spits out sentences in Kantian style provided |
| 7 |
by the "Kant generator for Python" by Mark Pilgrim, described in the |
| 8 |
book "Dive into Python". |
| 9 |
|
| 10 |
This is version 0.8c of the package |
| 11 |
|
| 12 |
Changes from earlier version: |
| 13 |
|
| 14 |
Version 0.8c is a maintenance release. |
| 15 |
|
| 16 |
Copyright 2011-2023 Enrico Gregorio |
| 17 |
|
| 18 |
It may be distributed and/or modified under the conditions of the |
| 19 |
LaTeX Project Public License (LPPL), either version 1.3c of this |
| 20 |
license or (at your option) any later version. The latest version |
| 21 |
of this license is in the file |
| 22 |
|
| 23 |
http://www.latex-project.org/lppl.txt |
| 24 |
|
| 25 |
Author: Enrico Gregorio |
| 26 |
Enrico dot Gregorio at univr dot it |
| 27 |
|
| 28 |
This work has the LPPL maintenance status "author-maintained". |
| 29 |
|
| 30 |
This work consists of the following files: |
| 31 |
|
| 32 |
README (this file) |
| 33 |
kantlipsum.dtx |
| 34 |
kantlipsum.pdf |
| 35 |
|
| 36 |
and of the derived file |
| 37 |
|
| 38 |
kantlipsum.sty |
| 39 |
|
| 40 |
To install the distribution: |
| 41 |
|
| 42 |
o run "tex kantlipsum.dtx" |
| 43 |
%</readme> |
| 44 |
%<*internal> |
| 45 |
\fi |
| 46 |
\def\nameofplainTeX{plain} |
| 47 |
\ifx\fmtname\nameofplainTeX\else |
| 48 |
\expandafter\begingroup |
| 49 |
\fi |
| 50 |
%</internal> |
| 51 |
%<*install> |
| 52 |
\input l3docstrip.tex |
| 53 |
\keepsilent |
| 54 |
\askforoverwritefalse |
| 55 |
\preamble |
| 56 |
--------------------------------------------------------------- |
| 57 |
The kantlipsum package --- Generate text in Kantian style |
| 58 |
Maintained by Enrico Gregorio |
| 59 |
E-mail: enrico DOT gregorio AT univr DOT it |
| 60 |
Released under the LaTeX Project Public License v1.3c or later |
| 61 |
See http://www.latex-project.org/lppl.txt |
| 62 |
--------------------------------------------------------------- |
| 63 |
\endpreamble |
| 64 |
\postamble |
| 65 |
Copyright (C) 2011-2023 by |
| 66 |
Enrico Gregorio |
| 67 |
enrico DOT gregorio AT univr DOT it |
| 68 |
|
| 69 |
It may be distributed and/or modified under the conditions of the |
| 70 |
LaTeX Project Public License (LPPL), either version 1.3c of this |
| 71 |
license or (at your option) any later version. The latest version |
| 72 |
of this license is in the file |
| 73 |
http://www.latex-project.org/lppl.txt |
| 74 |
This work consists of the file kantlipsum.dtx |
| 75 |
and the derived files kantlipsum.pdf, |
| 76 |
kantlipsum.sty and |
| 77 |
kantlipsum.ins. |
| 78 |
\endpostamble |
| 79 |
\usedir{tex/latex/kantlipsum} |
| 80 |
\generate{ |
| 81 |
\file{\jobname.sty}{\from{\jobname.dtx}{package}} |
| 82 |
} |
| 83 |
%</install> |
| 84 |
%<install>\endbatchfile |
| 85 |
%<*internal> |
| 86 |
\usedir{source/latex/kantlipsum} |
| 87 |
\generate{ |
| 88 |
\file{\jobname.ins}{\from{\jobname.dtx}{install}} |
| 89 |
} |
| 90 |
\nopreamble\nopostamble |
| 91 |
\usedir{doc/latex/kantlipsum} |
| 92 |
\generate{ |
| 93 |
\file{README.md}{\from{\jobname.dtx}{readme}} |
| 94 |
} |
| 95 |
\ifx\fmtname\nameofplainTeX |
| 96 |
\expandafter\endbatchfile |
| 97 |
\else |
| 98 |
\expandafter\endgroup |
| 99 |
\fi |
| 100 |
%</internal> |
| 101 |
%<*driver> |
| 102 |
\documentclass[a4paper,full]{l3doc} |
| 103 |
\usepackage{bookmark} |
| 104 |
\usepackage{kantlipsum} |
| 105 |
\begin{document} |
| 106 |
\DocInput{\jobname.dtx} |
| 107 |
\end{document} |
| 108 |
%</driver> |
| 109 |
% \fi |
| 110 |
% |
| 111 |
% \GetFileInfo{\jobname.sty} |
| 112 |
% |
| 113 |
% \title{^^A |
| 114 |
% The \textsf{kantlipsum} package\\ Dummy text in Kantian style^^A |
| 115 |
% \thanks{This file describes version \fileversion, |
| 116 |
% last revised \filedate.}^^A |
| 117 |
% } |
| 118 |
% |
| 119 |
% \author{^^A |
| 120 |
% Enrico Gregorio\thanks |
| 121 |
% {^^A |
| 122 |
% E-mail: |
| 123 |
% \texttt{Enrico DOT Gregorio AT univr DOT it}^^A |
| 124 |
% }^^A |
| 125 |
% } |
| 126 |
% |
| 127 |
% \date{Released \filedate} |
| 128 |
% |
| 129 |
% \maketitle |
| 130 |
% |
| 131 |
%\changes{v0.5}{2011/12/23}{First released version} |
| 132 |
%\changes{v0.6}{2012/10/14}{Fixes for kernel changes} |
| 133 |
%\changes{v0.6}{2012/10/14}{Added functions for producing an index} |
| 134 |
%\changes{v0.7}{2017/11/16}{Use new kernel function} |
| 135 |
%\changes{v0.8}{2017/07/23}{Print only a few sentences of a paragraph} |
| 136 |
%\changes{v0.8a}{2017/07/24}{Respect options and *-version} |
| 137 |
%\changes{v0.8b}{2023/11/21}{Maintenance release} |
| 138 |
%\changes{v0.8c}{2023/11/27}{Maintenance release} |
| 139 |
% |
| 140 |
% \begin{documentation} |
| 141 |
% |
| 142 |
% \section{Introduction} |
| 143 |
% |
| 144 |
% The \pkg{kantlipsum} package is modeled after \pkg{lipsum} and |
| 145 |
% offers pretty similar functionality, but instead of pseudolatin |
| 146 |
% utterances, it typesets paragraphs of nonsense in Kantian style |
| 147 |
% produced by the \emph{Kant generator for Python} by Mark Pilgrim, |
| 148 |
% found in \href{http://www.diveintopython.net/}{\emph{Dive into |
| 149 |
% Python}}. |
| 150 |
% |
| 151 |
% It has at least one advantage over \pkg{lipsum}: the text is in |
| 152 |
% English and so finding good hyphenation points should be less |
| 153 |
% problematic. On the contrary, the paragraphs are rather long, as |
| 154 |
% it's common in philosophical prose. |
| 155 |
% |
| 156 |
% \section{Example} |
| 157 |
% |
| 158 |
% \kant[1-3] |
| 159 |
% |
| 160 |
% \section{Options} |
| 161 |
% |
| 162 |
% The package has four document options, the first two of which are |
| 163 |
% alternative to each other: |
| 164 |
% \begin{itemize}[font=\ttfamily] |
| 165 |
% \item[par$\,\vert\,$nopar] With the default \texttt{par} all pieces |
| 166 |
% of text will be ended by a \cs{par} command; specifying \texttt{par} |
| 167 |
% is optional; the option \texttt{nopar} will not add this \cs{par} at |
| 168 |
% the end of each fragment of Kantian prose. |
| 169 |
% \item[numbers] Each piece of Kantian prose will be preceded by its |
| 170 |
% number (such as in ``1~\textbullet~As any dedicated reader can |
| 171 |
% clearly see\dots''), which can be useful for better control of what |
| 172 |
% is produced. |
| 173 |
% \item[index] Each paragraph will generate an index entry; a |
| 174 |
% |\makeindex| command will be needed, with a suitable package for |
| 175 |
% making the index, and |\printindex| for printing it. However the |
| 176 |
% index entry may be off by one, since the |\index| command is issued |
| 177 |
% at the beginning of the paragraph. Also there is no guarantee that |
| 178 |
% the indexed word really belongs to the paragraph. |
| 179 |
% \end{itemize} |
| 180 |
% |
| 181 |
% \section{Commands} |
| 182 |
% |
| 183 |
% The commands provided by the package are: |
| 184 |
% \begin{itemize}[font=\ttfamily] |
| 185 |
% \item[\cs{kant}] This command takes an optional argument which can |
| 186 |
% be of the form \texttt{[42]} (that is, only one integer) or |
| 187 |
% \texttt{[3-14]} (that is, two integers separated by a hyphen); as in |
| 188 |
% \pkg{lipsum}, \verb|\kant[42]|, \verb|\kant[3-14]| and \verb|\kant| |
| 189 |
% will produce the 42nd pseudokantian paragraph, the paragraphs from |
| 190 |
% the 3rd to the 14th, and those from the 1st to the 7th, |
| 191 |
% respectively. |
| 192 |
% \item[\cs{kant*}] The same as before, see later for the difference. |
| 193 |
% \item[\cs{kantdef}] This command takes two arguments, a control |
| 194 |
% sequence and an integer; the call \verb|\kantdef{\mytext}{164}| will |
| 195 |
% store in \cs{mytext} the 164th paragraph of pseudokantian text |
| 196 |
% provided by this package. |
| 197 |
% \end{itemize} |
| 198 |
% The commands \cs{kant}, \cs{kant*} and \cs{kantdef} take a further |
| 199 |
% optional argument; with \verb|\kant[42][1-3]| just the first three |
| 200 |
% sentences of paragraph number~42 will be printed; ranges outside the |
| 201 |
% actual number of sentences will be ignored. The requested sentences |
| 202 |
% are stored, in the case of \cs{kantdef}. |
| 203 |
% |
| 204 |
% What's the difference between \cs{kant} and \cs{kant*}? The normal |
| 205 |
% version will respect the given package option; that is, if |
| 206 |
% \texttt{par} is in force, \verb|\kant[1-2]| will produce \emph{two} |
| 207 |
% paragraphs, while \verb|\kant*[1-2]| will only produce a big chunk |
| 208 |
% of text without issuing any \verb|\par| command. The logic is |
| 209 |
% reversed if the \texttt{nopar} option has been given. |
| 210 |
% |
| 211 |
% By the way, 164 is the number of available pieces; if one exceeds |
| 212 |
% the limit, nothing will be printed. Thus \verb|\kant[164-200]| will |
| 213 |
% print only \emph{one} paragraph. However, printing all paragraphs |
| 214 |
% with the standard ten point size Computer Modern font and the |
| 215 |
% \pkg{article} class fills more than fifty pages, so it seems that |
| 216 |
% the supply of text can be sufficient. |
| 217 |
% |
| 218 |
% \subsection*{Note} |
| 219 |
% |
| 220 |
% This package is just an exercise for practicing with \LaTeX3 |
| 221 |
% syntax. It uses the ``experimental'' packages made available by the |
| 222 |
% \LaTeX3 team. Many thanks to Joseph Wright, Bruno Le Floch and Frank |
| 223 |
% Mittelbach for suggesting improvements. |
| 224 |
% |
| 225 |
% \subsection*{Changes from version 0.1} |
| 226 |
% |
| 227 |
% There's no user level change; the implementation has been modified |
| 228 |
% in some places (in particular a sequence is used to store the |
| 229 |
% phrases, rather than many token lists). |
| 230 |
% |
| 231 |
% \subsection*{Changes from version 0.5} |
| 232 |
% |
| 233 |
% Some changes in \LaTeX3 introduced some misfeatures, which this |
| 234 |
% version corrects. Some kernel function names were also changed; here |
| 235 |
% |\prg_stepwise_function:nnnN| that became |\int_step_function:nnnN|. |
| 236 |
% Some functions have been made |protected|. |
| 237 |
% |
| 238 |
% The most striking change is the possibility to generate an index: |
| 239 |
% each paragraph indexes one of its words or phrases. |
| 240 |
% |
| 241 |
% \subsection*{Changes from version 0.6} |
| 242 |
% |
| 243 |
% Maintenance release with new functions from \texttt{expl3}. Now |
| 244 |
% a kernel released on 2017/11/14 or later is required. |
| 245 |
% |
| 246 |
% \subsection*{Changes from version 0.7} |
| 247 |
% |
| 248 |
% Printing just some sentences in a paragraph is possible. Now |
| 249 |
% a kernel released on 2019/07/01 or later is required. |
| 250 |
% |
| 251 |
% \subsection*{Changes from version 0.8} |
| 252 |
% |
| 253 |
% Added a missing \cs{@@par:} |
| 254 |
% |
| 255 |
% \end{documentation} |
| 256 |
% |
| 257 |
% \begin{implementation} |
| 258 |
% |
| 259 |
% \section{\pkg{kantlipsum} implementation} |
| 260 |
% |
| 261 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 262 |
%<*package> |
| 263 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 264 |
% |
| 265 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 266 |
%<@@=kgl> |
| 267 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 268 |
% |
| 269 |
% |
| 270 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 271 |
\ProvidesExplPackage |
| 272 |
{kantlipsum} |
| 273 |
{2023/11/27} |
| 274 |
{0.8c} |
| 275 |
{Generate text in Kantian style} |
| 276 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 277 |
% |
| 278 |
% A check to make sure that \pkg{expl3} is not too old |
| 279 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 280 |
\@ifl@t@r\ExplLoaderFileDate{2022-11-09} |
| 281 |
{} |
| 282 |
{% |
| 283 |
\PackageError { kantlipsum } { Support~package~expl3~too~old } |
| 284 |
{ |
| 285 |
You~need~to~update~your~installation~of~the~bundles~ |
| 286 |
'l3kernel'~and~'l3packages'.\MessageBreak |
| 287 |
Loading~kantlipsum~will~abort! |
| 288 |
} |
| 289 |
\tex_endinput:D |
| 290 |
} |
| 291 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 292 |
% |
| 293 |
% \subsection{Package options and required packages} |
| 294 |
% We declare the allowed options and choose by default |
| 295 |
% \texttt{par}. We also need to declare a function |\@@_number:n| |
| 296 |
% that is set by the \texttt{numbers} option; its default action is to |
| 297 |
% gobble its argument. |
| 298 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 299 |
\DeclareOption { par } |
| 300 |
{ |
| 301 |
\cs_set_protected:Nn \@@_star: { \c_space_tl } |
| 302 |
\cs_set_protected:Nn \@@_nostar: { \par } |
| 303 |
} |
| 304 |
|
| 305 |
\DeclareOption{ nopar } |
| 306 |
{ |
| 307 |
\cs_set_protected:Nn \@@_star: { \par } |
| 308 |
\cs_set_protected:Nn \@@_nostar: { \c_space_tl } |
| 309 |
} |
| 310 |
|
| 311 |
\DeclareOption{ numbers } |
| 312 |
{ |
| 313 |
\cs_set_protected:Nn \@@_number:n |
| 314 |
{ |
| 315 |
#1\nobreak\enspace\textbullet\nobreak\enspace |
| 316 |
} |
| 317 |
} |
| 318 |
|
| 319 |
\bool_new:N \g_@@_makeindex_bool |
| 320 |
\bool_gset_false:N \g_@@_makeindex_bool |
| 321 |
\DeclareOption{ index } |
| 322 |
{ \bool_gset_true:N \g_@@_makeindex_bool } |
| 323 |
|
| 324 |
\cs_new_eq:NN \@@_number:n \use_none:n |
| 325 |
\ExecuteOptions{par} |
| 326 |
\ProcessOptions \scan_stop: |
| 327 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 328 |
% |
| 329 |
% \subsection{Messages} |
| 330 |
% We define two messages. |
| 331 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 332 |
\msg_new:nnn {kantlipsum}{how-many} |
| 333 |
{The~package~provides~paragraphs~1~to~#1.~ |
| 334 |
Values~outside~this~range~will~be~ignored.} |
| 335 |
\msg_new:nnnn {kantlipsum}{already-defined} |
| 336 |
{Control~sequence~#1~already~defined.} |
| 337 |
{The~control~sequence~#1~is~already~defined,~ |
| 338 |
I'll~ignore~it} |
| 339 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 340 |
% |
| 341 |
% \subsection{Variables and constants} |
| 342 |
% The |\l_@@_start_int| variable will contain the starting number for |
| 343 |
% processing, while |\l_@@_end_int| the ending number. The |
| 344 |
% |\g_@@_pars_seq| sequence will contain the pseudokantian sentences |
| 345 |
% and |\g_@@_words_seq| that contains the words to index. |
| 346 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 347 |
\int_new:N \l_@@_start_int |
| 348 |
\int_new:N \l_@@_end_int |
| 349 |
\seq_new:N \g_@@_pars_seq |
| 350 |
\seq_new:N \g_@@_words_seq |
| 351 |
\seq_new:N \l_@@_sentences_seq |
| 352 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 353 |
% |
| 354 |
% \subsection{User level commands} |
| 355 |
% There are two user level commands, \cs{kant} (with a *-variant) and \cs{kantdef}. |
| 356 |
% |
| 357 |
% \begin{function}{\kant} |
| 358 |
% The (optional) argument is described as before. We use the |
| 359 |
% \cs{SplitArgument} feature provided by \pkg{xparse} to decide |
| 360 |
% whether the `range form' has been specified. In the \cs{kant*} form |
| 361 |
% we reverse the logic. |
| 362 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 363 |
\NewDocumentCommand{\kant} |
| 364 |
{ |
| 365 |
s |
| 366 |
>{\SplitArgument{1}{-}}O{1-7} |
| 367 |
>{\SplitArgument{1}{-}}o} |
| 368 |
{ |
| 369 |
\group_begin: |
| 370 |
\IfBooleanTF{#1} |
| 371 |
{ \cs_set_eq:NN \@@_par: \@@_star: } |
| 372 |
{ \cs_set_eq:NN \@@_par: \@@_nostar: } |
| 373 |
\IfNoValueTF{#3} |
| 374 |
{ \@@_process:nn #2 \@@_print: } |
| 375 |
{ \@@_process:nnnn #2 #3 \tl_use:N \l_tmpa_tl \@@_par: } |
| 376 |
\group_end: |
| 377 |
} |
| 378 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 379 |
%\changes{v0.8a}{2019/07/24}{Added a missing \cs{@@par:}} |
| 380 |
% \end{function} |
| 381 |
% |
| 382 |
% \begin{function}{\kantdef} |
| 383 |
% Sometimes one needs just a piece of text without implicit \cs{par} |
| 384 |
% attached, so we provide \cs{kantdef}. In a group we neutralize the |
| 385 |
% meaning of |\@@_number:n| and |\@@_par:| and define the control |
| 386 |
% sequence given as first argument to the pseudokantian sentence being |
| 387 |
% the $k$th element of the sequence containing them, where $k$ is the |
| 388 |
% number given as second argument. If the control sequence is already |
| 389 |
% defined we issue an error and don't perform the definition. |
| 390 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 391 |
\NewDocumentCommand{\kantdef} |
| 392 |
{ |
| 393 |
m |
| 394 |
m |
| 395 |
>{\SplitArgument{1}{-}}O{1-50} |
| 396 |
} |
| 397 |
{ |
| 398 |
\group_begin: |
| 399 |
\@@_define:nnnn {#1} {#2} #3 |
| 400 |
\group_end: |
| 401 |
} |
| 402 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 403 |
% \end{function} |
| 404 |
% |
| 405 |
% \subsection{Internal functions} |
| 406 |
% \begin{function}{\@@_process:nn} |
| 407 |
% The function |\@@_process:nn| sets the temporary variables |
| 408 |
% |\l_@@_start_int| and |\l_@@_end_int|. If the optional argument to |
| 409 |
% \cs{kant} is missing they are already set to 1 and 7 respectively; |
| 410 |
% otherwise the argument has been split into its components; if the |
| 411 |
% argument was |[|$m$|]| we set both variables to $m$, otherwise it |
| 412 |
% was in the form |[|$m$|-|$n$|]| and we do the obvious action. |
| 413 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 414 |
\cs_new_protected:Nn \@@_process:nn |
| 415 |
{ |
| 416 |
\int_set:Nn \l_@@_start_int {#1} |
| 417 |
\tl_if_novalue:nTF {#2} |
| 418 |
{ \int_set:Nn \l_@@_end_int {#1} } |
| 419 |
{ \int_set:Nn \l_@@_end_int {#2} } |
| 420 |
} |
| 421 |
\cs_new_protected:Nn \@@_process:nnnn |
| 422 |
{ |
| 423 |
\tl_set:Ne \l_tmpa_tl { \seq_item:Nn \g_@@_pars_seq {#1} } |
| 424 |
\tl_if_novalue:nTF {#4} |
| 425 |
{ \@@_extract:nnV {#3} {#3} \l_tmpa_tl } |
| 426 |
{ \@@_extract:nnV {#3} {#4} \l_tmpa_tl } |
| 427 |
} |
| 428 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 429 |
% \end{function} |
| 430 |
% \changes{v0.7}{2017/11/16}{Use \cs{tl_if_novalue:nTF} instead of \cs{IfNoValueTF}} |
| 431 |
% |
| 432 |
% \begin{function}{\@@_print:,\@@_use:n} |
| 433 |
% The printing routine is in the function |\@@_print:|; we start a |
| 434 |
% loop printing item number $x$ in the sequence |\g_@@_pars_seq| for |
| 435 |
% all numbers $x$ in the specified range. The function |\@@_use:n| |
| 436 |
% function is a wrapper to be used with |\int_step_function:nnnN|: |
| 437 |
% it's passed a number as argument, builds the constant name |
| 438 |
% corresponding to it and produces the text. If the index entry is to |
| 439 |
% be issued, the appropriate element from |\g_@@_words_seq| is used; |
| 440 |
% the page reference might not be correct, though. |
| 441 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 442 |
\cs_new_protected:Nn \@@_print: |
| 443 |
{ |
| 444 |
\int_step_function:nnnN |
| 445 |
{\l_@@_start_int} {1} {\l_@@_end_int} \@@_use:n |
| 446 |
} |
| 447 |
\cs_new:Nn \@@_use:n |
| 448 |
{ |
| 449 |
\int_compare:nNnF { #1 } > { \seq_count:N \g_@@_pars_seq } |
| 450 |
{ \@@_number:n {#1} } |
| 451 |
\bool_if:NT \g_@@_makeindex_bool |
| 452 |
{ |
| 453 |
\use:x { \exp_not:N \index{ \seq_item:Nn \g_@@_words_seq {#1} } } |
| 454 |
} |
| 455 |
\seq_item:Nn \g_@@_pars_seq {#1} |
| 456 |
} |
| 457 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 458 |
% \end{function} |
| 459 |
% |
| 460 |
% \begin{function}{\@@_newpara:n} |
| 461 |
% The |\@@_newpara:n| appends a new item to the sequence |\g_@@_pars_seq| |
| 462 |
% consisting of, say, \meta{text of the 42nd sentence}|\@@_par:| |
| 463 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 464 |
\cs_new_protected:Nn \@@_newpara:n |
| 465 |
{ \seq_gput_right:Nn \g_@@_pars_seq {#1\@@_par:} } |
| 466 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 467 |
% \end{function} |
| 468 |
% |
| 469 |
% \begin{function}{\@@_newword:n} |
| 470 |
% The |\@@_newword:n| function appends a new item to the sequence |
| 471 |
% |\g_@@_words_seq| consisting of one word from the corresponding |
| 472 |
% paragraph. |
| 473 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 474 |
\cs_new_protected:Nn \@@_newword:n |
| 475 |
{ \seq_gput_right:Nn \g_@@_words_seq {#1} } |
| 476 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 477 |
% \end{function} |
| 478 |
% |
| 479 |
% \begin{function}{\@@define:nnnn} |
| 480 |
% The function |\@@define:nnnn| chooses the paragraph, then extracts the |
| 481 |
% requested sentences. |
| 482 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 483 |
\cs_new_protected:Nn \@@_define:nnnn |
| 484 |
{ |
| 485 |
\cs_set_eq:NN \@@_number:n \use_none:n |
| 486 |
\cs_set_eq:NN \@@_par: \prg_do_nothing: |
| 487 |
\cs_if_exist:NTF #1 |
| 488 |
{ |
| 489 |
\msg_error:nnn {kantlipsum} {already-defined} {#1} |
| 490 |
} |
| 491 |
{ |
| 492 |
\tl_set:Ne \l_tmpa_tl { \seq_item:Nn \g_@@_pars_seq {#2} } |
| 493 |
\tl_if_novalue:nTF {#4} |
| 494 |
{ \@@_extract:nnV {#3} {#3} \l_tmpa_tl } |
| 495 |
{ \@@_extract:nnV {#3} {#4} \l_tmpa_tl } |
| 496 |
\cs_new:Npe #1 { \l_tmpa_tl } |
| 497 |
} |
| 498 |
} |
| 499 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 500 |
% \end{function} |
| 501 |
% \begin{function}{\@@_extract:nnn} |
| 502 |
% This function does the extraction by splitting the input at periods |
| 503 |
% and then adding the requested sentences to another sequence that |
| 504 |
% later can be used. |
| 505 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 506 |
\cs_new_protected:Nn \@@_extract:nnn |
| 507 |
{ |
| 508 |
\seq_set_split:Nnn \l_@@_sentences_seq { . } {#3} |
| 509 |
\seq_clear:N \l_tmpa_seq |
| 510 |
\seq_map_indexed_inline:Nn \l_@@_sentences_seq |
| 511 |
{ |
| 512 |
\int_compare:nT { #1 <= ##1 <= #2 } |
| 513 |
{\seq_put_right:Nn \l_tmpa_seq { ##2 } } |
| 514 |
} |
| 515 |
\tl_set:Ne \l_tmpa_tl { \seq_use:Nn \l_tmpa_seq { .~ }. } |
| 516 |
} |
| 517 |
\cs_generate_variant:Nn \@@_extract:nnn { nnV } |
| 518 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 519 |
% \end{function} |
| 520 |
% |
| 521 |
% \subsection{Defining the sentences} |
| 522 |
% We start a group where we set the category |
| 523 |
% code of the space to 10 so as not to be forced to write |~| for |
| 524 |
% spaces. |
| 525 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 526 |
\group_begin: |
| 527 |
\char_set_catcode_space:n {`\ } |
| 528 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 529 |
% |
| 530 |
% Then we provide all of the sentences with the pattern |
| 531 |
% |\@@_newpara:n {|\meta{text}|}| |
| 532 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 533 |
\@@_newpara:n {As any dedicated reader can clearly see, the Ideal of |
| 534 |
practical reason is a representation of, as far as I know, the things |
| 535 |
in themselves; as I have shown elsewhere, the phenomena should only be |
| 536 |
used as a canon for our understanding. The paralogisms of practical |
| 537 |
reason are what first give rise to the architectonic of practical |
| 538 |
reason. As will easily be shown in the next section, reason would |
| 539 |
thereby be made to contradict, in view of these considerations, the |
| 540 |
Ideal of practical reason, yet the manifold depends on the phenomena. |
| 541 |
Necessity depends on, when thus treated as the practical employment of |
| 542 |
the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, time. |
| 543 |
Human reason depends on our sense perceptions, by means of analytic |
| 544 |
unity. There can be no doubt that the objects in space and time are |
| 545 |
what first give rise to human reason.} |
| 546 |
|
| 547 |
\@@_newpara:n {Let us suppose that the noumena have nothing to do |
| 548 |
with necessity, since knowledge of the Categories is a |
| 549 |
posteriori. Hume tells us that the transcendental unity of |
| 550 |
apperception can not take account of the discipline of natural reason, |
| 551 |
by means of analytic unity. As is proven in the ontological manuals, |
| 552 |
it is obvious that the transcendental unity of apperception proves the |
| 553 |
validity of the Antinomies; what we have alone been able to show is |
| 554 |
that, our understanding depends on the Categories. It remains a |
| 555 |
mystery why the Ideal stands in need of reason. It must not be |
| 556 |
supposed that our faculties have lying before them, in the case of the |
| 557 |
Ideal, the Antinomies; so, the transcendental aesthetic is just as |
| 558 |
necessary as our experience. By means of the Ideal, our sense |
| 559 |
perceptions are by their very nature contradictory.} |
| 560 |
|
| 561 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is shown in the writings of Aristotle, the things |
| 562 |
in themselves (and it remains a mystery why this is the case) are a |
| 563 |
representation of time. Our concepts have lying before them the |
| 564 |
paralogisms of natural reason, but our a posteriori concepts have |
| 565 |
lying before them the practical employment of our experience. Because |
| 566 |
of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, the paralogisms would |
| 567 |
thereby be made to contradict, indeed, space; for these reasons, the |
| 568 |
Transcendental Deduction has lying before it our sense perceptions. |
| 569 |
(Our a posteriori knowledge can never furnish a true and demonstrated |
| 570 |
science, because, like time, it depends on analytic principles.) So, |
| 571 |
it must not be supposed that our experience depends on, so, our sense |
| 572 |
perceptions, by means of analysis. Space constitutes the whole content |
| 573 |
for our sense perceptions, and time occupies part of the sphere of the |
| 574 |
Ideal concerning the existence of the objects in space and time in |
| 575 |
general.} |
| 576 |
|
| 577 |
\@@_newpara:n {As we have already seen, what we have alone been able |
| 578 |
to show is that the objects in space and time would be falsified; what |
| 579 |
we have alone been able to show is that, our judgements are what first |
| 580 |
give rise to metaphysics. As I have shown elsewhere, Aristotle tells |
| 581 |
us that the objects in space and time, in the full sense of these |
| 582 |
terms, would be falsified. Let us suppose that, indeed, our |
| 583 |
problematic judgements, indeed, can be treated like our concepts. As |
| 584 |
any dedicated reader can clearly see, our knowledge can be treated |
| 585 |
like the transcendental unity of apperception, but the phenomena |
| 586 |
occupy part of the sphere of the manifold concerning the existence of |
| 587 |
natural causes in general. Whence comes the architectonic of natural |
| 588 |
reason, the solution of which involves the relation between necessity |
| 589 |
and the Categories? Natural causes (and it is not at all certain that |
| 590 |
this is the case) constitute the whole content for the paralogisms. |
| 591 |
This could not be passed over in a complete system of transcendental |
| 592 |
philosophy, but in a merely critical essay the simple mention of the |
| 593 |
fact may suffice.} |
| 594 |
|
| 595 |
\@@_newpara:n {Therefore, we can deduce that the objects in space and |
| 596 |
time (and I assert, however, that this is the case) have lying before |
| 597 |
them the objects in space and time. Because of our necessary ignorance |
| 598 |
of the conditions, it must not be supposed that, then, formal logic |
| 599 |
(and what we have alone been able to show is that this is true) is a |
| 600 |
representation of the never-ending regress in the series of empirical |
| 601 |
conditions, but the discipline of pure reason, in so far as this |
| 602 |
expounds the contradictory rules of metaphysics, depends on the |
| 603 |
Antinomies. By means of analytic unity, our faculties, therefore, can |
| 604 |
never, as a whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, |
| 605 |
like the transcendental unity of apperception, they constitute the |
| 606 |
whole content for a priori principles; for these reasons, our |
| 607 |
experience is just as necessary as, in accordance with the principles |
| 608 |
of our a priori knowledge, philosophy. The objects in space and time |
| 609 |
abstract from all content of knowledge. Has it ever been suggested |
| 610 |
that it remains a mystery why there is no relation between the |
| 611 |
Antinomies and the phenomena? It must not be supposed that the |
| 612 |
Antinomies (and it is not at all certain that this is the case) are |
| 613 |
the clue to the discovery of philosophy, because of our necessary |
| 614 |
ignorance of the conditions. As I have shown elsewhere, to avoid all |
| 615 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that our understanding |
| 616 |
(and it must not be supposed that this is true) is what first gives |
| 617 |
rise to the architectonic of pure reason, as is evident upon close |
| 618 |
examination.} |
| 619 |
|
| 620 |
\@@_newpara:n {The things in themselves are what first give rise to |
| 621 |
reason, as is proven in the ontological manuals. By virtue of natural |
| 622 |
reason, let us suppose that the transcendental unity of apperception |
| 623 |
abstracts from all content of knowledge; in view of these |
| 624 |
considerations, the Ideal of human reason, on the contrary, is the key |
| 625 |
to understanding pure logic. Let us suppose that, irrespective of all |
| 626 |
empirical conditions, our understanding stands in need of our |
| 627 |
disjunctive judgements. As is shown in the writings of Aristotle, pure |
| 628 |
logic, in the case of the discipline of natural reason, abstracts from |
| 629 |
all content of knowledge. Our understanding is a representation of, in |
| 630 |
accordance with the principles of the employment of the paralogisms, |
| 631 |
time. I assert, as I have shown elsewhere, that our concepts can be |
| 632 |
treated like metaphysics. By means of the Ideal, it must not be |
| 633 |
supposed that the objects in space and time are what first give rise |
| 634 |
to the employment of pure reason.} |
| 635 |
|
| 636 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is evident upon close examination, to avoid all |
| 637 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, on the contrary, the |
| 638 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions is a |
| 639 |
representation of our inductive judgements, yet the things in |
| 640 |
themselves prove the validity of, on the contrary, the Categories. It |
| 641 |
remains a mystery why, indeed, the never-ending regress in the series |
| 642 |
of empirical conditions exists in philosophy, but the employment of |
| 643 |
the Antinomies, in respect of the intelligible character, can never |
| 644 |
furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the |
| 645 |
architectonic of pure reason, it is just as necessary as problematic |
| 646 |
principles. The practical employment of the objects in space and time |
| 647 |
is by its very nature contradictory, and the thing in itself would |
| 648 |
thereby be made to contradict the Ideal of practical reason. On the |
| 649 |
other hand, natural causes can not take account of, consequently, the |
| 650 |
Antinomies, as will easily be shown in the next section. |
| 651 |
Consequently, the Ideal of practical reason (and I assert that this is |
| 652 |
true) excludes the possibility of our sense perceptions. Our |
| 653 |
experience would thereby be made to contradict, for example, our |
| 654 |
ideas, but the transcendental objects in space and time (and let us |
| 655 |
suppose that this is the case) are the clue to the discovery of |
| 656 |
necessity. But the proof of this is a task from which we can here be |
| 657 |
absolved.} |
| 658 |
|
| 659 |
\@@_newpara:n {Thus, the Antinomies exclude the possibility of, on |
| 660 |
the other hand, natural causes, as will easily be shown in the next |
| 661 |
section. Still, the reader should be careful to observe that the |
| 662 |
phenomena have lying before them the intelligible objects in space and |
| 663 |
time, because of the relation between the manifold and the noumena. |
| 664 |
As is evident upon close examination, Aristotle tells us that, in |
| 665 |
reference to ends, our judgements (and the reader should be careful to |
| 666 |
observe that this is the case) constitute the whole content of the |
| 667 |
empirical objects in space and time. Our experience, with the sole |
| 668 |
exception of necessity, exists in metaphysics; therefore, metaphysics |
| 669 |
exists in our experience. (It must not be supposed that the thing in |
| 670 |
itself (and I assert that this is true) may not contradict itself, but |
| 671 |
it is still possible that it may be in contradictions with the |
| 672 |
transcendental unity of apperception; certainly, our judgements exist |
| 673 |
in natural causes.) The reader should be careful to observe that, |
| 674 |
indeed, the Ideal, on the other hand, can be treated like the noumena, |
| 675 |
but natural causes would thereby be made to contradict the Antinomies. |
| 676 |
The transcendental unity of apperception constitutes the whole content |
| 677 |
for the noumena, by means of analytic unity.} |
| 678 |
|
| 679 |
\@@_newpara:n {In all theoretical sciences, the paralogisms of human |
| 680 |
reason would be falsified, as is proven in the ontological manuals. |
| 681 |
The architectonic of human reason is what first gives rise to the |
| 682 |
Categories. As any dedicated reader can clearly see, the paralogisms |
| 683 |
should only be used as a canon for our experience. What we have alone |
| 684 |
been able to show is that, that is to say, our sense perceptions |
| 685 |
constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and some of this body must |
| 686 |
be known a posteriori. Human reason occupies part of the sphere of |
| 687 |
our experience concerning the existence of the phenomena in general.} |
| 688 |
|
| 689 |
\@@_newpara:n {By virtue of natural reason, our ampliative judgements |
| 690 |
would thereby be made to contradict, in all theoretical sciences, the |
| 691 |
pure employment of the discipline of human reason. Because of our |
| 692 |
necessary ignorance of the conditions, Hume tells us that the |
| 693 |
transcendental aesthetic constitutes the whole content for, still, the |
| 694 |
Ideal. By means of analytic unity, our sense perceptions, even as |
| 695 |
this relates to philosophy, abstract from all content of knowledge. |
| 696 |
With the sole exception of necessity, the reader should be careful to |
| 697 |
observe that our sense perceptions exclude the possibility of the |
| 698 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, since |
| 699 |
knowledge of natural causes is a posteriori. Let us suppose that the |
| 700 |
Ideal occupies part of the sphere of our knowledge concerning the |
| 701 |
existence of the phenomena in general.} |
| 702 |
|
| 703 |
\@@_newpara:n {By virtue of natural reason, what we have alone been |
| 704 |
able to show is that, in so far as this expounds the universal rules |
| 705 |
of our a posteriori concepts, the architectonic of natural reason can |
| 706 |
be treated like the architectonic of practical reason. Thus, our |
| 707 |
speculative judgements can not take account of the Ideal, since none |
| 708 |
of the Categories are speculative. With the sole exception of the |
| 709 |
Ideal, it is not at all certain that the transcendental objects in |
| 710 |
space and time prove the validity of, for example, the noumena, as is |
| 711 |
shown in the writings of Aristotle. As we have already seen, our |
| 712 |
experience is the clue to the discovery of the Antinomies; in the |
| 713 |
study of pure logic, our knowledge is just as necessary as, thus, |
| 714 |
space. By virtue of practical reason, the noumena, still, stand in |
| 715 |
need to the pure employment of the things in themselves.} |
| 716 |
|
| 717 |
\@@_newpara:n {The reader should be careful to observe that the |
| 718 |
objects in space and time are the clue to the discovery of, certainly, |
| 719 |
our a priori knowledge, by means of analytic unity. Our faculties |
| 720 |
abstract from all content of knowledge; for these reasons, the |
| 721 |
discipline of human reason stands in need of the transcendental |
| 722 |
aesthetic. There can be no doubt that, insomuch as the Ideal relies |
| 723 |
on our a posteriori concepts, philosophy, when thus treated as the |
| 724 |
things in themselves, exists in our hypothetical judgements, yet our a |
| 725 |
posteriori concepts are what first give rise to the phenomena. |
| 726 |
Philosophy (and I assert that this is true) excludes the possibility |
| 727 |
of the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, as |
| 728 |
will easily be shown in the next section. Still, is it true that the |
| 729 |
transcendental aesthetic can not take account of the objects in space |
| 730 |
and time, or is the real question whether the phenomena should only be |
| 731 |
used as a canon for the never-ending regress in the series of |
| 732 |
empirical conditions? By means of analytic unity, the Transcendental |
| 733 |
Deduction, still, is the mere result of the power of the |
| 734 |
Transcendental Deduction, a blind but indispensable function of the |
| 735 |
soul, but our faculties abstract from all content of a posteriori |
| 736 |
knowledge. It remains a mystery why, then, the discipline of human |
| 737 |
reason, in other words, is what first gives rise to the transcendental |
| 738 |
aesthetic, yet our faculties have lying before them the architectonic |
| 739 |
of human reason.} |
| 740 |
|
| 741 |
\@@_newpara:n {However, we can deduce that our experience (and it |
| 742 |
must not be supposed that this is true) stands in need of our |
| 743 |
experience, as we have already seen. On the other hand, it is not at |
| 744 |
all certain that necessity is a representation of, by means of the |
| 745 |
practical employment of the paralogisms of practical reason, the |
| 746 |
noumena. In all theoretical sciences, our faculties are what first |
| 747 |
give rise to natural causes. To avoid all misapprehension, it is |
| 748 |
necessary to explain that our ideas can never, as a whole, furnish a |
| 749 |
true and demonstrated science, because, like the Ideal of natural |
| 750 |
reason, they stand in need to inductive principles, as is shown in the |
| 751 |
writings of Galileo. As I have elsewhere shown, natural causes, in |
| 752 |
respect of the intelligible character, exist in the objects in space |
| 753 |
and time.} |
| 754 |
|
| 755 |
\@@_newpara:n {Our ideas, in the case of the Ideal of pure reason, |
| 756 |
are by their very nature contradictory. The objects in space and time |
| 757 |
can not take account of our understanding, and philosophy excludes the |
| 758 |
possibility of, certainly, space. I assert that our ideas, by means |
| 759 |
of philosophy, constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and all of |
| 760 |
this body must be known a posteriori, by means of analysis. It must |
| 761 |
not be supposed that space is by its very nature contradictory. Space |
| 762 |
would thereby be made to contradict, in the case of the manifold, the |
| 763 |
manifold. As is proven in the ontological manuals, Aristotle tells us |
| 764 |
that, in accordance with the principles of the discipline of human |
| 765 |
reason, the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions |
| 766 |
has lying before it our experience. This could not be passed over in |
| 767 |
a complete system of transcendental philosophy, but in a merely |
| 768 |
critical essay the simple mention of the fact may suffice.} |
| 769 |
|
| 770 |
\@@_newpara:n {Since knowledge of our faculties is a posteriori, pure |
| 771 |
logic teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of, indeed, |
| 772 |
the architectonic of human reason. As we have already seen, we can |
| 773 |
deduce that, irrespective of all empirical conditions, the Ideal of |
| 774 |
human reason is what first gives rise to, indeed, natural causes, yet |
| 775 |
the thing in itself can never furnish a true and demonstrated science, |
| 776 |
because, like necessity, it is the clue to the discovery of |
| 777 |
disjunctive principles. On the other hand, the manifold depends on |
| 778 |
the paralogisms. Our faculties exclude the possibility of, insomuch |
| 779 |
as philosophy relies on natural causes, the discipline of natural |
| 780 |
reason. In all theoretical sciences, what we have alone been able to |
| 781 |
show is that the objects in space and time exclude the possibility of |
| 782 |
our judgements, as will easily be shown in the next section. This is |
| 783 |
what chiefly concerns us.} |
| 784 |
|
| 785 |
\@@_newpara:n {Time (and let us suppose that this is true) is the |
| 786 |
clue to the discovery of the Categories, as we have already seen. |
| 787 |
Since knowledge of our faculties is a priori, to avoid all |
| 788 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the empirical objects |
| 789 |
in space and time can not take account of, in the case of the Ideal of |
| 790 |
natural reason, the manifold. It must not be supposed that pure |
| 791 |
reason stands in need of, certainly, our sense perceptions. On the |
| 792 |
other hand, our ampliative judgements would thereby be made to |
| 793 |
contradict, in the full sense of these terms, our hypothetical |
| 794 |
judgements. I assert, still, that philosophy is a representation of, |
| 795 |
however, formal logic; in the case of the manifold, the objects in |
| 796 |
space and time can be treated like the paralogisms of natural reason. |
| 797 |
This is what chiefly concerns us.} |
| 798 |
|
| 799 |
\@@_newpara:n {Because of the relation between pure logic and natural |
| 800 |
causes, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, |
| 801 |
even as this relates to the thing in itself, pure reason constitutes |
| 802 |
the whole content for our concepts, but the Ideal of practical reason |
| 803 |
may not contradict itself, but it is still possible that it may be in |
| 804 |
contradictions with, then, natural reason. It remains a mystery why |
| 805 |
natural causes would thereby be made to contradict the noumena; by |
| 806 |
means of our understanding, the Categories are just as necessary as |
| 807 |
our concepts. The Ideal, irrespective of all empirical conditions, |
| 808 |
depends on the Categories, as is shown in the writings of Aristotle. |
| 809 |
It is obvious that our ideas (and there can be no doubt that this is |
| 810 |
the case) constitute the whole content of practical reason. The |
| 811 |
Antinomies have nothing to do with the objects in space and time, yet |
| 812 |
general logic, in respect of the intelligible character, has nothing |
| 813 |
to do with our judgements. In my present remarks I am referring to |
| 814 |
the transcendental aesthetic only in so far as it is founded on |
| 815 |
analytic principles.} |
| 816 |
|
| 817 |
\@@_newpara:n {With the sole exception of our a priori knowledge, our |
| 818 |
faculties have nothing to do with our faculties. Pure reason (and we |
| 819 |
can deduce that this is true) would thereby be made to contradict the |
| 820 |
phenomena. As we have already seen, let us suppose that the |
| 821 |
transcendental aesthetic can thereby determine in its totality the |
| 822 |
objects in space and time. We can deduce that, that is to say, our |
| 823 |
experience is a representation of the paralogisms, and our |
| 824 |
hypothetical judgements constitute the whole content of our concepts. |
| 825 |
However, it is obvious that time can be treated like our a priori |
| 826 |
knowledge, by means of analytic unity. Philosophy has nothing to do |
| 827 |
with natural causes.} |
| 828 |
|
| 829 |
\@@_newpara:n {By means of analysis, our faculties stand in need to, |
| 830 |
indeed, the empirical objects in space and time. The objects in space |
| 831 |
and time, for these reasons, have nothing to do with our |
| 832 |
understanding. There can be no doubt that the noumena can not take |
| 833 |
account of the objects in space and time; consequently, the Ideal of |
| 834 |
natural reason has lying before it the noumena. By means of analysis, |
| 835 |
the Ideal of human reason is what first gives rise to, therefore, |
| 836 |
space, yet our sense perceptions exist in the discipline of practical |
| 837 |
reason.} |
| 838 |
|
| 839 |
\@@_newpara:n {The Ideal can not take account of, so far as I know, |
| 840 |
our faculties. As we have already seen, the objects in space and time |
| 841 |
are what first give rise to the never-ending regress in the series of |
| 842 |
empirical conditions; for these reasons, our a posteriori concepts |
| 843 |
have nothing to do with the paralogisms of pure reason. As we have |
| 844 |
already seen, metaphysics, by means of the Ideal, occupies part of the |
| 845 |
sphere of our experience concerning the existence of the objects in |
| 846 |
space and time in general, yet time excludes the possibility of our |
| 847 |
sense perceptions. I assert, thus, that our faculties would thereby |
| 848 |
be made to contradict, indeed, our knowledge. Natural causes, so |
| 849 |
regarded, exist in our judgements.} |
| 850 |
|
| 851 |
\@@_newpara:n {The never-ending regress in the series of empirical |
| 852 |
conditions may not contradict itself, but it is still possible that it |
| 853 |
may be in contradictions with, then, applied logic. The employment of |
| 854 |
the noumena stands in need of space; with the sole exception of our |
| 855 |
understanding, the Antinomies are a representation of the noumena. It |
| 856 |
must not be supposed that the discipline of human reason, in the case |
| 857 |
of the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, is |
| 858 |
a body of demonstrated science, and some of it must be known a |
| 859 |
posteriori; in all theoretical sciences, the thing in itself excludes |
| 860 |
the possibility of the objects in space and time. As will easily be |
| 861 |
shown in the next section, the reader should be careful to observe |
| 862 |
that the things in themselves, in view of these considerations, can be |
| 863 |
treated like the objects in space and time. In all theoretical |
| 864 |
sciences, we can deduce that the manifold exists in our sense |
| 865 |
perceptions. The things in themselves, indeed, occupy part of the |
| 866 |
sphere of philosophy concerning the existence of the transcendental |
| 867 |
objects in space and time in general, as is proven in the ontological |
| 868 |
manuals.} |
| 869 |
|
| 870 |
\@@_newpara:n {The transcendental unity of apperception, in the case |
| 871 |
of philosophy, is a body of demonstrated science, and some of it must |
| 872 |
be known a posteriori. Thus, the objects in space and time, insomuch |
| 873 |
as the discipline of practical reason relies on the Antinomies, |
| 874 |
constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and all of this body must |
| 875 |
be known a priori. Applied logic is a representation of, in natural |
| 876 |
theology, our experience. As any dedicated reader can clearly see, |
| 877 |
Hume tells us that, that is to say, the Categories (and Aristotle |
| 878 |
tells us that this is the case) exclude the possibility of the |
| 879 |
transcendental aesthetic. (Because of our necessary ignorance of the |
| 880 |
conditions, the paralogisms prove the validity of time.) As is shown |
| 881 |
in the writings of Hume, it must not be supposed that, in reference to |
| 882 |
ends, the Ideal is a body of demonstrated science, and some of it must |
| 883 |
be known a priori. By means of analysis, it is not at all certain |
| 884 |
that our a priori knowledge is just as necessary as our ideas. In my |
| 885 |
present remarks I am referring to time only in so far as it is founded |
| 886 |
on disjunctive principles.} |
| 887 |
|
| 888 |
\@@_newpara:n {The discipline of pure reason is what first gives rise |
| 889 |
to the Categories, but applied logic is the clue to the discovery of |
| 890 |
our sense perceptions. The never-ending regress in the series of |
| 891 |
empirical conditions teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the |
| 892 |
content of the pure employment of the paralogisms of natural reason. |
| 893 |
Let us suppose that the discipline of pure reason, so far as regards |
| 894 |
pure reason, is what first gives rise to the objects in space and |
| 895 |
time. It is not at all certain that our judgements, with the sole |
| 896 |
exception of our experience, can be treated like our experience; in |
| 897 |
the case of the Ideal, our understanding would thereby be made to |
| 898 |
contradict the manifold. As will easily be shown in the next section, |
| 899 |
the reader should be careful to observe that pure reason (and it is |
| 900 |
obvious that this is true) stands in need of the phenomena; for these |
| 901 |
reasons, our sense perceptions stand in need to the manifold. Our |
| 902 |
ideas are what first give rise to the paralogisms.} |
| 903 |
|
| 904 |
\@@_newpara:n {The things in themselves have lying before them the |
| 905 |
Antinomies, by virtue of human reason. By means of the transcendental |
| 906 |
aesthetic, let us suppose that the discipline of natural reason |
| 907 |
depends on natural causes, because of the relation between the |
| 908 |
transcendental aesthetic and the things in themselves. In view of |
| 909 |
these considerations, it is obvious that natural causes are the clue |
| 910 |
to the discovery of the transcendental unity of apperception, by means |
| 911 |
of analysis. We can deduce that our faculties, in particular, can be |
| 912 |
treated like the thing in itself; in the study of metaphysics, the |
| 913 |
thing in itself proves the validity of space. And can I entertain the |
| 914 |
Transcendental Deduction in thought, or does it present itself to me? |
| 915 |
By means of analysis, the phenomena can not take account of natural |
| 916 |
causes. This is not something we are in a position to establish.} |
| 917 |
|
| 918 |
\@@_newpara:n {Since some of the things in themselves are a |
| 919 |
posteriori, there can be no doubt that, when thus treated as our |
| 920 |
understanding, pure reason depends on, still, the Ideal of natural |
| 921 |
reason, and our speculative judgements constitute a body of |
| 922 |
demonstrated doctrine, and all of this body must be known a |
| 923 |
posteriori. As is shown in the writings of Aristotle, it is not at |
| 924 |
all certain that, in accordance with the principles of natural causes, |
| 925 |
the Transcendental Deduction is a body of demonstrated science, and |
| 926 |
all of it must be known a posteriori, yet our concepts are the clue to |
| 927 |
the discovery of the objects in space and time. Therefore, it is |
| 928 |
obvious that formal logic would be falsified. By means of analytic |
| 929 |
unity, it remains a mystery why, in particular, metaphysics teaches us |
| 930 |
nothing whatsoever regarding the content of the Ideal. The phenomena, |
| 931 |
on the other hand, would thereby be made to contradict the |
| 932 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions. As is |
| 933 |
shown in the writings of Aristotle, philosophy is a representation of, |
| 934 |
on the contrary, the employment of the Categories. Because of the |
| 935 |
relation between the transcendental unity of apperception and the |
| 936 |
paralogisms of natural reason, the paralogisms of human reason, in the |
| 937 |
study of the Transcendental Deduction, would be falsified, but |
| 938 |
metaphysics abstracts from all content of knowledge.} |
| 939 |
|
| 940 |
\@@_newpara:n {Since some of natural causes are disjunctive, the |
| 941 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions is the key |
| 942 |
to understanding, in particular, the noumena. By means of analysis, |
| 943 |
the Categories (and it is not at all certain that this is the case) |
| 944 |
exclude the possibility of our faculties. Let us suppose that the |
| 945 |
objects in space and time, irrespective of all empirical conditions, |
| 946 |
exist in the architectonic of natural reason, because of the relation |
| 947 |
between the architectonic of natural reason and our a posteriori |
| 948 |
concepts. I assert, as I have elsewhere shown, that, so regarded, our |
| 949 |
sense perceptions (and let us suppose that this is the case) are a |
| 950 |
representation of the practical employment of natural causes. (I |
| 951 |
assert that time constitutes the whole content for, in all theoretical |
| 952 |
sciences, our understanding, as will easily be shown in the next |
| 953 |
section.) With the sole exception of our knowledge, the reader should |
| 954 |
be careful to observe that natural causes (and it remains a mystery |
| 955 |
why this is the case) can not take account of our sense perceptions, |
| 956 |
as will easily be shown in the next section. Certainly, natural |
| 957 |
causes would thereby be made to contradict, with the sole exception of |
| 958 |
necessity, the things in themselves, because of our necessary |
| 959 |
ignorance of the conditions. But to this matter no answer is |
| 960 |
possible.} |
| 961 |
|
| 962 |
\@@_newpara:n {Since all of the objects in space and time are |
| 963 |
synthetic, it remains a mystery why, even as this relates to our |
| 964 |
experience, our a priori concepts should only be used as a canon for |
| 965 |
our judgements, but the phenomena should only be used as a canon for |
| 966 |
the practical employment of our judgements. Space, consequently, is a |
| 967 |
body of demonstrated science, and all of it must be known a priori, as |
| 968 |
will easily be shown in the next section. We can deduce that the |
| 969 |
Categories have lying before them the phenomena. Therefore, let us |
| 970 |
suppose that our ideas, in the study of the transcendental unity of |
| 971 |
apperception, should only be used as a canon for the pure employment |
| 972 |
of natural causes. Still, the reader should be careful to observe |
| 973 |
that the Ideal (and it remains a mystery why this is true) can not |
| 974 |
take account of our faculties, as is proven in the ontological |
| 975 |
manuals. Certainly, it remains a mystery why the manifold is just as |
| 976 |
necessary as the manifold, as is evident upon close examination.} |
| 977 |
|
| 978 |
\@@_newpara:n {In natural theology, what we have alone been able to |
| 979 |
show is that the architectonic of practical reason is the clue to the |
| 980 |
discovery of, still, the manifold, by means of analysis. Since |
| 981 |
knowledge of the objects in space and time is a priori, the things in |
| 982 |
themselves have lying before them, for example, the paralogisms of |
| 983 |
human reason. Let us suppose that our sense perceptions constitute |
| 984 |
the whole content of, by means of philosophy, necessity. Our concepts |
| 985 |
(and the reader should be careful to observe that this is the case) |
| 986 |
are just as necessary as the Ideal. To avoid all misapprehension, it |
| 987 |
is necessary to explain that the Categories occupy part of the sphere |
| 988 |
of the discipline of human reason concerning the existence of our |
| 989 |
faculties in general. The transcendental aesthetic, in so far as this |
| 990 |
expounds the contradictory rules of our a priori concepts, is the mere |
| 991 |
result of the power of our understanding, a blind but indispensable |
| 992 |
function of the soul. The manifold, in respect of the intelligible |
| 993 |
character, teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of the |
| 994 |
thing in itself; however, the objects in space and time exist in |
| 995 |
natural causes.} |
| 996 |
|
| 997 |
\@@_newpara:n {I assert, however, that our a posteriori concepts (and |
| 998 |
it is obvious that this is the case) would thereby be made to |
| 999 |
contradict the discipline of practical reason; however, the things in |
| 1000 |
themselves, however, constitute the whole content of philosophy. As |
| 1001 |
will easily be shown in the next section, the Antinomies would thereby |
| 1002 |
be made to contradict our understanding; in all theoretical sciences, |
| 1003 |
metaphysics, irrespective of all empirical conditions, excludes the |
| 1004 |
possibility of space. It is not at all certain that necessity (and it |
| 1005 |
is obvious that this is true) constitutes the whole content for the |
| 1006 |
objects in space and time; consequently, the paralogisms of practical |
| 1007 |
reason, however, exist in the Antinomies. The reader should be |
| 1008 |
careful to observe that transcendental logic, in so far as this |
| 1009 |
expounds the universal rules of formal logic, can never furnish a true |
| 1010 |
and demonstrated science, because, like the Ideal, it may not |
| 1011 |
contradict itself, but it is still possible that it may be in |
| 1012 |
contradictions with disjunctive principles. (Because of our necessary |
| 1013 |
ignorance of the conditions, the thing in itself is what first gives |
| 1014 |
rise to, insomuch as the transcendental aesthetic relies on the |
| 1015 |
objects in space and time, the transcendental objects in space and |
| 1016 |
time; thus, the never-ending regress in the series of empirical |
| 1017 |
conditions excludes the possibility of philosophy.) As we have |
| 1018 |
already seen, time depends on the objects in space and time; in the |
| 1019 |
study of the architectonic of pure reason, the phenomena are the clue |
| 1020 |
to the discovery of our understanding. Because of our necessary |
| 1021 |
ignorance of the conditions, I assert that, indeed, the architectonic |
| 1022 |
of natural reason, as I have elsewhere shown, would be falsified.} |
| 1023 |
|
| 1024 |
\@@_newpara:n {In natural theology, the transcendental unity of |
| 1025 |
apperception has nothing to do with the Antinomies. As will easily be |
| 1026 |
shown in the next section, our sense perceptions are by their very |
| 1027 |
nature contradictory, but our ideas, with the sole exception of human |
| 1028 |
reason, have nothing to do with our sense perceptions. Metaphysics is |
| 1029 |
the key to understanding natural causes, by means of analysis. It is |
| 1030 |
not at all certain that the paralogisms of human reason prove the |
| 1031 |
validity of, thus, the noumena, since all of our a posteriori |
| 1032 |
judgements are a priori. We can deduce that, indeed, the objects in |
| 1033 |
space and time can not take account of the Transcendental Deduction, |
| 1034 |
but our knowledge, on the other hand, would be falsified.} |
| 1035 |
|
| 1036 |
\@@_newpara:n {As we have already seen, our understanding is the clue |
| 1037 |
to the discovery of necessity. On the other hand, the Ideal of pure |
| 1038 |
reason is a body of demonstrated science, and all of it must be known |
| 1039 |
a posteriori, as is evident upon close examination. It is obvious |
| 1040 |
that the transcendental aesthetic, certainly, is a body of |
| 1041 |
demonstrated science, and some of it must be known a priori; in view |
| 1042 |
of these considerations, the noumena are the clue to the discovery of, |
| 1043 |
so far as I know, natural causes. In the case of space, our |
| 1044 |
experience depends on the Ideal of natural reason, as we have already |
| 1045 |
seen.} |
| 1046 |
|
| 1047 |
\@@_newpara:n {For these reasons, space is the key to understanding |
| 1048 |
the thing in itself. Our sense perceptions abstract from all content |
| 1049 |
of a priori knowledge, but the phenomena can never, as a whole, |
| 1050 |
furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like time, they are |
| 1051 |
just as necessary as disjunctive principles. Our problematic |
| 1052 |
judgements constitute the whole content of time. By means of |
| 1053 |
analysis, our ideas are by their very nature contradictory, and our a |
| 1054 |
posteriori concepts are a representation of natural causes. I assert |
| 1055 |
that the objects in space and time would thereby be made to |
| 1056 |
contradict, so far as regards the thing in itself, the Transcendental |
| 1057 |
Deduction; in natural theology, the noumena are the clue to the |
| 1058 |
discovery of, so far as I know, the Transcendental Deduction.} |
| 1059 |
|
| 1060 |
\@@_newpara:n {To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to |
| 1061 |
explain that, in respect of the intelligible character, the |
| 1062 |
transcendental aesthetic depends on the objects in space and time, yet |
| 1063 |
the manifold is the clue to the discovery of the Transcendental |
| 1064 |
Deduction. Therefore, the transcendental unity of apperception would |
| 1065 |
thereby be made to contradict, in the case of our understanding, our |
| 1066 |
ideas. There can be no doubt that the things in themselves prove the |
| 1067 |
validity of the objects in space and time, as is shown in the writings |
| 1068 |
of Aristotle. By means of analysis, there can be no doubt that, |
| 1069 |
insomuch as the discipline of pure reason relies on the Categories, |
| 1070 |
the transcendental unity of apperception would thereby be made to |
| 1071 |
contradict the never-ending regress in the series of empirical |
| 1072 |
conditions. In the case of space, the Categories exist in time. Our |
| 1073 |
faculties can be treated like our concepts. As is shown in the |
| 1074 |
writings of Galileo, the transcendental unity of apperception stands |
| 1075 |
in need of, in the case of necessity, our speculative judgements.} |
| 1076 |
|
| 1077 |
\@@_newpara:n {The phenomena (and it is obvious that this is the |
| 1078 |
case) prove the validity of our sense perceptions; in natural |
| 1079 |
theology, philosophy teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the |
| 1080 |
content of the transcendental objects in space and time. In natural |
| 1081 |
theology, our sense perceptions are a representation of the |
| 1082 |
Antinomies. The noumena exclude the possibility of, even as this |
| 1083 |
relates to the transcendental aesthetic, our knowledge. Our concepts |
| 1084 |
would thereby be made to contradict, that is to say, the noumena; in |
| 1085 |
the study of philosophy, space is by its very nature contradictory. |
| 1086 |
Since some of the Antinomies are problematic, our ideas are a |
| 1087 |
representation of our a priori concepts, yet space, in other words, |
| 1088 |
has lying before it the things in themselves. Aristotle tells us |
| 1089 |
that, in accordance with the principles of the phenomena, the |
| 1090 |
Antinomies are a representation of metaphysics.} |
| 1091 |
|
| 1092 |
\@@_newpara:n {The things in themselves can not take account of the |
| 1093 |
Transcendental Deduction. By means of analytic unity, it is obvious |
| 1094 |
that, that is to say, our sense perceptions, in all theoretical |
| 1095 |
sciences, can not take account of the thing in itself, yet the |
| 1096 |
transcendental unity of apperception, in the full sense of these |
| 1097 |
terms, would thereby be made to contradict the employment of our sense |
| 1098 |
perceptions. Our synthetic judgements would be falsified. Since some |
| 1099 |
of our faculties are problematic, the things in themselves exclude the |
| 1100 |
possibility of the Ideal. It must not be supposed that the things in |
| 1101 |
themselves are a representation of, in accordance with the principles |
| 1102 |
of philosophy, our sense perceptions.} |
| 1103 |
|
| 1104 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is proven in the ontological manuals, philosophy is |
| 1105 |
the mere result of the power of pure logic, a blind but indispensable |
| 1106 |
function of the soul; however, the phenomena can never, as a whole, |
| 1107 |
furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like general logic, |
| 1108 |
they exclude the possibility of problematic principles. To avoid all |
| 1109 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the never-ending |
| 1110 |
regress in the series of empirical conditions is by its very nature |
| 1111 |
contradictory. It must not be supposed that our a priori concepts |
| 1112 |
stand in need to natural causes, because of the relation between the |
| 1113 |
Ideal and our ideas. (We can deduce that the Antinomies would be |
| 1114 |
falsified.) Since knowledge of the Categories is a posteriori, what |
| 1115 |
we have alone been able to show is that, in the full sense of these |
| 1116 |
terms, necessity (and we can deduce that this is true) is the key to |
| 1117 |
understanding time, but the Ideal of natural reason is just as |
| 1118 |
necessary as our experience. As will easily be shown in the next |
| 1119 |
section, the thing in itself, with the sole exception of the manifold, |
| 1120 |
abstracts from all content of a posteriori knowledge. The question of |
| 1121 |
this matter's relation to objects is not in any way under discussion.} |
| 1122 |
|
| 1123 |
\@@_newpara:n {By means of the transcendental aesthetic, it remains a |
| 1124 |
mystery why the phenomena (and it is not at all certain that this is |
| 1125 |
the case) are the clue to the discovery of the never-ending regress in |
| 1126 |
the series of empirical conditions. In all theoretical sciences, |
| 1127 |
metaphysics exists in the objects in space and time, because of the |
| 1128 |
relation between formal logic and our synthetic judgements. The |
| 1129 |
Categories would thereby be made to contradict the paralogisms, as any |
| 1130 |
dedicated reader can clearly see. Therefore, there can be no doubt |
| 1131 |
that the paralogisms have nothing to do with, so far as regards the |
| 1132 |
Ideal and our faculties, the paralogisms, because of our necessary |
| 1133 |
ignorance of the conditions. It must not be supposed that the objects |
| 1134 |
in space and time occupy part of the sphere of necessity concerning |
| 1135 |
the existence of the noumena in general. In natural theology, the |
| 1136 |
things in themselves, therefore, are by their very nature |
| 1137 |
contradictory, by virtue of natural reason. This is the sense in |
| 1138 |
which it is to be understood in this work.} |
| 1139 |
|
| 1140 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is evident upon close examination, let us suppose |
| 1141 |
that, in accordance with the principles of time, our a priori concepts |
| 1142 |
are the clue to the discovery of philosophy. By means of analysis, to |
| 1143 |
avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, in |
| 1144 |
particular, the transcendental aesthetic can not take account of |
| 1145 |
natural causes. As we have already seen, the reader should be careful |
| 1146 |
to observe that, in accordance with the principles of the objects in |
| 1147 |
space and time, the noumena are the mere results of the power of our |
| 1148 |
understanding, a blind but indispensable function of the soul, and the |
| 1149 |
thing in itself abstracts from all content of a posteriori knowledge. |
| 1150 |
We can deduce that, indeed, our experience, in reference to ends, can |
| 1151 |
never furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the Ideal |
| 1152 |
of practical reason, it can thereby determine in its totality |
| 1153 |
speculative principles, yet our hypothetical judgements are just as |
| 1154 |
necessary as space. It is not at all certain that, insomuch as the |
| 1155 |
Ideal of practical reason relies on the noumena, the Categories prove |
| 1156 |
the validity of philosophy, yet pure reason is the key to |
| 1157 |
understanding the Categories. This is what chiefly concerns us.} |
| 1158 |
|
| 1159 |
\@@_newpara:n {Natural causes, when thus treated as the things in |
| 1160 |
themselves, abstract from all content of a posteriori knowledge, by |
| 1161 |
means of analytic unity. Our a posteriori knowledge, in other words, |
| 1162 |
is the key to understanding the Antinomies. As we have already seen, |
| 1163 |
what we have alone been able to show is that, so far as I know, the |
| 1164 |
objects in space and time are the clue to the discovery of the |
| 1165 |
manifold. The things in themselves are the clue to the discovery of, |
| 1166 |
in the case of the Ideal of natural reason, our concepts. To avoid |
| 1167 |
all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, so far as |
| 1168 |
regards philosophy, the discipline of human reason, for these reasons, |
| 1169 |
is a body of demonstrated science, and some of it must be known a |
| 1170 |
priori, but our faculties, consequently, would thereby be made to |
| 1171 |
contradict the Antinomies. It remains a mystery why our understanding |
| 1172 |
excludes the possibility of, insomuch as the Ideal relies on the |
| 1173 |
objects in space and time, our concepts. It is not at all certain |
| 1174 |
that the pure employment of the objects in space and time (and the |
| 1175 |
reader should be careful to observe that this is true) is the clue to |
| 1176 |
the discovery of the architectonic of pure reason. Let us suppose |
| 1177 |
that natural reason is a representation of, insomuch as space relies |
| 1178 |
on the paralogisms, the Transcendental Deduction, by means of |
| 1179 |
analysis.} |
| 1180 |
|
| 1181 |
\@@_newpara:n {As we have already seen, the Ideal constitutes the |
| 1182 |
whole content for the transcendental unity of apperception. By means |
| 1183 |
of analytic unity, let us suppose that, when thus treated as space, |
| 1184 |
our synthetic judgements, therefore, would be falsified, and the |
| 1185 |
objects in space and time are what first give rise to our sense |
| 1186 |
perceptions. Let us suppose that, in the full sense of these terms, |
| 1187 |
the discipline of practical reason can not take account of our |
| 1188 |
experience, and our ideas have lying before them our inductive |
| 1189 |
judgements. (Since all of the phenomena are speculative, to avoid all |
| 1190 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the noumena |
| 1191 |
constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and some of this body must |
| 1192 |
be known a posteriori; as I have elsewhere shown, the noumena are a |
| 1193 |
representation of the noumena.) Let us suppose that practical reason |
| 1194 |
can thereby determine in its totality, by means of the Ideal, the pure |
| 1195 |
employment of the discipline of practical reason. Galileo tells us |
| 1196 |
that the employment of the phenomena can be treated like our ideas; |
| 1197 |
still, the Categories, when thus treated as the paralogisms, exist in |
| 1198 |
the employment of the Antinomies. Let us apply this to our |
| 1199 |
experience.} |
| 1200 |
|
| 1201 |
\@@_newpara:n {I assert, thus, that the discipline of natural reason |
| 1202 |
can be treated like the transcendental aesthetic, since some of the |
| 1203 |
Categories are speculative. In the case of transcendental logic, our |
| 1204 |
ideas prove the validity of our understanding, as any dedicated reader |
| 1205 |
can clearly see. In natural theology, our ideas can not take account |
| 1206 |
of general logic, because of the relation between philosophy and the |
| 1207 |
noumena. As is evident upon close examination, natural causes should |
| 1208 |
only be used as a canon for the manifold, and our faculties, in |
| 1209 |
natural theology, are a representation of natural causes. As is shown |
| 1210 |
in the writings of Aristotle, the Ideal of human reason, for these |
| 1211 |
reasons, would be falsified. What we have alone been able to show is |
| 1212 |
that the Categories, so far as regards philosophy and the Categories, |
| 1213 |
are the mere results of the power of the Transcendental Deduction, a |
| 1214 |
blind but indispensable function of the soul, as is proven in the |
| 1215 |
ontological manuals.} |
| 1216 |
|
| 1217 |
\@@_newpara:n {The noumena have nothing to do with, thus, the |
| 1218 |
Antinomies. What we have alone been able to show is that the things |
| 1219 |
in themselves constitute the whole content of human reason, as is |
| 1220 |
proven in the ontological manuals. The noumena (and to avoid all |
| 1221 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that this is the case) are |
| 1222 |
the clue to the discovery of the architectonic of natural reason. As |
| 1223 |
we have already seen, let us suppose that our experience is what first |
| 1224 |
gives rise to, therefore, the transcendental unity of apperception; in |
| 1225 |
the study of the practical employment of the Antinomies, our |
| 1226 |
ampliative judgements are what first give rise to the objects in space |
| 1227 |
and time. Necessity can never furnish a true and demonstrated |
| 1228 |
science, because, like our understanding, it can thereby determine in |
| 1229 |
its totality hypothetical principles, and the empirical objects in |
| 1230 |
space and time are what first give rise to, in all theoretical |
| 1231 |
sciences, our a posteriori concepts.} |
| 1232 |
|
| 1233 |
\@@_newpara:n {Our understanding excludes the possibility of |
| 1234 |
practical reason. Our faculties stand in need to, consequently, the |
| 1235 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions; still, the |
| 1236 |
employment of necessity is what first gives rise to general logic. |
| 1237 |
With the sole exception of applied logic, to avoid all |
| 1238 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that time, in view of |
| 1239 |
these considerations, can never furnish a true and demonstrated |
| 1240 |
science, because, like the Ideal of human reason, it is a |
| 1241 |
representation of ampliative principles, as is evident upon close |
| 1242 |
examination. Since knowledge of the paralogisms of natural reason is |
| 1243 |
a priori, I assert, consequently, that, in so far as this expounds the |
| 1244 |
practical rules of the thing in itself, the things in themselves |
| 1245 |
exclude the possibility of the discipline of pure reason, yet the |
| 1246 |
empirical objects in space and time prove the validity of natural |
| 1247 |
causes.} |
| 1248 |
|
| 1249 |
\@@_newpara:n {Because of the relation between space and the noumena, |
| 1250 |
our experience is by its very nature contradictory. It is obvious |
| 1251 |
that natural causes constitute the whole content of the transcendental |
| 1252 |
unity of apperception, as any dedicated reader can clearly see. By |
| 1253 |
virtue of pure reason, our sense perceptions, in all theoretical |
| 1254 |
sciences, have lying before them human reason. In view of these |
| 1255 |
considerations, let us suppose that the transcendental objects in |
| 1256 |
space and time, in the study of the architectonic of practical reason, |
| 1257 |
exclude the possibility of the objects in space and time, because of |
| 1258 |
our necessary ignorance of the conditions. By means of philosophy, is |
| 1259 |
it true that formal logic can not take account of the manifold, or is |
| 1260 |
the real question whether our sense perceptions are the mere results |
| 1261 |
of the power of the transcendental aesthetic, a blind but |
| 1262 |
indispensable function of the soul? The objects in space and time are |
| 1263 |
just as necessary as the Antinomies, because of the relation between |
| 1264 |
metaphysics and the things in themselves. Human reason is a |
| 1265 |
representation of the transcendental aesthetic. In my present remarks |
| 1266 |
I am referring to the pure employment of our disjunctive judgements |
| 1267 |
only in so far as it is founded on inductive principles.} |
| 1268 |
|
| 1269 |
\@@_newpara:n {What we have alone been able to show is that our sense |
| 1270 |
perceptions are the clue to the discovery of our understanding; in |
| 1271 |
natural theology, necessity, in all theoretical sciences, occupies |
| 1272 |
part of the sphere of the transcendental unity of apperception |
| 1273 |
concerning the existence of our faculties in general. The |
| 1274 |
transcendental aesthetic is what first gives rise to the never-ending |
| 1275 |
regress in the series of empirical conditions, as any dedicated reader |
| 1276 |
can clearly see. The transcendental unity of apperception is what |
| 1277 |
first gives rise to, in all theoretical sciences, the Antinomies. The |
| 1278 |
phenomena, consequently, stand in need to the things in themselves. |
| 1279 |
By means of analytic unity, necessity, on the contrary, abstracts from |
| 1280 |
all content of a priori knowledge. The phenomena (and it remains a |
| 1281 |
mystery why this is the case) are just as necessary as the Ideal of |
| 1282 |
human reason.} |
| 1283 |
|
| 1284 |
\@@_newpara:n {As any dedicated reader can clearly see, our |
| 1285 |
experience is the clue to the discovery of philosophy; in the study of |
| 1286 |
space, the Categories are what first give rise to the transcendental |
| 1287 |
aesthetic. As any dedicated reader can clearly see, the reader should |
| 1288 |
be careful to observe that, so regarded, the never-ending regress in |
| 1289 |
the series of empirical conditions, as I have elsewhere shown, is the |
| 1290 |
mere result of the power of the transcendental unity of apperception, |
| 1291 |
a blind but indispensable function of the soul, but our judgements can |
| 1292 |
be treated like time. We can deduce that the objects in space and |
| 1293 |
time are just as necessary as the objects in space and time. |
| 1294 |
Aristotle tells us that, even as this relates to time, the objects in |
| 1295 |
space and time, however, abstract from all content of a posteriori |
| 1296 |
knowledge. To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain |
| 1297 |
that the phenomena (and it is not at all certain that this is the |
| 1298 |
case) stand in need to the discipline of practical reason; thus, our |
| 1299 |
knowledge, indeed, can not take account of our ideas.} |
| 1300 |
|
| 1301 |
\@@_newpara:n {In the study of time, our concepts prove the validity |
| 1302 |
of, as I have elsewhere shown, our understanding, as any dedicated |
| 1303 |
reader can clearly see. As will easily be shown in the next section, |
| 1304 |
the reader should be careful to observe that, so far as regards our |
| 1305 |
knowledge, natural causes, so far as regards the never-ending regress |
| 1306 |
in the series of empirical conditions and our a priori judgements, |
| 1307 |
should only be used as a canon for the pure employment of the |
| 1308 |
Transcendental Deduction, and our understanding can not take account |
| 1309 |
of formal logic. As any dedicated reader can clearly see, to avoid |
| 1310 |
all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the Antinomies |
| 1311 |
are just as necessary as, on the other hand, our ideas; however, the |
| 1312 |
Ideal, in the full sense of these terms, exists in the architectonic |
| 1313 |
of human reason. As is evident upon close examination, to avoid all |
| 1314 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, in other words, our |
| 1315 |
faculties have nothing to do with the manifold, but our faculties |
| 1316 |
should only be used as a canon for space. Our faculties prove the |
| 1317 |
validity of the Antinomies, and the things in themselves (and let us |
| 1318 |
suppose that this is the case) are the clue to the discovery of our |
| 1319 |
ideas. It remains a mystery why, then, the architectonic of practical |
| 1320 |
reason proves the validity of, therefore, the noumena.} |
| 1321 |
|
| 1322 |
\@@_newpara:n {The paralogisms of practical reason can be treated |
| 1323 |
like the paralogisms. The objects in space and time, therefore, are |
| 1324 |
what first give rise to the discipline of human reason; in all |
| 1325 |
theoretical sciences, the things in themselves (and we can deduce that |
| 1326 |
this is the case) have nothing to do with metaphysics. Therefore, |
| 1327 |
Aristotle tells us that our understanding exists in the Ideal of human |
| 1328 |
reason, as is proven in the ontological manuals. Thus, our sense |
| 1329 |
perceptions (and it remains a mystery why this is the case) would |
| 1330 |
thereby be made to contradict space. I assert, on the other hand, |
| 1331 |
that, in reference to ends, the objects in space and time can not take |
| 1332 |
account of the Categories, yet natural causes are the mere results of |
| 1333 |
the power of the discipline of human reason, a blind but indispensable |
| 1334 |
function of the soul. By virtue of practical reason, it must not be |
| 1335 |
supposed that, that is to say, our faculties would thereby be made to |
| 1336 |
contradict philosophy, yet our a posteriori concepts, insomuch as the |
| 1337 |
Ideal of pure reason relies on the intelligible objects in space and |
| 1338 |
time, are by their very nature contradictory.} |
| 1339 |
|
| 1340 |
\@@_newpara:n {Time, on the contrary, can never furnish a true and |
| 1341 |
demonstrated science, because, like the transcendental aesthetic, it |
| 1342 |
constitutes the whole content for ampliative principles, yet natural |
| 1343 |
reason, even as this relates to philosophy, proves the validity of the |
| 1344 |
thing in itself. As is evident upon close examination, the Ideal of |
| 1345 |
practical reason, when thus treated as the things in themselves, is by |
| 1346 |
its very nature contradictory; as I have elsewhere shown, our |
| 1347 |
understanding may not contradict itself, but it is still possible that |
| 1348 |
it may be in contradictions with the Ideal of practical reason. Since |
| 1349 |
all of the things in themselves are problematic, it remains a mystery |
| 1350 |
why, so regarded, our knowledge is the key to understanding our |
| 1351 |
problematic judgements, but our ideas (and to avoid all |
| 1352 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that this is the case) |
| 1353 |
have lying before them our disjunctive judgements. In the case of the |
| 1354 |
Ideal, we can deduce that the transcendental unity of apperception |
| 1355 |
excludes the possibility of the manifold, as we have already seen. |
| 1356 |
Consequently, the Ideal of pure reason can be treated like the |
| 1357 |
phenomena. Let us apply this to the Transcendental Deduction.} |
| 1358 |
|
| 1359 |
\@@_newpara:n {What we have alone been able to show is that our a |
| 1360 |
posteriori concepts (and it is obvious that this is the case) are what |
| 1361 |
first give rise to the transcendental unity of apperception. In the |
| 1362 |
case of necessity, the reader should be careful to observe that |
| 1363 |
metaphysics is a representation of natural causes, by means of |
| 1364 |
analysis. In all theoretical sciences, the phenomena (and the reader |
| 1365 |
should be careful to observe that this is the case) would thereby be |
| 1366 |
made to contradict natural reason. The transcendental aesthetic, in |
| 1367 |
the case of space, is by its very nature contradictory. By virtue of |
| 1368 |
human reason, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain |
| 1369 |
that the empirical objects in space and time exist in our judgements; |
| 1370 |
for these reasons, the Antinomies, by means of our experience, can be |
| 1371 |
treated like the architectonic of human reason. It must not be |
| 1372 |
supposed that our ideas have lying before them metaphysics; |
| 1373 |
consequently, the architectonic of pure reason, in all theoretical |
| 1374 |
sciences, would be falsified.} |
| 1375 |
|
| 1376 |
\@@_newpara:n {The Transcendental Deduction stands in need of the |
| 1377 |
Ideal of pure reason, and the noumena, for these reasons, are by their |
| 1378 |
very nature contradictory. The objects in space and time have lying |
| 1379 |
before them our ideas. The transcendental unity of apperception, |
| 1380 |
indeed, proves the validity of our understanding. The architectonic |
| 1381 |
of human reason, so regarded, would be falsified, as is evident upon |
| 1382 |
close examination. Since knowledge of the noumena is a priori, Hume |
| 1383 |
tells us that, then, the Transcendental Deduction, when thus treated |
| 1384 |
as the architectonic of natural reason, abstracts from all content of |
| 1385 |
knowledge, but the objects in space and time, for these reasons, stand |
| 1386 |
in need to the transcendental aesthetic. By means of analytic unity, |
| 1387 |
natural causes exclude the possibility of, consequently, metaphysics, |
| 1388 |
and the discipline of pure reason abstracts from all content of a |
| 1389 |
priori knowledge. We thus have a pure synthesis of apprehension.} |
| 1390 |
|
| 1391 |
\@@_newpara:n {Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, |
| 1392 |
what we have alone been able to show is that formal logic can not take |
| 1393 |
account of the Categories; in the study of the transcendental |
| 1394 |
aesthetic, philosophy can thereby determine in its totality the |
| 1395 |
noumena. In all theoretical sciences, I assert that necessity has |
| 1396 |
nothing to do with our sense perceptions. Because of the relation |
| 1397 |
between our understanding and the phenomena, the Categories are what |
| 1398 |
first give rise to, so far as regards time and the phenomena, the |
| 1399 |
transcendental aesthetic; in view of these considerations, the |
| 1400 |
phenomena can not take account of the Antinomies. As is proven in the |
| 1401 |
ontological manuals, the objects in space and time (and to avoid all |
| 1402 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that this is the case) are |
| 1403 |
what first give rise to the Ideal. In natural theology, let us |
| 1404 |
suppose that the Transcendental Deduction is the key to understanding, |
| 1405 |
so far as regards the thing in itself, the Ideal, as any dedicated |
| 1406 |
reader can clearly see. This is the sense in which it is to be |
| 1407 |
understood in this work.} |
| 1408 |
|
| 1409 |
\@@_newpara:n {It must not be supposed that, in respect of the |
| 1410 |
intelligible character, the Antinomies (and we can deduce that this is |
| 1411 |
the case) constitute the whole content of the phenomena, yet the |
| 1412 |
Categories exist in natural causes. The Ideal of natural reason, when |
| 1413 |
thus treated as metaphysics, can be treated like our faculties; |
| 1414 |
consequently, pure reason (and there can be no doubt that this is |
| 1415 |
true) is what first gives rise to our sense perceptions. The |
| 1416 |
paralogisms of practical reason exist in the objects in space and |
| 1417 |
time. As we have already seen, our sense perceptions stand in need to |
| 1418 |
space. Still, our a priori concepts, in the case of metaphysics, have |
| 1419 |
nothing to do with the Categories. Because of the relation between |
| 1420 |
the discipline of practical reason and our a posteriori concepts, we |
| 1421 |
can deduce that, when thus treated as the phenomena, our sense |
| 1422 |
perceptions (and there can be no doubt that this is the case) are what |
| 1423 |
first give rise to the discipline of practical reason.} |
| 1424 |
|
| 1425 |
\@@_newpara:n {Thus, the reader should be careful to observe that the |
| 1426 |
noumena would thereby be made to contradict necessity, because of our |
| 1427 |
necessary ignorance of the conditions. Consequently, our sense |
| 1428 |
perceptions are just as necessary as the architectonic of natural |
| 1429 |
reason, as is shown in the writings of Galileo. It remains a mystery |
| 1430 |
why, when thus treated as human reason, our concepts, when thus |
| 1431 |
treated as the Categories, can never, as a whole, furnish a true and |
| 1432 |
demonstrated science, because, like the Ideal, they are just as |
| 1433 |
necessary as synthetic principles, yet our sense perceptions would be |
| 1434 |
falsified. The noumena, in all theoretical sciences, can not take |
| 1435 |
account of space, as is proven in the ontological manuals. Since |
| 1436 |
knowledge of our analytic judgements is a priori, to avoid all |
| 1437 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the paralogisms |
| 1438 |
constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and none of this body must |
| 1439 |
be known a priori; in view of these considerations, the phenomena can |
| 1440 |
not take account of, for these reasons, the transcendental unity of |
| 1441 |
apperception.} |
| 1442 |
|
| 1443 |
\@@_newpara:n {The reader should be careful to observe that, for |
| 1444 |
example, pure logic depends on the transcendental unity of |
| 1445 |
apperception. As any dedicated reader can clearly see, our a priori |
| 1446 |
concepts are what first give rise to the Categories. Hume tells us |
| 1447 |
that our ideas are just as necessary as, on the other hand, natural |
| 1448 |
causes; however, natural causes should only be used as a canon for our |
| 1449 |
faculties. For these reasons, to avoid all misapprehension, it is |
| 1450 |
necessary to explain that our ideas are the clue to the discovery of |
| 1451 |
our understanding, as is shown in the writings of Hume. (By virtue of |
| 1452 |
natural reason, the employment of our disjunctive judgements, then, is |
| 1453 |
by its very nature contradictory.) By virtue of natural reason, the |
| 1454 |
Categories can not take account of our hypothetical judgements. The |
| 1455 |
transcendental aesthetic teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the |
| 1456 |
content of, consequently, the transcendental unity of apperception, as |
| 1457 |
will easily be shown in the next section. We thus have a pure |
| 1458 |
synthesis of apprehension.} |
| 1459 |
|
| 1460 |
\@@_newpara:n {The Antinomies have nothing to do with our faculties. |
| 1461 |
As is shown in the writings of Hume, we can deduce that, on the |
| 1462 |
contrary, the empirical objects in space and time prove the validity |
| 1463 |
of our ideas. The manifold may not contradict itself, but it is still |
| 1464 |
possible that it may be in contradictions with our a posteriori |
| 1465 |
concepts. For these reasons, the transcendental objects in space and |
| 1466 |
time (and it is obvious that this is the case) have nothing to do with |
| 1467 |
our faculties, as will easily be shown in the next section. What we |
| 1468 |
have alone been able to show is that the phenomena constitute the |
| 1469 |
whole content of the Antinomies; with the sole exception of |
| 1470 |
philosophy, the Categories have lying before them formal logic. Since |
| 1471 |
knowledge of the Antinomies is a posteriori, it remains a mystery why |
| 1472 |
the Antinomies (and there can be no doubt that this is the case) prove |
| 1473 |
the validity of the thing in itself; for these reasons, metaphysics is |
| 1474 |
the mere result of the power of the employment of our sense |
| 1475 |
perceptions, a blind but indispensable function of the soul. As I |
| 1476 |
have elsewhere shown, philosophy proves the validity of our sense |
| 1477 |
perceptions.} |
| 1478 |
|
| 1479 |
\@@_newpara:n {What we have alone been able to show is that the |
| 1480 |
phenomena, so far as I know, exist in the noumena; however, our |
| 1481 |
concepts, however, exclude the possibility of our judgements. Galileo |
| 1482 |
tells us that our a posteriori knowledge would thereby be made to |
| 1483 |
contradict transcendental logic; in the case of philosophy, our |
| 1484 |
judgements stand in need to applied logic. On the other hand, to |
| 1485 |
avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the objects |
| 1486 |
in space and time exclude the possibility of, insomuch as pure logic |
| 1487 |
relies on the objects in space and time, the transcendental unity of |
| 1488 |
apperception, by virtue of practical reason. Has it ever been |
| 1489 |
suggested that, as will easily be shown in the next section, the |
| 1490 |
reader should be careful to observe that there is a causal connection |
| 1491 |
bewteen philosophy and pure reason? In natural theology, it remains a |
| 1492 |
mystery why the discipline of natural reason is a body of demonstrated |
| 1493 |
science, and some of it must be known a posteriori, as will easily be |
| 1494 |
shown in the next section. In view of these considerations, let us |
| 1495 |
suppose that our sense perceptions, then, would be falsified, because |
| 1496 |
of the relation between the never-ending regress in the series of |
| 1497 |
empirical conditions and the paralogisms. This distinction must have |
| 1498 |
some ground in the nature of the never-ending regress in the series of |
| 1499 |
empirical conditions.} |
| 1500 |
|
| 1501 |
\@@_newpara:n {To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to |
| 1502 |
explain that time excludes the possibility of the discipline of human |
| 1503 |
reason; in the study of practical reason, the manifold has nothing to |
| 1504 |
do with time. Because of the relation between our a priori knowledge |
| 1505 |
and the phenomena, what we have alone been able to show is that our |
| 1506 |
experience is what first gives rise to the phenomena; thus, natural |
| 1507 |
causes are the clue to the discovery of, with the sole exception of |
| 1508 |
our experience, the objects in space and time. Our ideas are what |
| 1509 |
first give rise to our faculties. On the other hand, the phenomena |
| 1510 |
have lying before them our ideas, as is evident upon close |
| 1511 |
examination. The paralogisms of natural reason are a representation |
| 1512 |
of, thus, the manifold. I assert that space is what first gives rise |
| 1513 |
to the paralogisms of pure reason. As is shown in the writings of |
| 1514 |
Hume, space has nothing to do with, for example, necessity.} |
| 1515 |
|
| 1516 |
\@@_newpara:n {We can deduce that the Ideal of practical reason, even |
| 1517 |
as this relates to our knowledge, is a representation of the |
| 1518 |
discipline of human reason. The things in themselves are just as |
| 1519 |
necessary as our understanding. The noumena prove the validity of the |
| 1520 |
manifold. As will easily be shown in the next section, natural causes |
| 1521 |
occupy part of the sphere of our a priori knowledge concerning the |
| 1522 |
existence of the Antinomies in general. The Categories are the clue |
| 1523 |
to the discovery of, consequently, the Transcendental Deduction. Our |
| 1524 |
ideas are the mere results of the power of the Ideal of pure reason, a |
| 1525 |
blind but indispensable function of the soul. The divisions are thus |
| 1526 |
provided; all that is required is to fill them.} |
| 1527 |
|
| 1528 |
\@@_newpara:n {The never-ending regress in the series of empirical |
| 1529 |
conditions can be treated like the objects in space and time. What we |
| 1530 |
have alone been able to show is that, then, the transcendental |
| 1531 |
aesthetic, in reference to ends, would thereby be made to contradict |
| 1532 |
the Transcendental Deduction. The architectonic of practical reason |
| 1533 |
has nothing to do with our ideas; however, time can never furnish a |
| 1534 |
true and demonstrated science, because, like the Ideal, it depends on |
| 1535 |
hypothetical principles. Space has nothing to do with the Antinomies, |
| 1536 |
because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions. In all |
| 1537 |
theoretical sciences, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to |
| 1538 |
explain that the things in themselves are a representation of, in |
| 1539 |
other words, necessity, as is evident upon close examination.} |
| 1540 |
|
| 1541 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is proven in the ontological manuals, it remains a |
| 1542 |
mystery why our experience is the mere result of the power of the |
| 1543 |
discipline of human reason, a blind but indispensable function of the |
| 1544 |
soul. For these reasons, the employment of the thing in itself |
| 1545 |
teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of the Ideal of |
| 1546 |
natural reason. In the case of transcendental logic, there can be no |
| 1547 |
doubt that the Ideal of practical reason is just as necessary as the |
| 1548 |
Antinomies. I assert that, insomuch as the Ideal relies on the |
| 1549 |
noumena, the empirical objects in space and time stand in need to our |
| 1550 |
a priori concepts. (It must not be supposed that, so regarded, our |
| 1551 |
ideas exclude the possibility of, in the case of the Ideal, the |
| 1552 |
architectonic of human reason.) The reader should be careful to |
| 1553 |
observe that, irrespective of all empirical conditions, our concepts |
| 1554 |
are what first give rise to our experience. By means of analytic |
| 1555 |
unity, our faculties, in so far as this expounds the contradictory |
| 1556 |
rules of the objects in space and time, are the mere results of the |
| 1557 |
power of space, a blind but indispensable function of the soul, and |
| 1558 |
the transcendental unity of apperception can not take account of, |
| 1559 |
however, our faculties. But at present we shall turn our attention to |
| 1560 |
the thing in itself.} |
| 1561 |
|
| 1562 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is evident upon close examination, we can deduce |
| 1563 |
that the transcendental unity of apperception depends on the Ideal of |
| 1564 |
practical reason. Certainly, it is obvious that the Antinomies, in |
| 1565 |
accordance with the principles of the objects in space and time, |
| 1566 |
constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and none of this body must |
| 1567 |
be known a posteriori. Because of the relation between the discipline |
| 1568 |
of pure reason and our a posteriori concepts, I assert that, for |
| 1569 |
example, metaphysics, consequently, is by its very nature |
| 1570 |
contradictory, yet the transcendental aesthetic is the key to |
| 1571 |
understanding our understanding. By virtue of natural reason, the |
| 1572 |
objects in space and time are what first give rise to, when thus |
| 1573 |
treated as the paralogisms of human reason, the things in themselves, |
| 1574 |
but the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions can |
| 1575 |
not take account of the architectonic of human reason. What we have |
| 1576 |
alone been able to show is that natural causes, irrespective of all |
| 1577 |
empirical conditions, exist in the objects in space and time, as is |
| 1578 |
shown in the writings of Hume. By virtue of practical reason, our |
| 1579 |
sense perceptions are what first give rise to, irrespective of all |
| 1580 |
empirical conditions, necessity. Our sense perceptions, in the study |
| 1581 |
of necessity, would thereby be made to contradict transcendental |
| 1582 |
logic; consequently, natural reason stands in need of the objects in |
| 1583 |
space and time. There can be no doubt that, in other words, the |
| 1584 |
paralogisms of natural reason have nothing to do with the thing in |
| 1585 |
itself, but the paralogisms prove the validity of transcendental |
| 1586 |
logic.} |
| 1587 |
|
| 1588 |
\@@_newpara:n {We can deduce that, then, the noumena are just as |
| 1589 |
necessary as, so regarded, the practical employment of the objects in |
| 1590 |
space and time. It is obvious that the manifold has nothing to do |
| 1591 |
with our ideas; with the sole exception of the employment of the |
| 1592 |
noumena, natural reason, in natural theology, is the mere result of |
| 1593 |
the power of time, a blind but indispensable function of the soul. |
| 1594 |
Because of the relation between our understanding and the things in |
| 1595 |
themselves, it is not at all certain that, so far as regards the |
| 1596 |
transcendental unity of apperception and the paralogisms, the |
| 1597 |
phenomena can not take account of, so regarded, our sense perceptions, |
| 1598 |
yet our sense perceptions can never, as a whole, furnish a true and |
| 1599 |
demonstrated science, because, like time, they constitute the whole |
| 1600 |
content of analytic principles. Since knowledge of our sense |
| 1601 |
perceptions is a posteriori, it is obvious that, in accordance with |
| 1602 |
the principles of our faculties, metaphysics excludes the possibility |
| 1603 |
of the manifold, and the Ideal may not contradict itself, but it is |
| 1604 |
still possible that it may be in contradictions with, thus, our sense |
| 1605 |
perceptions. To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain |
| 1606 |
that our ideas exclude the possibility of, irrespective of all |
| 1607 |
empirical conditions, our ideas. Let us apply this to space.} |
| 1608 |
|
| 1609 |
\@@_newpara:n {It remains a mystery why our sense perceptions prove |
| 1610 |
the validity of our a priori concepts. The objects in space and time, |
| 1611 |
then, exist in metaphysics; therefore, the things in themselves can |
| 1612 |
not take account of the transcendental aesthetic. The Ideal of pure |
| 1613 |
reason can thereby determine in its totality, that is to say, our |
| 1614 |
ideas, and space constitutes the whole content for the discipline of |
| 1615 |
human reason. The paralogisms of pure reason are just as necessary |
| 1616 |
as, in all theoretical sciences, our knowledge. The things in |
| 1617 |
themselves constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and some of |
| 1618 |
this body must be known a posteriori.} |
| 1619 |
|
| 1620 |
\@@_newpara:n {As will easily be shown in the next section, the |
| 1621 |
Transcendental Deduction exists in the Ideal. To avoid all |
| 1622 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that pure reason (and it |
| 1623 |
is obvious that this is true) is the key to understanding the |
| 1624 |
transcendental unity of apperception. The reader should be careful to |
| 1625 |
observe that our experience depends on necessity. It is obvious that |
| 1626 |
space, thus, can be treated like the objects in space and time, |
| 1627 |
because of the relation between the transcendental unity of |
| 1628 |
apperception and the objects in space and time. It must not be |
| 1629 |
supposed that, even as this relates to natural reason, the Antinomies |
| 1630 |
(and it remains a mystery why this is the case) exclude the |
| 1631 |
possibility of the empirical objects in space and time, yet philosophy |
| 1632 |
proves the validity of practical reason. The things in themselves, on |
| 1633 |
the contrary, abstract from all content of a posteriori knowledge; in |
| 1634 |
all theoretical sciences, the noumena (and there can be no doubt that |
| 1635 |
this is the case) are just as necessary as the Antinomies. As is |
| 1636 |
shown in the writings of Galileo, I assert, in natural theology, that |
| 1637 |
the transcendental aesthetic, thus, exists in our faculties. Our |
| 1638 |
faculties are just as necessary as the Categories, yet the manifold |
| 1639 |
has lying before it, certainly, our understanding.} |
| 1640 |
|
| 1641 |
\@@_newpara:n {It is obvious that the never-ending regress in the |
| 1642 |
series of empirical conditions may not contradict itself, but it is |
| 1643 |
still possible that it may be in contradictions with the architectonic |
| 1644 |
of practical reason. The objects in space and time, so regarded, |
| 1645 |
should only be used as a canon for the architectonic of human reason, |
| 1646 |
as is proven in the ontological manuals. In all theoretical sciences, |
| 1647 |
the Antinomies can not take account of our concepts, because of our |
| 1648 |
necessary ignorance of the conditions. By means of analysis, the |
| 1649 |
things in themselves are a representation of our experience; for these |
| 1650 |
reasons, the paralogisms of practical reason have lying before them |
| 1651 |
our inductive judgements. Still, the architectonic of pure reason is |
| 1652 |
just as necessary as the never-ending regress in the series of |
| 1653 |
empirical conditions.} |
| 1654 |
|
| 1655 |
\@@_newpara:n {Thus, transcendental logic (and I assert, for these |
| 1656 |
reasons, that this is true) depends on the Antinomies. Still, general |
| 1657 |
logic (and it remains a mystery why this is true) is what first gives |
| 1658 |
rise to the objects in space and time, because of the relation between |
| 1659 |
metaphysics and the Antinomies. As will easily be shown in the next |
| 1660 |
section, the paralogisms constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, |
| 1661 |
and some of this body must be known a priori. On the other hand, the |
| 1662 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, in the |
| 1663 |
case of the Transcendental Deduction, exists in the noumena, as is |
| 1664 |
proven in the ontological manuals. By means of analytic unity, it |
| 1665 |
remains a mystery why our judgements are by their very nature |
| 1666 |
contradictory; however, the objects in space and time exclude the |
| 1667 |
possibility of the Categories. As any dedicated reader can clearly |
| 1668 |
see, the Antinomies would thereby be made to contradict the |
| 1669 |
transcendental aesthetic; in natural theology, our faculties |
| 1670 |
constitute the whole content of, for these reasons, the noumena. |
| 1671 |
However, the objects in space and time are what first give rise to our |
| 1672 |
understanding, because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions.} |
| 1673 |
|
| 1674 |
\@@_newpara:n {On the other hand, the Antinomies have nothing to do |
| 1675 |
with pure reason, because of our necessary ignorance of the |
| 1676 |
conditions. Our speculative judgements are what first give rise to |
| 1677 |
the Categories. Time is the key to understanding natural causes, as |
| 1678 |
is evident upon close examination. Galileo tells us that the objects |
| 1679 |
in space and time, irrespective of all empirical conditions, should |
| 1680 |
only be used as a canon for our sense perceptions, since knowledge of |
| 1681 |
the noumena is a priori. I assert that the Transcendental Deduction |
| 1682 |
depends on our concepts. By means of analytic unity, our sense |
| 1683 |
perceptions constitute the whole content of the manifold. In natural |
| 1684 |
theology, the discipline of natural reason, on the other hand, would |
| 1685 |
be falsified, as any dedicated reader can clearly see.} |
| 1686 |
|
| 1687 |
\@@_newpara:n {In the case of the discipline of human reason, it is |
| 1688 |
obvious that the phenomena, still, are the mere results of the power |
| 1689 |
of the practical employment of the Transcendental Deduction, a blind |
| 1690 |
but indispensable function of the soul, by means of analysis. As any |
| 1691 |
dedicated reader can clearly see, Aristotle tells us that natural |
| 1692 |
causes constitute the whole content of, as I have elsewhere shown, the |
| 1693 |
pure employment of the paralogisms. Aristotle tells us that, |
| 1694 |
irrespective of all empirical conditions, the thing in itself, indeed, |
| 1695 |
can never furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the |
| 1696 |
architectonic of practical reason, it has lying before it analytic |
| 1697 |
principles, yet the Categories have nothing to do with the objects in |
| 1698 |
space and time. Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, |
| 1699 |
human reason is just as necessary as our concepts, yet the practical |
| 1700 |
employment of the paralogisms is the mere result of the power of |
| 1701 |
metaphysics, a blind but indispensable function of the soul. For |
| 1702 |
these reasons, Hume tells us that natural causes have nothing to do |
| 1703 |
with the transcendental unity of apperception, by means of analytic |
| 1704 |
unity. The Antinomies can not take account of the Antinomies, because |
| 1705 |
of our necessary ignorance of the conditions. I assert, in all |
| 1706 |
theoretical sciences, that, that is to say, natural causes would |
| 1707 |
thereby be made to contradict, so regarded, the Ideal of natural |
| 1708 |
reason. Hume tells us that our ideas abstract from all content of a |
| 1709 |
posteriori knowledge, as is evident upon close examination.} |
| 1710 |
|
| 1711 |
\@@_newpara:n {The manifold is a representation of the phenomena. |
| 1712 |
Our judgements constitute the whole content of, on the other hand, the |
| 1713 |
things in themselves, as will easily be shown in the next section. By |
| 1714 |
means of analytic unity, the phenomena, in the full sense of these |
| 1715 |
terms, should only be used as a canon for the Ideal of human reason. |
| 1716 |
It is obvious that, so far as regards metaphysics and our judgements, |
| 1717 |
pure reason (and there can be no doubt that this is true) is the key |
| 1718 |
to understanding time. In the study of formal logic, the paralogisms |
| 1719 |
of pure reason are the clue to the discovery of, thus, the manifold.} |
| 1720 |
|
| 1721 |
\@@_newpara:n {There can be no doubt that the never-ending regress in |
| 1722 |
the series of empirical conditions may not contradict itself, but it |
| 1723 |
is still possible that it may be in contradictions with, indeed, our |
| 1724 |
sense perceptions. As is proven in the ontological manuals, the |
| 1725 |
architectonic of practical reason proves the validity of, in all |
| 1726 |
theoretical sciences, metaphysics; in view of these considerations, |
| 1727 |
our knowledge depends on our faculties. Since knowledge of our sense |
| 1728 |
perceptions is a priori, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary |
| 1729 |
to explain that natural reason is what first gives rise to our |
| 1730 |
faculties. There can be no doubt that, in the full sense of these |
| 1731 |
terms, the Antinomies exclude the possibility of the Transcendental |
| 1732 |
Deduction. (In view of these considerations, the empirical objects in |
| 1733 |
space and time are by their very nature contradictory.) It is obvious |
| 1734 |
that the objects in space and time can not take account of the |
| 1735 |
transcendental objects in space and time, as is proven in the |
| 1736 |
ontological manuals. As is evident upon close examination, what we |
| 1737 |
have alone been able to show is that the objects in space and time are |
| 1738 |
the mere results of the power of time, a blind but indispensable |
| 1739 |
function of the soul. The divisions are thus provided; all that is |
| 1740 |
required is to fill them.} |
| 1741 |
|
| 1742 |
\@@_newpara:n {As we have already seen, the Antinomies are a |
| 1743 |
representation of the Categories. Necessity stands in need of the |
| 1744 |
Antinomies. By virtue of natural reason, the Antinomies have lying |
| 1745 |
before them the Ideal of pure reason; on the other hand, the |
| 1746 |
Antinomies have nothing to do with natural causes. As I have |
| 1747 |
elsewhere shown, the reader should be careful to observe that the |
| 1748 |
things in themselves would thereby be made to contradict, in so far as |
| 1749 |
this expounds the universal rules of our faculties, our ideas. I |
| 1750 |
assert that, in so far as this expounds the necessary rules of human |
| 1751 |
reason, our concepts (and we can deduce that this is the case) prove |
| 1752 |
the validity of space, but our sense perceptions, so far as regards |
| 1753 |
the transcendental unity of apperception, can never, as a whole, |
| 1754 |
furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the |
| 1755 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, they have |
| 1756 |
nothing to do with disjunctive principles. But we have fallen short |
| 1757 |
of the necessary interconnection that we have in mind when we speak of |
| 1758 |
necessity.} |
| 1759 |
|
| 1760 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is evident upon close examination, the paralogisms |
| 1761 |
abstract from all content of a posteriori knowledge. Consequently, |
| 1762 |
the transcendental aesthetic, in reference to ends, occupies part of |
| 1763 |
the sphere of metaphysics concerning the existence of the Categories |
| 1764 |
in general. The objects in space and time, in particular, constitute |
| 1765 |
a body of demonstrated doctrine, and all of this body must be known a |
| 1766 |
posteriori; by means of the thing in itself, the noumena can be |
| 1767 |
treated like the thing in itself. The things in themselves, for |
| 1768 |
example, are the mere results of the power of philosophy, a blind but |
| 1769 |
indispensable function of the soul, as is shown in the writings of |
| 1770 |
Aristotle. As will easily be shown in the next section, it must not |
| 1771 |
be supposed that, in the full sense of these terms, our faculties, in |
| 1772 |
view of these considerations, constitute the whole content of the |
| 1773 |
objects in space and time, and our sense perceptions, in respect of |
| 1774 |
the intelligible character, can be treated like space. Because of our |
| 1775 |
necessary ignorance of the conditions, Hume tells us that the |
| 1776 |
manifold, irrespective of all empirical conditions, is what first |
| 1777 |
gives rise to space.} |
| 1778 |
|
| 1779 |
\@@_newpara:n {In view of these considerations, our experience |
| 1780 |
occupies part of the sphere of the Ideal concerning the existence of |
| 1781 |
the objects in space and time in general, as will easily be shown in |
| 1782 |
the next section. It must not be supposed that our ideas (and it |
| 1783 |
remains a mystery why this is the case) are a representation of the |
| 1784 |
intelligible objects in space and time. Consequently, the |
| 1785 |
Transcendental Deduction can thereby determine in its totality, in |
| 1786 |
other words, our ideas, because of our necessary ignorance of the |
| 1787 |
conditions. (In natural theology, our concepts abstract from all |
| 1788 |
content of a priori knowledge, as is proven in the ontological |
| 1789 |
manuals.) I assert, in the case of the manifold, that human reason is |
| 1790 |
a body of demonstrated science, and all of it must be known a |
| 1791 |
posteriori, by virtue of human reason. As is proven in the |
| 1792 |
ontological manuals, Aristotle tells us that the thing in itself, so |
| 1793 |
far as I know, can never furnish a true and demonstrated science, |
| 1794 |
because, like the architectonic of pure reason, it is just as |
| 1795 |
necessary as a priori principles.} |
| 1796 |
|
| 1797 |
\@@_newpara:n {To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to |
| 1798 |
explain that philosophy can not take account of our sense perceptions; |
| 1799 |
in the study of the discipline of natural reason, our experience, in |
| 1800 |
the study of the architectonic of practical reason, is the mere result |
| 1801 |
of the power of pure logic, a blind but indispensable function of the |
| 1802 |
soul. As is evident upon close examination, the noumena are what |
| 1803 |
first give rise to, on the contrary, the phenomena, but natural |
| 1804 |
reason, that is to say, excludes the possibility of our hypothetical |
| 1805 |
judgements. The objects in space and time are the clue to the |
| 1806 |
discovery of the thing in itself, because of our necessary ignorance |
| 1807 |
of the conditions. Therefore, there can be no doubt that the |
| 1808 |
architectonic of practical reason depends on the Antinomies, because |
| 1809 |
of our necessary ignorance of the conditions. Human reason (and there |
| 1810 |
can be no doubt that this is true) depends on our understanding, but |
| 1811 |
the Ideal can thereby determine in its totality metaphysics.} |
| 1812 |
|
| 1813 |
\@@_newpara:n {Since knowledge of the objects in space and time is a |
| 1814 |
posteriori, general logic, in respect of the intelligible character, |
| 1815 |
is by its very nature contradictory. By means of analytic unity, it |
| 1816 |
is not at all certain that space, insomuch as our understanding relies |
| 1817 |
on our sense perceptions, would thereby be made to contradict the |
| 1818 |
Ideal. By virtue of natural reason, the Antinomies are just as |
| 1819 |
necessary as, indeed, the thing in itself. The manifold, as I have |
| 1820 |
elsewhere shown, is a body of demonstrated science, and some of it |
| 1821 |
must be known a priori. There can be no doubt that, in particular, |
| 1822 |
the phenomena are a representation of pure logic, yet our sense |
| 1823 |
perceptions have lying before them our sense perceptions. I assert, |
| 1824 |
as I have elsewhere shown, that, indeed, our experience (and let us |
| 1825 |
suppose that this is true) excludes the possibility of the objects in |
| 1826 |
space and time, and the discipline of human reason, in accordance with |
| 1827 |
the principles of the transcendental unity of apperception, occupies |
| 1828 |
part of the sphere of our understanding concerning the existence of |
| 1829 |
the phenomena in general.} |
| 1830 |
|
| 1831 |
\@@_newpara:n {Human reason (and we can deduce that this is true) |
| 1832 |
proves the validity of the architectonic of natural reason. To avoid |
| 1833 |
all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the employment of |
| 1834 |
the things in themselves can not take account of the phenomena. The |
| 1835 |
transcendental aesthetic, on the contrary, can be treated like the |
| 1836 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions; certainly, |
| 1837 |
our faculties constitute the whole content of, in particular, the |
| 1838 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions. What we |
| 1839 |
have alone been able to show is that, then, the objects in space and |
| 1840 |
time stand in need to metaphysics, and our experience, in accordance |
| 1841 |
with the principles of time, stands in need of the never-ending |
| 1842 |
regress in the series of empirical conditions. Since knowledge of our |
| 1843 |
ideas is a posteriori, the phenomena are a representation of the |
| 1844 |
phenomena.} |
| 1845 |
|
| 1846 |
\@@_newpara:n {Necessity, as I have elsewhere shown, is the mere |
| 1847 |
result of the power of the architectonic of practical reason, a blind |
| 1848 |
but indispensable function of the soul. The paralogisms of pure |
| 1849 |
reason are the clue to the discovery of the practical employment of |
| 1850 |
the thing in itself. There can be no doubt that the never-ending |
| 1851 |
regress in the series of empirical conditions has lying before it the |
| 1852 |
paralogisms of human reason; with the sole exception of the |
| 1853 |
architectonic of pure reason, transcendental logic is just as |
| 1854 |
necessary as, then, our judgements. What we have alone been able to |
| 1855 |
show is that our synthetic judgements have lying before them, when |
| 1856 |
thus treated as space, our knowledge, by means of analysis. By virtue |
| 1857 |
of natural reason, the transcendental aesthetic can be treated like |
| 1858 |
general logic, yet the objects in space and time are just as necessary |
| 1859 |
as the noumena. } |
| 1860 |
|
| 1861 |
\@@_newpara:n {In view of these considerations, let us suppose that |
| 1862 |
the Categories exclude the possibility of the never-ending regress in |
| 1863 |
the series of empirical conditions. The manifold occupies part of the |
| 1864 |
sphere of the thing in itself concerning the existence of the things |
| 1865 |
in themselves in general, and formal logic, indeed, would be |
| 1866 |
falsified. It is not at all certain that, in reference to ends, the |
| 1867 |
discipline of practical reason, for example, occupies part of the |
| 1868 |
sphere of the discipline of practical reason concerning the existence |
| 1869 |
of our ampliative judgements in general, yet general logic is by its |
| 1870 |
very nature contradictory. Since all of our judgements are a priori, |
| 1871 |
there can be no doubt that, in the full sense of these terms, the |
| 1872 |
phenomena can not take account of the transcendental objects in space |
| 1873 |
and time. The architectonic of pure reason (and it is not at all |
| 1874 |
certain that this is true) stands in need of the things in themselves. |
| 1875 |
Philosophy is the key to understanding, thus, our sense perceptions. |
| 1876 |
This is what chiefly concerns us.} |
| 1877 |
|
| 1878 |
\@@_newpara:n {Our understanding would thereby be made to contradict, |
| 1879 |
so far as regards the Ideal, necessity. Our faculties, as I have |
| 1880 |
elsewhere shown, are the mere results of the power of time, a blind |
| 1881 |
but indispensable function of the soul. Time, with the sole exception |
| 1882 |
of formal logic, would be falsified, but the Ideal can not take |
| 1883 |
account of our sense perceptions. It is not at all certain that the |
| 1884 |
Antinomies are what first give rise to our experience; thus, our a |
| 1885 |
posteriori concepts are the clue to the discovery of, so regarded, the |
| 1886 |
practical employment of the Transcendental Deduction. Natural causes |
| 1887 |
occupy part of the sphere of practical reason concerning the existence |
| 1888 |
of the paralogisms of pure reason in general; in view of these |
| 1889 |
considerations, the noumena exclude the possibility of the employment |
| 1890 |
of the objects in space and time. The manifold is what first gives |
| 1891 |
rise to the paralogisms, but our judgements are the clue to the |
| 1892 |
discovery of, in the study of the thing in itself, the discipline of |
| 1893 |
practical reason.} |
| 1894 |
|
| 1895 |
\@@_newpara:n {Our a priori concepts, with the sole exception of our |
| 1896 |
experience, have lying before them our judgements. It must not be |
| 1897 |
supposed that the Antinomies are a representation of the discipline of |
| 1898 |
human reason, by means of analytic unity. In the study of the |
| 1899 |
transcendental aesthetic, the paralogisms constitute a body of |
| 1900 |
demonstrated doctrine, and some of this body must be known a |
| 1901 |
posteriori. The Categories are the mere results of the power of the |
| 1902 |
thing in itself, a blind but indispensable function of the soul. |
| 1903 |
Because of the relation between pure reason and the paralogisms of |
| 1904 |
human reason, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain |
| 1905 |
that, indeed, the objects in space and time (and to avoid all |
| 1906 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that this is the case) are |
| 1907 |
a representation of our concepts, yet the Ideal can be treated like |
| 1908 |
our inductive judgements. As is proven in the ontological manuals, |
| 1909 |
our understanding would thereby be made to contradict, thus, the |
| 1910 |
Transcendental Deduction; as I have elsewhere shown, the phenomena |
| 1911 |
abstract from all content of knowledge. The thing in itself excludes |
| 1912 |
the possibility of philosophy; therefore, space, for example, teaches |
| 1913 |
us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of metaphysics. We can |
| 1914 |
deduce that the noumena (and it must not be supposed that this is the |
| 1915 |
case) are a representation of the transcendental unity of |
| 1916 |
apperception; with the sole exception of the thing in itself, our |
| 1917 |
sense perceptions, as I have elsewhere shown, can never, as a whole, |
| 1918 |
furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the |
| 1919 |
transcendental unity of apperception, they exclude the possibility of |
| 1920 |
hypothetical principles.} |
| 1921 |
|
| 1922 |
\@@_newpara:n {Since none of our faculties are speculative, our ideas |
| 1923 |
should only be used as a canon for time. With the sole exception of |
| 1924 |
the manifold, our concepts exclude the possibility of the practical |
| 1925 |
employment of metaphysics, by means of analysis. Aristotle tells us |
| 1926 |
that necessity (and it is obvious that this is true) would thereby be |
| 1927 |
made to contradict the thing in itself, because of our necessary |
| 1928 |
ignorance of the conditions. As is proven in the ontological manuals, |
| 1929 |
metaphysics (and it remains a mystery why this is true) can thereby |
| 1930 |
determine in its totality the Ideal. In the study of the |
| 1931 |
transcendental unity of apperception, it is obvious that the phenomena |
| 1932 |
have nothing to do with, therefore, natural causes, by means of |
| 1933 |
analysis. Has it ever been suggested that it must not be supposed |
| 1934 |
that there is no relation bewteen the paralogisms of practical reason |
| 1935 |
and the Antinomies? Time, indeed, is a representation of the |
| 1936 |
Antinomies. The paralogisms of human reason are the clue to the |
| 1937 |
discovery of natural causes, by means of analysis. Let us suppose |
| 1938 |
that, in other words, the manifold, that is to say, abstracts from all |
| 1939 |
content of knowledge.} |
| 1940 |
|
| 1941 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is proven in the ontological manuals, Aristotle |
| 1942 |
tells us that the transcendental unity of apperception can be treated |
| 1943 |
like the discipline of pure reason; in the case of our understanding, |
| 1944 |
our sense perceptions are just as necessary as the noumena. The |
| 1945 |
reader should be careful to observe that the discipline of human |
| 1946 |
reason occupies part of the sphere of our understanding concerning the |
| 1947 |
existence of natural causes in general. The noumena prove the |
| 1948 |
validity of philosophy, and the paralogisms of human reason exclude |
| 1949 |
the possibility of our sense perceptions. Our faculties exist in our |
| 1950 |
a posteriori concepts; still, the never-ending regress in the series |
| 1951 |
of empirical conditions has lying before it necessity. Since |
| 1952 |
knowledge of our sense perceptions is a posteriori, the transcendental |
| 1953 |
aesthetic can never furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, |
| 1954 |
like the transcendental aesthetic, it has nothing to do with |
| 1955 |
ampliative principles. Transcendental logic exists in our faculties.} |
| 1956 |
|
| 1957 |
\@@_newpara:n {There can be no doubt that the objects in space and |
| 1958 |
time have nothing to do with our judgements. The architectonic of |
| 1959 |
human reason has nothing to do with the noumena. What we have alone |
| 1960 |
been able to show is that natural causes have nothing to do with, |
| 1961 |
still, our a priori concepts, as we have already seen. As any |
| 1962 |
dedicated reader can clearly see, it remains a mystery why, for |
| 1963 |
example, our ideas, with the sole exception of the thing in itself, |
| 1964 |
can not take account of the objects in space and time. It remains a |
| 1965 |
mystery why our faculties are a representation of the transcendental |
| 1966 |
aesthetic. Our ideas, in reference to ends, can never, as a whole, |
| 1967 |
furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the discipline |
| 1968 |
of natural reason, they are a representation of synthetic principles. |
| 1969 |
The transcendental unity of apperception is just as necessary as, in |
| 1970 |
view of these considerations, our ampliative judgements; with the sole |
| 1971 |
exception of the transcendental aesthetic, the thing in itself (and it |
| 1972 |
remains a mystery why this is true) is the clue to the discovery of |
| 1973 |
our speculative judgements.} |
| 1974 |
|
| 1975 |
\@@_newpara:n {As I have elsewhere shown, the Ideal is a body of |
| 1976 |
demonstrated science, and some of it must be known a priori, as is |
| 1977 |
evident upon close examination. Our ideas abstract from all content |
| 1978 |
of knowledge, and the phenomena have nothing to do with, then, |
| 1979 |
necessity. As is proven in the ontological manuals, the empirical |
| 1980 |
objects in space and time exclude the possibility of, in other words, |
| 1981 |
our sense perceptions. It must not be supposed that, then, the |
| 1982 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions stands in |
| 1983 |
need of, certainly, the Ideal of natural reason, yet pure reason can |
| 1984 |
not take account of the objects in space and time. The noumena, in |
| 1985 |
all theoretical sciences, prove the validity of the practical |
| 1986 |
employment of the manifold; in natural theology, the phenomena are |
| 1987 |
just as necessary as the paralogisms. It is not at all certain that |
| 1988 |
our concepts have lying before them our faculties, by means of |
| 1989 |
analytic unity. It is not at all certain that the architectonic of |
| 1990 |
practical reason, then, is what first gives rise to necessity; still, |
| 1991 |
our concepts stand in need to the objects in space and time.} |
| 1992 |
|
| 1993 |
\@@_newpara:n {It must not be supposed that our sense perceptions are |
| 1994 |
the clue to the discovery of the Antinomies. As will easily be shown |
| 1995 |
in the next section, our experience, in particular, excludes the |
| 1996 |
possibility of natural causes, yet the architectonic of human reason |
| 1997 |
can never furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like |
| 1998 |
philosophy, it can thereby determine in its totality problematic |
| 1999 |
principles. Let us suppose that, even as this relates to philosophy, |
| 2000 |
our a posteriori concepts, in view of these considerations, exist in |
| 2001 |
natural causes, yet space may not contradict itself, but it is still |
| 2002 |
possible that it may be in contradictions with the Categories. (The |
| 2003 |
thing in itself, in all theoretical sciences, exists in our ideas.) |
| 2004 |
Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, let us suppose |
| 2005 |
that the things in themselves should only be used as a canon for the |
| 2006 |
things in themselves; certainly, our ideas, therefore, abstract from |
| 2007 |
all content of a priori knowledge. Necessity constitutes the whole |
| 2008 |
content for practical reason. But we have fallen short of the |
| 2009 |
necessary interconnection that we have in mind when we speak of the |
| 2010 |
transcendental aesthetic. } |
| 2011 |
|
| 2012 |
\@@_newpara:n {As we have already seen, Aristotle tells us that, when |
| 2013 |
thus treated as the phenomena, the transcendental unity of |
| 2014 |
apperception can thereby determine in its totality the Ideal of human |
| 2015 |
reason. There can be no doubt that natural causes can not take |
| 2016 |
account of, certainly, the phenomena, since none of the paralogisms |
| 2017 |
are hypothetical. We can deduce that the transcendental aesthetic is |
| 2018 |
a body of demonstrated science, and none of it must be known a priori. |
| 2019 |
Hume tells us that, for example, our a posteriori knowledge |
| 2020 |
constitutes the whole content for our sense perceptions, yet the |
| 2021 |
discipline of pure reason, when thus treated as our understanding, |
| 2022 |
constitutes the whole content for the empirical objects in space and |
| 2023 |
time. The discipline of pure reason occupies part of the sphere of |
| 2024 |
the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions |
| 2025 |
concerning the existence of the things in themselves in general; |
| 2026 |
consequently, the architectonic of natural reason (and what we have |
| 2027 |
alone been able to show is that this is true) is the clue to the |
| 2028 |
discovery of the objects in space and time.} |
| 2029 |
|
| 2030 |
\@@_newpara:n {In the case of the Transcendental Deduction, our ideas |
| 2031 |
would thereby be made to contradict, in natural theology, the objects |
| 2032 |
in space and time. In all theoretical sciences, it remains a mystery |
| 2033 |
why the employment of our understanding has nothing to do with the |
| 2034 |
Categories. In the case of the never-ending regress in the series of |
| 2035 |
empirical conditions, it remains a mystery why natural causes can not |
| 2036 |
take account of the phenomena. By means of analysis, space would |
| 2037 |
thereby be made to contradict the objects in space and time; in |
| 2038 |
natural theology, the objects in space and time are a representation |
| 2039 |
of, in view of these considerations, our faculties. I assert that our |
| 2040 |
concepts would thereby be made to contradict, so far as I know, the |
| 2041 |
Transcendental Deduction. As is shown in the writings of Galileo, to |
| 2042 |
avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the objects |
| 2043 |
in space and time are the clue to the discovery of, therefore, |
| 2044 |
necessity; on the other hand, philosophy occupies part of the sphere |
| 2045 |
of the Transcendental Deduction concerning the existence of the |
| 2046 |
intelligible objects in space and time in general.} |
| 2047 |
|
| 2048 |
\@@_newpara:n {Still, time is by its very nature contradictory. The |
| 2049 |
paralogisms of practical reason constitute a body of demonstrated |
| 2050 |
doctrine, and none of this body must be known a priori; for these |
| 2051 |
reasons, the noumena are the mere results of the power of the |
| 2052 |
transcendental aesthetic, a blind but indispensable function of the |
| 2053 |
soul. On the other hand, Aristotle tells us that our a posteriori |
| 2054 |
concepts are the clue to the discovery of, thus, the transcendental |
| 2055 |
unity of apperception. As any dedicated reader can clearly see, the |
| 2056 |
discipline of pure reason can not take account of our faculties. It |
| 2057 |
must not be supposed that the Ideal, in particular, can never furnish |
| 2058 |
a true and demonstrated science, because, like time, it is the clue to |
| 2059 |
the discovery of problematic principles, since knowledge of the |
| 2060 |
objects in space and time is a priori. The Categories are what first |
| 2061 |
give rise to the Transcendental Deduction.} |
| 2062 |
|
| 2063 |
\@@_newpara:n {Our faculties, in the full sense of these terms, exist |
| 2064 |
in the noumena, because of the relation between space and the |
| 2065 |
phenomena. Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, the |
| 2066 |
paralogisms of practical reason are a representation of, indeed, our |
| 2067 |
understanding; in view of these considerations, the objects in space |
| 2068 |
and time, certainly, would be falsified. Let us suppose that, when |
| 2069 |
thus treated as philosophy, metaphysics is a body of demonstrated |
| 2070 |
science, and none of it must be known a priori, and our judgements |
| 2071 |
stand in need to, then, our ideas. The reader should be careful to |
| 2072 |
observe that the objects in space and time constitute the whole |
| 2073 |
content of, in accordance with the principles of our faculties, pure |
| 2074 |
logic; therefore, the things in themselves, however, are the mere |
| 2075 |
results of the power of pure reason, a blind but indispensable |
| 2076 |
function of the soul. There can be no doubt that our understanding |
| 2077 |
can never furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like time, |
| 2078 |
it may not contradict itself, but it is still possible that it may be |
| 2079 |
in contradictions with disjunctive principles; by means of our |
| 2080 |
knowledge, formal logic would thereby be made to contradict the |
| 2081 |
noumena.} |
| 2082 |
|
| 2083 |
\@@_newpara:n {Since all of our a posteriori concepts are synthetic, |
| 2084 |
applied logic has nothing to do with, for example, the noumena. With |
| 2085 |
the sole exception of philosophy, the Ideal of practical reason is |
| 2086 |
what first gives rise to our ideas, as is evident upon close |
| 2087 |
examination. The reader should be careful to observe that the pure |
| 2088 |
employment of our understanding is what first gives rise to the |
| 2089 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, by virtue |
| 2090 |
of natural reason. By virtue of natural reason, there can be no doubt |
| 2091 |
that, irrespective of all empirical conditions, the architectonic of |
| 2092 |
natural reason (and we can deduce that this is true) has nothing to do |
| 2093 |
with space, but our judgements (and what we have alone been able to |
| 2094 |
show is that this is the case) are the clue to the discovery of the |
| 2095 |
paralogisms of human reason. (The things in themselves, however, |
| 2096 |
exist in the thing in itself, and natural causes can not take account |
| 2097 |
of the objects in space and time.) We can deduce that the thing in |
| 2098 |
itself has lying before it the Transcendental Deduction, by virtue of |
| 2099 |
pure reason. As any dedicated reader can clearly see, to avoid all |
| 2100 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, in other words, the |
| 2101 |
objects in space and time can not take account of the noumena, but the |
| 2102 |
empirical objects in space and time, with the sole exception of |
| 2103 |
metaphysics, exist in the empirical objects in space and time. } |
| 2104 |
|
| 2105 |
\@@_newpara:n {On the other hand, the reader should be careful to |
| 2106 |
observe that the Transcendental Deduction can never furnish a true and |
| 2107 |
demonstrated science, because, like our experience, it would thereby |
| 2108 |
be made to contradict synthetic principles. The pure employment of |
| 2109 |
the Ideal, indeed, is a representation of the paralogisms of human |
| 2110 |
reason. Certainly, the phenomena should only be used as a canon for |
| 2111 |
the thing in itself. The Ideal, in so far as this expounds the |
| 2112 |
universal rules of the noumena, can be treated like practical reason. |
| 2113 |
To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the |
| 2114 |
thing in itself, then, can be treated like the Antinomies, as we have |
| 2115 |
already seen. As will easily be shown in the next section, the |
| 2116 |
noumena have lying before them the things in themselves; by means of |
| 2117 |
the transcendental unity of apperception, the discipline of practical |
| 2118 |
reason, even as this relates to the thing in itself, exists in time. |
| 2119 |
Consequently, the noumena (and let us suppose that this is the case) |
| 2120 |
prove the validity of the manifold, since knowledge of our sense |
| 2121 |
perceptions is a priori. This could not be passed over in a complete |
| 2122 |
system of transcendental philosophy, but in a merely critical essay |
| 2123 |
the simple mention of the fact may suffice.} |
| 2124 |
|
| 2125 |
\@@_newpara:n {Our sense perceptions are just as necessary as the |
| 2126 |
employment of the never-ending regress in the series of empirical |
| 2127 |
conditions, but our a priori concepts can never, as a whole, furnish a |
| 2128 |
true and demonstrated science, because, like necessity, they would |
| 2129 |
thereby be made to contradict problematic principles. What we have |
| 2130 |
alone been able to show is that our sense perceptions have nothing to |
| 2131 |
do with, certainly, the Transcendental Deduction. As any dedicated |
| 2132 |
reader can clearly see, it is obvious that the objects in space and |
| 2133 |
time constitute the whole content of metaphysics; still, the things in |
| 2134 |
themselves are the clue to the discovery of pure reason. The Ideal |
| 2135 |
(and there can be no doubt that this is true) is a representation of |
| 2136 |
our faculties. The discipline of practical reason is a representation |
| 2137 |
of, in other words, the Ideal of pure reason. It is not at all |
| 2138 |
certain that the things in themselves have lying before them the |
| 2139 |
Antinomies; certainly, the employment of our sense perceptions |
| 2140 |
abstracts from all content of a priori knowledge. The paralogisms of |
| 2141 |
pure reason should only be used as a canon for time.} |
| 2142 |
|
| 2143 |
\@@_newpara:n {By virtue of natural reason, I assert that the |
| 2144 |
paralogisms, for example, would be falsified; however, our inductive |
| 2145 |
judgements constitute the whole content of the discipline of natural |
| 2146 |
reason. The noumena constitute the whole content of the noumena. The |
| 2147 |
discipline of practical reason can never furnish a true and |
| 2148 |
demonstrated science, because, like the transcendental aesthetic, it |
| 2149 |
teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of disjunctive |
| 2150 |
principles. The paralogisms of pure reason (and what we have alone |
| 2151 |
been able to show is that this is the case) constitute the whole |
| 2152 |
content of our a posteriori concepts; certainly, the noumena should |
| 2153 |
only be used as a canon for the manifold. Natural causes, |
| 2154 |
consequently, are the mere results of the power of the thing in |
| 2155 |
itself, a blind but indispensable function of the soul. Since |
| 2156 |
knowledge of the objects in space and time is a posteriori, let us |
| 2157 |
suppose that our sense perceptions constitute the whole content of the |
| 2158 |
things in themselves; by means of philosophy, the architectonic of |
| 2159 |
pure reason is a representation of time. Since none of our sense |
| 2160 |
perceptions are inductive, we can deduce that the manifold abstracts |
| 2161 |
from all content of knowledge; on the other hand, our faculties should |
| 2162 |
only be used as a canon for the pure employment of the Categories.} |
| 2163 |
|
| 2164 |
\@@_newpara:n {Aristotle tells us that our ideas have lying before |
| 2165 |
them the phenomena. In the study of the employment of the objects in |
| 2166 |
space and time, it is not at all certain that the transcendental |
| 2167 |
aesthetic teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of, so |
| 2168 |
regarded, our experience, as is shown in the writings of Hume. The |
| 2169 |
Categories, indeed, are the mere results of the power of metaphysics, |
| 2170 |
a blind but indispensable function of the soul, since some of the |
| 2171 |
noumena are a posteriori. We can deduce that the objects in space and |
| 2172 |
time are a representation of the objects in space and time, as will |
| 2173 |
easily be shown in the next section. By virtue of pure reason, let us |
| 2174 |
suppose that our experience may not contradict itself, but it is still |
| 2175 |
possible that it may be in contradictions with, in respect of the |
| 2176 |
intelligible character, the transcendental unity of apperception; |
| 2177 |
however, the transcendental objects in space and time have lying |
| 2178 |
before them the employment of the Transcendental Deduction. Because |
| 2179 |
of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, the reader should be |
| 2180 |
careful to observe that, indeed, the transcendental aesthetic, still, |
| 2181 |
exists in natural causes.} |
| 2182 |
|
| 2183 |
\@@_newpara:n {Since none of the objects in space and time are |
| 2184 |
analytic, it remains a mystery why, in the full sense of these terms, |
| 2185 |
the objects in space and time have lying before them the Categories, |
| 2186 |
and our ideas (and let us suppose that this is the case) have lying |
| 2187 |
before them our problematic judgements. In the study of our |
| 2188 |
understanding, there can be no doubt that necessity (and it is obvious |
| 2189 |
that this is true) is a representation of the architectonic of natural |
| 2190 |
reason, as is proven in the ontological manuals. Since knowledge of |
| 2191 |
the Antinomies is a posteriori, our faculties would thereby be made to |
| 2192 |
contradict our sense perceptions. As will easily be shown in the next |
| 2193 |
section, the never-ending regress in the series of empirical |
| 2194 |
conditions, in the case of our experience, can be treated like the |
| 2195 |
phenomena, and the Categories exclude the possibility of, thus, our |
| 2196 |
knowledge. In which of our cognitive faculties are natural causes and |
| 2197 |
the objects in space and time connected together? Still, the |
| 2198 |
Transcendental Deduction stands in need of natural reason. There can |
| 2199 |
be no doubt that the manifold, when thus treated as the things in |
| 2200 |
themselves, is by its very nature contradictory.} |
| 2201 |
|
| 2202 |
\@@_newpara:n {As I have elsewhere shown, the never-ending regress in |
| 2203 |
the series of empirical conditions, in the study of the never-ending |
| 2204 |
regress in the series of empirical conditions, occupies part of the |
| 2205 |
sphere of the Transcendental Deduction concerning the existence of the |
| 2206 |
objects in space and time in general, by means of analytic unity. Our |
| 2207 |
faculties (and it remains a mystery why this is the case) can not take |
| 2208 |
account of the discipline of pure reason. As will easily be shown in |
| 2209 |
the next section, Hume tells us that the phenomena are just as |
| 2210 |
necessary as, consequently, necessity; for these reasons, formal |
| 2211 |
logic, that is to say, excludes the possibility of applied logic. As |
| 2212 |
is shown in the writings of Galileo, I assert, still, that, indeed, |
| 2213 |
the Ideal, for example, is a body of demonstrated science, and some of |
| 2214 |
it must be known a priori. As is shown in the writings of Hume, the |
| 2215 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, when thus |
| 2216 |
treated as the objects in space and time, constitutes the whole |
| 2217 |
content for the Ideal.} |
| 2218 |
|
| 2219 |
\@@_newpara:n {It is not at all certain that, so far as regards the |
| 2220 |
manifold and our ideas, the Categories are just as necessary as, in |
| 2221 |
the study of the architectonic of pure reason, the discipline of human |
| 2222 |
reason. It must not be supposed that metaphysics is the mere result |
| 2223 |
of the power of the Ideal of practical reason, a blind but |
| 2224 |
indispensable function of the soul; in the study of human reason, the |
| 2225 |
phenomena are a representation of metaphysics. Our understanding |
| 2226 |
proves the validity of the transcendental unity of apperception; |
| 2227 |
therefore, human reason depends on natural causes. In the study of |
| 2228 |
the architectonic of natural reason, what we have alone been able to |
| 2229 |
show is that our judgements constitute the whole content of, on the |
| 2230 |
other hand, our inductive judgements, as we have already seen. } |
| 2231 |
|
| 2232 |
\@@_newpara:n {The objects in space and time should only be used as a |
| 2233 |
canon for the phenomena. By means of analysis, to avoid all |
| 2234 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the noumena are just |
| 2235 |
as necessary as pure logic; however, natural causes exist in the Ideal |
| 2236 |
of natural reason. As I have elsewhere shown, the Categories have |
| 2237 |
lying before them our a priori knowledge, as is proven in the |
| 2238 |
ontological manuals. I assert that the Transcendental Deduction, |
| 2239 |
irrespective of all empirical conditions, can not take account of the |
| 2240 |
Ideal of practical reason. (The noumena would thereby be made to |
| 2241 |
contradict necessity, because of our necessary ignorance of the |
| 2242 |
conditions.) The Categories are the clue to the discovery of our |
| 2243 |
experience, yet our concepts, in view of these considerations, occupy |
| 2244 |
part of the sphere of our experience concerning the existence of the |
| 2245 |
noumena in general. As is proven in the ontological manuals, Galileo |
| 2246 |
tells us that space, in respect of the intelligible character, can |
| 2247 |
never furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like |
| 2248 |
philosophy, it has lying before it speculative principles. This is |
| 2249 |
the sense in which it is to be understood in this work.} |
| 2250 |
|
| 2251 |
\@@_newpara:n {Still, the Ideal is what first gives rise to, when |
| 2252 |
thus treated as our ideas, the transcendental aesthetic. As any |
| 2253 |
dedicated reader can clearly see, it is obvious that natural causes |
| 2254 |
exclude the possibility of natural causes; therefore, metaphysics is a |
| 2255 |
body of demonstrated science, and some of it must be known a |
| 2256 |
posteriori. I assert, as I have elsewhere shown, that the discipline |
| 2257 |
of human reason constitutes the whole content for our a priori |
| 2258 |
concepts, as is evident upon close examination. I assert that, on the |
| 2259 |
contrary, our understanding occupies part of the sphere of formal |
| 2260 |
logic concerning the existence of the objects in space and time in |
| 2261 |
general. It must not be supposed that, so regarded, the paralogisms |
| 2262 |
of practical reason abstract from all content of a priori knowledge. |
| 2263 |
Whence comes the Ideal of natural reason, the solution of which |
| 2264 |
involves the relation between our understanding and our judgements? |
| 2265 |
By means of analysis, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to |
| 2266 |
explain that time, even as this relates to human reason, can never |
| 2267 |
furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like time, it |
| 2268 |
excludes the possibility of hypothetical principles. As we have |
| 2269 |
already seen, we can deduce that our faculties, therefore, are the |
| 2270 |
mere results of the power of the transcendental unity of apperception, |
| 2271 |
a blind but indispensable function of the soul; by means of the |
| 2272 |
manifold, time is the key to understanding space. By virtue of human |
| 2273 |
reason, our speculative judgements have nothing to do with the Ideal.} |
| 2274 |
|
| 2275 |
\@@_newpara:n {Transcendental logic constitutes the whole content |
| 2276 |
for, for example, the never-ending regress in the series of empirical |
| 2277 |
conditions. It remains a mystery why, even as this relates to time, |
| 2278 |
the Ideal excludes the possibility of the Categories, but natural |
| 2279 |
reason, then, can never furnish a true and demonstrated science, |
| 2280 |
because, like the thing in itself, it is the key to understanding a |
| 2281 |
posteriori principles. What we have alone been able to show is that |
| 2282 |
the Transcendental Deduction is what first gives rise to the |
| 2283 |
Categories. As is proven in the ontological manuals, it is not at all |
| 2284 |
certain that, so far as I know, the Transcendental Deduction teaches |
| 2285 |
us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of, with the sole |
| 2286 |
exception of the never-ending regress in the series of empirical |
| 2287 |
conditions, natural causes, but the objects in space and time are the |
| 2288 |
clue to the discovery of the objects in space and time. The objects |
| 2289 |
in space and time are the clue to the discovery of the phenomena. The |
| 2290 |
transcendental aesthetic, in the case of metaphysics, can be treated |
| 2291 |
like necessity; for these reasons, the noumena exclude the possibility |
| 2292 |
of the Ideal.} |
| 2293 |
|
| 2294 |
\@@_newpara:n {The reader should be careful to observe that our a |
| 2295 |
posteriori knowledge has lying before it the Categories, as is shown |
| 2296 |
in the writings of Galileo. Thus, the Categories are the mere results |
| 2297 |
of the power of space, a blind but indispensable function of the soul. |
| 2298 |
In view of these considerations, it is obvious that the Categories are |
| 2299 |
just as necessary as, however, the never-ending regress in the series |
| 2300 |
of empirical conditions, as any dedicated reader can clearly see. |
| 2301 |
Because of the relation between the Ideal of human reason and the |
| 2302 |
objects in space and time, the empirical objects in space and time |
| 2303 |
have lying before them natural causes; still, our experience (and it |
| 2304 |
must not be supposed that this is true) depends on the Transcendental |
| 2305 |
Deduction. Because of the relation between the employment of the |
| 2306 |
Transcendental Deduction and the Antinomies, pure logic occupies part |
| 2307 |
of the sphere of necessity concerning the existence of the objects in |
| 2308 |
space and time in general; however, the things in themselves, still, |
| 2309 |
stand in need to our judgements. The Transcendental Deduction proves |
| 2310 |
the validity of the things in themselves, and our sense perceptions |
| 2311 |
would thereby be made to contradict our understanding.} |
| 2312 |
|
| 2313 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is proven in the ontological manuals, Galileo tells |
| 2314 |
us that natural causes, so far as regards necessity, can never, as a |
| 2315 |
whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the |
| 2316 |
manifold, they prove the validity of ampliative principles. Let us |
| 2317 |
suppose that, in particular, the Ideal of human reason is a body of |
| 2318 |
demonstrated science, and all of it must be known a posteriori. As is |
| 2319 |
proven in the ontological manuals, our faculties, consequently, are |
| 2320 |
the mere results of the power of human reason, a blind but |
| 2321 |
indispensable function of the soul, but the noumena can never, as a |
| 2322 |
whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like space, |
| 2323 |
they would thereby be made to contradict analytic principles. As is |
| 2324 |
shown in the writings of Hume, the intelligible objects in space and |
| 2325 |
time, in the study of the never-ending regress in the series of |
| 2326 |
empirical conditions, stand in need to our experience. On the other |
| 2327 |
hand, Galileo tells us that formal logic is by its very nature |
| 2328 |
contradictory. With the sole exception of the architectonic of |
| 2329 |
natural reason, there can be no doubt that our understanding would be |
| 2330 |
falsified. This is what chiefly concerns us.} |
| 2331 |
|
| 2332 |
\@@_newpara:n {Because of the relation between philosophy and the |
| 2333 |
objects in space and time, the Categories, in all theoretical |
| 2334 |
sciences, are by their very nature contradictory. What we have alone |
| 2335 |
been able to show is that our knowledge is a representation of the |
| 2336 |
Categories. With the sole exception of the practical employment of |
| 2337 |
the noumena, what we have alone been able to show is that the objects |
| 2338 |
in space and time would thereby be made to contradict the discipline |
| 2339 |
of pure reason, because of the relation between the manifold and our |
| 2340 |
ideas. The reader should be careful to observe that, then, the |
| 2341 |
Categories are by their very nature contradictory, but space is the |
| 2342 |
mere result of the power of the discipline of practical reason, a |
| 2343 |
blind but indispensable function of the soul. The noumena are by |
| 2344 |
their very nature contradictory. As any dedicated reader can clearly |
| 2345 |
see, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the |
| 2346 |
architectonic of human reason, on the contrary, excludes the |
| 2347 |
possibility of the paralogisms. The thing in itself, in view of these |
| 2348 |
considerations, is by its very nature contradictory. Let us apply |
| 2349 |
this to necessity.} |
| 2350 |
|
| 2351 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is proven in the ontological manuals, our sense |
| 2352 |
perceptions, as I have elsewhere shown, should only be used as a canon |
| 2353 |
for our ideas; in natural theology, the paralogisms, indeed, are by |
| 2354 |
their very nature contradictory. By virtue of practical reason, the |
| 2355 |
manifold, on the contrary, excludes the possibility of the |
| 2356 |
transcendental aesthetic, yet the thing in itself is by its very |
| 2357 |
nature contradictory. Our sense perceptions are just as necessary as |
| 2358 |
the Categories. As we have already seen, what we have alone been able |
| 2359 |
to show is that, in particular, the Ideal of natural reason stands in |
| 2360 |
need of, that is to say, our knowledge, but necessity is a body of |
| 2361 |
demonstrated science, and none of it must be known a priori. As we |
| 2362 |
have already seen, our judgements, therefore, constitute a body of |
| 2363 |
demonstrated doctrine, and all of this body must be known a priori. |
| 2364 |
Galileo tells us that the objects in space and time (and it is not at |
| 2365 |
all certain that this is the case) are a representation of our ideas; |
| 2366 |
still, time, with the sole exception of our experience, can be treated |
| 2367 |
like our sense perceptions. This is what chiefly concerns us. } |
| 2368 |
|
| 2369 |
\@@_newpara:n {The Categories, as I have elsewhere shown, constitute |
| 2370 |
the whole content of necessity. The transcendental unity of |
| 2371 |
apperception is just as necessary as the transcendental objects in |
| 2372 |
space and time. Consequently, I assert that the thing in itself is a |
| 2373 |
representation of, in the full sense of these terms, the objects in |
| 2374 |
space and time, because of the relation between the transcendental |
| 2375 |
aesthetic and our sense perceptions. The manifold, in particular, can |
| 2376 |
thereby determine in its totality metaphysics. Our a posteriori |
| 2377 |
concepts, in the case of our experience, prove the validity of the |
| 2378 |
transcendental objects in space and time, as will easily be shown in |
| 2379 |
the next section. There can be no doubt that necessity, even as this |
| 2380 |
relates to necessity, may not contradict itself, but it is still |
| 2381 |
possible that it may be in contradictions with the architectonic of |
| 2382 |
human reason.} |
| 2383 |
|
| 2384 |
\@@_newpara:n {Since knowledge of the objects in space and time is a |
| 2385 |
priori, it remains a mystery why, in reference to ends, the phenomena |
| 2386 |
prove the validity of the paralogisms. As is proven in the |
| 2387 |
ontological manuals, the empirical objects in space and time would |
| 2388 |
thereby be made to contradict the empirical objects in space and time; |
| 2389 |
in the study of the transcendental unity of apperception, the |
| 2390 |
Categories exist in our a priori concepts. Because of the relation |
| 2391 |
between space and our analytic judgements, the reader should be |
| 2392 |
careful to observe that the Categories (and I assert that this is the |
| 2393 |
case) can not take account of the discipline of pure reason; in the |
| 2394 |
study of the never-ending regress in the series of empirical |
| 2395 |
conditions, the transcendental aesthetic can never furnish a true and |
| 2396 |
demonstrated science, because, like the Ideal, it is just as necessary |
| 2397 |
as problematic principles. In the case of general logic, space (and |
| 2398 |
it is obvious that this is true) is just as necessary as the things in |
| 2399 |
themselves. By means of analytic unity, I assert, in view of these |
| 2400 |
considerations, that, irrespective of all empirical conditions, our |
| 2401 |
speculative judgements (and it is obvious that this is the case) are |
| 2402 |
what first give rise to the Antinomies. As will easily be shown in |
| 2403 |
the next section, it remains a mystery why our ideas would thereby be |
| 2404 |
made to contradict our judgements; therefore, our sense perceptions, |
| 2405 |
certainly, exclude the possibility of the noumena. As is shown in the |
| 2406 |
writings of Galileo, the objects in space and time exclude the |
| 2407 |
possibility of our ideas; thus, the objects in space and time, for |
| 2408 |
these reasons, are the clue to the discovery of the Antinomies.} |
| 2409 |
|
| 2410 |
\@@_newpara:n {With the sole exception of the never-ending regress in |
| 2411 |
the series of empirical conditions, it is not at all certain that the |
| 2412 |
noumena, in so far as this expounds the practical rules of the |
| 2413 |
paralogisms of pure reason, can never, as a whole, furnish a true and |
| 2414 |
demonstrated science, because, like the transcendental aesthetic, they |
| 2415 |
are just as necessary as ampliative principles, as will easily be |
| 2416 |
shown in the next section. As is evident upon close examination, the |
| 2417 |
objects in space and time constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, |
| 2418 |
and all of this body must be known a posteriori, but the architectonic |
| 2419 |
of practical reason would be falsified. Because of our necessary |
| 2420 |
ignorance of the conditions, it is not at all certain that, then, our |
| 2421 |
understanding proves the validity of, on the contrary, formal logic. |
| 2422 |
With the sole exception of the Ideal of natural reason, the Categories |
| 2423 |
exist in the paralogisms, since knowledge of the Antinomies is a |
| 2424 |
posteriori. Since knowledge of our ideas is a priori, it must not be |
| 2425 |
supposed that the manifold, as I have elsewhere shown, abstracts from |
| 2426 |
all content of knowledge; in the study of the Ideal of practical |
| 2427 |
reason, our concepts are the clue to the discovery of our experience.} |
| 2428 |
|
| 2429 |
\@@_newpara:n {What we have alone been able to show is that the |
| 2430 |
Categories would be falsified. Consequently, there can be no doubt |
| 2431 |
that the noumena can not take account of, even as this relates to |
| 2432 |
philosophy, the Antinomies, as any dedicated reader can clearly see. |
| 2433 |
Our judgements (and I assert that this is the case) are what first |
| 2434 |
give rise to the never-ending regress in the series of empirical |
| 2435 |
conditions. It is not at all certain that, in the full sense of these |
| 2436 |
terms, the objects in space and time stand in need to the Ideal of |
| 2437 |
pure reason, yet the Transcendental Deduction, in reference to ends, |
| 2438 |
is just as necessary as the Ideal. Has it ever been suggested that it |
| 2439 |
must not be supposed that there is a causal connection bewteen the |
| 2440 |
transcendental objects in space and time and the discipline of natural |
| 2441 |
reason? As will easily be shown in the next section, it is not at all |
| 2442 |
certain that the noumena can not take account of the Transcendental |
| 2443 |
Deduction. By virtue of human reason, I assert, in the study of the |
| 2444 |
manifold, that, indeed, the objects in space and time have lying |
| 2445 |
before them our faculties, and the architectonic of natural reason |
| 2446 |
stands in need of the things in themselves.} |
| 2447 |
|
| 2448 |
\@@_newpara:n {By means of analytic unity, the objects in space and |
| 2449 |
time (and there can be no doubt that this is the case) constitute the |
| 2450 |
whole content of the Antinomies, but our ideas have lying before them |
| 2451 |
the noumena. The Ideal is the key to understanding, that is to say, |
| 2452 |
the things in themselves. By means of analytic unity, our judgements |
| 2453 |
(and what we have alone been able to show is that this is the case) |
| 2454 |
have lying before them the Transcendental Deduction. Aristotle tells |
| 2455 |
us that metaphysics, in the study of the Ideal of practical reason, |
| 2456 |
occupies part of the sphere of applied logic concerning the existence |
| 2457 |
of the paralogisms in general; certainly, metaphysics can not take |
| 2458 |
account of necessity. But can I entertain human reason in thought, or |
| 2459 |
does it present itself to me? The things in themselves stand in need |
| 2460 |
to natural causes, by means of analytic unity. Since knowledge of |
| 2461 |
natural causes is a posteriori, the empirical objects in space and |
| 2462 |
time have nothing to do with philosophy. The divisions are thus |
| 2463 |
provided; all that is required is to fill them.} |
| 2464 |
|
| 2465 |
\@@_newpara:n {In view of these considerations, the noumena would |
| 2466 |
thereby be made to contradict, in view of these considerations, the |
| 2467 |
paralogisms of natural reason. Because of the relation between the |
| 2468 |
discipline of pure reason and our sense perceptions, we can deduce |
| 2469 |
that, on the contrary, the Categories are just as necessary as natural |
| 2470 |
causes, and metaphysics, in the full sense of these terms, can never |
| 2471 |
furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the |
| 2472 |
transcendental unity of apperception, it is the clue to the discovery |
| 2473 |
of speculative principles. We can deduce that natural causes, still, |
| 2474 |
are by their very nature contradictory, as we have already seen. As |
| 2475 |
we have already seen, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to |
| 2476 |
explain that, so far as I know, the objects in space and time, for |
| 2477 |
these reasons, are the clue to the discovery of the Ideal of human |
| 2478 |
reason. The reader should be careful to observe that the manifold, |
| 2479 |
irrespective of all empirical conditions, is by its very nature |
| 2480 |
contradictory. } |
| 2481 |
|
| 2482 |
\@@_newpara:n {The reader should be careful to observe that natural |
| 2483 |
causes (and to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain |
| 2484 |
that this is the case) have lying before them necessity. We can |
| 2485 |
deduce that our a priori knowledge (and Galileo tells us that this is |
| 2486 |
true) depends on the employment of the never-ending regress in the |
| 2487 |
series of empirical conditions. It remains a mystery why the |
| 2488 |
paralogisms of practical reason, for these reasons, exist in the |
| 2489 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, because of |
| 2490 |
the relation between the architectonic of pure reason and the |
| 2491 |
phenomena. Thus, the architectonic of pure reason excludes the |
| 2492 |
possibility of, on the other hand, the phenomena. And can I entertain |
| 2493 |
philosophy in thought, or does it present itself to me? Galileo tells |
| 2494 |
us that, that is to say, the practical employment of the architectonic |
| 2495 |
of natural reason, with the sole exception of the transcendental |
| 2496 |
aesthetic, abstracts from all content of knowledge. As is proven in |
| 2497 |
the ontological manuals, our ideas constitute the whole content of the |
| 2498 |
objects in space and time, but the objects in space and time (and it |
| 2499 |
is obvious that this is the case) are the clue to the discovery of the |
| 2500 |
paralogisms.} |
| 2501 |
|
| 2502 |
\@@_newpara:n {As any dedicated reader can clearly see, it is not at |
| 2503 |
all certain that, on the contrary, the objects in space and time, in |
| 2504 |
the case of space, stand in need to the objects in space and time, but |
| 2505 |
the phenomena have lying before them the discipline of human reason. |
| 2506 |
The never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, in |
| 2507 |
other words, is what first gives rise to general logic. Because of |
| 2508 |
our necessary ignorance of the conditions, our concepts, so far as |
| 2509 |
regards the Ideal of human reason, exist in the paralogisms; in the |
| 2510 |
study of time, the thing in itself is the clue to the discovery of the |
| 2511 |
manifold. I assert that our experience, in natural theology, |
| 2512 |
abstracts from all content of a priori knowledge; therefore, our ideas |
| 2513 |
are what first give rise to the Categories. As is evident upon close |
| 2514 |
examination, our ideas, for these reasons, can not take account of |
| 2515 |
philosophy. Has it ever been suggested that what we have alone been |
| 2516 |
able to show is that there is no relation bewteen the architectonic of |
| 2517 |
human reason and our sense perceptions? Since all of the noumena are |
| 2518 |
a priori, the noumena are the mere results of the power of the thing |
| 2519 |
in itself, a blind but indispensable function of the soul. There can |
| 2520 |
be no doubt that the empirical objects in space and time constitute a |
| 2521 |
body of demonstrated doctrine, and none of this body must be known a |
| 2522 |
posteriori; thus, time is the mere result of the power of the |
| 2523 |
Transcendental Deduction, a blind but indispensable function of the |
| 2524 |
soul. But this need not worry us.} |
| 2525 |
|
| 2526 |
\@@_newpara:n {Aristotle tells us that, insomuch as the pure |
| 2527 |
employment of the Categories relies on our ideas, the things in |
| 2528 |
themselves are just as necessary as, in all theoretical sciences, the |
| 2529 |
noumena. Therefore, let us suppose that the phenomena occupy part of |
| 2530 |
the sphere of philosophy concerning the existence of our concepts in |
| 2531 |
general. In all theoretical sciences, we can deduce that the |
| 2532 |
architectonic of pure reason is what first gives rise to the |
| 2533 |
employment of our concepts, by means of analysis. The things in |
| 2534 |
themselves occupy part of the sphere of the never-ending regress in |
| 2535 |
the series of empirical conditions concerning the existence of our |
| 2536 |
sense perceptions in general; thus, metaphysics may not contradict |
| 2537 |
itself, but it is still possible that it may be in contradictions |
| 2538 |
with, in other words, the transcendental unity of apperception. By |
| 2539 |
means of the architectonic of practical reason, our sense perceptions, |
| 2540 |
irrespective of all empirical conditions, abstract from all content of |
| 2541 |
knowledge. As is proven in the ontological manuals, metaphysics, so |
| 2542 |
far as regards the transcendental aesthetic and the intelligible |
| 2543 |
objects in space and time, is a body of demonstrated science, and none |
| 2544 |
of it must be known a priori; by means of philosophy, the Categories |
| 2545 |
are a representation of, in the case of time, the phenomena. As any |
| 2546 |
dedicated reader can clearly see, the Transcendental Deduction, in |
| 2547 |
other words, would thereby be made to contradict our understanding; |
| 2548 |
still, the employment of the noumena is a representation of the |
| 2549 |
Ideal.} |
| 2550 |
|
| 2551 |
\@@_newpara:n {We can deduce that the paralogisms of human reason are |
| 2552 |
a representation of, in the full sense of these terms, our experience. |
| 2553 |
The thing in itself, in reference to ends, exists in our judgements. |
| 2554 |
As is shown in the writings of Aristotle, let us suppose that, in |
| 2555 |
respect of the intelligible character, the Categories constitute the |
| 2556 |
whole content of our knowledge, yet metaphysics is a representation of |
| 2557 |
our judgements. As is evident upon close examination, the paralogisms |
| 2558 |
would thereby be made to contradict the manifold; therefore, pure |
| 2559 |
logic is a representation of time. In natural theology, the |
| 2560 |
discipline of natural reason abstracts from all content of a priori |
| 2561 |
knowledge. To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain |
| 2562 |
that the paralogisms of human reason have lying before them the Ideal |
| 2563 |
of pure reason, since none of the things in themselves are a priori. |
| 2564 |
Consequently, it remains a mystery why our concepts abstract from all |
| 2565 |
content of knowledge, since knowledge of the objects in space and time |
| 2566 |
is a posteriori.} |
| 2567 |
|
| 2568 |
\@@_newpara:n {Because of the relation between practical reason and |
| 2569 |
our problematic judgements, what we have alone been able to show is |
| 2570 |
that, in respect of the intelligible character, our faculties, |
| 2571 |
insomuch as our knowledge relies on the Categories, can be treated |
| 2572 |
like natural reason. In view of these considerations, the reader |
| 2573 |
should be careful to observe that the transcendental aesthetic is the |
| 2574 |
clue to the discovery of, in view of these considerations, the |
| 2575 |
phenomena. As is evident upon close examination, it remains a mystery |
| 2576 |
why the objects in space and time occupy part of the sphere of the |
| 2577 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions concerning |
| 2578 |
the existence of the Categories in general; in view of these |
| 2579 |
considerations, our experience, indeed, stands in need of the |
| 2580 |
phenomena. (However, the phenomena prove the validity of the Ideal, |
| 2581 |
by virtue of human reason.) We can deduce that, so regarded, our |
| 2582 |
faculties (and it remains a mystery why this is the case) are what |
| 2583 |
first give rise to the architectonic of pure reason. Our ideas can |
| 2584 |
not take account of, by means of space, our knowledge. But we have |
| 2585 |
fallen short of the necessary interconnection that we have in mind |
| 2586 |
when we speak of necessity.} |
| 2587 |
|
| 2588 |
\@@_newpara:n {It is not at all certain that space can not take |
| 2589 |
account of natural causes. The Transcendental Deduction can not take |
| 2590 |
account of our a priori knowledge; as I have elsewhere shown, the |
| 2591 |
objects in space and time (and let us suppose that this is the case) |
| 2592 |
can not take account of the objects in space and time. As is shown in |
| 2593 |
the writings of Galileo, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary |
| 2594 |
to explain that the Categories have lying before them, as I have |
| 2595 |
elsewhere shown, our ideas. The Ideal of human reason excludes the |
| 2596 |
possibility of the Ideal of human reason. By virtue of natural |
| 2597 |
reason, our ideas stand in need to the Ideal of practical reason. By |
| 2598 |
means of analysis, the phenomena, in the study of our understanding, |
| 2599 |
can not take account of the noumena, but the paralogisms of natural |
| 2600 |
reason, thus, abstract from all content of knowledge. This is not |
| 2601 |
something we are in a position to establish.} |
| 2602 |
|
| 2603 |
\@@_newpara:n {Since none of our ideas are inductive, our ideas |
| 2604 |
constitute the whole content of the paralogisms; consequently, our |
| 2605 |
faculties can not take account of metaphysics. As will easily be |
| 2606 |
shown in the next section, the Ideal, in reference to ends, may not |
| 2607 |
contradict itself, but it is still possible that it may be in |
| 2608 |
contradictions with the Categories; in all theoretical sciences, the |
| 2609 |
architectonic of practical reason, in the case of the practical |
| 2610 |
employment of our experience, can be treated like necessity. Because |
| 2611 |
of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, the things in themselves |
| 2612 |
are the mere results of the power of time, a blind but indispensable |
| 2613 |
function of the soul, and the Transcendental Deduction exists in the |
| 2614 |
Antinomies. As is proven in the ontological manuals, the thing in |
| 2615 |
itself (and what we have alone been able to show is that this is true) |
| 2616 |
constitutes the whole content for time. It remains a mystery why our |
| 2617 |
understanding (and Aristotle tells us that this is true) may not |
| 2618 |
contradict itself, but it is still possible that it may be in |
| 2619 |
contradictions with our judgements; in all theoretical sciences, the |
| 2620 |
objects in space and time constitute the whole content of our ideas. |
| 2621 |
Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, we can deduce |
| 2622 |
that, for example, our concepts, for example, are the mere results of |
| 2623 |
the power of pure reason, a blind but indispensable function of the |
| 2624 |
soul, yet the objects in space and time, with the sole exception of |
| 2625 |
the manifold, exist in our ideas.} |
| 2626 |
|
| 2627 |
\@@_newpara:n {In natural theology, it must not be supposed that the |
| 2628 |
objects in space and time, so far as regards the manifold, should only |
| 2629 |
be used as a canon for natural reason. The manifold, so far as |
| 2630 |
regards our a priori knowledge, teaches us nothing whatsoever |
| 2631 |
regarding the content of the Transcendental Deduction. By means of |
| 2632 |
analytic unity, we can deduce that, so far as regards our experience |
| 2633 |
and the objects in space and time, the objects in space and time would |
| 2634 |
thereby be made to contradict the Categories, but our concepts can |
| 2635 |
never, as a whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, |
| 2636 |
like our experience, they stand in need to ampliative principles. The |
| 2637 |
noumena, so far as I know, can never, as a whole, furnish a true and |
| 2638 |
demonstrated science, because, like the employment of the Categories, |
| 2639 |
they have lying before them ampliative principles, yet the phenomena |
| 2640 |
are just as necessary as natural causes. The reader should be careful |
| 2641 |
to observe that, so far as I know, the Ideal has nothing to do with |
| 2642 |
the Categories, but the things in themselves, however, constitute a |
| 2643 |
body of demonstrated doctrine, and some of this body must be known a |
| 2644 |
posteriori. And similarly with all the others.} |
| 2645 |
|
| 2646 |
\@@_newpara:n {Our speculative judgements, therefore, prove the |
| 2647 |
validity of the transcendental unity of apperception. Necessity is |
| 2648 |
just as necessary as, that is to say, transcendental logic. The |
| 2649 |
reader should be careful to observe that the noumena (and it must not |
| 2650 |
be supposed that this is the case) can not take account of our |
| 2651 |
faculties, as is shown in the writings of Aristotle. The Ideal (and |
| 2652 |
to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that this is |
| 2653 |
true) can not take account of the transcendental aesthetic, and the |
| 2654 |
employment of the manifold has nothing to do with, insomuch as the |
| 2655 |
architectonic of natural reason relies on the Antinomies, the |
| 2656 |
discipline of human reason. As any dedicated reader can clearly see, |
| 2657 |
the paralogisms prove the validity of, as I have elsewhere shown, the |
| 2658 |
architectonic of pure reason.} |
| 2659 |
|
| 2660 |
\@@_newpara:n {Space may not contradict itself, but it is still |
| 2661 |
possible that it may be in contradictions with, for these reasons, the |
| 2662 |
phenomena; with the sole exception of metaphysics, our ideas exclude |
| 2663 |
the possibility of, in natural theology, the thing in itself. What we |
| 2664 |
have alone been able to show is that, for example, the Ideal excludes |
| 2665 |
the possibility of time, yet the noumena (and I assert, in view of |
| 2666 |
these considerations, that this is the case) are just as necessary as |
| 2667 |
the objects in space and time. Because of the relation between |
| 2668 |
metaphysics and the paralogisms, the Categories are the mere results |
| 2669 |
of the power of the discipline of natural reason, a blind but |
| 2670 |
indispensable function of the soul. The objects in space and time, in |
| 2671 |
other words, are the mere results of the power of the transcendental |
| 2672 |
aesthetic, a blind but indispensable function of the soul. Since |
| 2673 |
knowledge of our faculties is a priori, what we have alone been able |
| 2674 |
to show is that necessity, in reference to ends, constitutes the whole |
| 2675 |
content for metaphysics; still, our understanding (and we can deduce |
| 2676 |
that this is true) excludes the possibility of our experience. As |
| 2677 |
will easily be shown in the next section, it must not be supposed |
| 2678 |
that, even as this relates to philosophy, the phenomena (and I assert, |
| 2679 |
with the sole exception of metaphysics, that this is the case) are a |
| 2680 |
representation of the objects in space and time, but the Antinomies |
| 2681 |
should only be used as a canon for our knowledge. But we have fallen |
| 2682 |
short of the necessary interconnection that we have in mind when we |
| 2683 |
speak of necessity.} |
| 2684 |
|
| 2685 |
\@@_newpara:n {The objects in space and time are the mere results of |
| 2686 |
the power of metaphysics, a blind but indispensable function of the |
| 2687 |
soul; in the study of our a posteriori knowledge, the manifold, so far |
| 2688 |
as I know, proves the validity of the Ideal. Hume tells us that, so |
| 2689 |
far as regards time, the phenomena, in view of these considerations, |
| 2690 |
stand in need to the thing in itself. There can be no doubt that the |
| 2691 |
things in themselves, in respect of the intelligible character, can be |
| 2692 |
treated like our ideas; as I have elsewhere shown, our concepts have |
| 2693 |
lying before them the phenomena. As is proven in the ontological |
| 2694 |
manuals, there can be no doubt that the phenomena, in all theoretical |
| 2695 |
sciences, constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and none of this |
| 2696 |
body must be known a priori. As is evident upon close examination, |
| 2697 |
the architectonic of natural reason, so regarded, is by its very |
| 2698 |
nature contradictory; for these reasons, the phenomena are a |
| 2699 |
representation of time. In natural theology, the Antinomies (and it |
| 2700 |
remains a mystery why this is the case) constitute the whole content |
| 2701 |
of the Categories, because of our necessary ignorance of the |
| 2702 |
conditions. But we have fallen short of the necessary interconnection |
| 2703 |
that we have in mind when we speak of the Categories.} |
| 2704 |
|
| 2705 |
\@@_newpara:n {Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, |
| 2706 |
it is not at all certain that, for example, the thing in itself (and |
| 2707 |
the reader should be careful to observe that this is true) can not |
| 2708 |
take account of our experience, and our concepts, in all theoretical |
| 2709 |
sciences, are a representation of the phenomena. Since some of the |
| 2710 |
phenomena are problematic, Hume tells us that metaphysics has lying |
| 2711 |
before it, however, natural causes. By virtue of natural reason, |
| 2712 |
Aristotle tells us that the things in themselves, therefore, should |
| 2713 |
only be used as a canon for our a posteriori judgements. Our |
| 2714 |
understanding can be treated like the transcendental unity of |
| 2715 |
apperception. The Categories can be treated like space.} |
| 2716 |
|
| 2717 |
\@@_newpara:n {Since some of our sense perceptions are hypothetical, |
| 2718 |
philosophy proves the validity of natural causes; on the other hand, |
| 2719 |
our experience, in other words, can never furnish a true and |
| 2720 |
demonstrated science, because, like our experience, it depends on |
| 2721 |
synthetic principles. Natural causes, in natural theology, constitute |
| 2722 |
a body of demonstrated doctrine, and all of this body must be known a |
| 2723 |
priori. What we have alone been able to show is that philosophy is a |
| 2724 |
representation of our concepts, as will easily be shown in the next |
| 2725 |
section. The Ideal may not contradict itself, but it is still |
| 2726 |
possible that it may be in contradictions with, in the study of the |
| 2727 |
transcendental aesthetic, our sense perceptions. (As is shown in the |
| 2728 |
writings of Galileo, the reader should be careful to observe that the |
| 2729 |
objects in space and time, by means of necessity, are by their very |
| 2730 |
nature contradictory.) The Antinomies can not take account of our |
| 2731 |
experience, by virtue of natural reason. Therefore, the noumena, in |
| 2732 |
view of these considerations, are by their very nature contradictory, |
| 2733 |
as will easily be shown in the next section.} |
| 2734 |
|
| 2735 |
\@@_newpara:n {On the other hand, the never-ending regress in the |
| 2736 |
series of empirical conditions stands in need of practical reason. As |
| 2737 |
will easily be shown in the next section, there can be no doubt that, |
| 2738 |
in so far as this expounds the contradictory rules of the discipline |
| 2739 |
of natural reason, metaphysics can be treated like metaphysics. As is |
| 2740 |
shown in the writings of Hume, what we have alone been able to show is |
| 2741 |
that the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions |
| 2742 |
would be falsified. Our experience can be treated like the |
| 2743 |
architectonic of human reason, as is shown in the writings of Galileo. |
| 2744 |
The thing in itself proves the validity of the phenomena, as is shown |
| 2745 |
in the writings of Hume. Certainly, what we have alone been able to |
| 2746 |
show is that natural causes, in reference to ends, would be falsified. |
| 2747 |
But this need not worry us.} |
| 2748 |
|
| 2749 |
\@@_newpara:n {Since some of the objects in space and time are |
| 2750 |
speculative, let us suppose that our sense perceptions are the clue to |
| 2751 |
the discovery of, in particular, our a posteriori knowledge. Since |
| 2752 |
knowledge of the transcendental objects in space and time is a |
| 2753 |
posteriori, what we have alone been able to show is that our a |
| 2754 |
posteriori concepts exclude the possibility of the never-ending |
| 2755 |
regress in the series of empirical conditions; by means of the |
| 2756 |
discipline of pure reason, our faculties are the clue to the discovery |
| 2757 |
of our a priori knowledge. Because of the relation between the |
| 2758 |
transcendental unity of apperception and the things in themselves, |
| 2759 |
there can be no doubt that our sense perceptions (and it is obvious |
| 2760 |
that this is the case) are what first give rise to the Categories. To |
| 2761 |
avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the |
| 2762 |
phenomena can not take account of, with the sole exception of the |
| 2763 |
transcendental unity of apperception, the noumena. Certainly, the |
| 2764 |
things in themselves are by their very nature contradictory, as is |
| 2765 |
shown in the writings of Galileo. Because of our necessary ignorance |
| 2766 |
of the conditions, we can deduce that, then, the thing in itself |
| 2767 |
constitutes the whole content for, still, the intelligible objects in |
| 2768 |
space and time, and space is the clue to the discovery of, in |
| 2769 |
particular, our a posteriori concepts. } |
| 2770 |
|
| 2771 |
\@@_newpara:n {The Ideal of human reason has nothing to do with time. |
| 2772 |
As we have already seen, Aristotle tells us that, so far as regards |
| 2773 |
the Transcendental Deduction, the transcendental aesthetic, insomuch |
| 2774 |
as the practical employment of the never-ending regress in the series |
| 2775 |
of empirical conditions relies on the things in themselves, can never |
| 2776 |
furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the |
| 2777 |
transcendental unity of apperception, it excludes the possibility of |
| 2778 |
speculative principles, and the Ideal is a representation of our |
| 2779 |
experience. Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, the |
| 2780 |
phenomena (and Aristotle tells us that this is the case) are the clue |
| 2781 |
to the discovery of our speculative judgements; in all theoretical |
| 2782 |
sciences, our understanding, when thus treated as the noumena, is a |
| 2783 |
body of demonstrated science, and some of it must be known a priori. |
| 2784 |
We can deduce that our knowledge, for example, exists in the |
| 2785 |
transcendental unity of apperception. Consequently, I assert, by |
| 2786 |
means of general logic, that the transcendental unity of apperception |
| 2787 |
teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of, consequently, |
| 2788 |
the Antinomies, because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions.} |
| 2789 |
|
| 2790 |
\@@_newpara:n {Since all of our concepts are inductive, there can be |
| 2791 |
no doubt that, in respect of the intelligible character, our ideas are |
| 2792 |
the clue to the discovery of the transcendental unity of apperception, |
| 2793 |
and the paralogisms of natural reason should only be used as a canon |
| 2794 |
for our judgements. Still, I assert that the objects in space and |
| 2795 |
time have lying before them, by means of transcendental logic, the |
| 2796 |
Transcendental Deduction. Our faculties can be treated like our |
| 2797 |
experience; thus, our ideas have lying before them the objects in |
| 2798 |
space and time. Our judgements constitute a body of demonstrated |
| 2799 |
doctrine, and none of this body must be known a posteriori. Time can |
| 2800 |
be treated like the manifold. As any dedicated reader can clearly |
| 2801 |
see, the employment of the noumena proves the validity of, certainly, |
| 2802 |
human reason, and space excludes the possibility of general logic. |
| 2803 |
Let us suppose that, indeed, the Ideal of pure reason, even as this |
| 2804 |
relates to our a priori knowledge, is the key to understanding the |
| 2805 |
Antinomies, yet the employment of the pure employment of our a |
| 2806 |
posteriori concepts is what first gives rise to, in all theoretical |
| 2807 |
sciences, the noumena.} |
| 2808 |
|
| 2809 |
\@@_newpara:n {Since knowledge of natural causes is a posteriori, it |
| 2810 |
is obvious that the transcendental unity of apperception is the mere |
| 2811 |
result of the power of the never-ending regress in the series of |
| 2812 |
empirical conditions, a blind but indispensable function of the soul; |
| 2813 |
in all theoretical sciences, natural causes exclude the possibility of |
| 2814 |
the noumena. Let us suppose that the transcendental objects in space |
| 2815 |
and time would thereby be made to contradict, so regarded, natural |
| 2816 |
causes. There can be no doubt that our understanding is the clue to |
| 2817 |
the discovery of the Ideal. Because of the relation between the Ideal |
| 2818 |
of pure reason and the Antinomies, the transcendental unity of |
| 2819 |
apperception, as I have elsewhere shown, can be treated like the |
| 2820 |
paralogisms, yet the phenomena are the clue to the discovery of the |
| 2821 |
Ideal. As I have elsewhere shown, I assert, in view of these |
| 2822 |
considerations, that our faculties, even as this relates to the thing |
| 2823 |
in itself, occupy part of the sphere of the Transcendental Deduction |
| 2824 |
concerning the existence of the Categories in general.} |
| 2825 |
|
| 2826 |
\@@_newpara:n {As we have already seen, it is not at all certain |
| 2827 |
that, that is to say, the Transcendental Deduction is the clue to the |
| 2828 |
discovery of, in particular, our knowledge, yet the thing in itself |
| 2829 |
would thereby be made to contradict our faculties. As is proven in |
| 2830 |
the ontological manuals, it is obvious that, when thus treated as our |
| 2831 |
understanding, the Categories have nothing to do with our |
| 2832 |
understanding, yet the never-ending regress in the series of empirical |
| 2833 |
conditions occupies part of the sphere of the architectonic of human |
| 2834 |
reason concerning the existence of the paralogisms in general. As |
| 2835 |
will easily be shown in the next section, general logic has nothing to |
| 2836 |
do with, in the full sense of these terms, the discipline of pure |
| 2837 |
reason. As is evident upon close examination, the Ideal of human |
| 2838 |
reason may not contradict itself, but it is still possible that it may |
| 2839 |
be in contradictions with the Antinomies. As will easily be shown in |
| 2840 |
the next section, the reader should be careful to observe that, even |
| 2841 |
as this relates to the transcendental unity of apperception, the |
| 2842 |
Categories, certainly, should only be used as a canon for the thing in |
| 2843 |
itself. This is not something we are in a position to establish.} |
| 2844 |
|
| 2845 |
\@@_newpara:n {It is obvious that space depends on the things in |
| 2846 |
themselves. There can be no doubt that, in particular, the Ideal, in |
| 2847 |
so far as this expounds the practical rules of the phenomena, is just |
| 2848 |
as necessary as the transcendental unity of apperception. There can |
| 2849 |
be no doubt that the manifold can not take account of, so far as |
| 2850 |
regards the architectonic of human reason, the things in themselves. |
| 2851 |
Thus, it remains a mystery why space depends on the manifold. To |
| 2852 |
avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that our |
| 2853 |
understanding (and to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to |
| 2854 |
explain that this is true) is a representation of the Antinomies.} |
| 2855 |
|
| 2856 |
\@@_newpara:n {By virtue of natural reason, the Antinomies are a |
| 2857 |
representation of metaphysics; in the case of the practical employment |
| 2858 |
of the transcendental aesthetic, the Categories are by their very |
| 2859 |
nature contradictory. It is not at all certain that the phenomena |
| 2860 |
have lying before them the objects in space and time, because of our |
| 2861 |
necessary ignorance of the conditions. Because of the relation |
| 2862 |
between applied logic and our faculties, it remains a mystery why our |
| 2863 |
ideas, consequently, exclude the possibility of philosophy; however, |
| 2864 |
the things in themselves prove the validity of, in the case of |
| 2865 |
metaphysics, the phenomena. By means of the transcendental aesthetic, |
| 2866 |
let us suppose that our ideas constitute a body of demonstrated |
| 2867 |
doctrine, and all of this body must be known a priori. Since all of |
| 2868 |
the objects in space and time are hypothetical, metaphysics is the key |
| 2869 |
to understanding the paralogisms, yet the Transcendental Deduction has |
| 2870 |
nothing to do with our a posteriori knowledge. There can be no doubt |
| 2871 |
that metaphysics is a representation of the transcendental unity of |
| 2872 |
apperception, as any dedicated reader can clearly see.} |
| 2873 |
|
| 2874 |
\@@_newpara:n {There can be no doubt that our concepts, in accordance |
| 2875 |
with the principles of the noumena, are by their very nature |
| 2876 |
contradictory, as is shown in the writings of Galileo. Space is what |
| 2877 |
first gives rise to, in other words, the Antinomies, and space depends |
| 2878 |
on the Ideal. Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, |
| 2879 |
our experience, indeed, proves the validity of the noumena. Hume |
| 2880 |
tells us that the phenomena can not take account of transcendental |
| 2881 |
logic. The objects in space and time, thus, exist in the manifold. |
| 2882 |
In which of our cognitive faculties are the manifold and the |
| 2883 |
Categories connected together? As will easily be shown in the next |
| 2884 |
section, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that |
| 2885 |
metaphysics, on the contrary, occupies part of the sphere of the thing |
| 2886 |
in itself concerning the existence of our synthetic judgements in |
| 2887 |
general.} |
| 2888 |
|
| 2889 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is evident upon close examination, I assert that, |
| 2890 |
so far as regards metaphysics, our knowledge proves the validity of, |
| 2891 |
on the contrary, the manifold, yet the objects in space and time are |
| 2892 |
what first give rise to, in the study of formal logic, the paralogisms |
| 2893 |
of pure reason. As will easily be shown in the next section, I |
| 2894 |
assert, in all theoretical sciences, that our understanding (and the |
| 2895 |
reader should be careful to observe that this is true) can not take |
| 2896 |
account of our sense perceptions. Because of the relation between the |
| 2897 |
Transcendental Deduction and our a priori concepts, the phenomena are |
| 2898 |
what first give rise to the intelligible objects in space and time, |
| 2899 |
and natural causes, indeed, abstract from all content of a priori |
| 2900 |
knowledge. By means of analysis, Galileo tells us that the Ideal has |
| 2901 |
lying before it, on the contrary, our sense perceptions. I assert, |
| 2902 |
for these reasons, that our knowledge stands in need of the things in |
| 2903 |
themselves, since knowledge of our faculties is a priori. But this is |
| 2904 |
to be dismissed as random groping.} |
| 2905 |
|
| 2906 |
\@@_newpara:n {Our understanding can not take account of our |
| 2907 |
faculties; certainly, the never-ending regress in the series of |
| 2908 |
empirical conditions is what first gives rise to, therefore, the |
| 2909 |
things in themselves. It is not at all certain that, then, time |
| 2910 |
occupies part of the sphere of the Transcendental Deduction concerning |
| 2911 |
the existence of the paralogisms of practical reason in general. We |
| 2912 |
can deduce that the thing in itself, on the other hand, abstracts from |
| 2913 |
all content of knowledge. On the other hand, our a priori knowledge |
| 2914 |
has lying before it the practical employment of the Antinomies. The |
| 2915 |
employment of our sense perceptions is what first gives rise to the |
| 2916 |
Antinomies, but the Categories, for these reasons, are by their very |
| 2917 |
nature contradictory. In natural theology, it is not at all certain |
| 2918 |
that our sense perceptions can not take account of our knowledge, by |
| 2919 |
means of analysis. Thus, the Categories would thereby be made to |
| 2920 |
contradict the things in themselves, as any dedicated reader can |
| 2921 |
clearly see.} |
| 2922 |
|
| 2923 |
\@@_newpara:n {The things in themselves are just as necessary as the |
| 2924 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions. As any |
| 2925 |
dedicated reader can clearly see, the architectonic of natural reason |
| 2926 |
(and it remains a mystery why this is true) can thereby determine in |
| 2927 |
its totality general logic. As will easily be shown in the next |
| 2928 |
section, natural causes are a representation of, on the contrary, the |
| 2929 |
Ideal of pure reason; as I have elsewhere shown, the things in |
| 2930 |
themselves, in particular, constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, |
| 2931 |
and none of this body must be known a priori. As we have already |
| 2932 |
seen, our ideas are the clue to the discovery of our faculties. |
| 2933 |
Whence comes applied logic, the solution of which involves the |
| 2934 |
relation between the noumena and the Transcendental Deduction? |
| 2935 |
Therefore, it is obvious that the empirical objects in space and time |
| 2936 |
can not take account of the noumena, because of our necessary |
| 2937 |
ignorance of the conditions. It is not at all certain that the |
| 2938 |
manifold stands in need of, for these reasons, the Antinomies, by |
| 2939 |
virtue of human reason.} |
| 2940 |
|
| 2941 |
\@@_newpara:n {By virtue of practical reason, there can be no doubt |
| 2942 |
that our experience, still, occupies part of the sphere of the |
| 2943 |
manifold concerning the existence of our analytic judgements in |
| 2944 |
general; as I have elsewhere shown, the Categories can never, as a |
| 2945 |
whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the |
| 2946 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, they are a |
| 2947 |
representation of synthetic principles. As is proven in the |
| 2948 |
ontological manuals, the Categories are what first give rise to, |
| 2949 |
consequently, our faculties. We can deduce that, insomuch as the |
| 2950 |
discipline of practical reason relies on our ideas, necessity can be |
| 2951 |
treated like the thing in itself, yet the noumena can never, as a |
| 2952 |
whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like time, |
| 2953 |
they are a representation of problematic principles. However, let us |
| 2954 |
suppose that the things in themselves are the clue to the discovery |
| 2955 |
of, consequently, our judgements, as we have already seen. Whence |
| 2956 |
comes time, the solution of which involves the relation between the |
| 2957 |
phenomena and the noumena? In the study of our experience, I assert |
| 2958 |
that the Ideal can not take account of the discipline of practical |
| 2959 |
reason, as is proven in the ontological manuals. The reader should be |
| 2960 |
careful to observe that the phenomena are what first give rise to the |
| 2961 |
Categories, by virtue of natural reason. As is proven in the |
| 2962 |
ontological manuals, the Ideal is a body of demonstrated science, and |
| 2963 |
some of it must be known a priori. This may be clear with an |
| 2964 |
example.} |
| 2965 |
|
| 2966 |
\@@_newpara:n {The transcendental unity of apperception, so far as |
| 2967 |
regards the Ideal of practical reason and the noumena, abstracts from |
| 2968 |
all content of a posteriori knowledge, by virtue of human reason. To |
| 2969 |
avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, that is to |
| 2970 |
say, our inductive judgements have nothing to do with, in the case of |
| 2971 |
the discipline of human reason, the things in themselves, and the |
| 2972 |
paralogisms of natural reason are the clue to the discovery of the |
| 2973 |
Transcendental Deduction. It remains a mystery why the noumena, in |
| 2974 |
natural theology, would be falsified; however, the things in |
| 2975 |
themselves can not take account of the thing in itself. As any |
| 2976 |
dedicated reader can clearly see, philosophy, in the study of the |
| 2977 |
thing in itself, can never furnish a true and demonstrated science, |
| 2978 |
because, like the Ideal of practical reason, it proves the validity of |
| 2979 |
inductive principles, but our sense perceptions, with the sole |
| 2980 |
exception of necessity, are the clue to the discovery of the |
| 2981 |
transcendental unity of apperception. Let us suppose that the |
| 2982 |
Categories can never, as a whole, furnish a true and demonstrated |
| 2983 |
science, because, like the employment of philosophy, they have nothing |
| 2984 |
to do with hypothetical principles. Our ideas have nothing to do with |
| 2985 |
the transcendental aesthetic.} |
| 2986 |
|
| 2987 |
\@@_newpara:n {In the case of philosophy, the Transcendental |
| 2988 |
Deduction proves the validity of necessity, by means of analysis. Our |
| 2989 |
sense perceptions have lying before them, certainly, our experience. |
| 2990 |
There can be no doubt that space (and it remains a mystery why this is |
| 2991 |
true) stands in need of the noumena. As I have elsewhere shown, the |
| 2992 |
transcendental unity of apperception has lying before it, irrespective |
| 2993 |
of all empirical conditions, the Transcendental Deduction. The |
| 2994 |
objects in space and time are the clue to the discovery of our |
| 2995 |
faculties, but the thing in itself, in accordance with the principles |
| 2996 |
of our experience, can be treated like the paralogisms. As is proven |
| 2997 |
in the ontological manuals, space has nothing to do with, thus, our |
| 2998 |
ideas, yet the things in themselves, in natural theology, can be |
| 2999 |
treated like the transcendental aesthetic.} |
| 3000 |
|
| 3001 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is shown in the writings of Galileo, it remains a |
| 3002 |
mystery why, so far as I know, the phenomena are the mere results of |
| 3003 |
the power of the Ideal of pure reason, a blind but indispensable |
| 3004 |
function of the soul, but the paralogisms (and there can be no doubt |
| 3005 |
that this is the case) exclude the possibility of the transcendental |
| 3006 |
aesthetic. Our experience, in accordance with the principles of |
| 3007 |
transcendental logic, occupies part of the sphere of the manifold |
| 3008 |
concerning the existence of the Categories in general. Our sense |
| 3009 |
perceptions can not take account of the Ideal, by virtue of natural |
| 3010 |
reason. Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, the |
| 3011 |
objects in space and time (and to avoid all misapprehension, it is |
| 3012 |
necessary to explain that this is the case) would thereby be made to |
| 3013 |
contradict the pure employment of space; in the case of the discipline |
| 3014 |
of human reason, the Antinomies exclude the possibility of the |
| 3015 |
transcendental aesthetic. Has it ever been suggested that, as we have |
| 3016 |
already seen, it remains a mystery why there is a causal connection |
| 3017 |
bewteen the Ideal of human reason and the Ideal of human reason? What |
| 3018 |
we have alone been able to show is that the Antinomies, for these |
| 3019 |
reasons, stand in need to our judgements. Let us suppose that, in |
| 3020 |
accordance with the principles of the Ideal of practical reason, the |
| 3021 |
Antinomies prove the validity of space, but natural causes (and I |
| 3022 |
assert, for these reasons, that this is the case) would thereby be |
| 3023 |
made to contradict the transcendental unity of apperception. But the |
| 3024 |
proof of this is a task from which we can here be absolved. } |
| 3025 |
|
| 3026 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is shown in the writings of Hume, the noumena |
| 3027 |
should only be used as a canon for the Categories. As is proven in |
| 3028 |
the ontological manuals, our sense perceptions, consequently, are by |
| 3029 |
their very nature contradictory; therefore, our experience (and it |
| 3030 |
must not be supposed that this is true) may not contradict itself, but |
| 3031 |
it is still possible that it may be in contradictions with the |
| 3032 |
architectonic of practical reason. We can deduce that the Categories |
| 3033 |
would thereby be made to contradict pure logic; for these reasons, |
| 3034 |
space is by its very nature contradictory. Formal logic is a |
| 3035 |
representation of our faculties. Metaphysics, insomuch as time relies |
| 3036 |
on the Antinomies, stands in need of space. Let us suppose that the |
| 3037 |
Antinomies constitute the whole content of our a priori concepts; on |
| 3038 |
the other hand, the Ideal of natural reason (and there can be no doubt |
| 3039 |
that this is true) is a representation of the manifold.} |
| 3040 |
|
| 3041 |
\@@_newpara:n {I assert, certainly, that, irrespective of all |
| 3042 |
empirical conditions, the Categories are just as necessary as, on the |
| 3043 |
other hand, the thing in itself, yet the manifold proves the validity |
| 3044 |
of, on the other hand, the employment of the transcendental unity of |
| 3045 |
apperception. As is proven in the ontological manuals, the |
| 3046 |
never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions exists in |
| 3047 |
the architectonic of practical reason. As is evident upon close |
| 3048 |
examination, it remains a mystery why the things in themselves have |
| 3049 |
lying before them, that is to say, the Ideal; however, the |
| 3050 |
architectonic of natural reason exists in the Ideal of pure reason. |
| 3051 |
Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, the noumena |
| 3052 |
exclude the possibility of, however, general logic; consequently, the |
| 3053 |
paralogisms of natural reason, when thus treated as our ideas, can be |
| 3054 |
treated like philosophy.} |
| 3055 |
|
| 3056 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is evident upon close examination, our faculties |
| 3057 |
stand in need to the transcendental objects in space and time; |
| 3058 |
certainly, our ideas are a representation of the objects in space and |
| 3059 |
time. The reader should be careful to observe that the Categories |
| 3060 |
constitute the whole content of the paralogisms of human reason. By |
| 3061 |
means of analytic unity, space would be falsified; with the sole |
| 3062 |
exception of the manifold, necessity, even as this relates to our |
| 3063 |
understanding, has nothing to do with natural causes. Time is just as |
| 3064 |
necessary as, indeed, the phenomena. Thus, the noumena, consequently, |
| 3065 |
exclude the possibility of the Transcendental Deduction, by means of |
| 3066 |
analysis. Has it ever been suggested that, as we have already seen, |
| 3067 |
Aristotle tells us that there is a causal connection bewteen the |
| 3068 |
noumena and the things in themselves? The employment of the |
| 3069 |
Antinomies is the key to understanding our ideas.} |
| 3070 |
|
| 3071 |
\@@_newpara:n {What we have alone been able to show is that the |
| 3072 |
employment of the transcendental aesthetic, still, exists in our sense |
| 3073 |
perceptions; as I have elsewhere shown, the phenomena exist in the |
| 3074 |
discipline of practical reason. Necessity (and Aristotle tells us |
| 3075 |
that this is true) has lying before it the objects in space and time; |
| 3076 |
in natural theology, our understanding, for example, proves the |
| 3077 |
validity of the objects in space and time. It is not at all certain |
| 3078 |
that our faculties, in the case of the thing in itself, are the clue |
| 3079 |
to the discovery of the Categories, as we have already seen. To avoid |
| 3080 |
all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, in reference to |
| 3081 |
ends, the Ideal would be falsified, and the Antinomies are a |
| 3082 |
representation of our a priori knowledge. (By means of analysis, to |
| 3083 |
avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, even as |
| 3084 |
this relates to the Ideal of practical reason, the phenomena |
| 3085 |
constitute the whole content of, in view of these considerations, our |
| 3086 |
knowledge, and the discipline of natural reason (and we can deduce |
| 3087 |
that this is true) is just as necessary as the manifold.) The reader |
| 3088 |
should be careful to observe that, indeed, our judgements can not take |
| 3089 |
account of our sense perceptions, but the thing in itself, so far as I |
| 3090 |
know, can not take account of our sense perceptions. Let us suppose |
| 3091 |
that our ideas are a representation of metaphysics.} |
| 3092 |
|
| 3093 |
\@@_newpara:n {By virtue of human reason, the Ideal of pure reason, |
| 3094 |
in the full sense of these terms, is by its very nature contradictory, |
| 3095 |
yet necessity is the key to understanding metaphysics. The Categories |
| 3096 |
have nothing to do with, therefore, the phenomena. We can deduce that |
| 3097 |
our experience can be treated like our a priori knowledge; certainly, |
| 3098 |
the objects in space and time are what first give rise to philosophy. |
| 3099 |
Because of the relation between the architectonic of natural reason |
| 3100 |
and the Antinomies, space has nothing to do with our ideas, but the |
| 3101 |
manifold occupies part of the sphere of the transcendental aesthetic |
| 3102 |
concerning the existence of the phenomena in general. The paralogisms |
| 3103 |
of human reason are the clue to the discovery of, on the contrary, our |
| 3104 |
understanding.} |
| 3105 |
|
| 3106 |
\@@_newpara:n {There can be no doubt that, in reference to ends, the |
| 3107 |
thing in itself excludes the possibility of the objects in space and |
| 3108 |
time, but the discipline of human reason is by its very nature |
| 3109 |
contradictory. It is obvious that, in other words, the manifold, in |
| 3110 |
so far as this expounds the practical rules of the thing in itself, is |
| 3111 |
the clue to the discovery of the things in themselves, yet our |
| 3112 |
experience has lying before it space. Our ideas would be falsified, |
| 3113 |
yet the thing in itself is just as necessary as the Antinomies. |
| 3114 |
Metaphysics exists in our speculative judgements. By means of |
| 3115 |
analysis, the phenomena are a representation of our faculties.} |
| 3116 |
|
| 3117 |
\@@_newpara:n {The phenomena stand in need to our sense perceptions, |
| 3118 |
but our concepts are the clue to the discovery of formal logic. The |
| 3119 |
objects in space and time have nothing to do with the things in |
| 3120 |
themselves, as is evident upon close examination. Time teaches us |
| 3121 |
nothing whatsoever regarding the content of the noumena. It is not at |
| 3122 |
all certain that, so far as regards the manifold and the objects in |
| 3123 |
space and time, the Transcendental Deduction, therefore, occupies part |
| 3124 |
of the sphere of pure logic concerning the existence of natural causes |
| 3125 |
in general, but the things in themselves, consequently, are a |
| 3126 |
representation of the intelligible objects in space and time. The |
| 3127 |
Transcendental Deduction (and to avoid all misapprehension, it is |
| 3128 |
necessary to explain that this is true) depends on necessity, as we |
| 3129 |
have already seen. Consequently, it remains a mystery why our a |
| 3130 |
priori concepts, on the other hand, are what first give rise to the |
| 3131 |
Ideal of human reason, as any dedicated reader can clearly see.} |
| 3132 |
|
| 3133 |
\@@_newpara:n {What we have alone been able to show is that, then, |
| 3134 |
the Ideal of human reason, in reference to ends, is the mere result of |
| 3135 |
the power of practical reason, a blind but indispensable function of |
| 3136 |
the soul, but the Ideal (and the reader should be careful to observe |
| 3137 |
that this is true) has lying before it our ideas. In the study of the |
| 3138 |
thing in itself, I assert, with the sole exception of the manifold, |
| 3139 |
that the Ideal of human reason is the clue to the discovery of the |
| 3140 |
practical employment of the Ideal of natural reason. As will easily |
| 3141 |
be shown in the next section, our ideas have lying before them the |
| 3142 |
Ideal of natural reason; thus, the Antinomies are what first give rise |
| 3143 |
to, indeed, the noumena. We can deduce that the Categories (and it is |
| 3144 |
obvious that this is the case) would thereby be made to contradict our |
| 3145 |
faculties. As we have already seen, it is not at all certain that |
| 3146 |
natural causes occupy part of the sphere of the architectonic of |
| 3147 |
natural reason concerning the existence of natural causes in general; |
| 3148 |
for these reasons, our ideas, in natural theology, occupy part of the |
| 3149 |
sphere of the never-ending regress in the series of empirical |
| 3150 |
conditions concerning the existence of our judgements in general. Yet |
| 3151 |
can I entertain the transcendental aesthetic in thought, or does it |
| 3152 |
present itself to me? In the study of the Ideal, the Ideal of pure |
| 3153 |
reason depends on time. However, our a priori judgements have lying |
| 3154 |
before them the employment of necessity, by means of analytic unity. |
| 3155 |
} |
| 3156 |
|
| 3157 |
\@@_newpara:n {As will easily be shown in the next section, it is not |
| 3158 |
at all certain that the transcendental unity of apperception is the |
| 3159 |
key to understanding the things in themselves; certainly, the |
| 3160 |
Categories prove the validity of our faculties. Let us suppose that |
| 3161 |
the paralogisms of natural reason (and we can deduce that this is the |
| 3162 |
case) are a representation of the discipline of human reason. It |
| 3163 |
remains a mystery why practical reason can be treated like the |
| 3164 |
phenomena. (As is shown in the writings of Aristotle, there can be no |
| 3165 |
doubt that the Categories, in the study of the discipline of human |
| 3166 |
reason, exclude the possibility of the Categories.) As will easily be |
| 3167 |
shown in the next section, our ideas stand in need to our knowledge. |
| 3168 |
As any dedicated reader can clearly see, the Antinomies exist in our a |
| 3169 |
posteriori concepts, yet the thing in itself can not take account of, |
| 3170 |
as I have elsewhere shown, the Categories. The question of this |
| 3171 |
matter's relation to objects is not in any way under discussion.} |
| 3172 |
|
| 3173 |
\@@_newpara:n {It must not be supposed that, so regarded, our |
| 3174 |
experience, in particular, can thereby determine in its totality our |
| 3175 |
analytic judgements, yet necessity has nothing to do with, in |
| 3176 |
reference to ends, the discipline of human reason. It is not at all |
| 3177 |
certain that the never-ending regress in the series of empirical |
| 3178 |
conditions would thereby be made to contradict, in particular, pure |
| 3179 |
logic; with the sole exception of the Ideal, our ideas, that is to |
| 3180 |
say, should only be used as a canon for our judgements. Since some of |
| 3181 |
the Antinomies are disjunctive, the Transcendental Deduction can be |
| 3182 |
treated like the never-ending regress in the series of empirical |
| 3183 |
conditions. In the case of the Transcendental Deduction, it is not at |
| 3184 |
all certain that the Ideal of natural reason, in view of these |
| 3185 |
considerations, can be treated like the architectonic of human reason. |
| 3186 |
The Antinomies (and Aristotle tells us that this is the case) exclude |
| 3187 |
the possibility of the Ideal of human reason; in the case of the |
| 3188 |
discipline of natural reason, necessity would thereby be made to |
| 3189 |
contradict, so far as I know, the Ideal of pure reason. |
| 3190 |
Transcendental logic is a representation of the Transcendental |
| 3191 |
Deduction; by means of the transcendental aesthetic, the thing in |
| 3192 |
itself can thereby determine in its totality the Ideal of pure reason. |
| 3193 |
In my present remarks I am referring to the never-ending regress in |
| 3194 |
the series of empirical conditions only in so far as it is founded on |
| 3195 |
hypothetical principles.} |
| 3196 |
|
| 3197 |
\@@_newpara:n {The things in themselves prove the validity of, on the |
| 3198 |
other hand, transcendental logic; therefore, necessity has lying |
| 3199 |
before it, indeed, the paralogisms. What we have alone been able to |
| 3200 |
show is that our ideas constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and |
| 3201 |
all of this body must be known a priori. Our understanding has lying |
| 3202 |
before it, for these reasons, our ampliative judgements. Because of |
| 3203 |
our necessary ignorance of the conditions, it is obvious that time may |
| 3204 |
not contradict itself, but it is still possible that it may be in |
| 3205 |
contradictions with, in view of these considerations, our ideas; |
| 3206 |
still, the practical employment of the transcendental objects in space |
| 3207 |
and time, that is to say, has lying before it the things in |
| 3208 |
themselves. Natural causes prove the validity of necessity.} |
| 3209 |
|
| 3210 |
\@@_newpara:n {The reader should be careful to observe that our a |
| 3211 |
priori concepts, in other words, can never, as a whole, furnish a true |
| 3212 |
and demonstrated science, because, like general logic, they prove the |
| 3213 |
validity of hypothetical principles, by virtue of human reason. There |
| 3214 |
can be no doubt that, indeed, the Antinomies, in other words, would be |
| 3215 |
falsified, and the phenomena constitute the whole content of the |
| 3216 |
discipline of natural reason. The phenomena can not take account of, |
| 3217 |
in natural theology, the Ideal of practical reason. Time can never |
| 3218 |
furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like necessity, it |
| 3219 |
has nothing to do with a posteriori principles; in view of these |
| 3220 |
considerations, our a priori concepts stand in need to the discipline |
| 3221 |
of pure reason. Our ideas constitute the whole content of the objects |
| 3222 |
in space and time, but the Ideal, indeed, is the key to understanding |
| 3223 |
our understanding.} |
| 3224 |
|
| 3225 |
\@@_newpara:n {As we have already seen, it is not at all certain that |
| 3226 |
the Ideal of pure reason is just as necessary as natural causes; in |
| 3227 |
the case of the Transcendental Deduction, our faculties, in natural |
| 3228 |
theology, abstract from all content of knowledge. The Categories can |
| 3229 |
never, as a whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, |
| 3230 |
like the manifold, they have lying before them a posteriori |
| 3231 |
principles, but time is by its very nature contradictory. We can |
| 3232 |
deduce that the Categories, so regarded, are by their very nature |
| 3233 |
contradictory; for these reasons, time is what first gives rise to our |
| 3234 |
ideas. Still, is it the case that pure logic constitutes the whole |
| 3235 |
content for the Transcendental Deduction, or is the real question |
| 3236 |
whether the paralogisms exist in our experience? Still, natural |
| 3237 |
reason, so far as I know, would be falsified, because of our necessary |
| 3238 |
ignorance of the conditions. Our faculties would be falsified.} |
| 3239 |
|
| 3240 |
\@@_newpara:n {The Ideal proves the validity of the objects in space |
| 3241 |
and time. To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain |
| 3242 |
that our judgements are a representation of, however, the manifold. |
| 3243 |
The objects in space and time exclude the possibility of necessity. |
| 3244 |
The reader should be careful to observe that the Ideal, consequently, |
| 3245 |
abstracts from all content of knowledge. There can be no doubt that, |
| 3246 |
indeed, the objects in space and time would thereby be made to |
| 3247 |
contradict human reason.} |
| 3248 |
|
| 3249 |
\@@_newpara:n {It is obvious that the transcendental unity of |
| 3250 |
apperception can be treated like the Ideal. I assert that applied |
| 3251 |
logic (and it is not at all certain that this is true) stands in need |
| 3252 |
of the objects in space and time; certainly, the Ideal of practical |
| 3253 |
reason is what first gives rise to the Categories. On the other hand, |
| 3254 |
our experience (and it remains a mystery why this is true) stands in |
| 3255 |
need of the transcendental unity of apperception. It remains a |
| 3256 |
mystery why the Antinomies prove the validity of metaphysics. There |
| 3257 |
can be no doubt that, in particular, the architectonic of pure reason, |
| 3258 |
in all theoretical sciences, can never furnish a true and demonstrated |
| 3259 |
science, because, like the manifold, it teaches us nothing whatsoever |
| 3260 |
regarding the content of hypothetical principles, but the phenomena, |
| 3261 |
with the sole exception of the transcendental aesthetic, have nothing |
| 3262 |
to do with philosophy. It is obvious that our understanding, that is |
| 3263 |
to say, is the mere result of the power of space, a blind but |
| 3264 |
indispensable function of the soul, by means of analytic unity. Since |
| 3265 |
knowledge of our sense perceptions is a priori, we can deduce that our |
| 3266 |
experience is what first gives rise to the architectonic of practical |
| 3267 |
reason. This may be clear with an example. } |
| 3268 |
|
| 3269 |
\@@_newpara:n {I assert, consequently, that the Transcendental |
| 3270 |
Deduction would thereby be made to contradict our faculties, as will |
| 3271 |
easily be shown in the next section. Let us suppose that our ideas, |
| 3272 |
in the full sense of these terms, occupy part of the sphere of formal |
| 3273 |
logic concerning the existence of the noumena in general. To avoid |
| 3274 |
all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the |
| 3275 |
Transcendental Deduction, so far as I know, occupies part of the |
| 3276 |
sphere of the architectonic of practical reason concerning the |
| 3277 |
existence of the Antinomies in general; certainly, the paralogisms |
| 3278 |
occupy part of the sphere of the architectonic of natural reason |
| 3279 |
concerning the existence of our ideas in general. To avoid all |
| 3280 |
misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the pure employment |
| 3281 |
of the architectonic of practical reason, still, is by its very nature |
| 3282 |
contradictory; consequently, the intelligible objects in space and |
| 3283 |
time would thereby be made to contradict the transcendental objects in |
| 3284 |
space and time. We can deduce that the thing in itself exists in the |
| 3285 |
Antinomies. As is evident upon close examination, the never-ending |
| 3286 |
regress in the series of empirical conditions depends on, therefore, |
| 3287 |
necessity. I assert that our judgements are a representation of the |
| 3288 |
noumena; on the other hand, the transcendental unity of apperception |
| 3289 |
teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of, then, the |
| 3290 |
Ideal of pure reason.} |
| 3291 |
|
| 3292 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is evident upon close examination, the things in |
| 3293 |
themselves are the clue to the discovery of the phenomena, and |
| 3294 |
philosophy (and what we have alone been able to show is that this is |
| 3295 |
true) teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of the |
| 3296 |
phenomena. Still, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to |
| 3297 |
explain that natural causes (and it is obvious that this is the case) |
| 3298 |
have nothing to do with our faculties. To avoid all misapprehension, |
| 3299 |
it is necessary to explain that, irrespective of all empirical |
| 3300 |
conditions, the employment of the objects in space and time can not |
| 3301 |
take account of, that is to say, our concepts, but the never-ending |
| 3302 |
regress in the series of empirical conditions constitutes the whole |
| 3303 |
content for our sense perceptions. In the case of the discipline of |
| 3304 |
pure reason, let us suppose that general logic stands in need of the |
| 3305 |
Ideal of human reason, as we have already seen. The noumena prove the |
| 3306 |
validity of, in the study of transcendental logic, our understanding.} |
| 3307 |
|
| 3308 |
\@@_newpara:n {Space (and what we have alone been able to show is |
| 3309 |
that this is true) stands in need of necessity, yet our understanding, |
| 3310 |
so far as regards the Ideal of practical reason, can never furnish a |
| 3311 |
true and demonstrated science, because, like the transcendental unity |
| 3312 |
of apperception, it has lying before it a priori principles. Since |
| 3313 |
some of our judgements are disjunctive, it remains a mystery why the |
| 3314 |
phenomena stand in need to the objects in space and time. In view of |
| 3315 |
these considerations, the Categories (and let us suppose that this is |
| 3316 |
the case) are just as necessary as the pure employment of the |
| 3317 |
phenomena. Let us suppose that the things in themselves, so far as I |
| 3318 |
know, abstract from all content of a posteriori knowledge. It is |
| 3319 |
obvious that, even as this relates to the thing in itself, natural |
| 3320 |
causes can never, as a whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science, |
| 3321 |
because, like metaphysics, they are just as necessary as inductive |
| 3322 |
principles. The architectonic of practical reason (and it is not at |
| 3323 |
all certain that this is true) depends on the thing in itself, but the |
| 3324 |
objects in space and time, as I have elsewhere shown, are the mere |
| 3325 |
results of the power of the employment of the Antinomies, a blind but |
| 3326 |
indispensable function of the soul. By means of analysis, there can |
| 3327 |
be no doubt that, in reference to ends, natural causes are a |
| 3328 |
representation of, in respect of the intelligible character, time, and |
| 3329 |
the pure employment of the discipline of natural reason has lying |
| 3330 |
before it our experience.} |
| 3331 |
|
| 3332 |
\@@_newpara:n {Still, it must not be supposed that our faculties are |
| 3333 |
a representation of the Ideal of practical reason, as is evident upon |
| 3334 |
close examination. As is proven in the ontological manuals, the |
| 3335 |
reader should be careful to observe that the objects in space and time |
| 3336 |
are the mere results of the power of time, a blind but indispensable |
| 3337 |
function of the soul; in all theoretical sciences, the Ideal is a |
| 3338 |
representation of, so far as regards the architectonic of natural |
| 3339 |
reason, our sense perceptions. Aristotle tells us that, in |
| 3340 |
particular, the objects in space and time, in the case of the |
| 3341 |
manifold, are a representation of the things in themselves, yet |
| 3342 |
natural causes stand in need to, irrespective of all empirical |
| 3343 |
conditions, the things in themselves. Certainly, the transcendental |
| 3344 |
unity of apperception, in accordance with the principles of the |
| 3345 |
intelligible objects in space and time, exists in our sense |
| 3346 |
perceptions. As we have already seen, the discipline of human reason |
| 3347 |
(and Galileo tells us that this is true) depends on the thing in |
| 3348 |
itself. Since some of natural causes are synthetic, the reader should |
| 3349 |
be careful to observe that, for example, the things in themselves (and |
| 3350 |
it is not at all certain that this is the case) are the clue to the |
| 3351 |
discovery of our concepts. But this need not worry us.} |
| 3352 |
|
| 3353 |
\@@_newpara:n {The architectonic of natural reason is the key to |
| 3354 |
understanding, so far as regards our a posteriori knowledge and the |
| 3355 |
paralogisms, time; still, the Categories, with the sole exception of |
| 3356 |
the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, should |
| 3357 |
only be used as a canon for the transcendental unity of apperception. |
| 3358 |
However, the reader should be careful to observe that the noumena |
| 3359 |
exist in time. Because of the relation between space and the |
| 3360 |
phenomena, let us suppose that our ideas are the clue to the discovery |
| 3361 |
of our faculties. The phenomena constitute the whole content of the |
| 3362 |
phenomena, but the transcendental unity of apperception, on the other |
| 3363 |
hand, would be falsified. (As is evident upon close examination, it |
| 3364 |
must not be supposed that our a posteriori knowledge is by its very |
| 3365 |
nature contradictory.) There can be no doubt that the practical |
| 3366 |
employment of our problematic judgements can be treated like the |
| 3367 |
transcendental aesthetic. Aristotle tells us that our faculties have |
| 3368 |
nothing to do with the objects in space and time. We thus have a pure |
| 3369 |
synthesis of apprehension.} |
| 3370 |
|
| 3371 |
\@@_newpara:n {Since none of the noumena are hypothetical, there can |
| 3372 |
be no doubt that, in particular, our knowledge, in other words, is the |
| 3373 |
clue to the discovery of the things in themselves. Therefore, the |
| 3374 |
Ideal is just as necessary as, then, the Ideal, as will easily be |
| 3375 |
shown in the next section. We can deduce that, then, our knowledge, |
| 3376 |
in respect of the intelligible character, is by its very nature |
| 3377 |
contradictory, and the noumena, in particular, are by their very |
| 3378 |
nature contradictory. The reader should be careful to observe that, |
| 3379 |
indeed, pure logic, still, is a body of demonstrated science, and none |
| 3380 |
of it must be known a posteriori, yet our speculative judgements exist |
| 3381 |
in the manifold. In the case of time, the Categories, by means of |
| 3382 |
transcendental logic, constitute the whole content of the things in |
| 3383 |
themselves, as any dedicated reader can clearly see.} |
| 3384 |
|
| 3385 |
\@@_newpara:n {Transcendental logic can thereby determine in its |
| 3386 |
totality, consequently, our faculties, because of our necessary |
| 3387 |
ignorance of the conditions. Since some of the paralogisms are |
| 3388 |
analytic, there can be no doubt that, in reference to ends, the |
| 3389 |
Antinomies, for these reasons, constitute the whole content of |
| 3390 |
necessity, yet the things in themselves constitute the whole content |
| 3391 |
of our understanding. In view of these considerations, it is obvious |
| 3392 |
that the paralogisms are by their very nature contradictory, as any |
| 3393 |
dedicated reader can clearly see. In natural theology, our ideas (and |
| 3394 |
it remains a mystery why this is the case) have nothing to do with the |
| 3395 |
discipline of pure reason, as any dedicated reader can clearly see. |
| 3396 |
What we have alone been able to show is that philosophy occupies part |
| 3397 |
of the sphere of the Transcendental Deduction concerning the existence |
| 3398 |
of natural causes in general. Since knowledge of the phenomena is a |
| 3399 |
posteriori, our ideas, in all theoretical sciences, can be treated |
| 3400 |
like time, but our judgements are just as necessary as the Categories. |
| 3401 |
Our understanding is a representation of the objects in space and |
| 3402 |
time, and the paralogisms are just as necessary as our experience.} |
| 3403 |
|
| 3404 |
\@@_newpara:n {Philosophy (and it must not be supposed that this is |
| 3405 |
true) is a representation of the never-ending regress in the series of |
| 3406 |
empirical conditions; however, the Antinomies have nothing to do with, |
| 3407 |
in the study of philosophy, the discipline of practical reason. |
| 3408 |
Because of the relation between philosophy and our ideas, it remains a |
| 3409 |
mystery why, so regarded, metaphysics depends on the employment of |
| 3410 |
natural causes. The pure employment of the Antinomies, in particular, |
| 3411 |
is a body of demonstrated science, and all of it must be known a |
| 3412 |
priori, but necessity is a representation of the Ideal. As will |
| 3413 |
easily be shown in the next section, it remains a mystery why the |
| 3414 |
Antinomies are what first give rise to the transcendental aesthetic; |
| 3415 |
in all theoretical sciences, the architectonic of pure reason has |
| 3416 |
nothing to do with, therefore, the noumena. The noumena are the clue |
| 3417 |
to the discovery of the Categories, yet the transcendental aesthetic, |
| 3418 |
for example, stands in need of natural causes. The Categories can not |
| 3419 |
take account of, so far as regards the architectonic of natural |
| 3420 |
reason, the paralogisms; in the study of general logic, the |
| 3421 |
transcendental unity of apperception, insomuch as the architectonic of |
| 3422 |
human reason relies on the Antinomies, can thereby determine in its |
| 3423 |
totality natural causes.} |
| 3424 |
|
| 3425 |
\@@_newpara:n {As is shown in the writings of Hume, it remains a |
| 3426 |
mystery why our judgements exclude the possibility of the |
| 3427 |
transcendental aesthetic; therefore, the transcendental aesthetic can |
| 3428 |
not take account of the thing in itself. Our knowledge depends on, |
| 3429 |
indeed, our knowledge. It is not at all certain that space is just as |
| 3430 |
necessary as the noumena. Is it true that metaphysics can not take |
| 3431 |
account of the paralogisms of human reason, or is the real question |
| 3432 |
whether the noumena are by their very nature contradictory? On the |
| 3433 |
other hand, time constitutes the whole content for necessity, by means |
| 3434 |
of analytic unity. There can be no doubt that the phenomena have |
| 3435 |
lying before them metaphysics. As is proven in the ontological |
| 3436 |
manuals, it remains a mystery why space exists in the objects in space |
| 3437 |
and time; still, the noumena, in the case of necessity, constitute the |
| 3438 |
whole content of philosophy.} |
| 3439 |
|
| 3440 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 3441 |
% |
| 3442 |
% Now we define the sequence of index words. |
| 3443 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 3444 |
\@@_newword:n {Ideal} |
| 3445 |
\@@_newword:n {noumena} |
| 3446 |
\@@_newword:n {Aristotle} |
| 3447 |
\@@_newword:n {transcendental} |
| 3448 |
\@@_newword:n {metaphysics} |
| 3449 |
\@@_newword:n {reason} |
| 3450 |
\@@_newword:n {science} |
| 3451 |
\@@_newword:n {necessity} |
| 3452 |
\@@_newword:n {Categories} |
| 3453 |
\@@_newword:n {philosophy} |
| 3454 |
\@@_newword:n {knowledge} |
| 3455 |
\@@_newword:n {regress} |
| 3456 |
\@@_newword:n {paralogism} |
| 3457 |
\@@_newword:n {empirical} |
| 3458 |
\@@_newword:n {space} |
| 3459 |
\@@_newword:n {manifold} |
| 3460 |
\@@_newword:n {understanding} |
| 3461 |
\@@_newword:n {aesthetic} |
| 3462 |
\@@_newword:n {noumena} |
| 3463 |
\@@_newword:n {sphere} |
| 3464 |
\@@_newword:n {time} |
| 3465 |
\@@_newword:n {practical reason} |
| 3466 |
\@@_newword:n {perception} |
| 3467 |
\@@_newword:n {things in themselves} |
| 3468 |
\@@_newword:n {doctrine} |
| 3469 |
\@@_newword:n {regress} |
| 3470 |
\@@_newword:n {mystery} |
| 3471 |
\@@_newword:n {existence} |
| 3472 |
\@@_newword:n {contradiction} |
| 3473 |
\@@_newword:n {a priori} |
| 3474 |
\@@_newword:n {natural causes} |
| 3475 |
\@@_newword:n {analysis} |
| 3476 |
\@@_newword:n {apperception} |
| 3477 |
\@@_newword:n {Antinomies} |
| 3478 |
\@@_newword:n {Transcendental Deduction} |
| 3479 |
\@@_newword:n {phenomena} |
| 3480 |
\@@_newword:n {formal logic} |
| 3481 |
\@@_newword:n {soul} |
| 3482 |
\@@_newword:n {misapprehension} |
| 3483 |
\@@_newword:n {elsewhere} |
| 3484 |
\@@_newword:n {theology} |
| 3485 |
\@@_newword:n {employment} |
| 3486 |
\@@_newword:n {logic} |
| 3487 |
\@@_newword:n {practical reason} |
| 3488 |
\@@_newword:n {theoretical sciences} |
| 3489 |
\@@_newword:n {a posteriori} |
| 3490 |
\@@_newword:n {mystery} |
| 3491 |
\@@_newword:n {philosophy} |
| 3492 |
\@@_newword:n {things in themselves} |
| 3493 |
\@@_newword:n {experience} |
| 3494 |
\@@_newword:n {contradictory} |
| 3495 |
\@@_newword:n {Categories} |
| 3496 |
\@@_newword:n {perceptions} |
| 3497 |
\@@_newword:n {Galileo} |
| 3498 |
\@@_newword:n {apperception} |
| 3499 |
\@@_newword:n {empirical objects} |
| 3500 |
\@@_newword:n {judgements} |
| 3501 |
\@@_newword:n {phenomena} |
| 3502 |
\@@_newword:n {power} |
| 3503 |
\@@_newword:n {hypothetical principles} |
| 3504 |
\@@_newword:n {transcendental logic} |
| 3505 |
\@@_newword:n {doctrine} |
| 3506 |
\@@_newword:n {understanding} |
| 3507 |
\@@_newword:n {totality} |
| 3508 |
\@@_newword:n {manifold} |
| 3509 |
\@@_newword:n {inductive judgements} |
| 3510 |
\@@_newword:n {Transcendental Deduction} |
| 3511 |
\@@_newword:n {analytic unity} |
| 3512 |
\@@_newword:n {Hume} |
| 3513 |
\@@_newword:n {canon} |
| 3514 |
\@@_newword:n {knowledge} |
| 3515 |
\@@_newword:n {universal} |
| 3516 |
\@@_newword:n {section} |
| 3517 |
\@@_newword:n {body} |
| 3518 |
\@@_newword:n {ignorance} |
| 3519 |
\@@_newword:n {sense perceptions} |
| 3520 |
\@@_newword:n {natural reason} |
| 3521 |
\@@_newword:n {exception} |
| 3522 |
\@@_newword:n {ampliative judgements} |
| 3523 |
\@@_newword:n {experience} |
| 3524 |
\@@_newword:n {Categories} |
| 3525 |
\@@_newword:n {analysis} |
| 3526 |
\@@_newword:n {philosophy} |
| 3527 |
\@@_newword:n {apperception} |
| 3528 |
\@@_newword:n {paralogism} |
| 3529 |
\@@_newword:n {ignorance} |
| 3530 |
\@@_newword:n {true} |
| 3531 |
\@@_newword:n {space} |
| 3532 |
\@@_newword:n {Ideal} |
| 3533 |
\@@_newword:n {accordance} |
| 3534 |
\@@_newword:n {regress} |
| 3535 |
\@@_newword:n {experience} |
| 3536 |
\@@_newword:n {a priori} |
| 3537 |
\@@_newword:n {disjunctive} |
| 3538 |
\@@_newword:n {soul} |
| 3539 |
\@@_newword:n {understanding} |
| 3540 |
\@@_newword:n {analytic unity} |
| 3541 |
\@@_newword:n {phenomena} |
| 3542 |
\@@_newword:n {practical reason} |
| 3543 |
\@@_newword:n {cause} |
| 3544 |
\@@_newword:n {manuals} |
| 3545 |
\@@_newword:n {dedicated reader} |
| 3546 |
\@@_newword:n {a posteriori} |
| 3547 |
\@@_newword:n {employment} |
| 3548 |
\@@_newword:n {natural theology} |
| 3549 |
\@@_newword:n {manifold} |
| 3550 |
\@@_newword:n {transcendental aesthetic} |
| 3551 |
\@@_newword:n {close} |
| 3552 |
\@@_newword:n {full} |
| 3553 |
\@@_newword:n {Aristotle} |
| 3554 |
\@@_newword:n {clue} |
| 3555 |
\@@_newword:n {me} |
| 3556 |
\@@_newword:n {account} |
| 3557 |
\@@_newword:n {things} |
| 3558 |
\@@_newword:n {sense} |
| 3559 |
\@@_newword:n {intelligible} |
| 3560 |
\@@_newword:n {understanding} |
| 3561 |
\@@_newword:n {Categories} |
| 3562 |
\@@_newword:n {never} |
| 3563 |
\@@_newword:n {apperception} |
| 3564 |
\@@_newword:n {Ideal} |
| 3565 |
\@@_newword:n {need} |
| 3566 |
\@@_newword:n {space} |
| 3567 |
\@@_newword:n {virtue} |
| 3568 |
\@@_newword:n {Hume} |
| 3569 |
\@@_newword:n {still} |
| 3570 |
\@@_newword:n {whatsoever} |
| 3571 |
\@@_newword:n {even} |
| 3572 |
\@@_newword:n {sphere} |
| 3573 |
\@@_newword:n {position} |
| 3574 |
\@@_newword:n {ignorance} |
| 3575 |
\@@_newword:n {word} |
| 3576 |
\@@_newword:n {phenomena} |
| 3577 |
\@@_newword:n {theology} |
| 3578 |
\@@_newword:n {mystery} |
| 3579 |
\@@_newword:n {Categories} |
| 3580 |
\@@_newword:n {perception} |
| 3581 |
\@@_newword:n {power} |
| 3582 |
\@@_newword:n {experience} |
| 3583 |
\@@_newword:n {never-ending} |
| 3584 |
\@@_newword:n {analytic} |
| 3585 |
\@@_newword:n {itself} |
| 3586 |
\@@_newword:n {a priori} |
| 3587 |
\@@_newword:n {rule} |
| 3588 |
\@@_newword:n {Transcendental Deduction} |
| 3589 |
\@@_newword:n {empirical conditions} |
| 3590 |
\@@_newword:n {knowledge} |
| 3591 |
\@@_newword:n {disjunctive} |
| 3592 |
\@@_newword:n {transcendental} |
| 3593 |
\@@_newword:n {science} |
| 3594 |
\@@_newword:n {falsified} |
| 3595 |
\@@_newword:n {reader} |
| 3596 |
\@@_newword:n {blind} |
| 3597 |
\@@_newword:n {employment} |
| 3598 |
\@@_newword:n {discipline} |
| 3599 |
\@@_newword:n {function} |
| 3600 |
\@@_newword:n {careful} |
| 3601 |
\@@_newword:n {Aristotle} |
| 3602 |
\@@_newword:n {Categories} |
| 3603 |
\@@_newword:n {part} |
| 3604 |
\@@_newword:n {noumena} |
| 3605 |
\@@_newword:n {doubt} |
| 3606 |
\@@_newword:n {duck} |
| 3607 |
\@@_newword:n {Kant} |
| 3608 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 3609 |
% |
| 3610 |
% Finally we close the group and issue a message in the log file |
| 3611 |
% stating how many sentences are available. |
| 3612 |
% \begin{macrocode} |
| 3613 |
\group_end: |
| 3614 |
\msg_info:nne {kantlipsum} {how-many} |
| 3615 |
{ \int_eval:n {\seq_count:N \g_@@_pars_seq} } |
| 3616 |
% \end{macrocode} |
| 3617 |
% |
| 3618 |
% \iffalse |
| 3619 |
%</package> |
| 3620 |
% \fi |
| 3621 |
% \end{implementation} |
| 3622 |
% |
| 3623 |
% \PrintIndex |