Debian Codegraph @

texmf-dist/source/latex/kantlipsum/kantlipsum.dtx

raw
1 % \iffalse meta-comment
2 %<*internal>
3 \iffalse
4 %</internal>
5 %<*readme>
6 The kantlipsum package spits out sentences in Kantian style provided
7 by the "Kant generator for Python" by Mark Pilgrim, described in the
8 book "Dive into Python".
9
10 This is version 0.8c of the package
11
12 Changes from earlier version:
13
14 Version 0.8c is a maintenance release.
15
16 Copyright 2011-2023 Enrico Gregorio
17
18 It may be distributed and/or modified under the conditions of the
19 LaTeX Project Public License (LPPL), either version 1.3c of this
20 license or (at your option) any later version. The latest version
21 of this license is in the file
22
23 http://www.latex-project.org/lppl.txt
24
25 Author: Enrico Gregorio
26 Enrico dot Gregorio at univr dot it
27
28 This work has the LPPL maintenance status "author-maintained".
29
30 This work consists of the following files:
31
32 README (this file)
33 kantlipsum.dtx
34 kantlipsum.pdf
35
36 and of the derived file
37
38 kantlipsum.sty
39
40 To install the distribution:
41
42 o run "tex kantlipsum.dtx"
43 %</readme>
44 %<*internal>
45 \fi
46 \def\nameofplainTeX{plain}
47 \ifx\fmtname\nameofplainTeX\else
48 \expandafter\begingroup
49 \fi
50 %</internal>
51 %<*install>
52 \input l3docstrip.tex
53 \keepsilent
54 \askforoverwritefalse
55 \preamble
56 ---------------------------------------------------------------
57 The kantlipsum package --- Generate text in Kantian style
58 Maintained by Enrico Gregorio
59 E-mail: enrico DOT gregorio AT univr DOT it
60 Released under the LaTeX Project Public License v1.3c or later
61 See http://www.latex-project.org/lppl.txt
62 ---------------------------------------------------------------
63 \endpreamble
64 \postamble
65 Copyright (C) 2011-2023 by
66 Enrico Gregorio
67 enrico DOT gregorio AT univr DOT it
68
69 It may be distributed and/or modified under the conditions of the
70 LaTeX Project Public License (LPPL), either version 1.3c of this
71 license or (at your option) any later version. The latest version
72 of this license is in the file
73 http://www.latex-project.org/lppl.txt
74 This work consists of the file kantlipsum.dtx
75 and the derived files kantlipsum.pdf,
76 kantlipsum.sty and
77 kantlipsum.ins.
78 \endpostamble
79 \usedir{tex/latex/kantlipsum}
80 \generate{
81 \file{\jobname.sty}{\from{\jobname.dtx}{package}}
82 }
83 %</install>
84 %<install>\endbatchfile
85 %<*internal>
86 \usedir{source/latex/kantlipsum}
87 \generate{
88 \file{\jobname.ins}{\from{\jobname.dtx}{install}}
89 }
90 \nopreamble\nopostamble
91 \usedir{doc/latex/kantlipsum}
92 \generate{
93 \file{README.md}{\from{\jobname.dtx}{readme}}
94 }
95 \ifx\fmtname\nameofplainTeX
96 \expandafter\endbatchfile
97 \else
98 \expandafter\endgroup
99 \fi
100 %</internal>
101 %<*driver>
102 \documentclass[a4paper,full]{l3doc}
103 \usepackage{bookmark}
104 \usepackage{kantlipsum}
105 \begin{document}
106 \DocInput{\jobname.dtx}
107 \end{document}
108 %</driver>
109 % \fi
110 %
111 % \GetFileInfo{\jobname.sty}
112 %
113 % \title{^^A
114 % The \textsf{kantlipsum} package\\ Dummy text in Kantian style^^A
115 % \thanks{This file describes version \fileversion,
116 % last revised \filedate.}^^A
117 % }
118 %
119 % \author{^^A
120 % Enrico Gregorio\thanks
121 % {^^A
122 % E-mail:
123 % \texttt{Enrico DOT Gregorio AT univr DOT it}^^A
124 % }^^A
125 % }
126 %
127 % \date{Released \filedate}
128 %
129 % \maketitle
130 %
131 %\changes{v0.5}{2011/12/23}{First released version}
132 %\changes{v0.6}{2012/10/14}{Fixes for kernel changes}
133 %\changes{v0.6}{2012/10/14}{Added functions for producing an index}
134 %\changes{v0.7}{2017/11/16}{Use new kernel function}
135 %\changes{v0.8}{2017/07/23}{Print only a few sentences of a paragraph}
136 %\changes{v0.8a}{2017/07/24}{Respect options and *-version}
137 %\changes{v0.8b}{2023/11/21}{Maintenance release}
138 %\changes{v0.8c}{2023/11/27}{Maintenance release}
139 %
140 % \begin{documentation}
141 %
142 % \section{Introduction}
143 %
144 % The \pkg{kantlipsum} package is modeled after \pkg{lipsum} and
145 % offers pretty similar functionality, but instead of pseudolatin
146 % utterances, it typesets paragraphs of nonsense in Kantian style
147 % produced by the \emph{Kant generator for Python} by Mark Pilgrim,
148 % found in \href{http://www.diveintopython.net/}{\emph{Dive into
149 % Python}}.
150 %
151 % It has at least one advantage over \pkg{lipsum}: the text is in
152 % English and so finding good hyphenation points should be less
153 % problematic. On the contrary, the paragraphs are rather long, as
154 % it's common in philosophical prose.
155 %
156 % \section{Example}
157 %
158 % \kant[1-3]
159 %
160 % \section{Options}
161 %
162 % The package has four document options, the first two of which are
163 % alternative to each other:
164 % \begin{itemize}[font=\ttfamily]
165 % \item[par$\,\vert\,$nopar] With the default \texttt{par} all pieces
166 % of text will be ended by a \cs{par} command; specifying \texttt{par}
167 % is optional; the option \texttt{nopar} will not add this \cs{par} at
168 % the end of each fragment of Kantian prose.
169 % \item[numbers] Each piece of Kantian prose will be preceded by its
170 % number (such as in ``1~\textbullet~As any dedicated reader can
171 % clearly see\dots''), which can be useful for better control of what
172 % is produced.
173 % \item[index] Each paragraph will generate an index entry; a
174 % |\makeindex| command will be needed, with a suitable package for
175 % making the index, and |\printindex| for printing it. However the
176 % index entry may be off by one, since the |\index| command is issued
177 % at the beginning of the paragraph. Also there is no guarantee that
178 % the indexed word really belongs to the paragraph.
179 % \end{itemize}
180 %
181 % \section{Commands}
182 %
183 % The commands provided by the package are:
184 % \begin{itemize}[font=\ttfamily]
185 % \item[\cs{kant}] This command takes an optional argument which can
186 % be of the form \texttt{[42]} (that is, only one integer) or
187 % \texttt{[3-14]} (that is, two integers separated by a hyphen); as in
188 % \pkg{lipsum}, \verb|\kant[42]|, \verb|\kant[3-14]| and \verb|\kant|
189 % will produce the 42nd pseudokantian paragraph, the paragraphs from
190 % the 3rd to the 14th, and those from the 1st to the 7th,
191 % respectively.
192 % \item[\cs{kant*}] The same as before, see later for the difference.
193 % \item[\cs{kantdef}] This command takes two arguments, a control
194 % sequence and an integer; the call \verb|\kantdef{\mytext}{164}| will
195 % store in \cs{mytext} the 164th paragraph of pseudokantian text
196 % provided by this package.
197 % \end{itemize}
198 % The commands \cs{kant}, \cs{kant*} and \cs{kantdef} take a further
199 % optional argument; with \verb|\kant[42][1-3]| just the first three
200 % sentences of paragraph number~42 will be printed; ranges outside the
201 % actual number of sentences will be ignored. The requested sentences
202 % are stored, in the case of \cs{kantdef}.
203 %
204 % What's the difference between \cs{kant} and \cs{kant*}? The normal
205 % version will respect the given package option; that is, if
206 % \texttt{par} is in force, \verb|\kant[1-2]| will produce \emph{two}
207 % paragraphs, while \verb|\kant*[1-2]| will only produce a big chunk
208 % of text without issuing any \verb|\par| command. The logic is
209 % reversed if the \texttt{nopar} option has been given.
210 %
211 % By the way, 164 is the number of available pieces; if one exceeds
212 % the limit, nothing will be printed. Thus \verb|\kant[164-200]| will
213 % print only \emph{one} paragraph. However, printing all paragraphs
214 % with the standard ten point size Computer Modern font and the
215 % \pkg{article} class fills more than fifty pages, so it seems that
216 % the supply of text can be sufficient.
217 %
218 % \subsection*{Note}
219 %
220 % This package is just an exercise for practicing with \LaTeX3
221 % syntax. It uses the ``experimental'' packages made available by the
222 % \LaTeX3 team. Many thanks to Joseph Wright, Bruno Le Floch and Frank
223 % Mittelbach for suggesting improvements.
224 %
225 % \subsection*{Changes from version 0.1}
226 %
227 % There's no user level change; the implementation has been modified
228 % in some places (in particular a sequence is used to store the
229 % phrases, rather than many token lists).
230 %
231 % \subsection*{Changes from version 0.5}
232 %
233 % Some changes in \LaTeX3 introduced some misfeatures, which this
234 % version corrects. Some kernel function names were also changed; here
235 % |\prg_stepwise_function:nnnN| that became |\int_step_function:nnnN|.
236 % Some functions have been made |protected|.
237 %
238 % The most striking change is the possibility to generate an index:
239 % each paragraph indexes one of its words or phrases.
240 %
241 % \subsection*{Changes from version 0.6}
242 %
243 % Maintenance release with new functions from \texttt{expl3}. Now
244 % a kernel released on 2017/11/14 or later is required.
245 %
246 % \subsection*{Changes from version 0.7}
247 %
248 % Printing just some sentences in a paragraph is possible. Now
249 % a kernel released on 2019/07/01 or later is required.
250 %
251 % \subsection*{Changes from version 0.8}
252 %
253 % Added a missing \cs{@@par:}
254 %
255 % \end{documentation}
256 %
257 % \begin{implementation}
258 %
259 % \section{\pkg{kantlipsum} implementation}
260 %
261 % \begin{macrocode}
262 %<*package>
263 % \end{macrocode}
264 %
265 % \begin{macrocode}
266 %<@@=kgl>
267 % \end{macrocode}
268 %
269 %
270 % \begin{macrocode}
271 \ProvidesExplPackage
272 {kantlipsum}
273 {2023/11/27}
274 {0.8c}
275 {Generate text in Kantian style}
276 % \end{macrocode}
277 %
278 % A check to make sure that \pkg{expl3} is not too old
279 % \begin{macrocode}
280 \@ifl@t@r\ExplLoaderFileDate{2022-11-09}
281 {}
282 {%
283 \PackageError { kantlipsum } { Support~package~expl3~too~old }
284 {
285 You~need~to~update~your~installation~of~the~bundles~
286 'l3kernel'~and~'l3packages'.\MessageBreak
287 Loading~kantlipsum~will~abort!
288 }
289 \tex_endinput:D
290 }
291 % \end{macrocode}
292 %
293 % \subsection{Package options and required packages}
294 % We declare the allowed options and choose by default
295 % \texttt{par}. We also need to declare a function |\@@_number:n|
296 % that is set by the \texttt{numbers} option; its default action is to
297 % gobble its argument.
298 % \begin{macrocode}
299 \DeclareOption { par }
300 {
301 \cs_set_protected:Nn \@@_star: { \c_space_tl }
302 \cs_set_protected:Nn \@@_nostar: { \par }
303 }
304
305 \DeclareOption{ nopar }
306 {
307 \cs_set_protected:Nn \@@_star: { \par }
308 \cs_set_protected:Nn \@@_nostar: { \c_space_tl }
309 }
310
311 \DeclareOption{ numbers }
312 {
313 \cs_set_protected:Nn \@@_number:n
314 {
315 #1\nobreak\enspace\textbullet\nobreak\enspace
316 }
317 }
318
319 \bool_new:N \g_@@_makeindex_bool
320 \bool_gset_false:N \g_@@_makeindex_bool
321 \DeclareOption{ index }
322 { \bool_gset_true:N \g_@@_makeindex_bool }
323
324 \cs_new_eq:NN \@@_number:n \use_none:n
325 \ExecuteOptions{par}
326 \ProcessOptions \scan_stop:
327 % \end{macrocode}
328 %
329 % \subsection{Messages}
330 % We define two messages.
331 % \begin{macrocode}
332 \msg_new:nnn {kantlipsum}{how-many}
333 {The~package~provides~paragraphs~1~to~#1.~
334 Values~outside~this~range~will~be~ignored.}
335 \msg_new:nnnn {kantlipsum}{already-defined}
336 {Control~sequence~#1~already~defined.}
337 {The~control~sequence~#1~is~already~defined,~
338 I'll~ignore~it}
339 % \end{macrocode}
340 %
341 % \subsection{Variables and constants}
342 % The |\l_@@_start_int| variable will contain the starting number for
343 % processing, while |\l_@@_end_int| the ending number. The
344 % |\g_@@_pars_seq| sequence will contain the pseudokantian sentences
345 % and |\g_@@_words_seq| that contains the words to index.
346 % \begin{macrocode}
347 \int_new:N \l_@@_start_int
348 \int_new:N \l_@@_end_int
349 \seq_new:N \g_@@_pars_seq
350 \seq_new:N \g_@@_words_seq
351 \seq_new:N \l_@@_sentences_seq
352 % \end{macrocode}
353 %
354 % \subsection{User level commands}
355 % There are two user level commands, \cs{kant} (with a *-variant) and \cs{kantdef}.
356 %
357 % \begin{function}{\kant}
358 % The (optional) argument is described as before. We use the
359 % \cs{SplitArgument} feature provided by \pkg{xparse} to decide
360 % whether the `range form' has been specified. In the \cs{kant*} form
361 % we reverse the logic.
362 % \begin{macrocode}
363 \NewDocumentCommand{\kant}
364 {
365 s
366 >{\SplitArgument{1}{-}}O{1-7}
367 >{\SplitArgument{1}{-}}o}
368 {
369 \group_begin:
370 \IfBooleanTF{#1}
371 { \cs_set_eq:NN \@@_par: \@@_star: }
372 { \cs_set_eq:NN \@@_par: \@@_nostar: }
373 \IfNoValueTF{#3}
374 { \@@_process:nn #2 \@@_print: }
375 { \@@_process:nnnn #2 #3 \tl_use:N \l_tmpa_tl \@@_par: }
376 \group_end:
377 }
378 % \end{macrocode}
379 %\changes{v0.8a}{2019/07/24}{Added a missing \cs{@@par:}}
380 % \end{function}
381 %
382 % \begin{function}{\kantdef}
383 % Sometimes one needs just a piece of text without implicit \cs{par}
384 % attached, so we provide \cs{kantdef}. In a group we neutralize the
385 % meaning of |\@@_number:n| and |\@@_par:| and define the control
386 % sequence given as first argument to the pseudokantian sentence being
387 % the $k$th element of the sequence containing them, where $k$ is the
388 % number given as second argument. If the control sequence is already
389 % defined we issue an error and don't perform the definition.
390 % \begin{macrocode}
391 \NewDocumentCommand{\kantdef}
392 {
393 m
394 m
395 >{\SplitArgument{1}{-}}O{1-50}
396 }
397 {
398 \group_begin:
399 \@@_define:nnnn {#1} {#2} #3
400 \group_end:
401 }
402 % \end{macrocode}
403 % \end{function}
404 %
405 % \subsection{Internal functions}
406 % \begin{function}{\@@_process:nn}
407 % The function |\@@_process:nn| sets the temporary variables
408 % |\l_@@_start_int| and |\l_@@_end_int|. If the optional argument to
409 % \cs{kant} is missing they are already set to 1 and 7 respectively;
410 % otherwise the argument has been split into its components; if the
411 % argument was |[|$m$|]| we set both variables to $m$, otherwise it
412 % was in the form |[|$m$|-|$n$|]| and we do the obvious action.
413 % \begin{macrocode}
414 \cs_new_protected:Nn \@@_process:nn
415 {
416 \int_set:Nn \l_@@_start_int {#1}
417 \tl_if_novalue:nTF {#2}
418 { \int_set:Nn \l_@@_end_int {#1} }
419 { \int_set:Nn \l_@@_end_int {#2} }
420 }
421 \cs_new_protected:Nn \@@_process:nnnn
422 {
423 \tl_set:Ne \l_tmpa_tl { \seq_item:Nn \g_@@_pars_seq {#1} }
424 \tl_if_novalue:nTF {#4}
425 { \@@_extract:nnV {#3} {#3} \l_tmpa_tl }
426 { \@@_extract:nnV {#3} {#4} \l_tmpa_tl }
427 }
428 % \end{macrocode}
429 % \end{function}
430 % \changes{v0.7}{2017/11/16}{Use \cs{tl_if_novalue:nTF} instead of \cs{IfNoValueTF}}
431 %
432 % \begin{function}{\@@_print:,\@@_use:n}
433 % The printing routine is in the function |\@@_print:|; we start a
434 % loop printing item number $x$ in the sequence |\g_@@_pars_seq| for
435 % all numbers $x$ in the specified range. The function |\@@_use:n|
436 % function is a wrapper to be used with |\int_step_function:nnnN|:
437 % it's passed a number as argument, builds the constant name
438 % corresponding to it and produces the text. If the index entry is to
439 % be issued, the appropriate element from |\g_@@_words_seq| is used;
440 % the page reference might not be correct, though.
441 % \begin{macrocode}
442 \cs_new_protected:Nn \@@_print:
443 {
444 \int_step_function:nnnN
445 {\l_@@_start_int} {1} {\l_@@_end_int} \@@_use:n
446 }
447 \cs_new:Nn \@@_use:n
448 {
449 \int_compare:nNnF { #1 } > { \seq_count:N \g_@@_pars_seq }
450 { \@@_number:n {#1} }
451 \bool_if:NT \g_@@_makeindex_bool
452 {
453 \use:x { \exp_not:N \index{ \seq_item:Nn \g_@@_words_seq {#1} } }
454 }
455 \seq_item:Nn \g_@@_pars_seq {#1}
456 }
457 % \end{macrocode}
458 % \end{function}
459 %
460 % \begin{function}{\@@_newpara:n}
461 % The |\@@_newpara:n| appends a new item to the sequence |\g_@@_pars_seq|
462 % consisting of, say, \meta{text of the 42nd sentence}|\@@_par:|
463 % \begin{macrocode}
464 \cs_new_protected:Nn \@@_newpara:n
465 { \seq_gput_right:Nn \g_@@_pars_seq {#1\@@_par:} }
466 % \end{macrocode}
467 % \end{function}
468 %
469 % \begin{function}{\@@_newword:n}
470 % The |\@@_newword:n| function appends a new item to the sequence
471 % |\g_@@_words_seq| consisting of one word from the corresponding
472 % paragraph.
473 % \begin{macrocode}
474 \cs_new_protected:Nn \@@_newword:n
475 { \seq_gput_right:Nn \g_@@_words_seq {#1} }
476 % \end{macrocode}
477 % \end{function}
478 %
479 % \begin{function}{\@@define:nnnn}
480 % The function |\@@define:nnnn| chooses the paragraph, then extracts the
481 % requested sentences.
482 % \begin{macrocode}
483 \cs_new_protected:Nn \@@_define:nnnn
484 {
485 \cs_set_eq:NN \@@_number:n \use_none:n
486 \cs_set_eq:NN \@@_par: \prg_do_nothing:
487 \cs_if_exist:NTF #1
488 {
489 \msg_error:nnn {kantlipsum} {already-defined} {#1}
490 }
491 {
492 \tl_set:Ne \l_tmpa_tl { \seq_item:Nn \g_@@_pars_seq {#2} }
493 \tl_if_novalue:nTF {#4}
494 { \@@_extract:nnV {#3} {#3} \l_tmpa_tl }
495 { \@@_extract:nnV {#3} {#4} \l_tmpa_tl }
496 \cs_new:Npe #1 { \l_tmpa_tl }
497 }
498 }
499 % \end{macrocode}
500 % \end{function}
501 % \begin{function}{\@@_extract:nnn}
502 % This function does the extraction by splitting the input at periods
503 % and then adding the requested sentences to another sequence that
504 % later can be used.
505 % \begin{macrocode}
506 \cs_new_protected:Nn \@@_extract:nnn
507 {
508 \seq_set_split:Nnn \l_@@_sentences_seq { . } {#3}
509 \seq_clear:N \l_tmpa_seq
510 \seq_map_indexed_inline:Nn \l_@@_sentences_seq
511 {
512 \int_compare:nT { #1 <= ##1 <= #2 }
513 {\seq_put_right:Nn \l_tmpa_seq { ##2 } }
514 }
515 \tl_set:Ne \l_tmpa_tl { \seq_use:Nn \l_tmpa_seq { .~ }. }
516 }
517 \cs_generate_variant:Nn \@@_extract:nnn { nnV }
518 % \end{macrocode}
519 % \end{function}
520 %
521 % \subsection{Defining the sentences}
522 % We start a group where we set the category
523 % code of the space to 10 so as not to be forced to write |~| for
524 % spaces.
525 % \begin{macrocode}
526 \group_begin:
527 \char_set_catcode_space:n {`\ }
528 % \end{macrocode}
529 %
530 % Then we provide all of the sentences with the pattern
531 % |\@@_newpara:n {|\meta{text}|}|
532 % \begin{macrocode}
533 \@@_newpara:n {As any dedicated reader can clearly see, the Ideal of
534 practical reason is a representation of, as far as I know, the things
535 in themselves; as I have shown elsewhere, the phenomena should only be
536 used as a canon for our understanding. The paralogisms of practical
537 reason are what first give rise to the architectonic of practical
538 reason. As will easily be shown in the next section, reason would
539 thereby be made to contradict, in view of these considerations, the
540 Ideal of practical reason, yet the manifold depends on the phenomena.
541 Necessity depends on, when thus treated as the practical employment of
542 the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, time.
543 Human reason depends on our sense perceptions, by means of analytic
544 unity. There can be no doubt that the objects in space and time are
545 what first give rise to human reason.}
546
547 \@@_newpara:n {Let us suppose that the noumena have nothing to do
548 with necessity, since knowledge of the Categories is a
549 posteriori. Hume tells us that the transcendental unity of
550 apperception can not take account of the discipline of natural reason,
551 by means of analytic unity. As is proven in the ontological manuals,
552 it is obvious that the transcendental unity of apperception proves the
553 validity of the Antinomies; what we have alone been able to show is
554 that, our understanding depends on the Categories. It remains a
555 mystery why the Ideal stands in need of reason. It must not be
556 supposed that our faculties have lying before them, in the case of the
557 Ideal, the Antinomies; so, the transcendental aesthetic is just as
558 necessary as our experience. By means of the Ideal, our sense
559 perceptions are by their very nature contradictory.}
560
561 \@@_newpara:n {As is shown in the writings of Aristotle, the things
562 in themselves (and it remains a mystery why this is the case) are a
563 representation of time. Our concepts have lying before them the
564 paralogisms of natural reason, but our a posteriori concepts have
565 lying before them the practical employment of our experience. Because
566 of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, the paralogisms would
567 thereby be made to contradict, indeed, space; for these reasons, the
568 Transcendental Deduction has lying before it our sense perceptions.
569 (Our a posteriori knowledge can never furnish a true and demonstrated
570 science, because, like time, it depends on analytic principles.) So,
571 it must not be supposed that our experience depends on, so, our sense
572 perceptions, by means of analysis. Space constitutes the whole content
573 for our sense perceptions, and time occupies part of the sphere of the
574 Ideal concerning the existence of the objects in space and time in
575 general.}
576
577 \@@_newpara:n {As we have already seen, what we have alone been able
578 to show is that the objects in space and time would be falsified; what
579 we have alone been able to show is that, our judgements are what first
580 give rise to metaphysics. As I have shown elsewhere, Aristotle tells
581 us that the objects in space and time, in the full sense of these
582 terms, would be falsified. Let us suppose that, indeed, our
583 problematic judgements, indeed, can be treated like our concepts. As
584 any dedicated reader can clearly see, our knowledge can be treated
585 like the transcendental unity of apperception, but the phenomena
586 occupy part of the sphere of the manifold concerning the existence of
587 natural causes in general. Whence comes the architectonic of natural
588 reason, the solution of which involves the relation between necessity
589 and the Categories? Natural causes (and it is not at all certain that
590 this is the case) constitute the whole content for the paralogisms.
591 This could not be passed over in a complete system of transcendental
592 philosophy, but in a merely critical essay the simple mention of the
593 fact may suffice.}
594
595 \@@_newpara:n {Therefore, we can deduce that the objects in space and
596 time (and I assert, however, that this is the case) have lying before
597 them the objects in space and time. Because of our necessary ignorance
598 of the conditions, it must not be supposed that, then, formal logic
599 (and what we have alone been able to show is that this is true) is a
600 representation of the never-ending regress in the series of empirical
601 conditions, but the discipline of pure reason, in so far as this
602 expounds the contradictory rules of metaphysics, depends on the
603 Antinomies. By means of analytic unity, our faculties, therefore, can
604 never, as a whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science, because,
605 like the transcendental unity of apperception, they constitute the
606 whole content for a priori principles; for these reasons, our
607 experience is just as necessary as, in accordance with the principles
608 of our a priori knowledge, philosophy. The objects in space and time
609 abstract from all content of knowledge. Has it ever been suggested
610 that it remains a mystery why there is no relation between the
611 Antinomies and the phenomena? It must not be supposed that the
612 Antinomies (and it is not at all certain that this is the case) are
613 the clue to the discovery of philosophy, because of our necessary
614 ignorance of the conditions. As I have shown elsewhere, to avoid all
615 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that our understanding
616 (and it must not be supposed that this is true) is what first gives
617 rise to the architectonic of pure reason, as is evident upon close
618 examination.}
619
620 \@@_newpara:n {The things in themselves are what first give rise to
621 reason, as is proven in the ontological manuals. By virtue of natural
622 reason, let us suppose that the transcendental unity of apperception
623 abstracts from all content of knowledge; in view of these
624 considerations, the Ideal of human reason, on the contrary, is the key
625 to understanding pure logic. Let us suppose that, irrespective of all
626 empirical conditions, our understanding stands in need of our
627 disjunctive judgements. As is shown in the writings of Aristotle, pure
628 logic, in the case of the discipline of natural reason, abstracts from
629 all content of knowledge. Our understanding is a representation of, in
630 accordance with the principles of the employment of the paralogisms,
631 time. I assert, as I have shown elsewhere, that our concepts can be
632 treated like metaphysics. By means of the Ideal, it must not be
633 supposed that the objects in space and time are what first give rise
634 to the employment of pure reason.}
635
636 \@@_newpara:n {As is evident upon close examination, to avoid all
637 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, on the contrary, the
638 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions is a
639 representation of our inductive judgements, yet the things in
640 themselves prove the validity of, on the contrary, the Categories. It
641 remains a mystery why, indeed, the never-ending regress in the series
642 of empirical conditions exists in philosophy, but the employment of
643 the Antinomies, in respect of the intelligible character, can never
644 furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the
645 architectonic of pure reason, it is just as necessary as problematic
646 principles. The practical employment of the objects in space and time
647 is by its very nature contradictory, and the thing in itself would
648 thereby be made to contradict the Ideal of practical reason. On the
649 other hand, natural causes can not take account of, consequently, the
650 Antinomies, as will easily be shown in the next section.
651 Consequently, the Ideal of practical reason (and I assert that this is
652 true) excludes the possibility of our sense perceptions. Our
653 experience would thereby be made to contradict, for example, our
654 ideas, but the transcendental objects in space and time (and let us
655 suppose that this is the case) are the clue to the discovery of
656 necessity. But the proof of this is a task from which we can here be
657 absolved.}
658
659 \@@_newpara:n {Thus, the Antinomies exclude the possibility of, on
660 the other hand, natural causes, as will easily be shown in the next
661 section. Still, the reader should be careful to observe that the
662 phenomena have lying before them the intelligible objects in space and
663 time, because of the relation between the manifold and the noumena.
664 As is evident upon close examination, Aristotle tells us that, in
665 reference to ends, our judgements (and the reader should be careful to
666 observe that this is the case) constitute the whole content of the
667 empirical objects in space and time. Our experience, with the sole
668 exception of necessity, exists in metaphysics; therefore, metaphysics
669 exists in our experience. (It must not be supposed that the thing in
670 itself (and I assert that this is true) may not contradict itself, but
671 it is still possible that it may be in contradictions with the
672 transcendental unity of apperception; certainly, our judgements exist
673 in natural causes.) The reader should be careful to observe that,
674 indeed, the Ideal, on the other hand, can be treated like the noumena,
675 but natural causes would thereby be made to contradict the Antinomies.
676 The transcendental unity of apperception constitutes the whole content
677 for the noumena, by means of analytic unity.}
678
679 \@@_newpara:n {In all theoretical sciences, the paralogisms of human
680 reason would be falsified, as is proven in the ontological manuals.
681 The architectonic of human reason is what first gives rise to the
682 Categories. As any dedicated reader can clearly see, the paralogisms
683 should only be used as a canon for our experience. What we have alone
684 been able to show is that, that is to say, our sense perceptions
685 constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and some of this body must
686 be known a posteriori. Human reason occupies part of the sphere of
687 our experience concerning the existence of the phenomena in general.}
688
689 \@@_newpara:n {By virtue of natural reason, our ampliative judgements
690 would thereby be made to contradict, in all theoretical sciences, the
691 pure employment of the discipline of human reason. Because of our
692 necessary ignorance of the conditions, Hume tells us that the
693 transcendental aesthetic constitutes the whole content for, still, the
694 Ideal. By means of analytic unity, our sense perceptions, even as
695 this relates to philosophy, abstract from all content of knowledge.
696 With the sole exception of necessity, the reader should be careful to
697 observe that our sense perceptions exclude the possibility of the
698 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, since
699 knowledge of natural causes is a posteriori. Let us suppose that the
700 Ideal occupies part of the sphere of our knowledge concerning the
701 existence of the phenomena in general.}
702
703 \@@_newpara:n {By virtue of natural reason, what we have alone been
704 able to show is that, in so far as this expounds the universal rules
705 of our a posteriori concepts, the architectonic of natural reason can
706 be treated like the architectonic of practical reason. Thus, our
707 speculative judgements can not take account of the Ideal, since none
708 of the Categories are speculative. With the sole exception of the
709 Ideal, it is not at all certain that the transcendental objects in
710 space and time prove the validity of, for example, the noumena, as is
711 shown in the writings of Aristotle. As we have already seen, our
712 experience is the clue to the discovery of the Antinomies; in the
713 study of pure logic, our knowledge is just as necessary as, thus,
714 space. By virtue of practical reason, the noumena, still, stand in
715 need to the pure employment of the things in themselves.}
716
717 \@@_newpara:n {The reader should be careful to observe that the
718 objects in space and time are the clue to the discovery of, certainly,
719 our a priori knowledge, by means of analytic unity. Our faculties
720 abstract from all content of knowledge; for these reasons, the
721 discipline of human reason stands in need of the transcendental
722 aesthetic. There can be no doubt that, insomuch as the Ideal relies
723 on our a posteriori concepts, philosophy, when thus treated as the
724 things in themselves, exists in our hypothetical judgements, yet our a
725 posteriori concepts are what first give rise to the phenomena.
726 Philosophy (and I assert that this is true) excludes the possibility
727 of the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, as
728 will easily be shown in the next section. Still, is it true that the
729 transcendental aesthetic can not take account of the objects in space
730 and time, or is the real question whether the phenomena should only be
731 used as a canon for the never-ending regress in the series of
732 empirical conditions? By means of analytic unity, the Transcendental
733 Deduction, still, is the mere result of the power of the
734 Transcendental Deduction, a blind but indispensable function of the
735 soul, but our faculties abstract from all content of a posteriori
736 knowledge. It remains a mystery why, then, the discipline of human
737 reason, in other words, is what first gives rise to the transcendental
738 aesthetic, yet our faculties have lying before them the architectonic
739 of human reason.}
740
741 \@@_newpara:n {However, we can deduce that our experience (and it
742 must not be supposed that this is true) stands in need of our
743 experience, as we have already seen. On the other hand, it is not at
744 all certain that necessity is a representation of, by means of the
745 practical employment of the paralogisms of practical reason, the
746 noumena. In all theoretical sciences, our faculties are what first
747 give rise to natural causes. To avoid all misapprehension, it is
748 necessary to explain that our ideas can never, as a whole, furnish a
749 true and demonstrated science, because, like the Ideal of natural
750 reason, they stand in need to inductive principles, as is shown in the
751 writings of Galileo. As I have elsewhere shown, natural causes, in
752 respect of the intelligible character, exist in the objects in space
753 and time.}
754
755 \@@_newpara:n {Our ideas, in the case of the Ideal of pure reason,
756 are by their very nature contradictory. The objects in space and time
757 can not take account of our understanding, and philosophy excludes the
758 possibility of, certainly, space. I assert that our ideas, by means
759 of philosophy, constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and all of
760 this body must be known a posteriori, by means of analysis. It must
761 not be supposed that space is by its very nature contradictory. Space
762 would thereby be made to contradict, in the case of the manifold, the
763 manifold. As is proven in the ontological manuals, Aristotle tells us
764 that, in accordance with the principles of the discipline of human
765 reason, the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions
766 has lying before it our experience. This could not be passed over in
767 a complete system of transcendental philosophy, but in a merely
768 critical essay the simple mention of the fact may suffice.}
769
770 \@@_newpara:n {Since knowledge of our faculties is a posteriori, pure
771 logic teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of, indeed,
772 the architectonic of human reason. As we have already seen, we can
773 deduce that, irrespective of all empirical conditions, the Ideal of
774 human reason is what first gives rise to, indeed, natural causes, yet
775 the thing in itself can never furnish a true and demonstrated science,
776 because, like necessity, it is the clue to the discovery of
777 disjunctive principles. On the other hand, the manifold depends on
778 the paralogisms. Our faculties exclude the possibility of, insomuch
779 as philosophy relies on natural causes, the discipline of natural
780 reason. In all theoretical sciences, what we have alone been able to
781 show is that the objects in space and time exclude the possibility of
782 our judgements, as will easily be shown in the next section. This is
783 what chiefly concerns us.}
784
785 \@@_newpara:n {Time (and let us suppose that this is true) is the
786 clue to the discovery of the Categories, as we have already seen.
787 Since knowledge of our faculties is a priori, to avoid all
788 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the empirical objects
789 in space and time can not take account of, in the case of the Ideal of
790 natural reason, the manifold. It must not be supposed that pure
791 reason stands in need of, certainly, our sense perceptions. On the
792 other hand, our ampliative judgements would thereby be made to
793 contradict, in the full sense of these terms, our hypothetical
794 judgements. I assert, still, that philosophy is a representation of,
795 however, formal logic; in the case of the manifold, the objects in
796 space and time can be treated like the paralogisms of natural reason.
797 This is what chiefly concerns us.}
798
799 \@@_newpara:n {Because of the relation between pure logic and natural
800 causes, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that,
801 even as this relates to the thing in itself, pure reason constitutes
802 the whole content for our concepts, but the Ideal of practical reason
803 may not contradict itself, but it is still possible that it may be in
804 contradictions with, then, natural reason. It remains a mystery why
805 natural causes would thereby be made to contradict the noumena; by
806 means of our understanding, the Categories are just as necessary as
807 our concepts. The Ideal, irrespective of all empirical conditions,
808 depends on the Categories, as is shown in the writings of Aristotle.
809 It is obvious that our ideas (and there can be no doubt that this is
810 the case) constitute the whole content of practical reason. The
811 Antinomies have nothing to do with the objects in space and time, yet
812 general logic, in respect of the intelligible character, has nothing
813 to do with our judgements. In my present remarks I am referring to
814 the transcendental aesthetic only in so far as it is founded on
815 analytic principles.}
816
817 \@@_newpara:n {With the sole exception of our a priori knowledge, our
818 faculties have nothing to do with our faculties. Pure reason (and we
819 can deduce that this is true) would thereby be made to contradict the
820 phenomena. As we have already seen, let us suppose that the
821 transcendental aesthetic can thereby determine in its totality the
822 objects in space and time. We can deduce that, that is to say, our
823 experience is a representation of the paralogisms, and our
824 hypothetical judgements constitute the whole content of our concepts.
825 However, it is obvious that time can be treated like our a priori
826 knowledge, by means of analytic unity. Philosophy has nothing to do
827 with natural causes.}
828
829 \@@_newpara:n {By means of analysis, our faculties stand in need to,
830 indeed, the empirical objects in space and time. The objects in space
831 and time, for these reasons, have nothing to do with our
832 understanding. There can be no doubt that the noumena can not take
833 account of the objects in space and time; consequently, the Ideal of
834 natural reason has lying before it the noumena. By means of analysis,
835 the Ideal of human reason is what first gives rise to, therefore,
836 space, yet our sense perceptions exist in the discipline of practical
837 reason.}
838
839 \@@_newpara:n {The Ideal can not take account of, so far as I know,
840 our faculties. As we have already seen, the objects in space and time
841 are what first give rise to the never-ending regress in the series of
842 empirical conditions; for these reasons, our a posteriori concepts
843 have nothing to do with the paralogisms of pure reason. As we have
844 already seen, metaphysics, by means of the Ideal, occupies part of the
845 sphere of our experience concerning the existence of the objects in
846 space and time in general, yet time excludes the possibility of our
847 sense perceptions. I assert, thus, that our faculties would thereby
848 be made to contradict, indeed, our knowledge. Natural causes, so
849 regarded, exist in our judgements.}
850
851 \@@_newpara:n {The never-ending regress in the series of empirical
852 conditions may not contradict itself, but it is still possible that it
853 may be in contradictions with, then, applied logic. The employment of
854 the noumena stands in need of space; with the sole exception of our
855 understanding, the Antinomies are a representation of the noumena. It
856 must not be supposed that the discipline of human reason, in the case
857 of the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, is
858 a body of demonstrated science, and some of it must be known a
859 posteriori; in all theoretical sciences, the thing in itself excludes
860 the possibility of the objects in space and time. As will easily be
861 shown in the next section, the reader should be careful to observe
862 that the things in themselves, in view of these considerations, can be
863 treated like the objects in space and time. In all theoretical
864 sciences, we can deduce that the manifold exists in our sense
865 perceptions. The things in themselves, indeed, occupy part of the
866 sphere of philosophy concerning the existence of the transcendental
867 objects in space and time in general, as is proven in the ontological
868 manuals.}
869
870 \@@_newpara:n {The transcendental unity of apperception, in the case
871 of philosophy, is a body of demonstrated science, and some of it must
872 be known a posteriori. Thus, the objects in space and time, insomuch
873 as the discipline of practical reason relies on the Antinomies,
874 constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and all of this body must
875 be known a priori. Applied logic is a representation of, in natural
876 theology, our experience. As any dedicated reader can clearly see,
877 Hume tells us that, that is to say, the Categories (and Aristotle
878 tells us that this is the case) exclude the possibility of the
879 transcendental aesthetic. (Because of our necessary ignorance of the
880 conditions, the paralogisms prove the validity of time.) As is shown
881 in the writings of Hume, it must not be supposed that, in reference to
882 ends, the Ideal is a body of demonstrated science, and some of it must
883 be known a priori. By means of analysis, it is not at all certain
884 that our a priori knowledge is just as necessary as our ideas. In my
885 present remarks I am referring to time only in so far as it is founded
886 on disjunctive principles.}
887
888 \@@_newpara:n {The discipline of pure reason is what first gives rise
889 to the Categories, but applied logic is the clue to the discovery of
890 our sense perceptions. The never-ending regress in the series of
891 empirical conditions teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the
892 content of the pure employment of the paralogisms of natural reason.
893 Let us suppose that the discipline of pure reason, so far as regards
894 pure reason, is what first gives rise to the objects in space and
895 time. It is not at all certain that our judgements, with the sole
896 exception of our experience, can be treated like our experience; in
897 the case of the Ideal, our understanding would thereby be made to
898 contradict the manifold. As will easily be shown in the next section,
899 the reader should be careful to observe that pure reason (and it is
900 obvious that this is true) stands in need of the phenomena; for these
901 reasons, our sense perceptions stand in need to the manifold. Our
902 ideas are what first give rise to the paralogisms.}
903
904 \@@_newpara:n {The things in themselves have lying before them the
905 Antinomies, by virtue of human reason. By means of the transcendental
906 aesthetic, let us suppose that the discipline of natural reason
907 depends on natural causes, because of the relation between the
908 transcendental aesthetic and the things in themselves. In view of
909 these considerations, it is obvious that natural causes are the clue
910 to the discovery of the transcendental unity of apperception, by means
911 of analysis. We can deduce that our faculties, in particular, can be
912 treated like the thing in itself; in the study of metaphysics, the
913 thing in itself proves the validity of space. And can I entertain the
914 Transcendental Deduction in thought, or does it present itself to me?
915 By means of analysis, the phenomena can not take account of natural
916 causes. This is not something we are in a position to establish.}
917
918 \@@_newpara:n {Since some of the things in themselves are a
919 posteriori, there can be no doubt that, when thus treated as our
920 understanding, pure reason depends on, still, the Ideal of natural
921 reason, and our speculative judgements constitute a body of
922 demonstrated doctrine, and all of this body must be known a
923 posteriori. As is shown in the writings of Aristotle, it is not at
924 all certain that, in accordance with the principles of natural causes,
925 the Transcendental Deduction is a body of demonstrated science, and
926 all of it must be known a posteriori, yet our concepts are the clue to
927 the discovery of the objects in space and time. Therefore, it is
928 obvious that formal logic would be falsified. By means of analytic
929 unity, it remains a mystery why, in particular, metaphysics teaches us
930 nothing whatsoever regarding the content of the Ideal. The phenomena,
931 on the other hand, would thereby be made to contradict the
932 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions. As is
933 shown in the writings of Aristotle, philosophy is a representation of,
934 on the contrary, the employment of the Categories. Because of the
935 relation between the transcendental unity of apperception and the
936 paralogisms of natural reason, the paralogisms of human reason, in the
937 study of the Transcendental Deduction, would be falsified, but
938 metaphysics abstracts from all content of knowledge.}
939
940 \@@_newpara:n {Since some of natural causes are disjunctive, the
941 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions is the key
942 to understanding, in particular, the noumena. By means of analysis,
943 the Categories (and it is not at all certain that this is the case)
944 exclude the possibility of our faculties. Let us suppose that the
945 objects in space and time, irrespective of all empirical conditions,
946 exist in the architectonic of natural reason, because of the relation
947 between the architectonic of natural reason and our a posteriori
948 concepts. I assert, as I have elsewhere shown, that, so regarded, our
949 sense perceptions (and let us suppose that this is the case) are a
950 representation of the practical employment of natural causes. (I
951 assert that time constitutes the whole content for, in all theoretical
952 sciences, our understanding, as will easily be shown in the next
953 section.) With the sole exception of our knowledge, the reader should
954 be careful to observe that natural causes (and it remains a mystery
955 why this is the case) can not take account of our sense perceptions,
956 as will easily be shown in the next section. Certainly, natural
957 causes would thereby be made to contradict, with the sole exception of
958 necessity, the things in themselves, because of our necessary
959 ignorance of the conditions. But to this matter no answer is
960 possible.}
961
962 \@@_newpara:n {Since all of the objects in space and time are
963 synthetic, it remains a mystery why, even as this relates to our
964 experience, our a priori concepts should only be used as a canon for
965 our judgements, but the phenomena should only be used as a canon for
966 the practical employment of our judgements. Space, consequently, is a
967 body of demonstrated science, and all of it must be known a priori, as
968 will easily be shown in the next section. We can deduce that the
969 Categories have lying before them the phenomena. Therefore, let us
970 suppose that our ideas, in the study of the transcendental unity of
971 apperception, should only be used as a canon for the pure employment
972 of natural causes. Still, the reader should be careful to observe
973 that the Ideal (and it remains a mystery why this is true) can not
974 take account of our faculties, as is proven in the ontological
975 manuals. Certainly, it remains a mystery why the manifold is just as
976 necessary as the manifold, as is evident upon close examination.}
977
978 \@@_newpara:n {In natural theology, what we have alone been able to
979 show is that the architectonic of practical reason is the clue to the
980 discovery of, still, the manifold, by means of analysis. Since
981 knowledge of the objects in space and time is a priori, the things in
982 themselves have lying before them, for example, the paralogisms of
983 human reason. Let us suppose that our sense perceptions constitute
984 the whole content of, by means of philosophy, necessity. Our concepts
985 (and the reader should be careful to observe that this is the case)
986 are just as necessary as the Ideal. To avoid all misapprehension, it
987 is necessary to explain that the Categories occupy part of the sphere
988 of the discipline of human reason concerning the existence of our
989 faculties in general. The transcendental aesthetic, in so far as this
990 expounds the contradictory rules of our a priori concepts, is the mere
991 result of the power of our understanding, a blind but indispensable
992 function of the soul. The manifold, in respect of the intelligible
993 character, teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of the
994 thing in itself; however, the objects in space and time exist in
995 natural causes.}
996
997 \@@_newpara:n {I assert, however, that our a posteriori concepts (and
998 it is obvious that this is the case) would thereby be made to
999 contradict the discipline of practical reason; however, the things in
1000 themselves, however, constitute the whole content of philosophy. As
1001 will easily be shown in the next section, the Antinomies would thereby
1002 be made to contradict our understanding; in all theoretical sciences,
1003 metaphysics, irrespective of all empirical conditions, excludes the
1004 possibility of space. It is not at all certain that necessity (and it
1005 is obvious that this is true) constitutes the whole content for the
1006 objects in space and time; consequently, the paralogisms of practical
1007 reason, however, exist in the Antinomies. The reader should be
1008 careful to observe that transcendental logic, in so far as this
1009 expounds the universal rules of formal logic, can never furnish a true
1010 and demonstrated science, because, like the Ideal, it may not
1011 contradict itself, but it is still possible that it may be in
1012 contradictions with disjunctive principles. (Because of our necessary
1013 ignorance of the conditions, the thing in itself is what first gives
1014 rise to, insomuch as the transcendental aesthetic relies on the
1015 objects in space and time, the transcendental objects in space and
1016 time; thus, the never-ending regress in the series of empirical
1017 conditions excludes the possibility of philosophy.) As we have
1018 already seen, time depends on the objects in space and time; in the
1019 study of the architectonic of pure reason, the phenomena are the clue
1020 to the discovery of our understanding. Because of our necessary
1021 ignorance of the conditions, I assert that, indeed, the architectonic
1022 of natural reason, as I have elsewhere shown, would be falsified.}
1023
1024 \@@_newpara:n {In natural theology, the transcendental unity of
1025 apperception has nothing to do with the Antinomies. As will easily be
1026 shown in the next section, our sense perceptions are by their very
1027 nature contradictory, but our ideas, with the sole exception of human
1028 reason, have nothing to do with our sense perceptions. Metaphysics is
1029 the key to understanding natural causes, by means of analysis. It is
1030 not at all certain that the paralogisms of human reason prove the
1031 validity of, thus, the noumena, since all of our a posteriori
1032 judgements are a priori. We can deduce that, indeed, the objects in
1033 space and time can not take account of the Transcendental Deduction,
1034 but our knowledge, on the other hand, would be falsified.}
1035
1036 \@@_newpara:n {As we have already seen, our understanding is the clue
1037 to the discovery of necessity. On the other hand, the Ideal of pure
1038 reason is a body of demonstrated science, and all of it must be known
1039 a posteriori, as is evident upon close examination. It is obvious
1040 that the transcendental aesthetic, certainly, is a body of
1041 demonstrated science, and some of it must be known a priori; in view
1042 of these considerations, the noumena are the clue to the discovery of,
1043 so far as I know, natural causes. In the case of space, our
1044 experience depends on the Ideal of natural reason, as we have already
1045 seen.}
1046
1047 \@@_newpara:n {For these reasons, space is the key to understanding
1048 the thing in itself. Our sense perceptions abstract from all content
1049 of a priori knowledge, but the phenomena can never, as a whole,
1050 furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like time, they are
1051 just as necessary as disjunctive principles. Our problematic
1052 judgements constitute the whole content of time. By means of
1053 analysis, our ideas are by their very nature contradictory, and our a
1054 posteriori concepts are a representation of natural causes. I assert
1055 that the objects in space and time would thereby be made to
1056 contradict, so far as regards the thing in itself, the Transcendental
1057 Deduction; in natural theology, the noumena are the clue to the
1058 discovery of, so far as I know, the Transcendental Deduction.}
1059
1060 \@@_newpara:n {To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to
1061 explain that, in respect of the intelligible character, the
1062 transcendental aesthetic depends on the objects in space and time, yet
1063 the manifold is the clue to the discovery of the Transcendental
1064 Deduction. Therefore, the transcendental unity of apperception would
1065 thereby be made to contradict, in the case of our understanding, our
1066 ideas. There can be no doubt that the things in themselves prove the
1067 validity of the objects in space and time, as is shown in the writings
1068 of Aristotle. By means of analysis, there can be no doubt that,
1069 insomuch as the discipline of pure reason relies on the Categories,
1070 the transcendental unity of apperception would thereby be made to
1071 contradict the never-ending regress in the series of empirical
1072 conditions. In the case of space, the Categories exist in time. Our
1073 faculties can be treated like our concepts. As is shown in the
1074 writings of Galileo, the transcendental unity of apperception stands
1075 in need of, in the case of necessity, our speculative judgements.}
1076
1077 \@@_newpara:n {The phenomena (and it is obvious that this is the
1078 case) prove the validity of our sense perceptions; in natural
1079 theology, philosophy teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the
1080 content of the transcendental objects in space and time. In natural
1081 theology, our sense perceptions are a representation of the
1082 Antinomies. The noumena exclude the possibility of, even as this
1083 relates to the transcendental aesthetic, our knowledge. Our concepts
1084 would thereby be made to contradict, that is to say, the noumena; in
1085 the study of philosophy, space is by its very nature contradictory.
1086 Since some of the Antinomies are problematic, our ideas are a
1087 representation of our a priori concepts, yet space, in other words,
1088 has lying before it the things in themselves. Aristotle tells us
1089 that, in accordance with the principles of the phenomena, the
1090 Antinomies are a representation of metaphysics.}
1091
1092 \@@_newpara:n {The things in themselves can not take account of the
1093 Transcendental Deduction. By means of analytic unity, it is obvious
1094 that, that is to say, our sense perceptions, in all theoretical
1095 sciences, can not take account of the thing in itself, yet the
1096 transcendental unity of apperception, in the full sense of these
1097 terms, would thereby be made to contradict the employment of our sense
1098 perceptions. Our synthetic judgements would be falsified. Since some
1099 of our faculties are problematic, the things in themselves exclude the
1100 possibility of the Ideal. It must not be supposed that the things in
1101 themselves are a representation of, in accordance with the principles
1102 of philosophy, our sense perceptions.}
1103
1104 \@@_newpara:n {As is proven in the ontological manuals, philosophy is
1105 the mere result of the power of pure logic, a blind but indispensable
1106 function of the soul; however, the phenomena can never, as a whole,
1107 furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like general logic,
1108 they exclude the possibility of problematic principles. To avoid all
1109 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the never-ending
1110 regress in the series of empirical conditions is by its very nature
1111 contradictory. It must not be supposed that our a priori concepts
1112 stand in need to natural causes, because of the relation between the
1113 Ideal and our ideas. (We can deduce that the Antinomies would be
1114 falsified.) Since knowledge of the Categories is a posteriori, what
1115 we have alone been able to show is that, in the full sense of these
1116 terms, necessity (and we can deduce that this is true) is the key to
1117 understanding time, but the Ideal of natural reason is just as
1118 necessary as our experience. As will easily be shown in the next
1119 section, the thing in itself, with the sole exception of the manifold,
1120 abstracts from all content of a posteriori knowledge. The question of
1121 this matter's relation to objects is not in any way under discussion.}
1122
1123 \@@_newpara:n {By means of the transcendental aesthetic, it remains a
1124 mystery why the phenomena (and it is not at all certain that this is
1125 the case) are the clue to the discovery of the never-ending regress in
1126 the series of empirical conditions. In all theoretical sciences,
1127 metaphysics exists in the objects in space and time, because of the
1128 relation between formal logic and our synthetic judgements. The
1129 Categories would thereby be made to contradict the paralogisms, as any
1130 dedicated reader can clearly see. Therefore, there can be no doubt
1131 that the paralogisms have nothing to do with, so far as regards the
1132 Ideal and our faculties, the paralogisms, because of our necessary
1133 ignorance of the conditions. It must not be supposed that the objects
1134 in space and time occupy part of the sphere of necessity concerning
1135 the existence of the noumena in general. In natural theology, the
1136 things in themselves, therefore, are by their very nature
1137 contradictory, by virtue of natural reason. This is the sense in
1138 which it is to be understood in this work.}
1139
1140 \@@_newpara:n {As is evident upon close examination, let us suppose
1141 that, in accordance with the principles of time, our a priori concepts
1142 are the clue to the discovery of philosophy. By means of analysis, to
1143 avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, in
1144 particular, the transcendental aesthetic can not take account of
1145 natural causes. As we have already seen, the reader should be careful
1146 to observe that, in accordance with the principles of the objects in
1147 space and time, the noumena are the mere results of the power of our
1148 understanding, a blind but indispensable function of the soul, and the
1149 thing in itself abstracts from all content of a posteriori knowledge.
1150 We can deduce that, indeed, our experience, in reference to ends, can
1151 never furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the Ideal
1152 of practical reason, it can thereby determine in its totality
1153 speculative principles, yet our hypothetical judgements are just as
1154 necessary as space. It is not at all certain that, insomuch as the
1155 Ideal of practical reason relies on the noumena, the Categories prove
1156 the validity of philosophy, yet pure reason is the key to
1157 understanding the Categories. This is what chiefly concerns us.}
1158
1159 \@@_newpara:n {Natural causes, when thus treated as the things in
1160 themselves, abstract from all content of a posteriori knowledge, by
1161 means of analytic unity. Our a posteriori knowledge, in other words,
1162 is the key to understanding the Antinomies. As we have already seen,
1163 what we have alone been able to show is that, so far as I know, the
1164 objects in space and time are the clue to the discovery of the
1165 manifold. The things in themselves are the clue to the discovery of,
1166 in the case of the Ideal of natural reason, our concepts. To avoid
1167 all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, so far as
1168 regards philosophy, the discipline of human reason, for these reasons,
1169 is a body of demonstrated science, and some of it must be known a
1170 priori, but our faculties, consequently, would thereby be made to
1171 contradict the Antinomies. It remains a mystery why our understanding
1172 excludes the possibility of, insomuch as the Ideal relies on the
1173 objects in space and time, our concepts. It is not at all certain
1174 that the pure employment of the objects in space and time (and the
1175 reader should be careful to observe that this is true) is the clue to
1176 the discovery of the architectonic of pure reason. Let us suppose
1177 that natural reason is a representation of, insomuch as space relies
1178 on the paralogisms, the Transcendental Deduction, by means of
1179 analysis.}
1180
1181 \@@_newpara:n {As we have already seen, the Ideal constitutes the
1182 whole content for the transcendental unity of apperception. By means
1183 of analytic unity, let us suppose that, when thus treated as space,
1184 our synthetic judgements, therefore, would be falsified, and the
1185 objects in space and time are what first give rise to our sense
1186 perceptions. Let us suppose that, in the full sense of these terms,
1187 the discipline of practical reason can not take account of our
1188 experience, and our ideas have lying before them our inductive
1189 judgements. (Since all of the phenomena are speculative, to avoid all
1190 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the noumena
1191 constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and some of this body must
1192 be known a posteriori; as I have elsewhere shown, the noumena are a
1193 representation of the noumena.) Let us suppose that practical reason
1194 can thereby determine in its totality, by means of the Ideal, the pure
1195 employment of the discipline of practical reason. Galileo tells us
1196 that the employment of the phenomena can be treated like our ideas;
1197 still, the Categories, when thus treated as the paralogisms, exist in
1198 the employment of the Antinomies. Let us apply this to our
1199 experience.}
1200
1201 \@@_newpara:n {I assert, thus, that the discipline of natural reason
1202 can be treated like the transcendental aesthetic, since some of the
1203 Categories are speculative. In the case of transcendental logic, our
1204 ideas prove the validity of our understanding, as any dedicated reader
1205 can clearly see. In natural theology, our ideas can not take account
1206 of general logic, because of the relation between philosophy and the
1207 noumena. As is evident upon close examination, natural causes should
1208 only be used as a canon for the manifold, and our faculties, in
1209 natural theology, are a representation of natural causes. As is shown
1210 in the writings of Aristotle, the Ideal of human reason, for these
1211 reasons, would be falsified. What we have alone been able to show is
1212 that the Categories, so far as regards philosophy and the Categories,
1213 are the mere results of the power of the Transcendental Deduction, a
1214 blind but indispensable function of the soul, as is proven in the
1215 ontological manuals.}
1216
1217 \@@_newpara:n {The noumena have nothing to do with, thus, the
1218 Antinomies. What we have alone been able to show is that the things
1219 in themselves constitute the whole content of human reason, as is
1220 proven in the ontological manuals. The noumena (and to avoid all
1221 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that this is the case) are
1222 the clue to the discovery of the architectonic of natural reason. As
1223 we have already seen, let us suppose that our experience is what first
1224 gives rise to, therefore, the transcendental unity of apperception; in
1225 the study of the practical employment of the Antinomies, our
1226 ampliative judgements are what first give rise to the objects in space
1227 and time. Necessity can never furnish a true and demonstrated
1228 science, because, like our understanding, it can thereby determine in
1229 its totality hypothetical principles, and the empirical objects in
1230 space and time are what first give rise to, in all theoretical
1231 sciences, our a posteriori concepts.}
1232
1233 \@@_newpara:n {Our understanding excludes the possibility of
1234 practical reason. Our faculties stand in need to, consequently, the
1235 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions; still, the
1236 employment of necessity is what first gives rise to general logic.
1237 With the sole exception of applied logic, to avoid all
1238 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that time, in view of
1239 these considerations, can never furnish a true and demonstrated
1240 science, because, like the Ideal of human reason, it is a
1241 representation of ampliative principles, as is evident upon close
1242 examination. Since knowledge of the paralogisms of natural reason is
1243 a priori, I assert, consequently, that, in so far as this expounds the
1244 practical rules of the thing in itself, the things in themselves
1245 exclude the possibility of the discipline of pure reason, yet the
1246 empirical objects in space and time prove the validity of natural
1247 causes.}
1248
1249 \@@_newpara:n {Because of the relation between space and the noumena,
1250 our experience is by its very nature contradictory. It is obvious
1251 that natural causes constitute the whole content of the transcendental
1252 unity of apperception, as any dedicated reader can clearly see. By
1253 virtue of pure reason, our sense perceptions, in all theoretical
1254 sciences, have lying before them human reason. In view of these
1255 considerations, let us suppose that the transcendental objects in
1256 space and time, in the study of the architectonic of practical reason,
1257 exclude the possibility of the objects in space and time, because of
1258 our necessary ignorance of the conditions. By means of philosophy, is
1259 it true that formal logic can not take account of the manifold, or is
1260 the real question whether our sense perceptions are the mere results
1261 of the power of the transcendental aesthetic, a blind but
1262 indispensable function of the soul? The objects in space and time are
1263 just as necessary as the Antinomies, because of the relation between
1264 metaphysics and the things in themselves. Human reason is a
1265 representation of the transcendental aesthetic. In my present remarks
1266 I am referring to the pure employment of our disjunctive judgements
1267 only in so far as it is founded on inductive principles.}
1268
1269 \@@_newpara:n {What we have alone been able to show is that our sense
1270 perceptions are the clue to the discovery of our understanding; in
1271 natural theology, necessity, in all theoretical sciences, occupies
1272 part of the sphere of the transcendental unity of apperception
1273 concerning the existence of our faculties in general. The
1274 transcendental aesthetic is what first gives rise to the never-ending
1275 regress in the series of empirical conditions, as any dedicated reader
1276 can clearly see. The transcendental unity of apperception is what
1277 first gives rise to, in all theoretical sciences, the Antinomies. The
1278 phenomena, consequently, stand in need to the things in themselves.
1279 By means of analytic unity, necessity, on the contrary, abstracts from
1280 all content of a priori knowledge. The phenomena (and it remains a
1281 mystery why this is the case) are just as necessary as the Ideal of
1282 human reason.}
1283
1284 \@@_newpara:n {As any dedicated reader can clearly see, our
1285 experience is the clue to the discovery of philosophy; in the study of
1286 space, the Categories are what first give rise to the transcendental
1287 aesthetic. As any dedicated reader can clearly see, the reader should
1288 be careful to observe that, so regarded, the never-ending regress in
1289 the series of empirical conditions, as I have elsewhere shown, is the
1290 mere result of the power of the transcendental unity of apperception,
1291 a blind but indispensable function of the soul, but our judgements can
1292 be treated like time. We can deduce that the objects in space and
1293 time are just as necessary as the objects in space and time.
1294 Aristotle tells us that, even as this relates to time, the objects in
1295 space and time, however, abstract from all content of a posteriori
1296 knowledge. To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain
1297 that the phenomena (and it is not at all certain that this is the
1298 case) stand in need to the discipline of practical reason; thus, our
1299 knowledge, indeed, can not take account of our ideas.}
1300
1301 \@@_newpara:n {In the study of time, our concepts prove the validity
1302 of, as I have elsewhere shown, our understanding, as any dedicated
1303 reader can clearly see. As will easily be shown in the next section,
1304 the reader should be careful to observe that, so far as regards our
1305 knowledge, natural causes, so far as regards the never-ending regress
1306 in the series of empirical conditions and our a priori judgements,
1307 should only be used as a canon for the pure employment of the
1308 Transcendental Deduction, and our understanding can not take account
1309 of formal logic. As any dedicated reader can clearly see, to avoid
1310 all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the Antinomies
1311 are just as necessary as, on the other hand, our ideas; however, the
1312 Ideal, in the full sense of these terms, exists in the architectonic
1313 of human reason. As is evident upon close examination, to avoid all
1314 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, in other words, our
1315 faculties have nothing to do with the manifold, but our faculties
1316 should only be used as a canon for space. Our faculties prove the
1317 validity of the Antinomies, and the things in themselves (and let us
1318 suppose that this is the case) are the clue to the discovery of our
1319 ideas. It remains a mystery why, then, the architectonic of practical
1320 reason proves the validity of, therefore, the noumena.}
1321
1322 \@@_newpara:n {The paralogisms of practical reason can be treated
1323 like the paralogisms. The objects in space and time, therefore, are
1324 what first give rise to the discipline of human reason; in all
1325 theoretical sciences, the things in themselves (and we can deduce that
1326 this is the case) have nothing to do with metaphysics. Therefore,
1327 Aristotle tells us that our understanding exists in the Ideal of human
1328 reason, as is proven in the ontological manuals. Thus, our sense
1329 perceptions (and it remains a mystery why this is the case) would
1330 thereby be made to contradict space. I assert, on the other hand,
1331 that, in reference to ends, the objects in space and time can not take
1332 account of the Categories, yet natural causes are the mere results of
1333 the power of the discipline of human reason, a blind but indispensable
1334 function of the soul. By virtue of practical reason, it must not be
1335 supposed that, that is to say, our faculties would thereby be made to
1336 contradict philosophy, yet our a posteriori concepts, insomuch as the
1337 Ideal of pure reason relies on the intelligible objects in space and
1338 time, are by their very nature contradictory.}
1339
1340 \@@_newpara:n {Time, on the contrary, can never furnish a true and
1341 demonstrated science, because, like the transcendental aesthetic, it
1342 constitutes the whole content for ampliative principles, yet natural
1343 reason, even as this relates to philosophy, proves the validity of the
1344 thing in itself. As is evident upon close examination, the Ideal of
1345 practical reason, when thus treated as the things in themselves, is by
1346 its very nature contradictory; as I have elsewhere shown, our
1347 understanding may not contradict itself, but it is still possible that
1348 it may be in contradictions with the Ideal of practical reason. Since
1349 all of the things in themselves are problematic, it remains a mystery
1350 why, so regarded, our knowledge is the key to understanding our
1351 problematic judgements, but our ideas (and to avoid all
1352 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that this is the case)
1353 have lying before them our disjunctive judgements. In the case of the
1354 Ideal, we can deduce that the transcendental unity of apperception
1355 excludes the possibility of the manifold, as we have already seen.
1356 Consequently, the Ideal of pure reason can be treated like the
1357 phenomena. Let us apply this to the Transcendental Deduction.}
1358
1359 \@@_newpara:n {What we have alone been able to show is that our a
1360 posteriori concepts (and it is obvious that this is the case) are what
1361 first give rise to the transcendental unity of apperception. In the
1362 case of necessity, the reader should be careful to observe that
1363 metaphysics is a representation of natural causes, by means of
1364 analysis. In all theoretical sciences, the phenomena (and the reader
1365 should be careful to observe that this is the case) would thereby be
1366 made to contradict natural reason. The transcendental aesthetic, in
1367 the case of space, is by its very nature contradictory. By virtue of
1368 human reason, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain
1369 that the empirical objects in space and time exist in our judgements;
1370 for these reasons, the Antinomies, by means of our experience, can be
1371 treated like the architectonic of human reason. It must not be
1372 supposed that our ideas have lying before them metaphysics;
1373 consequently, the architectonic of pure reason, in all theoretical
1374 sciences, would be falsified.}
1375
1376 \@@_newpara:n {The Transcendental Deduction stands in need of the
1377 Ideal of pure reason, and the noumena, for these reasons, are by their
1378 very nature contradictory. The objects in space and time have lying
1379 before them our ideas. The transcendental unity of apperception,
1380 indeed, proves the validity of our understanding. The architectonic
1381 of human reason, so regarded, would be falsified, as is evident upon
1382 close examination. Since knowledge of the noumena is a priori, Hume
1383 tells us that, then, the Transcendental Deduction, when thus treated
1384 as the architectonic of natural reason, abstracts from all content of
1385 knowledge, but the objects in space and time, for these reasons, stand
1386 in need to the transcendental aesthetic. By means of analytic unity,
1387 natural causes exclude the possibility of, consequently, metaphysics,
1388 and the discipline of pure reason abstracts from all content of a
1389 priori knowledge. We thus have a pure synthesis of apprehension.}
1390
1391 \@@_newpara:n {Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions,
1392 what we have alone been able to show is that formal logic can not take
1393 account of the Categories; in the study of the transcendental
1394 aesthetic, philosophy can thereby determine in its totality the
1395 noumena. In all theoretical sciences, I assert that necessity has
1396 nothing to do with our sense perceptions. Because of the relation
1397 between our understanding and the phenomena, the Categories are what
1398 first give rise to, so far as regards time and the phenomena, the
1399 transcendental aesthetic; in view of these considerations, the
1400 phenomena can not take account of the Antinomies. As is proven in the
1401 ontological manuals, the objects in space and time (and to avoid all
1402 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that this is the case) are
1403 what first give rise to the Ideal. In natural theology, let us
1404 suppose that the Transcendental Deduction is the key to understanding,
1405 so far as regards the thing in itself, the Ideal, as any dedicated
1406 reader can clearly see. This is the sense in which it is to be
1407 understood in this work.}
1408
1409 \@@_newpara:n {It must not be supposed that, in respect of the
1410 intelligible character, the Antinomies (and we can deduce that this is
1411 the case) constitute the whole content of the phenomena, yet the
1412 Categories exist in natural causes. The Ideal of natural reason, when
1413 thus treated as metaphysics, can be treated like our faculties;
1414 consequently, pure reason (and there can be no doubt that this is
1415 true) is what first gives rise to our sense perceptions. The
1416 paralogisms of practical reason exist in the objects in space and
1417 time. As we have already seen, our sense perceptions stand in need to
1418 space. Still, our a priori concepts, in the case of metaphysics, have
1419 nothing to do with the Categories. Because of the relation between
1420 the discipline of practical reason and our a posteriori concepts, we
1421 can deduce that, when thus treated as the phenomena, our sense
1422 perceptions (and there can be no doubt that this is the case) are what
1423 first give rise to the discipline of practical reason.}
1424
1425 \@@_newpara:n {Thus, the reader should be careful to observe that the
1426 noumena would thereby be made to contradict necessity, because of our
1427 necessary ignorance of the conditions. Consequently, our sense
1428 perceptions are just as necessary as the architectonic of natural
1429 reason, as is shown in the writings of Galileo. It remains a mystery
1430 why, when thus treated as human reason, our concepts, when thus
1431 treated as the Categories, can never, as a whole, furnish a true and
1432 demonstrated science, because, like the Ideal, they are just as
1433 necessary as synthetic principles, yet our sense perceptions would be
1434 falsified. The noumena, in all theoretical sciences, can not take
1435 account of space, as is proven in the ontological manuals. Since
1436 knowledge of our analytic judgements is a priori, to avoid all
1437 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the paralogisms
1438 constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and none of this body must
1439 be known a priori; in view of these considerations, the phenomena can
1440 not take account of, for these reasons, the transcendental unity of
1441 apperception.}
1442
1443 \@@_newpara:n {The reader should be careful to observe that, for
1444 example, pure logic depends on the transcendental unity of
1445 apperception. As any dedicated reader can clearly see, our a priori
1446 concepts are what first give rise to the Categories. Hume tells us
1447 that our ideas are just as necessary as, on the other hand, natural
1448 causes; however, natural causes should only be used as a canon for our
1449 faculties. For these reasons, to avoid all misapprehension, it is
1450 necessary to explain that our ideas are the clue to the discovery of
1451 our understanding, as is shown in the writings of Hume. (By virtue of
1452 natural reason, the employment of our disjunctive judgements, then, is
1453 by its very nature contradictory.) By virtue of natural reason, the
1454 Categories can not take account of our hypothetical judgements. The
1455 transcendental aesthetic teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the
1456 content of, consequently, the transcendental unity of apperception, as
1457 will easily be shown in the next section. We thus have a pure
1458 synthesis of apprehension.}
1459
1460 \@@_newpara:n {The Antinomies have nothing to do with our faculties.
1461 As is shown in the writings of Hume, we can deduce that, on the
1462 contrary, the empirical objects in space and time prove the validity
1463 of our ideas. The manifold may not contradict itself, but it is still
1464 possible that it may be in contradictions with our a posteriori
1465 concepts. For these reasons, the transcendental objects in space and
1466 time (and it is obvious that this is the case) have nothing to do with
1467 our faculties, as will easily be shown in the next section. What we
1468 have alone been able to show is that the phenomena constitute the
1469 whole content of the Antinomies; with the sole exception of
1470 philosophy, the Categories have lying before them formal logic. Since
1471 knowledge of the Antinomies is a posteriori, it remains a mystery why
1472 the Antinomies (and there can be no doubt that this is the case) prove
1473 the validity of the thing in itself; for these reasons, metaphysics is
1474 the mere result of the power of the employment of our sense
1475 perceptions, a blind but indispensable function of the soul. As I
1476 have elsewhere shown, philosophy proves the validity of our sense
1477 perceptions.}
1478
1479 \@@_newpara:n {What we have alone been able to show is that the
1480 phenomena, so far as I know, exist in the noumena; however, our
1481 concepts, however, exclude the possibility of our judgements. Galileo
1482 tells us that our a posteriori knowledge would thereby be made to
1483 contradict transcendental logic; in the case of philosophy, our
1484 judgements stand in need to applied logic. On the other hand, to
1485 avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the objects
1486 in space and time exclude the possibility of, insomuch as pure logic
1487 relies on the objects in space and time, the transcendental unity of
1488 apperception, by virtue of practical reason. Has it ever been
1489 suggested that, as will easily be shown in the next section, the
1490 reader should be careful to observe that there is a causal connection
1491 bewteen philosophy and pure reason? In natural theology, it remains a
1492 mystery why the discipline of natural reason is a body of demonstrated
1493 science, and some of it must be known a posteriori, as will easily be
1494 shown in the next section. In view of these considerations, let us
1495 suppose that our sense perceptions, then, would be falsified, because
1496 of the relation between the never-ending regress in the series of
1497 empirical conditions and the paralogisms. This distinction must have
1498 some ground in the nature of the never-ending regress in the series of
1499 empirical conditions.}
1500
1501 \@@_newpara:n {To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to
1502 explain that time excludes the possibility of the discipline of human
1503 reason; in the study of practical reason, the manifold has nothing to
1504 do with time. Because of the relation between our a priori knowledge
1505 and the phenomena, what we have alone been able to show is that our
1506 experience is what first gives rise to the phenomena; thus, natural
1507 causes are the clue to the discovery of, with the sole exception of
1508 our experience, the objects in space and time. Our ideas are what
1509 first give rise to our faculties. On the other hand, the phenomena
1510 have lying before them our ideas, as is evident upon close
1511 examination. The paralogisms of natural reason are a representation
1512 of, thus, the manifold. I assert that space is what first gives rise
1513 to the paralogisms of pure reason. As is shown in the writings of
1514 Hume, space has nothing to do with, for example, necessity.}
1515
1516 \@@_newpara:n {We can deduce that the Ideal of practical reason, even
1517 as this relates to our knowledge, is a representation of the
1518 discipline of human reason. The things in themselves are just as
1519 necessary as our understanding. The noumena prove the validity of the
1520 manifold. As will easily be shown in the next section, natural causes
1521 occupy part of the sphere of our a priori knowledge concerning the
1522 existence of the Antinomies in general. The Categories are the clue
1523 to the discovery of, consequently, the Transcendental Deduction. Our
1524 ideas are the mere results of the power of the Ideal of pure reason, a
1525 blind but indispensable function of the soul. The divisions are thus
1526 provided; all that is required is to fill them.}
1527
1528 \@@_newpara:n {The never-ending regress in the series of empirical
1529 conditions can be treated like the objects in space and time. What we
1530 have alone been able to show is that, then, the transcendental
1531 aesthetic, in reference to ends, would thereby be made to contradict
1532 the Transcendental Deduction. The architectonic of practical reason
1533 has nothing to do with our ideas; however, time can never furnish a
1534 true and demonstrated science, because, like the Ideal, it depends on
1535 hypothetical principles. Space has nothing to do with the Antinomies,
1536 because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions. In all
1537 theoretical sciences, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to
1538 explain that the things in themselves are a representation of, in
1539 other words, necessity, as is evident upon close examination.}
1540
1541 \@@_newpara:n {As is proven in the ontological manuals, it remains a
1542 mystery why our experience is the mere result of the power of the
1543 discipline of human reason, a blind but indispensable function of the
1544 soul. For these reasons, the employment of the thing in itself
1545 teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of the Ideal of
1546 natural reason. In the case of transcendental logic, there can be no
1547 doubt that the Ideal of practical reason is just as necessary as the
1548 Antinomies. I assert that, insomuch as the Ideal relies on the
1549 noumena, the empirical objects in space and time stand in need to our
1550 a priori concepts. (It must not be supposed that, so regarded, our
1551 ideas exclude the possibility of, in the case of the Ideal, the
1552 architectonic of human reason.) The reader should be careful to
1553 observe that, irrespective of all empirical conditions, our concepts
1554 are what first give rise to our experience. By means of analytic
1555 unity, our faculties, in so far as this expounds the contradictory
1556 rules of the objects in space and time, are the mere results of the
1557 power of space, a blind but indispensable function of the soul, and
1558 the transcendental unity of apperception can not take account of,
1559 however, our faculties. But at present we shall turn our attention to
1560 the thing in itself.}
1561
1562 \@@_newpara:n {As is evident upon close examination, we can deduce
1563 that the transcendental unity of apperception depends on the Ideal of
1564 practical reason. Certainly, it is obvious that the Antinomies, in
1565 accordance with the principles of the objects in space and time,
1566 constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and none of this body must
1567 be known a posteriori. Because of the relation between the discipline
1568 of pure reason and our a posteriori concepts, I assert that, for
1569 example, metaphysics, consequently, is by its very nature
1570 contradictory, yet the transcendental aesthetic is the key to
1571 understanding our understanding. By virtue of natural reason, the
1572 objects in space and time are what first give rise to, when thus
1573 treated as the paralogisms of human reason, the things in themselves,
1574 but the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions can
1575 not take account of the architectonic of human reason. What we have
1576 alone been able to show is that natural causes, irrespective of all
1577 empirical conditions, exist in the objects in space and time, as is
1578 shown in the writings of Hume. By virtue of practical reason, our
1579 sense perceptions are what first give rise to, irrespective of all
1580 empirical conditions, necessity. Our sense perceptions, in the study
1581 of necessity, would thereby be made to contradict transcendental
1582 logic; consequently, natural reason stands in need of the objects in
1583 space and time. There can be no doubt that, in other words, the
1584 paralogisms of natural reason have nothing to do with the thing in
1585 itself, but the paralogisms prove the validity of transcendental
1586 logic.}
1587
1588 \@@_newpara:n {We can deduce that, then, the noumena are just as
1589 necessary as, so regarded, the practical employment of the objects in
1590 space and time. It is obvious that the manifold has nothing to do
1591 with our ideas; with the sole exception of the employment of the
1592 noumena, natural reason, in natural theology, is the mere result of
1593 the power of time, a blind but indispensable function of the soul.
1594 Because of the relation between our understanding and the things in
1595 themselves, it is not at all certain that, so far as regards the
1596 transcendental unity of apperception and the paralogisms, the
1597 phenomena can not take account of, so regarded, our sense perceptions,
1598 yet our sense perceptions can never, as a whole, furnish a true and
1599 demonstrated science, because, like time, they constitute the whole
1600 content of analytic principles. Since knowledge of our sense
1601 perceptions is a posteriori, it is obvious that, in accordance with
1602 the principles of our faculties, metaphysics excludes the possibility
1603 of the manifold, and the Ideal may not contradict itself, but it is
1604 still possible that it may be in contradictions with, thus, our sense
1605 perceptions. To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain
1606 that our ideas exclude the possibility of, irrespective of all
1607 empirical conditions, our ideas. Let us apply this to space.}
1608
1609 \@@_newpara:n {It remains a mystery why our sense perceptions prove
1610 the validity of our a priori concepts. The objects in space and time,
1611 then, exist in metaphysics; therefore, the things in themselves can
1612 not take account of the transcendental aesthetic. The Ideal of pure
1613 reason can thereby determine in its totality, that is to say, our
1614 ideas, and space constitutes the whole content for the discipline of
1615 human reason. The paralogisms of pure reason are just as necessary
1616 as, in all theoretical sciences, our knowledge. The things in
1617 themselves constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and some of
1618 this body must be known a posteriori.}
1619
1620 \@@_newpara:n {As will easily be shown in the next section, the
1621 Transcendental Deduction exists in the Ideal. To avoid all
1622 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that pure reason (and it
1623 is obvious that this is true) is the key to understanding the
1624 transcendental unity of apperception. The reader should be careful to
1625 observe that our experience depends on necessity. It is obvious that
1626 space, thus, can be treated like the objects in space and time,
1627 because of the relation between the transcendental unity of
1628 apperception and the objects in space and time. It must not be
1629 supposed that, even as this relates to natural reason, the Antinomies
1630 (and it remains a mystery why this is the case) exclude the
1631 possibility of the empirical objects in space and time, yet philosophy
1632 proves the validity of practical reason. The things in themselves, on
1633 the contrary, abstract from all content of a posteriori knowledge; in
1634 all theoretical sciences, the noumena (and there can be no doubt that
1635 this is the case) are just as necessary as the Antinomies. As is
1636 shown in the writings of Galileo, I assert, in natural theology, that
1637 the transcendental aesthetic, thus, exists in our faculties. Our
1638 faculties are just as necessary as the Categories, yet the manifold
1639 has lying before it, certainly, our understanding.}
1640
1641 \@@_newpara:n {It is obvious that the never-ending regress in the
1642 series of empirical conditions may not contradict itself, but it is
1643 still possible that it may be in contradictions with the architectonic
1644 of practical reason. The objects in space and time, so regarded,
1645 should only be used as a canon for the architectonic of human reason,
1646 as is proven in the ontological manuals. In all theoretical sciences,
1647 the Antinomies can not take account of our concepts, because of our
1648 necessary ignorance of the conditions. By means of analysis, the
1649 things in themselves are a representation of our experience; for these
1650 reasons, the paralogisms of practical reason have lying before them
1651 our inductive judgements. Still, the architectonic of pure reason is
1652 just as necessary as the never-ending regress in the series of
1653 empirical conditions.}
1654
1655 \@@_newpara:n {Thus, transcendental logic (and I assert, for these
1656 reasons, that this is true) depends on the Antinomies. Still, general
1657 logic (and it remains a mystery why this is true) is what first gives
1658 rise to the objects in space and time, because of the relation between
1659 metaphysics and the Antinomies. As will easily be shown in the next
1660 section, the paralogisms constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine,
1661 and some of this body must be known a priori. On the other hand, the
1662 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, in the
1663 case of the Transcendental Deduction, exists in the noumena, as is
1664 proven in the ontological manuals. By means of analytic unity, it
1665 remains a mystery why our judgements are by their very nature
1666 contradictory; however, the objects in space and time exclude the
1667 possibility of the Categories. As any dedicated reader can clearly
1668 see, the Antinomies would thereby be made to contradict the
1669 transcendental aesthetic; in natural theology, our faculties
1670 constitute the whole content of, for these reasons, the noumena.
1671 However, the objects in space and time are what first give rise to our
1672 understanding, because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions.}
1673
1674 \@@_newpara:n {On the other hand, the Antinomies have nothing to do
1675 with pure reason, because of our necessary ignorance of the
1676 conditions. Our speculative judgements are what first give rise to
1677 the Categories. Time is the key to understanding natural causes, as
1678 is evident upon close examination. Galileo tells us that the objects
1679 in space and time, irrespective of all empirical conditions, should
1680 only be used as a canon for our sense perceptions, since knowledge of
1681 the noumena is a priori. I assert that the Transcendental Deduction
1682 depends on our concepts. By means of analytic unity, our sense
1683 perceptions constitute the whole content of the manifold. In natural
1684 theology, the discipline of natural reason, on the other hand, would
1685 be falsified, as any dedicated reader can clearly see.}
1686
1687 \@@_newpara:n {In the case of the discipline of human reason, it is
1688 obvious that the phenomena, still, are the mere results of the power
1689 of the practical employment of the Transcendental Deduction, a blind
1690 but indispensable function of the soul, by means of analysis. As any
1691 dedicated reader can clearly see, Aristotle tells us that natural
1692 causes constitute the whole content of, as I have elsewhere shown, the
1693 pure employment of the paralogisms. Aristotle tells us that,
1694 irrespective of all empirical conditions, the thing in itself, indeed,
1695 can never furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the
1696 architectonic of practical reason, it has lying before it analytic
1697 principles, yet the Categories have nothing to do with the objects in
1698 space and time. Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions,
1699 human reason is just as necessary as our concepts, yet the practical
1700 employment of the paralogisms is the mere result of the power of
1701 metaphysics, a blind but indispensable function of the soul. For
1702 these reasons, Hume tells us that natural causes have nothing to do
1703 with the transcendental unity of apperception, by means of analytic
1704 unity. The Antinomies can not take account of the Antinomies, because
1705 of our necessary ignorance of the conditions. I assert, in all
1706 theoretical sciences, that, that is to say, natural causes would
1707 thereby be made to contradict, so regarded, the Ideal of natural
1708 reason. Hume tells us that our ideas abstract from all content of a
1709 posteriori knowledge, as is evident upon close examination.}
1710
1711 \@@_newpara:n {The manifold is a representation of the phenomena.
1712 Our judgements constitute the whole content of, on the other hand, the
1713 things in themselves, as will easily be shown in the next section. By
1714 means of analytic unity, the phenomena, in the full sense of these
1715 terms, should only be used as a canon for the Ideal of human reason.
1716 It is obvious that, so far as regards metaphysics and our judgements,
1717 pure reason (and there can be no doubt that this is true) is the key
1718 to understanding time. In the study of formal logic, the paralogisms
1719 of pure reason are the clue to the discovery of, thus, the manifold.}
1720
1721 \@@_newpara:n {There can be no doubt that the never-ending regress in
1722 the series of empirical conditions may not contradict itself, but it
1723 is still possible that it may be in contradictions with, indeed, our
1724 sense perceptions. As is proven in the ontological manuals, the
1725 architectonic of practical reason proves the validity of, in all
1726 theoretical sciences, metaphysics; in view of these considerations,
1727 our knowledge depends on our faculties. Since knowledge of our sense
1728 perceptions is a priori, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary
1729 to explain that natural reason is what first gives rise to our
1730 faculties. There can be no doubt that, in the full sense of these
1731 terms, the Antinomies exclude the possibility of the Transcendental
1732 Deduction. (In view of these considerations, the empirical objects in
1733 space and time are by their very nature contradictory.) It is obvious
1734 that the objects in space and time can not take account of the
1735 transcendental objects in space and time, as is proven in the
1736 ontological manuals. As is evident upon close examination, what we
1737 have alone been able to show is that the objects in space and time are
1738 the mere results of the power of time, a blind but indispensable
1739 function of the soul. The divisions are thus provided; all that is
1740 required is to fill them.}
1741
1742 \@@_newpara:n {As we have already seen, the Antinomies are a
1743 representation of the Categories. Necessity stands in need of the
1744 Antinomies. By virtue of natural reason, the Antinomies have lying
1745 before them the Ideal of pure reason; on the other hand, the
1746 Antinomies have nothing to do with natural causes. As I have
1747 elsewhere shown, the reader should be careful to observe that the
1748 things in themselves would thereby be made to contradict, in so far as
1749 this expounds the universal rules of our faculties, our ideas. I
1750 assert that, in so far as this expounds the necessary rules of human
1751 reason, our concepts (and we can deduce that this is the case) prove
1752 the validity of space, but our sense perceptions, so far as regards
1753 the transcendental unity of apperception, can never, as a whole,
1754 furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the
1755 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, they have
1756 nothing to do with disjunctive principles. But we have fallen short
1757 of the necessary interconnection that we have in mind when we speak of
1758 necessity.}
1759
1760 \@@_newpara:n {As is evident upon close examination, the paralogisms
1761 abstract from all content of a posteriori knowledge. Consequently,
1762 the transcendental aesthetic, in reference to ends, occupies part of
1763 the sphere of metaphysics concerning the existence of the Categories
1764 in general. The objects in space and time, in particular, constitute
1765 a body of demonstrated doctrine, and all of this body must be known a
1766 posteriori; by means of the thing in itself, the noumena can be
1767 treated like the thing in itself. The things in themselves, for
1768 example, are the mere results of the power of philosophy, a blind but
1769 indispensable function of the soul, as is shown in the writings of
1770 Aristotle. As will easily be shown in the next section, it must not
1771 be supposed that, in the full sense of these terms, our faculties, in
1772 view of these considerations, constitute the whole content of the
1773 objects in space and time, and our sense perceptions, in respect of
1774 the intelligible character, can be treated like space. Because of our
1775 necessary ignorance of the conditions, Hume tells us that the
1776 manifold, irrespective of all empirical conditions, is what first
1777 gives rise to space.}
1778
1779 \@@_newpara:n {In view of these considerations, our experience
1780 occupies part of the sphere of the Ideal concerning the existence of
1781 the objects in space and time in general, as will easily be shown in
1782 the next section. It must not be supposed that our ideas (and it
1783 remains a mystery why this is the case) are a representation of the
1784 intelligible objects in space and time. Consequently, the
1785 Transcendental Deduction can thereby determine in its totality, in
1786 other words, our ideas, because of our necessary ignorance of the
1787 conditions. (In natural theology, our concepts abstract from all
1788 content of a priori knowledge, as is proven in the ontological
1789 manuals.) I assert, in the case of the manifold, that human reason is
1790 a body of demonstrated science, and all of it must be known a
1791 posteriori, by virtue of human reason. As is proven in the
1792 ontological manuals, Aristotle tells us that the thing in itself, so
1793 far as I know, can never furnish a true and demonstrated science,
1794 because, like the architectonic of pure reason, it is just as
1795 necessary as a priori principles.}
1796
1797 \@@_newpara:n {To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to
1798 explain that philosophy can not take account of our sense perceptions;
1799 in the study of the discipline of natural reason, our experience, in
1800 the study of the architectonic of practical reason, is the mere result
1801 of the power of pure logic, a blind but indispensable function of the
1802 soul. As is evident upon close examination, the noumena are what
1803 first give rise to, on the contrary, the phenomena, but natural
1804 reason, that is to say, excludes the possibility of our hypothetical
1805 judgements. The objects in space and time are the clue to the
1806 discovery of the thing in itself, because of our necessary ignorance
1807 of the conditions. Therefore, there can be no doubt that the
1808 architectonic of practical reason depends on the Antinomies, because
1809 of our necessary ignorance of the conditions. Human reason (and there
1810 can be no doubt that this is true) depends on our understanding, but
1811 the Ideal can thereby determine in its totality metaphysics.}
1812
1813 \@@_newpara:n {Since knowledge of the objects in space and time is a
1814 posteriori, general logic, in respect of the intelligible character,
1815 is by its very nature contradictory. By means of analytic unity, it
1816 is not at all certain that space, insomuch as our understanding relies
1817 on our sense perceptions, would thereby be made to contradict the
1818 Ideal. By virtue of natural reason, the Antinomies are just as
1819 necessary as, indeed, the thing in itself. The manifold, as I have
1820 elsewhere shown, is a body of demonstrated science, and some of it
1821 must be known a priori. There can be no doubt that, in particular,
1822 the phenomena are a representation of pure logic, yet our sense
1823 perceptions have lying before them our sense perceptions. I assert,
1824 as I have elsewhere shown, that, indeed, our experience (and let us
1825 suppose that this is true) excludes the possibility of the objects in
1826 space and time, and the discipline of human reason, in accordance with
1827 the principles of the transcendental unity of apperception, occupies
1828 part of the sphere of our understanding concerning the existence of
1829 the phenomena in general.}
1830
1831 \@@_newpara:n {Human reason (and we can deduce that this is true)
1832 proves the validity of the architectonic of natural reason. To avoid
1833 all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the employment of
1834 the things in themselves can not take account of the phenomena. The
1835 transcendental aesthetic, on the contrary, can be treated like the
1836 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions; certainly,
1837 our faculties constitute the whole content of, in particular, the
1838 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions. What we
1839 have alone been able to show is that, then, the objects in space and
1840 time stand in need to metaphysics, and our experience, in accordance
1841 with the principles of time, stands in need of the never-ending
1842 regress in the series of empirical conditions. Since knowledge of our
1843 ideas is a posteriori, the phenomena are a representation of the
1844 phenomena.}
1845
1846 \@@_newpara:n {Necessity, as I have elsewhere shown, is the mere
1847 result of the power of the architectonic of practical reason, a blind
1848 but indispensable function of the soul. The paralogisms of pure
1849 reason are the clue to the discovery of the practical employment of
1850 the thing in itself. There can be no doubt that the never-ending
1851 regress in the series of empirical conditions has lying before it the
1852 paralogisms of human reason; with the sole exception of the
1853 architectonic of pure reason, transcendental logic is just as
1854 necessary as, then, our judgements. What we have alone been able to
1855 show is that our synthetic judgements have lying before them, when
1856 thus treated as space, our knowledge, by means of analysis. By virtue
1857 of natural reason, the transcendental aesthetic can be treated like
1858 general logic, yet the objects in space and time are just as necessary
1859 as the noumena. }
1860
1861 \@@_newpara:n {In view of these considerations, let us suppose that
1862 the Categories exclude the possibility of the never-ending regress in
1863 the series of empirical conditions. The manifold occupies part of the
1864 sphere of the thing in itself concerning the existence of the things
1865 in themselves in general, and formal logic, indeed, would be
1866 falsified. It is not at all certain that, in reference to ends, the
1867 discipline of practical reason, for example, occupies part of the
1868 sphere of the discipline of practical reason concerning the existence
1869 of our ampliative judgements in general, yet general logic is by its
1870 very nature contradictory. Since all of our judgements are a priori,
1871 there can be no doubt that, in the full sense of these terms, the
1872 phenomena can not take account of the transcendental objects in space
1873 and time. The architectonic of pure reason (and it is not at all
1874 certain that this is true) stands in need of the things in themselves.
1875 Philosophy is the key to understanding, thus, our sense perceptions.
1876 This is what chiefly concerns us.}
1877
1878 \@@_newpara:n {Our understanding would thereby be made to contradict,
1879 so far as regards the Ideal, necessity. Our faculties, as I have
1880 elsewhere shown, are the mere results of the power of time, a blind
1881 but indispensable function of the soul. Time, with the sole exception
1882 of formal logic, would be falsified, but the Ideal can not take
1883 account of our sense perceptions. It is not at all certain that the
1884 Antinomies are what first give rise to our experience; thus, our a
1885 posteriori concepts are the clue to the discovery of, so regarded, the
1886 practical employment of the Transcendental Deduction. Natural causes
1887 occupy part of the sphere of practical reason concerning the existence
1888 of the paralogisms of pure reason in general; in view of these
1889 considerations, the noumena exclude the possibility of the employment
1890 of the objects in space and time. The manifold is what first gives
1891 rise to the paralogisms, but our judgements are the clue to the
1892 discovery of, in the study of the thing in itself, the discipline of
1893 practical reason.}
1894
1895 \@@_newpara:n {Our a priori concepts, with the sole exception of our
1896 experience, have lying before them our judgements. It must not be
1897 supposed that the Antinomies are a representation of the discipline of
1898 human reason, by means of analytic unity. In the study of the
1899 transcendental aesthetic, the paralogisms constitute a body of
1900 demonstrated doctrine, and some of this body must be known a
1901 posteriori. The Categories are the mere results of the power of the
1902 thing in itself, a blind but indispensable function of the soul.
1903 Because of the relation between pure reason and the paralogisms of
1904 human reason, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain
1905 that, indeed, the objects in space and time (and to avoid all
1906 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that this is the case) are
1907 a representation of our concepts, yet the Ideal can be treated like
1908 our inductive judgements. As is proven in the ontological manuals,
1909 our understanding would thereby be made to contradict, thus, the
1910 Transcendental Deduction; as I have elsewhere shown, the phenomena
1911 abstract from all content of knowledge. The thing in itself excludes
1912 the possibility of philosophy; therefore, space, for example, teaches
1913 us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of metaphysics. We can
1914 deduce that the noumena (and it must not be supposed that this is the
1915 case) are a representation of the transcendental unity of
1916 apperception; with the sole exception of the thing in itself, our
1917 sense perceptions, as I have elsewhere shown, can never, as a whole,
1918 furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the
1919 transcendental unity of apperception, they exclude the possibility of
1920 hypothetical principles.}
1921
1922 \@@_newpara:n {Since none of our faculties are speculative, our ideas
1923 should only be used as a canon for time. With the sole exception of
1924 the manifold, our concepts exclude the possibility of the practical
1925 employment of metaphysics, by means of analysis. Aristotle tells us
1926 that necessity (and it is obvious that this is true) would thereby be
1927 made to contradict the thing in itself, because of our necessary
1928 ignorance of the conditions. As is proven in the ontological manuals,
1929 metaphysics (and it remains a mystery why this is true) can thereby
1930 determine in its totality the Ideal. In the study of the
1931 transcendental unity of apperception, it is obvious that the phenomena
1932 have nothing to do with, therefore, natural causes, by means of
1933 analysis. Has it ever been suggested that it must not be supposed
1934 that there is no relation bewteen the paralogisms of practical reason
1935 and the Antinomies? Time, indeed, is a representation of the
1936 Antinomies. The paralogisms of human reason are the clue to the
1937 discovery of natural causes, by means of analysis. Let us suppose
1938 that, in other words, the manifold, that is to say, abstracts from all
1939 content of knowledge.}
1940
1941 \@@_newpara:n {As is proven in the ontological manuals, Aristotle
1942 tells us that the transcendental unity of apperception can be treated
1943 like the discipline of pure reason; in the case of our understanding,
1944 our sense perceptions are just as necessary as the noumena. The
1945 reader should be careful to observe that the discipline of human
1946 reason occupies part of the sphere of our understanding concerning the
1947 existence of natural causes in general. The noumena prove the
1948 validity of philosophy, and the paralogisms of human reason exclude
1949 the possibility of our sense perceptions. Our faculties exist in our
1950 a posteriori concepts; still, the never-ending regress in the series
1951 of empirical conditions has lying before it necessity. Since
1952 knowledge of our sense perceptions is a posteriori, the transcendental
1953 aesthetic can never furnish a true and demonstrated science, because,
1954 like the transcendental aesthetic, it has nothing to do with
1955 ampliative principles. Transcendental logic exists in our faculties.}
1956
1957 \@@_newpara:n {There can be no doubt that the objects in space and
1958 time have nothing to do with our judgements. The architectonic of
1959 human reason has nothing to do with the noumena. What we have alone
1960 been able to show is that natural causes have nothing to do with,
1961 still, our a priori concepts, as we have already seen. As any
1962 dedicated reader can clearly see, it remains a mystery why, for
1963 example, our ideas, with the sole exception of the thing in itself,
1964 can not take account of the objects in space and time. It remains a
1965 mystery why our faculties are a representation of the transcendental
1966 aesthetic. Our ideas, in reference to ends, can never, as a whole,
1967 furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the discipline
1968 of natural reason, they are a representation of synthetic principles.
1969 The transcendental unity of apperception is just as necessary as, in
1970 view of these considerations, our ampliative judgements; with the sole
1971 exception of the transcendental aesthetic, the thing in itself (and it
1972 remains a mystery why this is true) is the clue to the discovery of
1973 our speculative judgements.}
1974
1975 \@@_newpara:n {As I have elsewhere shown, the Ideal is a body of
1976 demonstrated science, and some of it must be known a priori, as is
1977 evident upon close examination. Our ideas abstract from all content
1978 of knowledge, and the phenomena have nothing to do with, then,
1979 necessity. As is proven in the ontological manuals, the empirical
1980 objects in space and time exclude the possibility of, in other words,
1981 our sense perceptions. It must not be supposed that, then, the
1982 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions stands in
1983 need of, certainly, the Ideal of natural reason, yet pure reason can
1984 not take account of the objects in space and time. The noumena, in
1985 all theoretical sciences, prove the validity of the practical
1986 employment of the manifold; in natural theology, the phenomena are
1987 just as necessary as the paralogisms. It is not at all certain that
1988 our concepts have lying before them our faculties, by means of
1989 analytic unity. It is not at all certain that the architectonic of
1990 practical reason, then, is what first gives rise to necessity; still,
1991 our concepts stand in need to the objects in space and time.}
1992
1993 \@@_newpara:n {It must not be supposed that our sense perceptions are
1994 the clue to the discovery of the Antinomies. As will easily be shown
1995 in the next section, our experience, in particular, excludes the
1996 possibility of natural causes, yet the architectonic of human reason
1997 can never furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like
1998 philosophy, it can thereby determine in its totality problematic
1999 principles. Let us suppose that, even as this relates to philosophy,
2000 our a posteriori concepts, in view of these considerations, exist in
2001 natural causes, yet space may not contradict itself, but it is still
2002 possible that it may be in contradictions with the Categories. (The
2003 thing in itself, in all theoretical sciences, exists in our ideas.)
2004 Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, let us suppose
2005 that the things in themselves should only be used as a canon for the
2006 things in themselves; certainly, our ideas, therefore, abstract from
2007 all content of a priori knowledge. Necessity constitutes the whole
2008 content for practical reason. But we have fallen short of the
2009 necessary interconnection that we have in mind when we speak of the
2010 transcendental aesthetic. }
2011
2012 \@@_newpara:n {As we have already seen, Aristotle tells us that, when
2013 thus treated as the phenomena, the transcendental unity of
2014 apperception can thereby determine in its totality the Ideal of human
2015 reason. There can be no doubt that natural causes can not take
2016 account of, certainly, the phenomena, since none of the paralogisms
2017 are hypothetical. We can deduce that the transcendental aesthetic is
2018 a body of demonstrated science, and none of it must be known a priori.
2019 Hume tells us that, for example, our a posteriori knowledge
2020 constitutes the whole content for our sense perceptions, yet the
2021 discipline of pure reason, when thus treated as our understanding,
2022 constitutes the whole content for the empirical objects in space and
2023 time. The discipline of pure reason occupies part of the sphere of
2024 the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions
2025 concerning the existence of the things in themselves in general;
2026 consequently, the architectonic of natural reason (and what we have
2027 alone been able to show is that this is true) is the clue to the
2028 discovery of the objects in space and time.}
2029
2030 \@@_newpara:n {In the case of the Transcendental Deduction, our ideas
2031 would thereby be made to contradict, in natural theology, the objects
2032 in space and time. In all theoretical sciences, it remains a mystery
2033 why the employment of our understanding has nothing to do with the
2034 Categories. In the case of the never-ending regress in the series of
2035 empirical conditions, it remains a mystery why natural causes can not
2036 take account of the phenomena. By means of analysis, space would
2037 thereby be made to contradict the objects in space and time; in
2038 natural theology, the objects in space and time are a representation
2039 of, in view of these considerations, our faculties. I assert that our
2040 concepts would thereby be made to contradict, so far as I know, the
2041 Transcendental Deduction. As is shown in the writings of Galileo, to
2042 avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the objects
2043 in space and time are the clue to the discovery of, therefore,
2044 necessity; on the other hand, philosophy occupies part of the sphere
2045 of the Transcendental Deduction concerning the existence of the
2046 intelligible objects in space and time in general.}
2047
2048 \@@_newpara:n {Still, time is by its very nature contradictory. The
2049 paralogisms of practical reason constitute a body of demonstrated
2050 doctrine, and none of this body must be known a priori; for these
2051 reasons, the noumena are the mere results of the power of the
2052 transcendental aesthetic, a blind but indispensable function of the
2053 soul. On the other hand, Aristotle tells us that our a posteriori
2054 concepts are the clue to the discovery of, thus, the transcendental
2055 unity of apperception. As any dedicated reader can clearly see, the
2056 discipline of pure reason can not take account of our faculties. It
2057 must not be supposed that the Ideal, in particular, can never furnish
2058 a true and demonstrated science, because, like time, it is the clue to
2059 the discovery of problematic principles, since knowledge of the
2060 objects in space and time is a priori. The Categories are what first
2061 give rise to the Transcendental Deduction.}
2062
2063 \@@_newpara:n {Our faculties, in the full sense of these terms, exist
2064 in the noumena, because of the relation between space and the
2065 phenomena. Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, the
2066 paralogisms of practical reason are a representation of, indeed, our
2067 understanding; in view of these considerations, the objects in space
2068 and time, certainly, would be falsified. Let us suppose that, when
2069 thus treated as philosophy, metaphysics is a body of demonstrated
2070 science, and none of it must be known a priori, and our judgements
2071 stand in need to, then, our ideas. The reader should be careful to
2072 observe that the objects in space and time constitute the whole
2073 content of, in accordance with the principles of our faculties, pure
2074 logic; therefore, the things in themselves, however, are the mere
2075 results of the power of pure reason, a blind but indispensable
2076 function of the soul. There can be no doubt that our understanding
2077 can never furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like time,
2078 it may not contradict itself, but it is still possible that it may be
2079 in contradictions with disjunctive principles; by means of our
2080 knowledge, formal logic would thereby be made to contradict the
2081 noumena.}
2082
2083 \@@_newpara:n {Since all of our a posteriori concepts are synthetic,
2084 applied logic has nothing to do with, for example, the noumena. With
2085 the sole exception of philosophy, the Ideal of practical reason is
2086 what first gives rise to our ideas, as is evident upon close
2087 examination. The reader should be careful to observe that the pure
2088 employment of our understanding is what first gives rise to the
2089 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, by virtue
2090 of natural reason. By virtue of natural reason, there can be no doubt
2091 that, irrespective of all empirical conditions, the architectonic of
2092 natural reason (and we can deduce that this is true) has nothing to do
2093 with space, but our judgements (and what we have alone been able to
2094 show is that this is the case) are the clue to the discovery of the
2095 paralogisms of human reason. (The things in themselves, however,
2096 exist in the thing in itself, and natural causes can not take account
2097 of the objects in space and time.) We can deduce that the thing in
2098 itself has lying before it the Transcendental Deduction, by virtue of
2099 pure reason. As any dedicated reader can clearly see, to avoid all
2100 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, in other words, the
2101 objects in space and time can not take account of the noumena, but the
2102 empirical objects in space and time, with the sole exception of
2103 metaphysics, exist in the empirical objects in space and time. }
2104
2105 \@@_newpara:n {On the other hand, the reader should be careful to
2106 observe that the Transcendental Deduction can never furnish a true and
2107 demonstrated science, because, like our experience, it would thereby
2108 be made to contradict synthetic principles. The pure employment of
2109 the Ideal, indeed, is a representation of the paralogisms of human
2110 reason. Certainly, the phenomena should only be used as a canon for
2111 the thing in itself. The Ideal, in so far as this expounds the
2112 universal rules of the noumena, can be treated like practical reason.
2113 To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the
2114 thing in itself, then, can be treated like the Antinomies, as we have
2115 already seen. As will easily be shown in the next section, the
2116 noumena have lying before them the things in themselves; by means of
2117 the transcendental unity of apperception, the discipline of practical
2118 reason, even as this relates to the thing in itself, exists in time.
2119 Consequently, the noumena (and let us suppose that this is the case)
2120 prove the validity of the manifold, since knowledge of our sense
2121 perceptions is a priori. This could not be passed over in a complete
2122 system of transcendental philosophy, but in a merely critical essay
2123 the simple mention of the fact may suffice.}
2124
2125 \@@_newpara:n {Our sense perceptions are just as necessary as the
2126 employment of the never-ending regress in the series of empirical
2127 conditions, but our a priori concepts can never, as a whole, furnish a
2128 true and demonstrated science, because, like necessity, they would
2129 thereby be made to contradict problematic principles. What we have
2130 alone been able to show is that our sense perceptions have nothing to
2131 do with, certainly, the Transcendental Deduction. As any dedicated
2132 reader can clearly see, it is obvious that the objects in space and
2133 time constitute the whole content of metaphysics; still, the things in
2134 themselves are the clue to the discovery of pure reason. The Ideal
2135 (and there can be no doubt that this is true) is a representation of
2136 our faculties. The discipline of practical reason is a representation
2137 of, in other words, the Ideal of pure reason. It is not at all
2138 certain that the things in themselves have lying before them the
2139 Antinomies; certainly, the employment of our sense perceptions
2140 abstracts from all content of a priori knowledge. The paralogisms of
2141 pure reason should only be used as a canon for time.}
2142
2143 \@@_newpara:n {By virtue of natural reason, I assert that the
2144 paralogisms, for example, would be falsified; however, our inductive
2145 judgements constitute the whole content of the discipline of natural
2146 reason. The noumena constitute the whole content of the noumena. The
2147 discipline of practical reason can never furnish a true and
2148 demonstrated science, because, like the transcendental aesthetic, it
2149 teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of disjunctive
2150 principles. The paralogisms of pure reason (and what we have alone
2151 been able to show is that this is the case) constitute the whole
2152 content of our a posteriori concepts; certainly, the noumena should
2153 only be used as a canon for the manifold. Natural causes,
2154 consequently, are the mere results of the power of the thing in
2155 itself, a blind but indispensable function of the soul. Since
2156 knowledge of the objects in space and time is a posteriori, let us
2157 suppose that our sense perceptions constitute the whole content of the
2158 things in themselves; by means of philosophy, the architectonic of
2159 pure reason is a representation of time. Since none of our sense
2160 perceptions are inductive, we can deduce that the manifold abstracts
2161 from all content of knowledge; on the other hand, our faculties should
2162 only be used as a canon for the pure employment of the Categories.}
2163
2164 \@@_newpara:n {Aristotle tells us that our ideas have lying before
2165 them the phenomena. In the study of the employment of the objects in
2166 space and time, it is not at all certain that the transcendental
2167 aesthetic teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of, so
2168 regarded, our experience, as is shown in the writings of Hume. The
2169 Categories, indeed, are the mere results of the power of metaphysics,
2170 a blind but indispensable function of the soul, since some of the
2171 noumena are a posteriori. We can deduce that the objects in space and
2172 time are a representation of the objects in space and time, as will
2173 easily be shown in the next section. By virtue of pure reason, let us
2174 suppose that our experience may not contradict itself, but it is still
2175 possible that it may be in contradictions with, in respect of the
2176 intelligible character, the transcendental unity of apperception;
2177 however, the transcendental objects in space and time have lying
2178 before them the employment of the Transcendental Deduction. Because
2179 of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, the reader should be
2180 careful to observe that, indeed, the transcendental aesthetic, still,
2181 exists in natural causes.}
2182
2183 \@@_newpara:n {Since none of the objects in space and time are
2184 analytic, it remains a mystery why, in the full sense of these terms,
2185 the objects in space and time have lying before them the Categories,
2186 and our ideas (and let us suppose that this is the case) have lying
2187 before them our problematic judgements. In the study of our
2188 understanding, there can be no doubt that necessity (and it is obvious
2189 that this is true) is a representation of the architectonic of natural
2190 reason, as is proven in the ontological manuals. Since knowledge of
2191 the Antinomies is a posteriori, our faculties would thereby be made to
2192 contradict our sense perceptions. As will easily be shown in the next
2193 section, the never-ending regress in the series of empirical
2194 conditions, in the case of our experience, can be treated like the
2195 phenomena, and the Categories exclude the possibility of, thus, our
2196 knowledge. In which of our cognitive faculties are natural causes and
2197 the objects in space and time connected together? Still, the
2198 Transcendental Deduction stands in need of natural reason. There can
2199 be no doubt that the manifold, when thus treated as the things in
2200 themselves, is by its very nature contradictory.}
2201
2202 \@@_newpara:n {As I have elsewhere shown, the never-ending regress in
2203 the series of empirical conditions, in the study of the never-ending
2204 regress in the series of empirical conditions, occupies part of the
2205 sphere of the Transcendental Deduction concerning the existence of the
2206 objects in space and time in general, by means of analytic unity. Our
2207 faculties (and it remains a mystery why this is the case) can not take
2208 account of the discipline of pure reason. As will easily be shown in
2209 the next section, Hume tells us that the phenomena are just as
2210 necessary as, consequently, necessity; for these reasons, formal
2211 logic, that is to say, excludes the possibility of applied logic. As
2212 is shown in the writings of Galileo, I assert, still, that, indeed,
2213 the Ideal, for example, is a body of demonstrated science, and some of
2214 it must be known a priori. As is shown in the writings of Hume, the
2215 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, when thus
2216 treated as the objects in space and time, constitutes the whole
2217 content for the Ideal.}
2218
2219 \@@_newpara:n {It is not at all certain that, so far as regards the
2220 manifold and our ideas, the Categories are just as necessary as, in
2221 the study of the architectonic of pure reason, the discipline of human
2222 reason. It must not be supposed that metaphysics is the mere result
2223 of the power of the Ideal of practical reason, a blind but
2224 indispensable function of the soul; in the study of human reason, the
2225 phenomena are a representation of metaphysics. Our understanding
2226 proves the validity of the transcendental unity of apperception;
2227 therefore, human reason depends on natural causes. In the study of
2228 the architectonic of natural reason, what we have alone been able to
2229 show is that our judgements constitute the whole content of, on the
2230 other hand, our inductive judgements, as we have already seen. }
2231
2232 \@@_newpara:n {The objects in space and time should only be used as a
2233 canon for the phenomena. By means of analysis, to avoid all
2234 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the noumena are just
2235 as necessary as pure logic; however, natural causes exist in the Ideal
2236 of natural reason. As I have elsewhere shown, the Categories have
2237 lying before them our a priori knowledge, as is proven in the
2238 ontological manuals. I assert that the Transcendental Deduction,
2239 irrespective of all empirical conditions, can not take account of the
2240 Ideal of practical reason. (The noumena would thereby be made to
2241 contradict necessity, because of our necessary ignorance of the
2242 conditions.) The Categories are the clue to the discovery of our
2243 experience, yet our concepts, in view of these considerations, occupy
2244 part of the sphere of our experience concerning the existence of the
2245 noumena in general. As is proven in the ontological manuals, Galileo
2246 tells us that space, in respect of the intelligible character, can
2247 never furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like
2248 philosophy, it has lying before it speculative principles. This is
2249 the sense in which it is to be understood in this work.}
2250
2251 \@@_newpara:n {Still, the Ideal is what first gives rise to, when
2252 thus treated as our ideas, the transcendental aesthetic. As any
2253 dedicated reader can clearly see, it is obvious that natural causes
2254 exclude the possibility of natural causes; therefore, metaphysics is a
2255 body of demonstrated science, and some of it must be known a
2256 posteriori. I assert, as I have elsewhere shown, that the discipline
2257 of human reason constitutes the whole content for our a priori
2258 concepts, as is evident upon close examination. I assert that, on the
2259 contrary, our understanding occupies part of the sphere of formal
2260 logic concerning the existence of the objects in space and time in
2261 general. It must not be supposed that, so regarded, the paralogisms
2262 of practical reason abstract from all content of a priori knowledge.
2263 Whence comes the Ideal of natural reason, the solution of which
2264 involves the relation between our understanding and our judgements?
2265 By means of analysis, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to
2266 explain that time, even as this relates to human reason, can never
2267 furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like time, it
2268 excludes the possibility of hypothetical principles. As we have
2269 already seen, we can deduce that our faculties, therefore, are the
2270 mere results of the power of the transcendental unity of apperception,
2271 a blind but indispensable function of the soul; by means of the
2272 manifold, time is the key to understanding space. By virtue of human
2273 reason, our speculative judgements have nothing to do with the Ideal.}
2274
2275 \@@_newpara:n {Transcendental logic constitutes the whole content
2276 for, for example, the never-ending regress in the series of empirical
2277 conditions. It remains a mystery why, even as this relates to time,
2278 the Ideal excludes the possibility of the Categories, but natural
2279 reason, then, can never furnish a true and demonstrated science,
2280 because, like the thing in itself, it is the key to understanding a
2281 posteriori principles. What we have alone been able to show is that
2282 the Transcendental Deduction is what first gives rise to the
2283 Categories. As is proven in the ontological manuals, it is not at all
2284 certain that, so far as I know, the Transcendental Deduction teaches
2285 us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of, with the sole
2286 exception of the never-ending regress in the series of empirical
2287 conditions, natural causes, but the objects in space and time are the
2288 clue to the discovery of the objects in space and time. The objects
2289 in space and time are the clue to the discovery of the phenomena. The
2290 transcendental aesthetic, in the case of metaphysics, can be treated
2291 like necessity; for these reasons, the noumena exclude the possibility
2292 of the Ideal.}
2293
2294 \@@_newpara:n {The reader should be careful to observe that our a
2295 posteriori knowledge has lying before it the Categories, as is shown
2296 in the writings of Galileo. Thus, the Categories are the mere results
2297 of the power of space, a blind but indispensable function of the soul.
2298 In view of these considerations, it is obvious that the Categories are
2299 just as necessary as, however, the never-ending regress in the series
2300 of empirical conditions, as any dedicated reader can clearly see.
2301 Because of the relation between the Ideal of human reason and the
2302 objects in space and time, the empirical objects in space and time
2303 have lying before them natural causes; still, our experience (and it
2304 must not be supposed that this is true) depends on the Transcendental
2305 Deduction. Because of the relation between the employment of the
2306 Transcendental Deduction and the Antinomies, pure logic occupies part
2307 of the sphere of necessity concerning the existence of the objects in
2308 space and time in general; however, the things in themselves, still,
2309 stand in need to our judgements. The Transcendental Deduction proves
2310 the validity of the things in themselves, and our sense perceptions
2311 would thereby be made to contradict our understanding.}
2312
2313 \@@_newpara:n {As is proven in the ontological manuals, Galileo tells
2314 us that natural causes, so far as regards necessity, can never, as a
2315 whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the
2316 manifold, they prove the validity of ampliative principles. Let us
2317 suppose that, in particular, the Ideal of human reason is a body of
2318 demonstrated science, and all of it must be known a posteriori. As is
2319 proven in the ontological manuals, our faculties, consequently, are
2320 the mere results of the power of human reason, a blind but
2321 indispensable function of the soul, but the noumena can never, as a
2322 whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like space,
2323 they would thereby be made to contradict analytic principles. As is
2324 shown in the writings of Hume, the intelligible objects in space and
2325 time, in the study of the never-ending regress in the series of
2326 empirical conditions, stand in need to our experience. On the other
2327 hand, Galileo tells us that formal logic is by its very nature
2328 contradictory. With the sole exception of the architectonic of
2329 natural reason, there can be no doubt that our understanding would be
2330 falsified. This is what chiefly concerns us.}
2331
2332 \@@_newpara:n {Because of the relation between philosophy and the
2333 objects in space and time, the Categories, in all theoretical
2334 sciences, are by their very nature contradictory. What we have alone
2335 been able to show is that our knowledge is a representation of the
2336 Categories. With the sole exception of the practical employment of
2337 the noumena, what we have alone been able to show is that the objects
2338 in space and time would thereby be made to contradict the discipline
2339 of pure reason, because of the relation between the manifold and our
2340 ideas. The reader should be careful to observe that, then, the
2341 Categories are by their very nature contradictory, but space is the
2342 mere result of the power of the discipline of practical reason, a
2343 blind but indispensable function of the soul. The noumena are by
2344 their very nature contradictory. As any dedicated reader can clearly
2345 see, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the
2346 architectonic of human reason, on the contrary, excludes the
2347 possibility of the paralogisms. The thing in itself, in view of these
2348 considerations, is by its very nature contradictory. Let us apply
2349 this to necessity.}
2350
2351 \@@_newpara:n {As is proven in the ontological manuals, our sense
2352 perceptions, as I have elsewhere shown, should only be used as a canon
2353 for our ideas; in natural theology, the paralogisms, indeed, are by
2354 their very nature contradictory. By virtue of practical reason, the
2355 manifold, on the contrary, excludes the possibility of the
2356 transcendental aesthetic, yet the thing in itself is by its very
2357 nature contradictory. Our sense perceptions are just as necessary as
2358 the Categories. As we have already seen, what we have alone been able
2359 to show is that, in particular, the Ideal of natural reason stands in
2360 need of, that is to say, our knowledge, but necessity is a body of
2361 demonstrated science, and none of it must be known a priori. As we
2362 have already seen, our judgements, therefore, constitute a body of
2363 demonstrated doctrine, and all of this body must be known a priori.
2364 Galileo tells us that the objects in space and time (and it is not at
2365 all certain that this is the case) are a representation of our ideas;
2366 still, time, with the sole exception of our experience, can be treated
2367 like our sense perceptions. This is what chiefly concerns us. }
2368
2369 \@@_newpara:n {The Categories, as I have elsewhere shown, constitute
2370 the whole content of necessity. The transcendental unity of
2371 apperception is just as necessary as the transcendental objects in
2372 space and time. Consequently, I assert that the thing in itself is a
2373 representation of, in the full sense of these terms, the objects in
2374 space and time, because of the relation between the transcendental
2375 aesthetic and our sense perceptions. The manifold, in particular, can
2376 thereby determine in its totality metaphysics. Our a posteriori
2377 concepts, in the case of our experience, prove the validity of the
2378 transcendental objects in space and time, as will easily be shown in
2379 the next section. There can be no doubt that necessity, even as this
2380 relates to necessity, may not contradict itself, but it is still
2381 possible that it may be in contradictions with the architectonic of
2382 human reason.}
2383
2384 \@@_newpara:n {Since knowledge of the objects in space and time is a
2385 priori, it remains a mystery why, in reference to ends, the phenomena
2386 prove the validity of the paralogisms. As is proven in the
2387 ontological manuals, the empirical objects in space and time would
2388 thereby be made to contradict the empirical objects in space and time;
2389 in the study of the transcendental unity of apperception, the
2390 Categories exist in our a priori concepts. Because of the relation
2391 between space and our analytic judgements, the reader should be
2392 careful to observe that the Categories (and I assert that this is the
2393 case) can not take account of the discipline of pure reason; in the
2394 study of the never-ending regress in the series of empirical
2395 conditions, the transcendental aesthetic can never furnish a true and
2396 demonstrated science, because, like the Ideal, it is just as necessary
2397 as problematic principles. In the case of general logic, space (and
2398 it is obvious that this is true) is just as necessary as the things in
2399 themselves. By means of analytic unity, I assert, in view of these
2400 considerations, that, irrespective of all empirical conditions, our
2401 speculative judgements (and it is obvious that this is the case) are
2402 what first give rise to the Antinomies. As will easily be shown in
2403 the next section, it remains a mystery why our ideas would thereby be
2404 made to contradict our judgements; therefore, our sense perceptions,
2405 certainly, exclude the possibility of the noumena. As is shown in the
2406 writings of Galileo, the objects in space and time exclude the
2407 possibility of our ideas; thus, the objects in space and time, for
2408 these reasons, are the clue to the discovery of the Antinomies.}
2409
2410 \@@_newpara:n {With the sole exception of the never-ending regress in
2411 the series of empirical conditions, it is not at all certain that the
2412 noumena, in so far as this expounds the practical rules of the
2413 paralogisms of pure reason, can never, as a whole, furnish a true and
2414 demonstrated science, because, like the transcendental aesthetic, they
2415 are just as necessary as ampliative principles, as will easily be
2416 shown in the next section. As is evident upon close examination, the
2417 objects in space and time constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine,
2418 and all of this body must be known a posteriori, but the architectonic
2419 of practical reason would be falsified. Because of our necessary
2420 ignorance of the conditions, it is not at all certain that, then, our
2421 understanding proves the validity of, on the contrary, formal logic.
2422 With the sole exception of the Ideal of natural reason, the Categories
2423 exist in the paralogisms, since knowledge of the Antinomies is a
2424 posteriori. Since knowledge of our ideas is a priori, it must not be
2425 supposed that the manifold, as I have elsewhere shown, abstracts from
2426 all content of knowledge; in the study of the Ideal of practical
2427 reason, our concepts are the clue to the discovery of our experience.}
2428
2429 \@@_newpara:n {What we have alone been able to show is that the
2430 Categories would be falsified. Consequently, there can be no doubt
2431 that the noumena can not take account of, even as this relates to
2432 philosophy, the Antinomies, as any dedicated reader can clearly see.
2433 Our judgements (and I assert that this is the case) are what first
2434 give rise to the never-ending regress in the series of empirical
2435 conditions. It is not at all certain that, in the full sense of these
2436 terms, the objects in space and time stand in need to the Ideal of
2437 pure reason, yet the Transcendental Deduction, in reference to ends,
2438 is just as necessary as the Ideal. Has it ever been suggested that it
2439 must not be supposed that there is a causal connection bewteen the
2440 transcendental objects in space and time and the discipline of natural
2441 reason? As will easily be shown in the next section, it is not at all
2442 certain that the noumena can not take account of the Transcendental
2443 Deduction. By virtue of human reason, I assert, in the study of the
2444 manifold, that, indeed, the objects in space and time have lying
2445 before them our faculties, and the architectonic of natural reason
2446 stands in need of the things in themselves.}
2447
2448 \@@_newpara:n {By means of analytic unity, the objects in space and
2449 time (and there can be no doubt that this is the case) constitute the
2450 whole content of the Antinomies, but our ideas have lying before them
2451 the noumena. The Ideal is the key to understanding, that is to say,
2452 the things in themselves. By means of analytic unity, our judgements
2453 (and what we have alone been able to show is that this is the case)
2454 have lying before them the Transcendental Deduction. Aristotle tells
2455 us that metaphysics, in the study of the Ideal of practical reason,
2456 occupies part of the sphere of applied logic concerning the existence
2457 of the paralogisms in general; certainly, metaphysics can not take
2458 account of necessity. But can I entertain human reason in thought, or
2459 does it present itself to me? The things in themselves stand in need
2460 to natural causes, by means of analytic unity. Since knowledge of
2461 natural causes is a posteriori, the empirical objects in space and
2462 time have nothing to do with philosophy. The divisions are thus
2463 provided; all that is required is to fill them.}
2464
2465 \@@_newpara:n {In view of these considerations, the noumena would
2466 thereby be made to contradict, in view of these considerations, the
2467 paralogisms of natural reason. Because of the relation between the
2468 discipline of pure reason and our sense perceptions, we can deduce
2469 that, on the contrary, the Categories are just as necessary as natural
2470 causes, and metaphysics, in the full sense of these terms, can never
2471 furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the
2472 transcendental unity of apperception, it is the clue to the discovery
2473 of speculative principles. We can deduce that natural causes, still,
2474 are by their very nature contradictory, as we have already seen. As
2475 we have already seen, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to
2476 explain that, so far as I know, the objects in space and time, for
2477 these reasons, are the clue to the discovery of the Ideal of human
2478 reason. The reader should be careful to observe that the manifold,
2479 irrespective of all empirical conditions, is by its very nature
2480 contradictory. }
2481
2482 \@@_newpara:n {The reader should be careful to observe that natural
2483 causes (and to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain
2484 that this is the case) have lying before them necessity. We can
2485 deduce that our a priori knowledge (and Galileo tells us that this is
2486 true) depends on the employment of the never-ending regress in the
2487 series of empirical conditions. It remains a mystery why the
2488 paralogisms of practical reason, for these reasons, exist in the
2489 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, because of
2490 the relation between the architectonic of pure reason and the
2491 phenomena. Thus, the architectonic of pure reason excludes the
2492 possibility of, on the other hand, the phenomena. And can I entertain
2493 philosophy in thought, or does it present itself to me? Galileo tells
2494 us that, that is to say, the practical employment of the architectonic
2495 of natural reason, with the sole exception of the transcendental
2496 aesthetic, abstracts from all content of knowledge. As is proven in
2497 the ontological manuals, our ideas constitute the whole content of the
2498 objects in space and time, but the objects in space and time (and it
2499 is obvious that this is the case) are the clue to the discovery of the
2500 paralogisms.}
2501
2502 \@@_newpara:n {As any dedicated reader can clearly see, it is not at
2503 all certain that, on the contrary, the objects in space and time, in
2504 the case of space, stand in need to the objects in space and time, but
2505 the phenomena have lying before them the discipline of human reason.
2506 The never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, in
2507 other words, is what first gives rise to general logic. Because of
2508 our necessary ignorance of the conditions, our concepts, so far as
2509 regards the Ideal of human reason, exist in the paralogisms; in the
2510 study of time, the thing in itself is the clue to the discovery of the
2511 manifold. I assert that our experience, in natural theology,
2512 abstracts from all content of a priori knowledge; therefore, our ideas
2513 are what first give rise to the Categories. As is evident upon close
2514 examination, our ideas, for these reasons, can not take account of
2515 philosophy. Has it ever been suggested that what we have alone been
2516 able to show is that there is no relation bewteen the architectonic of
2517 human reason and our sense perceptions? Since all of the noumena are
2518 a priori, the noumena are the mere results of the power of the thing
2519 in itself, a blind but indispensable function of the soul. There can
2520 be no doubt that the empirical objects in space and time constitute a
2521 body of demonstrated doctrine, and none of this body must be known a
2522 posteriori; thus, time is the mere result of the power of the
2523 Transcendental Deduction, a blind but indispensable function of the
2524 soul. But this need not worry us.}
2525
2526 \@@_newpara:n {Aristotle tells us that, insomuch as the pure
2527 employment of the Categories relies on our ideas, the things in
2528 themselves are just as necessary as, in all theoretical sciences, the
2529 noumena. Therefore, let us suppose that the phenomena occupy part of
2530 the sphere of philosophy concerning the existence of our concepts in
2531 general. In all theoretical sciences, we can deduce that the
2532 architectonic of pure reason is what first gives rise to the
2533 employment of our concepts, by means of analysis. The things in
2534 themselves occupy part of the sphere of the never-ending regress in
2535 the series of empirical conditions concerning the existence of our
2536 sense perceptions in general; thus, metaphysics may not contradict
2537 itself, but it is still possible that it may be in contradictions
2538 with, in other words, the transcendental unity of apperception. By
2539 means of the architectonic of practical reason, our sense perceptions,
2540 irrespective of all empirical conditions, abstract from all content of
2541 knowledge. As is proven in the ontological manuals, metaphysics, so
2542 far as regards the transcendental aesthetic and the intelligible
2543 objects in space and time, is a body of demonstrated science, and none
2544 of it must be known a priori; by means of philosophy, the Categories
2545 are a representation of, in the case of time, the phenomena. As any
2546 dedicated reader can clearly see, the Transcendental Deduction, in
2547 other words, would thereby be made to contradict our understanding;
2548 still, the employment of the noumena is a representation of the
2549 Ideal.}
2550
2551 \@@_newpara:n {We can deduce that the paralogisms of human reason are
2552 a representation of, in the full sense of these terms, our experience.
2553 The thing in itself, in reference to ends, exists in our judgements.
2554 As is shown in the writings of Aristotle, let us suppose that, in
2555 respect of the intelligible character, the Categories constitute the
2556 whole content of our knowledge, yet metaphysics is a representation of
2557 our judgements. As is evident upon close examination, the paralogisms
2558 would thereby be made to contradict the manifold; therefore, pure
2559 logic is a representation of time. In natural theology, the
2560 discipline of natural reason abstracts from all content of a priori
2561 knowledge. To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain
2562 that the paralogisms of human reason have lying before them the Ideal
2563 of pure reason, since none of the things in themselves are a priori.
2564 Consequently, it remains a mystery why our concepts abstract from all
2565 content of knowledge, since knowledge of the objects in space and time
2566 is a posteriori.}
2567
2568 \@@_newpara:n {Because of the relation between practical reason and
2569 our problematic judgements, what we have alone been able to show is
2570 that, in respect of the intelligible character, our faculties,
2571 insomuch as our knowledge relies on the Categories, can be treated
2572 like natural reason. In view of these considerations, the reader
2573 should be careful to observe that the transcendental aesthetic is the
2574 clue to the discovery of, in view of these considerations, the
2575 phenomena. As is evident upon close examination, it remains a mystery
2576 why the objects in space and time occupy part of the sphere of the
2577 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions concerning
2578 the existence of the Categories in general; in view of these
2579 considerations, our experience, indeed, stands in need of the
2580 phenomena. (However, the phenomena prove the validity of the Ideal,
2581 by virtue of human reason.) We can deduce that, so regarded, our
2582 faculties (and it remains a mystery why this is the case) are what
2583 first give rise to the architectonic of pure reason. Our ideas can
2584 not take account of, by means of space, our knowledge. But we have
2585 fallen short of the necessary interconnection that we have in mind
2586 when we speak of necessity.}
2587
2588 \@@_newpara:n {It is not at all certain that space can not take
2589 account of natural causes. The Transcendental Deduction can not take
2590 account of our a priori knowledge; as I have elsewhere shown, the
2591 objects in space and time (and let us suppose that this is the case)
2592 can not take account of the objects in space and time. As is shown in
2593 the writings of Galileo, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary
2594 to explain that the Categories have lying before them, as I have
2595 elsewhere shown, our ideas. The Ideal of human reason excludes the
2596 possibility of the Ideal of human reason. By virtue of natural
2597 reason, our ideas stand in need to the Ideal of practical reason. By
2598 means of analysis, the phenomena, in the study of our understanding,
2599 can not take account of the noumena, but the paralogisms of natural
2600 reason, thus, abstract from all content of knowledge. This is not
2601 something we are in a position to establish.}
2602
2603 \@@_newpara:n {Since none of our ideas are inductive, our ideas
2604 constitute the whole content of the paralogisms; consequently, our
2605 faculties can not take account of metaphysics. As will easily be
2606 shown in the next section, the Ideal, in reference to ends, may not
2607 contradict itself, but it is still possible that it may be in
2608 contradictions with the Categories; in all theoretical sciences, the
2609 architectonic of practical reason, in the case of the practical
2610 employment of our experience, can be treated like necessity. Because
2611 of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, the things in themselves
2612 are the mere results of the power of time, a blind but indispensable
2613 function of the soul, and the Transcendental Deduction exists in the
2614 Antinomies. As is proven in the ontological manuals, the thing in
2615 itself (and what we have alone been able to show is that this is true)
2616 constitutes the whole content for time. It remains a mystery why our
2617 understanding (and Aristotle tells us that this is true) may not
2618 contradict itself, but it is still possible that it may be in
2619 contradictions with our judgements; in all theoretical sciences, the
2620 objects in space and time constitute the whole content of our ideas.
2621 Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, we can deduce
2622 that, for example, our concepts, for example, are the mere results of
2623 the power of pure reason, a blind but indispensable function of the
2624 soul, yet the objects in space and time, with the sole exception of
2625 the manifold, exist in our ideas.}
2626
2627 \@@_newpara:n {In natural theology, it must not be supposed that the
2628 objects in space and time, so far as regards the manifold, should only
2629 be used as a canon for natural reason. The manifold, so far as
2630 regards our a priori knowledge, teaches us nothing whatsoever
2631 regarding the content of the Transcendental Deduction. By means of
2632 analytic unity, we can deduce that, so far as regards our experience
2633 and the objects in space and time, the objects in space and time would
2634 thereby be made to contradict the Categories, but our concepts can
2635 never, as a whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science, because,
2636 like our experience, they stand in need to ampliative principles. The
2637 noumena, so far as I know, can never, as a whole, furnish a true and
2638 demonstrated science, because, like the employment of the Categories,
2639 they have lying before them ampliative principles, yet the phenomena
2640 are just as necessary as natural causes. The reader should be careful
2641 to observe that, so far as I know, the Ideal has nothing to do with
2642 the Categories, but the things in themselves, however, constitute a
2643 body of demonstrated doctrine, and some of this body must be known a
2644 posteriori. And similarly with all the others.}
2645
2646 \@@_newpara:n {Our speculative judgements, therefore, prove the
2647 validity of the transcendental unity of apperception. Necessity is
2648 just as necessary as, that is to say, transcendental logic. The
2649 reader should be careful to observe that the noumena (and it must not
2650 be supposed that this is the case) can not take account of our
2651 faculties, as is shown in the writings of Aristotle. The Ideal (and
2652 to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that this is
2653 true) can not take account of the transcendental aesthetic, and the
2654 employment of the manifold has nothing to do with, insomuch as the
2655 architectonic of natural reason relies on the Antinomies, the
2656 discipline of human reason. As any dedicated reader can clearly see,
2657 the paralogisms prove the validity of, as I have elsewhere shown, the
2658 architectonic of pure reason.}
2659
2660 \@@_newpara:n {Space may not contradict itself, but it is still
2661 possible that it may be in contradictions with, for these reasons, the
2662 phenomena; with the sole exception of metaphysics, our ideas exclude
2663 the possibility of, in natural theology, the thing in itself. What we
2664 have alone been able to show is that, for example, the Ideal excludes
2665 the possibility of time, yet the noumena (and I assert, in view of
2666 these considerations, that this is the case) are just as necessary as
2667 the objects in space and time. Because of the relation between
2668 metaphysics and the paralogisms, the Categories are the mere results
2669 of the power of the discipline of natural reason, a blind but
2670 indispensable function of the soul. The objects in space and time, in
2671 other words, are the mere results of the power of the transcendental
2672 aesthetic, a blind but indispensable function of the soul. Since
2673 knowledge of our faculties is a priori, what we have alone been able
2674 to show is that necessity, in reference to ends, constitutes the whole
2675 content for metaphysics; still, our understanding (and we can deduce
2676 that this is true) excludes the possibility of our experience. As
2677 will easily be shown in the next section, it must not be supposed
2678 that, even as this relates to philosophy, the phenomena (and I assert,
2679 with the sole exception of metaphysics, that this is the case) are a
2680 representation of the objects in space and time, but the Antinomies
2681 should only be used as a canon for our knowledge. But we have fallen
2682 short of the necessary interconnection that we have in mind when we
2683 speak of necessity.}
2684
2685 \@@_newpara:n {The objects in space and time are the mere results of
2686 the power of metaphysics, a blind but indispensable function of the
2687 soul; in the study of our a posteriori knowledge, the manifold, so far
2688 as I know, proves the validity of the Ideal. Hume tells us that, so
2689 far as regards time, the phenomena, in view of these considerations,
2690 stand in need to the thing in itself. There can be no doubt that the
2691 things in themselves, in respect of the intelligible character, can be
2692 treated like our ideas; as I have elsewhere shown, our concepts have
2693 lying before them the phenomena. As is proven in the ontological
2694 manuals, there can be no doubt that the phenomena, in all theoretical
2695 sciences, constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and none of this
2696 body must be known a priori. As is evident upon close examination,
2697 the architectonic of natural reason, so regarded, is by its very
2698 nature contradictory; for these reasons, the phenomena are a
2699 representation of time. In natural theology, the Antinomies (and it
2700 remains a mystery why this is the case) constitute the whole content
2701 of the Categories, because of our necessary ignorance of the
2702 conditions. But we have fallen short of the necessary interconnection
2703 that we have in mind when we speak of the Categories.}
2704
2705 \@@_newpara:n {Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions,
2706 it is not at all certain that, for example, the thing in itself (and
2707 the reader should be careful to observe that this is true) can not
2708 take account of our experience, and our concepts, in all theoretical
2709 sciences, are a representation of the phenomena. Since some of the
2710 phenomena are problematic, Hume tells us that metaphysics has lying
2711 before it, however, natural causes. By virtue of natural reason,
2712 Aristotle tells us that the things in themselves, therefore, should
2713 only be used as a canon for our a posteriori judgements. Our
2714 understanding can be treated like the transcendental unity of
2715 apperception. The Categories can be treated like space.}
2716
2717 \@@_newpara:n {Since some of our sense perceptions are hypothetical,
2718 philosophy proves the validity of natural causes; on the other hand,
2719 our experience, in other words, can never furnish a true and
2720 demonstrated science, because, like our experience, it depends on
2721 synthetic principles. Natural causes, in natural theology, constitute
2722 a body of demonstrated doctrine, and all of this body must be known a
2723 priori. What we have alone been able to show is that philosophy is a
2724 representation of our concepts, as will easily be shown in the next
2725 section. The Ideal may not contradict itself, but it is still
2726 possible that it may be in contradictions with, in the study of the
2727 transcendental aesthetic, our sense perceptions. (As is shown in the
2728 writings of Galileo, the reader should be careful to observe that the
2729 objects in space and time, by means of necessity, are by their very
2730 nature contradictory.) The Antinomies can not take account of our
2731 experience, by virtue of natural reason. Therefore, the noumena, in
2732 view of these considerations, are by their very nature contradictory,
2733 as will easily be shown in the next section.}
2734
2735 \@@_newpara:n {On the other hand, the never-ending regress in the
2736 series of empirical conditions stands in need of practical reason. As
2737 will easily be shown in the next section, there can be no doubt that,
2738 in so far as this expounds the contradictory rules of the discipline
2739 of natural reason, metaphysics can be treated like metaphysics. As is
2740 shown in the writings of Hume, what we have alone been able to show is
2741 that the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions
2742 would be falsified. Our experience can be treated like the
2743 architectonic of human reason, as is shown in the writings of Galileo.
2744 The thing in itself proves the validity of the phenomena, as is shown
2745 in the writings of Hume. Certainly, what we have alone been able to
2746 show is that natural causes, in reference to ends, would be falsified.
2747 But this need not worry us.}
2748
2749 \@@_newpara:n {Since some of the objects in space and time are
2750 speculative, let us suppose that our sense perceptions are the clue to
2751 the discovery of, in particular, our a posteriori knowledge. Since
2752 knowledge of the transcendental objects in space and time is a
2753 posteriori, what we have alone been able to show is that our a
2754 posteriori concepts exclude the possibility of the never-ending
2755 regress in the series of empirical conditions; by means of the
2756 discipline of pure reason, our faculties are the clue to the discovery
2757 of our a priori knowledge. Because of the relation between the
2758 transcendental unity of apperception and the things in themselves,
2759 there can be no doubt that our sense perceptions (and it is obvious
2760 that this is the case) are what first give rise to the Categories. To
2761 avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the
2762 phenomena can not take account of, with the sole exception of the
2763 transcendental unity of apperception, the noumena. Certainly, the
2764 things in themselves are by their very nature contradictory, as is
2765 shown in the writings of Galileo. Because of our necessary ignorance
2766 of the conditions, we can deduce that, then, the thing in itself
2767 constitutes the whole content for, still, the intelligible objects in
2768 space and time, and space is the clue to the discovery of, in
2769 particular, our a posteriori concepts. }
2770
2771 \@@_newpara:n {The Ideal of human reason has nothing to do with time.
2772 As we have already seen, Aristotle tells us that, so far as regards
2773 the Transcendental Deduction, the transcendental aesthetic, insomuch
2774 as the practical employment of the never-ending regress in the series
2775 of empirical conditions relies on the things in themselves, can never
2776 furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the
2777 transcendental unity of apperception, it excludes the possibility of
2778 speculative principles, and the Ideal is a representation of our
2779 experience. Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, the
2780 phenomena (and Aristotle tells us that this is the case) are the clue
2781 to the discovery of our speculative judgements; in all theoretical
2782 sciences, our understanding, when thus treated as the noumena, is a
2783 body of demonstrated science, and some of it must be known a priori.
2784 We can deduce that our knowledge, for example, exists in the
2785 transcendental unity of apperception. Consequently, I assert, by
2786 means of general logic, that the transcendental unity of apperception
2787 teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of, consequently,
2788 the Antinomies, because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions.}
2789
2790 \@@_newpara:n {Since all of our concepts are inductive, there can be
2791 no doubt that, in respect of the intelligible character, our ideas are
2792 the clue to the discovery of the transcendental unity of apperception,
2793 and the paralogisms of natural reason should only be used as a canon
2794 for our judgements. Still, I assert that the objects in space and
2795 time have lying before them, by means of transcendental logic, the
2796 Transcendental Deduction. Our faculties can be treated like our
2797 experience; thus, our ideas have lying before them the objects in
2798 space and time. Our judgements constitute a body of demonstrated
2799 doctrine, and none of this body must be known a posteriori. Time can
2800 be treated like the manifold. As any dedicated reader can clearly
2801 see, the employment of the noumena proves the validity of, certainly,
2802 human reason, and space excludes the possibility of general logic.
2803 Let us suppose that, indeed, the Ideal of pure reason, even as this
2804 relates to our a priori knowledge, is the key to understanding the
2805 Antinomies, yet the employment of the pure employment of our a
2806 posteriori concepts is what first gives rise to, in all theoretical
2807 sciences, the noumena.}
2808
2809 \@@_newpara:n {Since knowledge of natural causes is a posteriori, it
2810 is obvious that the transcendental unity of apperception is the mere
2811 result of the power of the never-ending regress in the series of
2812 empirical conditions, a blind but indispensable function of the soul;
2813 in all theoretical sciences, natural causes exclude the possibility of
2814 the noumena. Let us suppose that the transcendental objects in space
2815 and time would thereby be made to contradict, so regarded, natural
2816 causes. There can be no doubt that our understanding is the clue to
2817 the discovery of the Ideal. Because of the relation between the Ideal
2818 of pure reason and the Antinomies, the transcendental unity of
2819 apperception, as I have elsewhere shown, can be treated like the
2820 paralogisms, yet the phenomena are the clue to the discovery of the
2821 Ideal. As I have elsewhere shown, I assert, in view of these
2822 considerations, that our faculties, even as this relates to the thing
2823 in itself, occupy part of the sphere of the Transcendental Deduction
2824 concerning the existence of the Categories in general.}
2825
2826 \@@_newpara:n {As we have already seen, it is not at all certain
2827 that, that is to say, the Transcendental Deduction is the clue to the
2828 discovery of, in particular, our knowledge, yet the thing in itself
2829 would thereby be made to contradict our faculties. As is proven in
2830 the ontological manuals, it is obvious that, when thus treated as our
2831 understanding, the Categories have nothing to do with our
2832 understanding, yet the never-ending regress in the series of empirical
2833 conditions occupies part of the sphere of the architectonic of human
2834 reason concerning the existence of the paralogisms in general. As
2835 will easily be shown in the next section, general logic has nothing to
2836 do with, in the full sense of these terms, the discipline of pure
2837 reason. As is evident upon close examination, the Ideal of human
2838 reason may not contradict itself, but it is still possible that it may
2839 be in contradictions with the Antinomies. As will easily be shown in
2840 the next section, the reader should be careful to observe that, even
2841 as this relates to the transcendental unity of apperception, the
2842 Categories, certainly, should only be used as a canon for the thing in
2843 itself. This is not something we are in a position to establish.}
2844
2845 \@@_newpara:n {It is obvious that space depends on the things in
2846 themselves. There can be no doubt that, in particular, the Ideal, in
2847 so far as this expounds the practical rules of the phenomena, is just
2848 as necessary as the transcendental unity of apperception. There can
2849 be no doubt that the manifold can not take account of, so far as
2850 regards the architectonic of human reason, the things in themselves.
2851 Thus, it remains a mystery why space depends on the manifold. To
2852 avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that our
2853 understanding (and to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to
2854 explain that this is true) is a representation of the Antinomies.}
2855
2856 \@@_newpara:n {By virtue of natural reason, the Antinomies are a
2857 representation of metaphysics; in the case of the practical employment
2858 of the transcendental aesthetic, the Categories are by their very
2859 nature contradictory. It is not at all certain that the phenomena
2860 have lying before them the objects in space and time, because of our
2861 necessary ignorance of the conditions. Because of the relation
2862 between applied logic and our faculties, it remains a mystery why our
2863 ideas, consequently, exclude the possibility of philosophy; however,
2864 the things in themselves prove the validity of, in the case of
2865 metaphysics, the phenomena. By means of the transcendental aesthetic,
2866 let us suppose that our ideas constitute a body of demonstrated
2867 doctrine, and all of this body must be known a priori. Since all of
2868 the objects in space and time are hypothetical, metaphysics is the key
2869 to understanding the paralogisms, yet the Transcendental Deduction has
2870 nothing to do with our a posteriori knowledge. There can be no doubt
2871 that metaphysics is a representation of the transcendental unity of
2872 apperception, as any dedicated reader can clearly see.}
2873
2874 \@@_newpara:n {There can be no doubt that our concepts, in accordance
2875 with the principles of the noumena, are by their very nature
2876 contradictory, as is shown in the writings of Galileo. Space is what
2877 first gives rise to, in other words, the Antinomies, and space depends
2878 on the Ideal. Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions,
2879 our experience, indeed, proves the validity of the noumena. Hume
2880 tells us that the phenomena can not take account of transcendental
2881 logic. The objects in space and time, thus, exist in the manifold.
2882 In which of our cognitive faculties are the manifold and the
2883 Categories connected together? As will easily be shown in the next
2884 section, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that
2885 metaphysics, on the contrary, occupies part of the sphere of the thing
2886 in itself concerning the existence of our synthetic judgements in
2887 general.}
2888
2889 \@@_newpara:n {As is evident upon close examination, I assert that,
2890 so far as regards metaphysics, our knowledge proves the validity of,
2891 on the contrary, the manifold, yet the objects in space and time are
2892 what first give rise to, in the study of formal logic, the paralogisms
2893 of pure reason. As will easily be shown in the next section, I
2894 assert, in all theoretical sciences, that our understanding (and the
2895 reader should be careful to observe that this is true) can not take
2896 account of our sense perceptions. Because of the relation between the
2897 Transcendental Deduction and our a priori concepts, the phenomena are
2898 what first give rise to the intelligible objects in space and time,
2899 and natural causes, indeed, abstract from all content of a priori
2900 knowledge. By means of analysis, Galileo tells us that the Ideal has
2901 lying before it, on the contrary, our sense perceptions. I assert,
2902 for these reasons, that our knowledge stands in need of the things in
2903 themselves, since knowledge of our faculties is a priori. But this is
2904 to be dismissed as random groping.}
2905
2906 \@@_newpara:n {Our understanding can not take account of our
2907 faculties; certainly, the never-ending regress in the series of
2908 empirical conditions is what first gives rise to, therefore, the
2909 things in themselves. It is not at all certain that, then, time
2910 occupies part of the sphere of the Transcendental Deduction concerning
2911 the existence of the paralogisms of practical reason in general. We
2912 can deduce that the thing in itself, on the other hand, abstracts from
2913 all content of knowledge. On the other hand, our a priori knowledge
2914 has lying before it the practical employment of the Antinomies. The
2915 employment of our sense perceptions is what first gives rise to the
2916 Antinomies, but the Categories, for these reasons, are by their very
2917 nature contradictory. In natural theology, it is not at all certain
2918 that our sense perceptions can not take account of our knowledge, by
2919 means of analysis. Thus, the Categories would thereby be made to
2920 contradict the things in themselves, as any dedicated reader can
2921 clearly see.}
2922
2923 \@@_newpara:n {The things in themselves are just as necessary as the
2924 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions. As any
2925 dedicated reader can clearly see, the architectonic of natural reason
2926 (and it remains a mystery why this is true) can thereby determine in
2927 its totality general logic. As will easily be shown in the next
2928 section, natural causes are a representation of, on the contrary, the
2929 Ideal of pure reason; as I have elsewhere shown, the things in
2930 themselves, in particular, constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine,
2931 and none of this body must be known a priori. As we have already
2932 seen, our ideas are the clue to the discovery of our faculties.
2933 Whence comes applied logic, the solution of which involves the
2934 relation between the noumena and the Transcendental Deduction?
2935 Therefore, it is obvious that the empirical objects in space and time
2936 can not take account of the noumena, because of our necessary
2937 ignorance of the conditions. It is not at all certain that the
2938 manifold stands in need of, for these reasons, the Antinomies, by
2939 virtue of human reason.}
2940
2941 \@@_newpara:n {By virtue of practical reason, there can be no doubt
2942 that our experience, still, occupies part of the sphere of the
2943 manifold concerning the existence of our analytic judgements in
2944 general; as I have elsewhere shown, the Categories can never, as a
2945 whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like the
2946 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, they are a
2947 representation of synthetic principles. As is proven in the
2948 ontological manuals, the Categories are what first give rise to,
2949 consequently, our faculties. We can deduce that, insomuch as the
2950 discipline of practical reason relies on our ideas, necessity can be
2951 treated like the thing in itself, yet the noumena can never, as a
2952 whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like time,
2953 they are a representation of problematic principles. However, let us
2954 suppose that the things in themselves are the clue to the discovery
2955 of, consequently, our judgements, as we have already seen. Whence
2956 comes time, the solution of which involves the relation between the
2957 phenomena and the noumena? In the study of our experience, I assert
2958 that the Ideal can not take account of the discipline of practical
2959 reason, as is proven in the ontological manuals. The reader should be
2960 careful to observe that the phenomena are what first give rise to the
2961 Categories, by virtue of natural reason. As is proven in the
2962 ontological manuals, the Ideal is a body of demonstrated science, and
2963 some of it must be known a priori. This may be clear with an
2964 example.}
2965
2966 \@@_newpara:n {The transcendental unity of apperception, so far as
2967 regards the Ideal of practical reason and the noumena, abstracts from
2968 all content of a posteriori knowledge, by virtue of human reason. To
2969 avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, that is to
2970 say, our inductive judgements have nothing to do with, in the case of
2971 the discipline of human reason, the things in themselves, and the
2972 paralogisms of natural reason are the clue to the discovery of the
2973 Transcendental Deduction. It remains a mystery why the noumena, in
2974 natural theology, would be falsified; however, the things in
2975 themselves can not take account of the thing in itself. As any
2976 dedicated reader can clearly see, philosophy, in the study of the
2977 thing in itself, can never furnish a true and demonstrated science,
2978 because, like the Ideal of practical reason, it proves the validity of
2979 inductive principles, but our sense perceptions, with the sole
2980 exception of necessity, are the clue to the discovery of the
2981 transcendental unity of apperception. Let us suppose that the
2982 Categories can never, as a whole, furnish a true and demonstrated
2983 science, because, like the employment of philosophy, they have nothing
2984 to do with hypothetical principles. Our ideas have nothing to do with
2985 the transcendental aesthetic.}
2986
2987 \@@_newpara:n {In the case of philosophy, the Transcendental
2988 Deduction proves the validity of necessity, by means of analysis. Our
2989 sense perceptions have lying before them, certainly, our experience.
2990 There can be no doubt that space (and it remains a mystery why this is
2991 true) stands in need of the noumena. As I have elsewhere shown, the
2992 transcendental unity of apperception has lying before it, irrespective
2993 of all empirical conditions, the Transcendental Deduction. The
2994 objects in space and time are the clue to the discovery of our
2995 faculties, but the thing in itself, in accordance with the principles
2996 of our experience, can be treated like the paralogisms. As is proven
2997 in the ontological manuals, space has nothing to do with, thus, our
2998 ideas, yet the things in themselves, in natural theology, can be
2999 treated like the transcendental aesthetic.}
3000
3001 \@@_newpara:n {As is shown in the writings of Galileo, it remains a
3002 mystery why, so far as I know, the phenomena are the mere results of
3003 the power of the Ideal of pure reason, a blind but indispensable
3004 function of the soul, but the paralogisms (and there can be no doubt
3005 that this is the case) exclude the possibility of the transcendental
3006 aesthetic. Our experience, in accordance with the principles of
3007 transcendental logic, occupies part of the sphere of the manifold
3008 concerning the existence of the Categories in general. Our sense
3009 perceptions can not take account of the Ideal, by virtue of natural
3010 reason. Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, the
3011 objects in space and time (and to avoid all misapprehension, it is
3012 necessary to explain that this is the case) would thereby be made to
3013 contradict the pure employment of space; in the case of the discipline
3014 of human reason, the Antinomies exclude the possibility of the
3015 transcendental aesthetic. Has it ever been suggested that, as we have
3016 already seen, it remains a mystery why there is a causal connection
3017 bewteen the Ideal of human reason and the Ideal of human reason? What
3018 we have alone been able to show is that the Antinomies, for these
3019 reasons, stand in need to our judgements. Let us suppose that, in
3020 accordance with the principles of the Ideal of practical reason, the
3021 Antinomies prove the validity of space, but natural causes (and I
3022 assert, for these reasons, that this is the case) would thereby be
3023 made to contradict the transcendental unity of apperception. But the
3024 proof of this is a task from which we can here be absolved. }
3025
3026 \@@_newpara:n {As is shown in the writings of Hume, the noumena
3027 should only be used as a canon for the Categories. As is proven in
3028 the ontological manuals, our sense perceptions, consequently, are by
3029 their very nature contradictory; therefore, our experience (and it
3030 must not be supposed that this is true) may not contradict itself, but
3031 it is still possible that it may be in contradictions with the
3032 architectonic of practical reason. We can deduce that the Categories
3033 would thereby be made to contradict pure logic; for these reasons,
3034 space is by its very nature contradictory. Formal logic is a
3035 representation of our faculties. Metaphysics, insomuch as time relies
3036 on the Antinomies, stands in need of space. Let us suppose that the
3037 Antinomies constitute the whole content of our a priori concepts; on
3038 the other hand, the Ideal of natural reason (and there can be no doubt
3039 that this is true) is a representation of the manifold.}
3040
3041 \@@_newpara:n {I assert, certainly, that, irrespective of all
3042 empirical conditions, the Categories are just as necessary as, on the
3043 other hand, the thing in itself, yet the manifold proves the validity
3044 of, on the other hand, the employment of the transcendental unity of
3045 apperception. As is proven in the ontological manuals, the
3046 never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions exists in
3047 the architectonic of practical reason. As is evident upon close
3048 examination, it remains a mystery why the things in themselves have
3049 lying before them, that is to say, the Ideal; however, the
3050 architectonic of natural reason exists in the Ideal of pure reason.
3051 Because of our necessary ignorance of the conditions, the noumena
3052 exclude the possibility of, however, general logic; consequently, the
3053 paralogisms of natural reason, when thus treated as our ideas, can be
3054 treated like philosophy.}
3055
3056 \@@_newpara:n {As is evident upon close examination, our faculties
3057 stand in need to the transcendental objects in space and time;
3058 certainly, our ideas are a representation of the objects in space and
3059 time. The reader should be careful to observe that the Categories
3060 constitute the whole content of the paralogisms of human reason. By
3061 means of analytic unity, space would be falsified; with the sole
3062 exception of the manifold, necessity, even as this relates to our
3063 understanding, has nothing to do with natural causes. Time is just as
3064 necessary as, indeed, the phenomena. Thus, the noumena, consequently,
3065 exclude the possibility of the Transcendental Deduction, by means of
3066 analysis. Has it ever been suggested that, as we have already seen,
3067 Aristotle tells us that there is a causal connection bewteen the
3068 noumena and the things in themselves? The employment of the
3069 Antinomies is the key to understanding our ideas.}
3070
3071 \@@_newpara:n {What we have alone been able to show is that the
3072 employment of the transcendental aesthetic, still, exists in our sense
3073 perceptions; as I have elsewhere shown, the phenomena exist in the
3074 discipline of practical reason. Necessity (and Aristotle tells us
3075 that this is true) has lying before it the objects in space and time;
3076 in natural theology, our understanding, for example, proves the
3077 validity of the objects in space and time. It is not at all certain
3078 that our faculties, in the case of the thing in itself, are the clue
3079 to the discovery of the Categories, as we have already seen. To avoid
3080 all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, in reference to
3081 ends, the Ideal would be falsified, and the Antinomies are a
3082 representation of our a priori knowledge. (By means of analysis, to
3083 avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that, even as
3084 this relates to the Ideal of practical reason, the phenomena
3085 constitute the whole content of, in view of these considerations, our
3086 knowledge, and the discipline of natural reason (and we can deduce
3087 that this is true) is just as necessary as the manifold.) The reader
3088 should be careful to observe that, indeed, our judgements can not take
3089 account of our sense perceptions, but the thing in itself, so far as I
3090 know, can not take account of our sense perceptions. Let us suppose
3091 that our ideas are a representation of metaphysics.}
3092
3093 \@@_newpara:n {By virtue of human reason, the Ideal of pure reason,
3094 in the full sense of these terms, is by its very nature contradictory,
3095 yet necessity is the key to understanding metaphysics. The Categories
3096 have nothing to do with, therefore, the phenomena. We can deduce that
3097 our experience can be treated like our a priori knowledge; certainly,
3098 the objects in space and time are what first give rise to philosophy.
3099 Because of the relation between the architectonic of natural reason
3100 and the Antinomies, space has nothing to do with our ideas, but the
3101 manifold occupies part of the sphere of the transcendental aesthetic
3102 concerning the existence of the phenomena in general. The paralogisms
3103 of human reason are the clue to the discovery of, on the contrary, our
3104 understanding.}
3105
3106 \@@_newpara:n {There can be no doubt that, in reference to ends, the
3107 thing in itself excludes the possibility of the objects in space and
3108 time, but the discipline of human reason is by its very nature
3109 contradictory. It is obvious that, in other words, the manifold, in
3110 so far as this expounds the practical rules of the thing in itself, is
3111 the clue to the discovery of the things in themselves, yet our
3112 experience has lying before it space. Our ideas would be falsified,
3113 yet the thing in itself is just as necessary as the Antinomies.
3114 Metaphysics exists in our speculative judgements. By means of
3115 analysis, the phenomena are a representation of our faculties.}
3116
3117 \@@_newpara:n {The phenomena stand in need to our sense perceptions,
3118 but our concepts are the clue to the discovery of formal logic. The
3119 objects in space and time have nothing to do with the things in
3120 themselves, as is evident upon close examination. Time teaches us
3121 nothing whatsoever regarding the content of the noumena. It is not at
3122 all certain that, so far as regards the manifold and the objects in
3123 space and time, the Transcendental Deduction, therefore, occupies part
3124 of the sphere of pure logic concerning the existence of natural causes
3125 in general, but the things in themselves, consequently, are a
3126 representation of the intelligible objects in space and time. The
3127 Transcendental Deduction (and to avoid all misapprehension, it is
3128 necessary to explain that this is true) depends on necessity, as we
3129 have already seen. Consequently, it remains a mystery why our a
3130 priori concepts, on the other hand, are what first give rise to the
3131 Ideal of human reason, as any dedicated reader can clearly see.}
3132
3133 \@@_newpara:n {What we have alone been able to show is that, then,
3134 the Ideal of human reason, in reference to ends, is the mere result of
3135 the power of practical reason, a blind but indispensable function of
3136 the soul, but the Ideal (and the reader should be careful to observe
3137 that this is true) has lying before it our ideas. In the study of the
3138 thing in itself, I assert, with the sole exception of the manifold,
3139 that the Ideal of human reason is the clue to the discovery of the
3140 practical employment of the Ideal of natural reason. As will easily
3141 be shown in the next section, our ideas have lying before them the
3142 Ideal of natural reason; thus, the Antinomies are what first give rise
3143 to, indeed, the noumena. We can deduce that the Categories (and it is
3144 obvious that this is the case) would thereby be made to contradict our
3145 faculties. As we have already seen, it is not at all certain that
3146 natural causes occupy part of the sphere of the architectonic of
3147 natural reason concerning the existence of natural causes in general;
3148 for these reasons, our ideas, in natural theology, occupy part of the
3149 sphere of the never-ending regress in the series of empirical
3150 conditions concerning the existence of our judgements in general. Yet
3151 can I entertain the transcendental aesthetic in thought, or does it
3152 present itself to me? In the study of the Ideal, the Ideal of pure
3153 reason depends on time. However, our a priori judgements have lying
3154 before them the employment of necessity, by means of analytic unity.
3155 }
3156
3157 \@@_newpara:n {As will easily be shown in the next section, it is not
3158 at all certain that the transcendental unity of apperception is the
3159 key to understanding the things in themselves; certainly, the
3160 Categories prove the validity of our faculties. Let us suppose that
3161 the paralogisms of natural reason (and we can deduce that this is the
3162 case) are a representation of the discipline of human reason. It
3163 remains a mystery why practical reason can be treated like the
3164 phenomena. (As is shown in the writings of Aristotle, there can be no
3165 doubt that the Categories, in the study of the discipline of human
3166 reason, exclude the possibility of the Categories.) As will easily be
3167 shown in the next section, our ideas stand in need to our knowledge.
3168 As any dedicated reader can clearly see, the Antinomies exist in our a
3169 posteriori concepts, yet the thing in itself can not take account of,
3170 as I have elsewhere shown, the Categories. The question of this
3171 matter's relation to objects is not in any way under discussion.}
3172
3173 \@@_newpara:n {It must not be supposed that, so regarded, our
3174 experience, in particular, can thereby determine in its totality our
3175 analytic judgements, yet necessity has nothing to do with, in
3176 reference to ends, the discipline of human reason. It is not at all
3177 certain that the never-ending regress in the series of empirical
3178 conditions would thereby be made to contradict, in particular, pure
3179 logic; with the sole exception of the Ideal, our ideas, that is to
3180 say, should only be used as a canon for our judgements. Since some of
3181 the Antinomies are disjunctive, the Transcendental Deduction can be
3182 treated like the never-ending regress in the series of empirical
3183 conditions. In the case of the Transcendental Deduction, it is not at
3184 all certain that the Ideal of natural reason, in view of these
3185 considerations, can be treated like the architectonic of human reason.
3186 The Antinomies (and Aristotle tells us that this is the case) exclude
3187 the possibility of the Ideal of human reason; in the case of the
3188 discipline of natural reason, necessity would thereby be made to
3189 contradict, so far as I know, the Ideal of pure reason.
3190 Transcendental logic is a representation of the Transcendental
3191 Deduction; by means of the transcendental aesthetic, the thing in
3192 itself can thereby determine in its totality the Ideal of pure reason.
3193 In my present remarks I am referring to the never-ending regress in
3194 the series of empirical conditions only in so far as it is founded on
3195 hypothetical principles.}
3196
3197 \@@_newpara:n {The things in themselves prove the validity of, on the
3198 other hand, transcendental logic; therefore, necessity has lying
3199 before it, indeed, the paralogisms. What we have alone been able to
3200 show is that our ideas constitute a body of demonstrated doctrine, and
3201 all of this body must be known a priori. Our understanding has lying
3202 before it, for these reasons, our ampliative judgements. Because of
3203 our necessary ignorance of the conditions, it is obvious that time may
3204 not contradict itself, but it is still possible that it may be in
3205 contradictions with, in view of these considerations, our ideas;
3206 still, the practical employment of the transcendental objects in space
3207 and time, that is to say, has lying before it the things in
3208 themselves. Natural causes prove the validity of necessity.}
3209
3210 \@@_newpara:n {The reader should be careful to observe that our a
3211 priori concepts, in other words, can never, as a whole, furnish a true
3212 and demonstrated science, because, like general logic, they prove the
3213 validity of hypothetical principles, by virtue of human reason. There
3214 can be no doubt that, indeed, the Antinomies, in other words, would be
3215 falsified, and the phenomena constitute the whole content of the
3216 discipline of natural reason. The phenomena can not take account of,
3217 in natural theology, the Ideal of practical reason. Time can never
3218 furnish a true and demonstrated science, because, like necessity, it
3219 has nothing to do with a posteriori principles; in view of these
3220 considerations, our a priori concepts stand in need to the discipline
3221 of pure reason. Our ideas constitute the whole content of the objects
3222 in space and time, but the Ideal, indeed, is the key to understanding
3223 our understanding.}
3224
3225 \@@_newpara:n {As we have already seen, it is not at all certain that
3226 the Ideal of pure reason is just as necessary as natural causes; in
3227 the case of the Transcendental Deduction, our faculties, in natural
3228 theology, abstract from all content of knowledge. The Categories can
3229 never, as a whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science, because,
3230 like the manifold, they have lying before them a posteriori
3231 principles, but time is by its very nature contradictory. We can
3232 deduce that the Categories, so regarded, are by their very nature
3233 contradictory; for these reasons, time is what first gives rise to our
3234 ideas. Still, is it the case that pure logic constitutes the whole
3235 content for the Transcendental Deduction, or is the real question
3236 whether the paralogisms exist in our experience? Still, natural
3237 reason, so far as I know, would be falsified, because of our necessary
3238 ignorance of the conditions. Our faculties would be falsified.}
3239
3240 \@@_newpara:n {The Ideal proves the validity of the objects in space
3241 and time. To avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain
3242 that our judgements are a representation of, however, the manifold.
3243 The objects in space and time exclude the possibility of necessity.
3244 The reader should be careful to observe that the Ideal, consequently,
3245 abstracts from all content of knowledge. There can be no doubt that,
3246 indeed, the objects in space and time would thereby be made to
3247 contradict human reason.}
3248
3249 \@@_newpara:n {It is obvious that the transcendental unity of
3250 apperception can be treated like the Ideal. I assert that applied
3251 logic (and it is not at all certain that this is true) stands in need
3252 of the objects in space and time; certainly, the Ideal of practical
3253 reason is what first gives rise to the Categories. On the other hand,
3254 our experience (and it remains a mystery why this is true) stands in
3255 need of the transcendental unity of apperception. It remains a
3256 mystery why the Antinomies prove the validity of metaphysics. There
3257 can be no doubt that, in particular, the architectonic of pure reason,
3258 in all theoretical sciences, can never furnish a true and demonstrated
3259 science, because, like the manifold, it teaches us nothing whatsoever
3260 regarding the content of hypothetical principles, but the phenomena,
3261 with the sole exception of the transcendental aesthetic, have nothing
3262 to do with philosophy. It is obvious that our understanding, that is
3263 to say, is the mere result of the power of space, a blind but
3264 indispensable function of the soul, by means of analytic unity. Since
3265 knowledge of our sense perceptions is a priori, we can deduce that our
3266 experience is what first gives rise to the architectonic of practical
3267 reason. This may be clear with an example. }
3268
3269 \@@_newpara:n {I assert, consequently, that the Transcendental
3270 Deduction would thereby be made to contradict our faculties, as will
3271 easily be shown in the next section. Let us suppose that our ideas,
3272 in the full sense of these terms, occupy part of the sphere of formal
3273 logic concerning the existence of the noumena in general. To avoid
3274 all misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the
3275 Transcendental Deduction, so far as I know, occupies part of the
3276 sphere of the architectonic of practical reason concerning the
3277 existence of the Antinomies in general; certainly, the paralogisms
3278 occupy part of the sphere of the architectonic of natural reason
3279 concerning the existence of our ideas in general. To avoid all
3280 misapprehension, it is necessary to explain that the pure employment
3281 of the architectonic of practical reason, still, is by its very nature
3282 contradictory; consequently, the intelligible objects in space and
3283 time would thereby be made to contradict the transcendental objects in
3284 space and time. We can deduce that the thing in itself exists in the
3285 Antinomies. As is evident upon close examination, the never-ending
3286 regress in the series of empirical conditions depends on, therefore,
3287 necessity. I assert that our judgements are a representation of the
3288 noumena; on the other hand, the transcendental unity of apperception
3289 teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of, then, the
3290 Ideal of pure reason.}
3291
3292 \@@_newpara:n {As is evident upon close examination, the things in
3293 themselves are the clue to the discovery of the phenomena, and
3294 philosophy (and what we have alone been able to show is that this is
3295 true) teaches us nothing whatsoever regarding the content of the
3296 phenomena. Still, to avoid all misapprehension, it is necessary to
3297 explain that natural causes (and it is obvious that this is the case)
3298 have nothing to do with our faculties. To avoid all misapprehension,
3299 it is necessary to explain that, irrespective of all empirical
3300 conditions, the employment of the objects in space and time can not
3301 take account of, that is to say, our concepts, but the never-ending
3302 regress in the series of empirical conditions constitutes the whole
3303 content for our sense perceptions. In the case of the discipline of
3304 pure reason, let us suppose that general logic stands in need of the
3305 Ideal of human reason, as we have already seen. The noumena prove the
3306 validity of, in the study of transcendental logic, our understanding.}
3307
3308 \@@_newpara:n {Space (and what we have alone been able to show is
3309 that this is true) stands in need of necessity, yet our understanding,
3310 so far as regards the Ideal of practical reason, can never furnish a
3311 true and demonstrated science, because, like the transcendental unity
3312 of apperception, it has lying before it a priori principles. Since
3313 some of our judgements are disjunctive, it remains a mystery why the
3314 phenomena stand in need to the objects in space and time. In view of
3315 these considerations, the Categories (and let us suppose that this is
3316 the case) are just as necessary as the pure employment of the
3317 phenomena. Let us suppose that the things in themselves, so far as I
3318 know, abstract from all content of a posteriori knowledge. It is
3319 obvious that, even as this relates to the thing in itself, natural
3320 causes can never, as a whole, furnish a true and demonstrated science,
3321 because, like metaphysics, they are just as necessary as inductive
3322 principles. The architectonic of practical reason (and it is not at
3323 all certain that this is true) depends on the thing in itself, but the
3324 objects in space and time, as I have elsewhere shown, are the mere
3325 results of the power of the employment of the Antinomies, a blind but
3326 indispensable function of the soul. By means of analysis, there can
3327 be no doubt that, in reference to ends, natural causes are a
3328 representation of, in respect of the intelligible character, time, and
3329 the pure employment of the discipline of natural reason has lying
3330 before it our experience.}
3331
3332 \@@_newpara:n {Still, it must not be supposed that our faculties are
3333 a representation of the Ideal of practical reason, as is evident upon
3334 close examination. As is proven in the ontological manuals, the
3335 reader should be careful to observe that the objects in space and time
3336 are the mere results of the power of time, a blind but indispensable
3337 function of the soul; in all theoretical sciences, the Ideal is a
3338 representation of, so far as regards the architectonic of natural
3339 reason, our sense perceptions. Aristotle tells us that, in
3340 particular, the objects in space and time, in the case of the
3341 manifold, are a representation of the things in themselves, yet
3342 natural causes stand in need to, irrespective of all empirical
3343 conditions, the things in themselves. Certainly, the transcendental
3344 unity of apperception, in accordance with the principles of the
3345 intelligible objects in space and time, exists in our sense
3346 perceptions. As we have already seen, the discipline of human reason
3347 (and Galileo tells us that this is true) depends on the thing in
3348 itself. Since some of natural causes are synthetic, the reader should
3349 be careful to observe that, for example, the things in themselves (and
3350 it is not at all certain that this is the case) are the clue to the
3351 discovery of our concepts. But this need not worry us.}
3352
3353 \@@_newpara:n {The architectonic of natural reason is the key to
3354 understanding, so far as regards our a posteriori knowledge and the
3355 paralogisms, time; still, the Categories, with the sole exception of
3356 the never-ending regress in the series of empirical conditions, should
3357 only be used as a canon for the transcendental unity of apperception.
3358 However, the reader should be careful to observe that the noumena
3359 exist in time. Because of the relation between space and the
3360 phenomena, let us suppose that our ideas are the clue to the discovery
3361 of our faculties. The phenomena constitute the whole content of the
3362 phenomena, but the transcendental unity of apperception, on the other
3363 hand, would be falsified. (As is evident upon close examination, it
3364 must not be supposed that our a posteriori knowledge is by its very
3365 nature contradictory.) There can be no doubt that the practical
3366 employment of our problematic judgements can be treated like the
3367 transcendental aesthetic. Aristotle tells us that our faculties have
3368 nothing to do with the objects in space and time. We thus have a pure
3369 synthesis of apprehension.}
3370
3371 \@@_newpara:n {Since none of the noumena are hypothetical, there can
3372 be no doubt that, in particular, our knowledge, in other words, is the
3373 clue to the discovery of the things in themselves. Therefore, the
3374 Ideal is just as necessary as, then, the Ideal, as will easily be
3375 shown in the next section. We can deduce that, then, our knowledge,
3376 in respect of the intelligible character, is by its very nature
3377 contradictory, and the noumena, in particular, are by their very
3378 nature contradictory. The reader should be careful to observe that,
3379 indeed, pure logic, still, is a body of demonstrated science, and none
3380 of it must be known a posteriori, yet our speculative judgements exist
3381 in the manifold. In the case of time, the Categories, by means of
3382 transcendental logic, constitute the whole content of the things in
3383 themselves, as any dedicated reader can clearly see.}
3384
3385 \@@_newpara:n {Transcendental logic can thereby determine in its
3386 totality, consequently, our faculties, because of our necessary
3387 ignorance of the conditions. Since some of the paralogisms are
3388 analytic, there can be no doubt that, in reference to ends, the
3389 Antinomies, for these reasons, constitute the whole content of
3390 necessity, yet the things in themselves constitute the whole content
3391 of our understanding. In view of these considerations, it is obvious
3392 that the paralogisms are by their very nature contradictory, as any
3393 dedicated reader can clearly see. In natural theology, our ideas (and
3394 it remains a mystery why this is the case) have nothing to do with the
3395 discipline of pure reason, as any dedicated reader can clearly see.
3396 What we have alone been able to show is that philosophy occupies part
3397 of the sphere of the Transcendental Deduction concerning the existence
3398 of natural causes in general. Since knowledge of the phenomena is a
3399 posteriori, our ideas, in all theoretical sciences, can be treated
3400 like time, but our judgements are just as necessary as the Categories.
3401 Our understanding is a representation of the objects in space and
3402 time, and the paralogisms are just as necessary as our experience.}
3403
3404 \@@_newpara:n {Philosophy (and it must not be supposed that this is
3405 true) is a representation of the never-ending regress in the series of
3406 empirical conditions; however, the Antinomies have nothing to do with,
3407 in the study of philosophy, the discipline of practical reason.
3408 Because of the relation between philosophy and our ideas, it remains a
3409 mystery why, so regarded, metaphysics depends on the employment of
3410 natural causes. The pure employment of the Antinomies, in particular,
3411 is a body of demonstrated science, and all of it must be known a
3412 priori, but necessity is a representation of the Ideal. As will
3413 easily be shown in the next section, it remains a mystery why the
3414 Antinomies are what first give rise to the transcendental aesthetic;
3415 in all theoretical sciences, the architectonic of pure reason has
3416 nothing to do with, therefore, the noumena. The noumena are the clue
3417 to the discovery of the Categories, yet the transcendental aesthetic,
3418 for example, stands in need of natural causes. The Categories can not
3419 take account of, so far as regards the architectonic of natural
3420 reason, the paralogisms; in the study of general logic, the
3421 transcendental unity of apperception, insomuch as the architectonic of
3422 human reason relies on the Antinomies, can thereby determine in its
3423 totality natural causes.}
3424
3425 \@@_newpara:n {As is shown in the writings of Hume, it remains a
3426 mystery why our judgements exclude the possibility of the
3427 transcendental aesthetic; therefore, the transcendental aesthetic can
3428 not take account of the thing in itself. Our knowledge depends on,
3429 indeed, our knowledge. It is not at all certain that space is just as
3430 necessary as the noumena. Is it true that metaphysics can not take
3431 account of the paralogisms of human reason, or is the real question
3432 whether the noumena are by their very nature contradictory? On the
3433 other hand, time constitutes the whole content for necessity, by means
3434 of analytic unity. There can be no doubt that the phenomena have
3435 lying before them metaphysics. As is proven in the ontological
3436 manuals, it remains a mystery why space exists in the objects in space
3437 and time; still, the noumena, in the case of necessity, constitute the
3438 whole content of philosophy.}
3439
3440 % \end{macrocode}
3441 %
3442 % Now we define the sequence of index words.
3443 % \begin{macrocode}
3444 \@@_newword:n {Ideal}
3445 \@@_newword:n {noumena}
3446 \@@_newword:n {Aristotle}
3447 \@@_newword:n {transcendental}
3448 \@@_newword:n {metaphysics}
3449 \@@_newword:n {reason}
3450 \@@_newword:n {science}
3451 \@@_newword:n {necessity}
3452 \@@_newword:n {Categories}
3453 \@@_newword:n {philosophy}
3454 \@@_newword:n {knowledge}
3455 \@@_newword:n {regress}
3456 \@@_newword:n {paralogism}
3457 \@@_newword:n {empirical}
3458 \@@_newword:n {space}
3459 \@@_newword:n {manifold}
3460 \@@_newword:n {understanding}
3461 \@@_newword:n {aesthetic}
3462 \@@_newword:n {noumena}
3463 \@@_newword:n {sphere}
3464 \@@_newword:n {time}
3465 \@@_newword:n {practical reason}
3466 \@@_newword:n {perception}
3467 \@@_newword:n {things in themselves}
3468 \@@_newword:n {doctrine}
3469 \@@_newword:n {regress}
3470 \@@_newword:n {mystery}
3471 \@@_newword:n {existence}
3472 \@@_newword:n {contradiction}
3473 \@@_newword:n {a priori}
3474 \@@_newword:n {natural causes}
3475 \@@_newword:n {analysis}
3476 \@@_newword:n {apperception}
3477 \@@_newword:n {Antinomies}
3478 \@@_newword:n {Transcendental Deduction}
3479 \@@_newword:n {phenomena}
3480 \@@_newword:n {formal logic}
3481 \@@_newword:n {soul}
3482 \@@_newword:n {misapprehension}
3483 \@@_newword:n {elsewhere}
3484 \@@_newword:n {theology}
3485 \@@_newword:n {employment}
3486 \@@_newword:n {logic}
3487 \@@_newword:n {practical reason}
3488 \@@_newword:n {theoretical sciences}
3489 \@@_newword:n {a posteriori}
3490 \@@_newword:n {mystery}
3491 \@@_newword:n {philosophy}
3492 \@@_newword:n {things in themselves}
3493 \@@_newword:n {experience}
3494 \@@_newword:n {contradictory}
3495 \@@_newword:n {Categories}
3496 \@@_newword:n {perceptions}
3497 \@@_newword:n {Galileo}
3498 \@@_newword:n {apperception}
3499 \@@_newword:n {empirical objects}
3500 \@@_newword:n {judgements}
3501 \@@_newword:n {phenomena}
3502 \@@_newword:n {power}
3503 \@@_newword:n {hypothetical principles}
3504 \@@_newword:n {transcendental logic}
3505 \@@_newword:n {doctrine}
3506 \@@_newword:n {understanding}
3507 \@@_newword:n {totality}
3508 \@@_newword:n {manifold}
3509 \@@_newword:n {inductive judgements}
3510 \@@_newword:n {Transcendental Deduction}
3511 \@@_newword:n {analytic unity}
3512 \@@_newword:n {Hume}
3513 \@@_newword:n {canon}
3514 \@@_newword:n {knowledge}
3515 \@@_newword:n {universal}
3516 \@@_newword:n {section}
3517 \@@_newword:n {body}
3518 \@@_newword:n {ignorance}
3519 \@@_newword:n {sense perceptions}
3520 \@@_newword:n {natural reason}
3521 \@@_newword:n {exception}
3522 \@@_newword:n {ampliative judgements}
3523 \@@_newword:n {experience}
3524 \@@_newword:n {Categories}
3525 \@@_newword:n {analysis}
3526 \@@_newword:n {philosophy}
3527 \@@_newword:n {apperception}
3528 \@@_newword:n {paralogism}
3529 \@@_newword:n {ignorance}
3530 \@@_newword:n {true}
3531 \@@_newword:n {space}
3532 \@@_newword:n {Ideal}
3533 \@@_newword:n {accordance}
3534 \@@_newword:n {regress}
3535 \@@_newword:n {experience}
3536 \@@_newword:n {a priori}
3537 \@@_newword:n {disjunctive}
3538 \@@_newword:n {soul}
3539 \@@_newword:n {understanding}
3540 \@@_newword:n {analytic unity}
3541 \@@_newword:n {phenomena}
3542 \@@_newword:n {practical reason}
3543 \@@_newword:n {cause}
3544 \@@_newword:n {manuals}
3545 \@@_newword:n {dedicated reader}
3546 \@@_newword:n {a posteriori}
3547 \@@_newword:n {employment}
3548 \@@_newword:n {natural theology}
3549 \@@_newword:n {manifold}
3550 \@@_newword:n {transcendental aesthetic}
3551 \@@_newword:n {close}
3552 \@@_newword:n {full}
3553 \@@_newword:n {Aristotle}
3554 \@@_newword:n {clue}
3555 \@@_newword:n {me}
3556 \@@_newword:n {account}
3557 \@@_newword:n {things}
3558 \@@_newword:n {sense}
3559 \@@_newword:n {intelligible}
3560 \@@_newword:n {understanding}
3561 \@@_newword:n {Categories}
3562 \@@_newword:n {never}
3563 \@@_newword:n {apperception}
3564 \@@_newword:n {Ideal}
3565 \@@_newword:n {need}
3566 \@@_newword:n {space}
3567 \@@_newword:n {virtue}
3568 \@@_newword:n {Hume}
3569 \@@_newword:n {still}
3570 \@@_newword:n {whatsoever}
3571 \@@_newword:n {even}
3572 \@@_newword:n {sphere}
3573 \@@_newword:n {position}
3574 \@@_newword:n {ignorance}
3575 \@@_newword:n {word}
3576 \@@_newword:n {phenomena}
3577 \@@_newword:n {theology}
3578 \@@_newword:n {mystery}
3579 \@@_newword:n {Categories}
3580 \@@_newword:n {perception}
3581 \@@_newword:n {power}
3582 \@@_newword:n {experience}
3583 \@@_newword:n {never-ending}
3584 \@@_newword:n {analytic}
3585 \@@_newword:n {itself}
3586 \@@_newword:n {a priori}
3587 \@@_newword:n {rule}
3588 \@@_newword:n {Transcendental Deduction}
3589 \@@_newword:n {empirical conditions}
3590 \@@_newword:n {knowledge}
3591 \@@_newword:n {disjunctive}
3592 \@@_newword:n {transcendental}
3593 \@@_newword:n {science}
3594 \@@_newword:n {falsified}
3595 \@@_newword:n {reader}
3596 \@@_newword:n {blind}
3597 \@@_newword:n {employment}
3598 \@@_newword:n {discipline}
3599 \@@_newword:n {function}
3600 \@@_newword:n {careful}
3601 \@@_newword:n {Aristotle}
3602 \@@_newword:n {Categories}
3603 \@@_newword:n {part}
3604 \@@_newword:n {noumena}
3605 \@@_newword:n {doubt}
3606 \@@_newword:n {duck}
3607 \@@_newword:n {Kant}
3608 % \end{macrocode}
3609 %
3610 % Finally we close the group and issue a message in the log file
3611 % stating how many sentences are available.
3612 % \begin{macrocode}
3613 \group_end:
3614 \msg_info:nne {kantlipsum} {how-many}
3615 { \int_eval:n {\seq_count:N \g_@@_pars_seq} }
3616 % \end{macrocode}
3617 %
3618 % \iffalse
3619 %</package>
3620 % \fi
3621 % \end{implementation}
3622 %
3623 % \PrintIndex