| 1 |
Intellectual Property Due Diligence |
| 2 |
----------------------------------- |
| 3 |
|
| 4 |
Modems and voice coding are heavily patented areas. Implementing these without |
| 5 |
serious consideration of IP issues would be foolish. This document describes |
| 6 |
the basis on which the software has been implemented. |
| 7 |
|
| 8 |
|
| 9 |
A check of the intellectual property information at the ITU web site shows a |
| 10 |
number of patent claims against the current standards implemented by spandsp. |
| 11 |
It is important to realise, however, that some of these patents have long |
| 12 |
since expired (group III fax dates back to the 1970s). Also, many are |
| 13 |
related to recent additions to the FAX standard, such as colour FAX handling, |
| 14 |
which few people ever use. |
| 15 |
|
| 16 |
The V.14 rate adaption standard seems free of patent encumberance. |
| 17 |
|
| 18 |
One patent is listed as relevant to the V.17 standard. It is a patent from |
| 19 |
IBM, but the ITU database does not specify its nature. I believe it is |
| 20 |
related to the trellis coding used, and I think it has expired. I do not |
| 21 |
know for sure. The techniques used in the implementation should be free of |
| 22 |
patent encumberance. Most of the implementation is similar to the V.29 |
| 23 |
modem. The key addition the trellis code processing. The trellis encoding |
| 24 |
is trivial. The decoding uses Viterbi techniques, which are quite old. |
| 25 |
|
| 26 |
The V.21 standard dates from the 1950s. The V.23 standard is also very old. |
| 27 |
There is no possibility that any patents related to it are still in force. |
| 28 |
However, the implementation also needs to be free of patented techniques. |
| 29 |
The implementation only uses very mature numerical oscillator and quadrature |
| 30 |
correlation techniques, so there should be no patent issues. |
| 31 |
|
| 32 |
Only one patent is listed as relevant to the V.29 standard. This dates from |
| 33 |
the 1970s, and must have expired. The modem has been implemented using only |
| 34 |
very mature techniques, none of which can be less than 20 years old. There |
| 35 |
seem no possibility, therefore, that any patents are still in force related |
| 36 |
to the techniques used. |
| 37 |
|
| 38 |
Some aspect of the V.8 standard seems to have patents associated with it, |
| 39 |
according to the ITU patent database. I am unclear what these are. V.8 is a |
| 40 |
very simple standard. There seems to be nothing innovative about it. |
| 41 |
|
| 42 |
Many patents are listed as relevant to the T.30 standard. However, they all |
| 43 |
appear to relate to newer features, such as colour FAX, added in recent years. |
| 44 |
The current implementation only covers the original features from the late |
| 45 |
1970s, where there appear to be patent issues. |
| 46 |
|
| 47 |
The T.4 standard defines the image compression and decompression techniques |
| 48 |
used for group 3 FAXes. The spandsp implementation is based on code derived |
| 49 |
from freely available implementations of T.4. These have existed for a number |
| 50 |
of years without IP issues. The standard is old enough for any patents to have |
| 51 |
expired, anyway. |
| 52 |
|
| 53 |
V.42bis compression uses the LZW algorithm. This is the same algorithm used in |
| 54 |
GIF files. Unisys patented this algorithm. However, the Unisys patent has now |
| 55 |
expired. |