Debian Codegraph @

doc/nxcomp/README.on-retroactive-DXPC-license

raw
1 On DXPC retroactive relicensing as BSD-2-clause
2 ===============================================
3
4 TL;DR; In May 2015, all versions of DXPC released before version 3.8.1 (sometime
5 in 2002) have retroactively been re-licensed by all previous maintainers
6 of DXPC as BSD-2-clause.
7
8 This README file gives an overview of the discussion thread that lead to
9 the retroactive re-licensing of DXPC.
10
11 For the full discussion, see doc/DXPC_re-licensed_debug_784565.mbox in
12 this source project or #784565 on the Debian bug tracker [1].
13
14 light+love,
15 20150521, Mike Gabriel <[email protected]>
16
17 [1] https://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=784565
18
19 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
20
21 STEP 1
22 ======
23
24 In May 2015, a serious license issue around the nxcomp code shipped in
25 this source project was raised and solved on the Debian bug tracker (thanks to
26 Francesco Poli and many others): http://bugs.debian.org/784565
27
28 """
29 From: "Francesco Poli \(wintermute\)" <[email protected]>
30 To: Debian Bug Tracking System <[email protected]>
31 Date: Wed, 06 May 2015 19:35:32 +0200
32
33 I noticed that the debian/copyright states:
34
35 [...]
36 | Parts of this software are derived from DXPC project. These copyright
37 | notices apply to original DXPC code:
38 |
39 | Redistribution and use in source and binary forms are permitted provided
40 | that the above copyright notice and this paragraph are duplicated in all
41 | such forms.
42 |
43 | THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED ``AS IS'' AND WITHOUT ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED
44 | WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF
45 | MERCHANTIBILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.
46 |
47 | Copyright (c) 1995,1996 Brian Pane
48 | Copyright (c) 1996,1997 Zachary Vonler and Brian Pane
49 | Copyright (c) 1999 Kevin Vigor and Brian Pane
50 | Copyright (c) 2000,2001 Gian Filippo Pinzari and Brian Pane
51 [...]
52
53 This license lacks the permission to modify the DXPC code.
54 Hence, the original DXPC code does not appear to comply with the
55 DFSG. And the nx-libs-lite is in part derived from DXPC code.
56
57 This basically means that nx-libs-lite includes parts which are
58 non-free (as they are derived from non-modifiable code) and
59 are also possibly legally undistributable (as they are non-modifiable,
60 but actually modified). The combination with the rest of nx-libs-lite
61 (which is GPL-licensed) may also be legally undistributable (since
62 the license with no permission to modify is GPL-incompatible).
63
64
65 If there's anything I misunderstood, please clarify.
66
67 Otherwise, please address this issue as soon as possible.
68 The copyright owners for the original DXPC code should be
69 contacted and persuaded to re-license under GPL-compatible
70 terms.
71 """
72
73 The issue has been settled by asking all recent maintainers (i.e.,
74 copyright holders) of DXPC, to agree on considering the BSD-2-clause
75 license (as introduced in DXPC 3.8.1) retro-actively as the license of
76 all pre-3.8.1 DXPC releases.
77
78 STEP 2:
79 =======
80
81 Kevin Vigor, the (at that time being) latest known maintainer of DXPC
82 replied back immediately and provided the info given below. He also
83 stated that he agrees to applying BSD-2-clause retroactively to all
84 pre-3.8.1 releases of DXPC.
85
86 """
87 From: Kevin Vigor <[email protected]>
88 To: Mike Gabriel <[email protected]>
89 CC: [email protected], [...]
90 Subject: Re: Bug#784565: nx-libs-lite: parts are derived from non-free code
91
92 Hi Mike, et al,
93
94 I am not the original author of dxpc, that being Brian Pane. However,
95 I took over maintenance circa 1999 and am still the primary maintainer
96 (though the project has effectively been dead for most of a decade
97 now).
98
99 As you are aware, when I inherited the code, it was licensed under a
100 variant of the BSD license that did not include the 'with
101 modification' clause. To the best of my recollection, somebody from
102 the FSF contacted me circa 2001 regarding this and as a result,
103 subsequent releases were done under a standard 2-clause BSD license
104 with the modification clause. Again, to the best of my recollection, I
105 contacted Brian about this change and he offered no objection.
106
107 Further, I recall distinctly that NoMachine contacted me and
108 explicitly asked permission before including DXPC code in NX, which I
109 happily granted with no new conditions beyond the BSD license already
110 in play.
111
112 It is possible, though by no means certain, that I could dig up
113 ancient email to corroborate this account if necessary. However, I am
114 more than willing to publicly state that I believe NoMachine's use of
115 DXPC code to be both legal and ethical, and that my intent when
116 changing the license to 2-clause BSD was simply to clarity the
117 existing intent and that it ought therefore be considered retroactive.
118
119 Yours,
120 Kevin Vigor
121
122 [...]
123 """
124
125 STEP 3:
126 -------
127
128 We were not able to dig out any recent mail address of Zachary Volner,
129 another of the DXPC copyright holders, but a phone number.
130
131 On Friday, May 15th, I (Mike Gabriel) called that phone number and left a
132 message on - hopefully - Zach's voicebox, asking him to mail me, so I
133 could explain everything. He mailed back and later on posted the below
134 statement to the Debian BTS, also expressing his agreement to the
135 retroactive re-licensing of DXPC.
136
137 """
138 Date: Mon, 18 May 2015 10:05:38 -0500
139 Subject: Re: Bug#784565: nx-libs-lite: parts are derived from non-free code
140 From: Zach Vonler <[email protected]>
141 To: [email protected]
142
143 On Thu, 14 May 2015 05:55:42 +0000 Mike Gabriel <
144 [email protected]> wrote:
145
146 >
147 > TL;DR; So here comes my actual question: are you (Brian Pane, Zachary
148 > Vonler, Gian Filippo Pinzari) ok with retroactively regarding
149 > pre-3.8.1 code of DXPC (that you probably all worked on at that time)
150 > as BSD-2-clause? Are you ok with others having taken or taking the
151 > pre-3.8.1 DXPC code and distribute it in a modified form?
152 >
153
154
155 > A yes from all of you as DXPC copyright holders is essential for the
156 > continuation of nx-libs development under a free license. This may
157 > also possibly be an issue for NXv4 in case parts of it have been
158 > derived from DXPC.
159
160
161 Yes, I am fine with considering the license change to be retroactive to
162 cover the time I was the maintainer.
163
164 I have no objections to others distributing modified versions of that code.
165
166 Zach
167 """
168
169 STEP 4:
170 -------
171
172 By 18th May 2015, Brian Pane had not mailed back to us. Hoping he is well
173 and alive. Giving my personal gratitude to him for his work on DXPC back
174 in the nighties.
175
176 However, Kevin found an old archive of the DXPC mailing lists, esp. a
177 post by Brian expressing openness to modifications of all DXPC code
178 versions.
179
180 We refer to this regarding his consent on the re-licensing.
181
182 """
183 Date: Mon, 18 May 2015 15:11:42 -0600
184 From: Kevin Vigor <[email protected]>
185 To: Mike Gabriel <[email protected]>, [email protected], Francesco Poli <[email protected]>
186 CC: [...]
187 Subject: Re: Bug#784565: nx-libs-lite: parts are derived from non-free code
188
189 By the way, poking around the interwebs I find there is an archive of the old DXPC mailing list available at:
190
191 http://marc.info/?l=dxpc&r=1&w=2
192
193 I think you will find this of particular interest:
194
195
196 http://marc.info/?l=dxpc&m=93093790813555&w=2
197
198
199 List: dxpc
200 Subject: Re: future tecnologies
201 From: Brian Pane <brianp () cnet ! com>
202 Date: 1999-07-02 16:42:18
203 [Download message RAW]
204
205 Kevin Vigor <[email protected]> wrote:
206 > On 01-Jul-99 [email protected] wrote:
207 > > Speaking of licensing, are you putting your 3.8.0 changes to the dxpc
208 > > code itself under GPL, or are they going to use the original dxpc's
209 > > licensing?
210 >
211 > No, as you can probably guess, I am no fan of the GPL. For stuff on
212 > this level, where my hacking is pretty simple and probably devoid of
213 > commercial value, I'll just release my changes to the public domain and
214 > give up even a copyright interest in them.
215 >
216 > Your and Zach's copyrights still stand, of course.
217 >
218 > I *think* that fact that we use the LZO library and API, but do not
219 > directly incorporate the code, allows us to escape the clutch of the GPL
220 > virus.
221 >
222 > btw, is there an original dxpc license? I haven't seen anything but a
223 > copyright notice, which to my non-lawyerly mind translates as "free to
224 > all the world as is, negotiate with copyright owner if modifying or
225 > including in some other product".
226
227 The copyright banner in the Readme is all the documentation there's ever
228 been. My intent was to allow _any_ distribution, use, and modification
229 of the source, without imposing restrictions on the licensing style of
230 any system into which others might incorporate the code. We probably
231 should start stating this clearly in the distributions.
232
233 -brian
234
235 [prev in list] [next in list] [prev in thread] [next in thread]
236 """
237
238 STEP 5:
239 -------
240
241 Last but not least, Kevin informed us that Gian Filippo Pinzari never
242 contributed any code to any of the official DPXC releases. So we assumed
243 that his copyrights on the code stem from the time where he - under the
244 NoMachine umbrella - worked on the code and should probably be associated
245 with the GPL-2 re-licensing of the code later on done by NoMachine
246 (which we did in the LICENSE file).
247
248 It also appears, that there has been an incongruity between the copyright
249 statement in nxcomp/Misc.cpp and nxcomp/LICENSE for Gian Filippo Pinzari.
250 We used the copyright years (2000,2003) from nxcomp/Misc.cpp instead of
251 those originally given in nxcomp/LICENSE (2000,2006).
252
253 """
254 Date: Mon, 18 May 2015 19:16:25 -0600
255 From: Kevin Vigor <[email protected]>
256 To: Francesco Poli <[email protected]>,
257 Mike Gabriel <[email protected]>
258 CC: [email protected], [...]
259 Subject: Re: [pkg-x2go-devel] Bug#784565: Bug#784565: nx-libs-lite: parts are derived from non-free code
260
261 On 5/18/2015 4:14 PM, Francesco Poli wrote:
262 > If it is confirmed that Gian Filippo contributed to the forking of
263 > DXPC within the NoMachine project, but not directly to DXPC, then I
264 > think that he made his contributions available under the terms of the
265 > GPL v2 of the NoMachine project. If this is the case, no feedback
266 > should be required from his side.
267 I can confirm that Gian Fillippo never contributed directly to DXPC.
268 You'll note his name does not appear in the DXPC README, and never has.
269 """