Debian Codegraph @

t/test-mails/josey-fold

raw
1 From mail-miner-10529@localhost Wed Dec 18 12:07:55 2002
2 Received: from mailman.opengroup.org ([192.153.166.9])
3 by deep-dark-truthful-mirror.pad with smtp (Exim 3.36 #1 (Debian))
4 id 18Buh5-0006Zr-00
5 for <[email protected]>; Wed, 13 Nov 2002 10:24:23 +0000
6 Received: (qmail 1679 invoked by uid 503); 13 Nov 2002 10:10:49 -0000
7 Resent-Date: 13 Nov 2002 10:10:49 -0000
8 Date: Wed, 13 Nov 2002 10:06:51 GMT
9 From: Andrew Josey <[email protected]>
10 Message-Id: <[email protected]>
11 In-Reply-To: Joanna Farley's message as of Nov 13, 9:56am.
12 References:
13 <[email protected]>
14 <[email protected]>
15 <[email protected]>
16 X-Mailer: Z-Mail (5.0.0 30July97)
17 To: [email protected]
18 Subject: Re: Defect in XBD lround
19 MIME-Version: 1.0
20 Resent-Message-ID: <gZGK1B.A.uY.iUi09@mailman>
21 Resent-To: [email protected]
22 Resent-From: [email protected]
23 X-Mailing-List: austin-group-l:archive/latest/4823
24 X-Loop: [email protected]
25 Precedence: list
26 Resent-Sender: [email protected]
27 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
28
29 Joanna, All
30
31 Thanks. I got the following response from Fred Tydeman.
32
33 C99 Defect Report (DR) 240 covers this. The main body of C99
34 (7.12.9.7) says range error, while Annex F (F.9.6.7 and F.9.6.5)
35 says "invalid" (domain error). The result was to change 7.12.9.7
36 to allow for either range or domain error. The preferred error
37 is domain error (so as match Annex F). So, no need to change XBD.
38
39 regards
40 Andrew
41
42 On Nov 13, 9:56am in "Re: Defect in XBD lr", Joanna Farley wrote:
43 > Sun's expert in this area after some discussions with a colleague
44 > outside of Sun concluded that for lround, to align with both C99 and SUS
45 > changes of the following form were necessary:
46 >
47 > + If x is +/-Inf/NaN, a domain error occurs, and
48 > + errno is set to EDOM in MATH_ERRNO mode;
49 > + the invalid exception is raised in MATH_ERREXCEPT mode.
50 > [to align with C99 Annex F.4]
51 >
52 > + If x is too large to be represented as a long, a *range* error
53 > may occur, and
54 > + errno *may be* set to ERANGE in MATH_ERRNO mode;
55 > [to align with C99 7.12.9.7]
56 > + the invalid exception *is* raised in MATH_ERREXCEPT mode.
57 > [to align with C99 Annex F.4]
58 >
59 > They believe it is a bit awkward to have errno set to ERANGE in
60 > MATH_ERRNO mode yet the invalid exception raised in MAH_ERREXCEPT mode,
61 > but that just reflects an imperfect mapping of the C notion of errno to
62 > the IEEE 754 notion of data conversion.
63 >
64 > I'll work with our expert to draft text refecting the above to suggest
65 > replacement text for lines 23678-23684 on lround page 721 of XSH6.
66 >
67 > Thanks
68 >
69 > Joanna
70 >
71 >
72 > Andrew Josey wrote:
73 > >
74 > > The text referred to is MX shaded and part of the ISO 60559 floating
75 > > point option. I do not think changing the Domain Error to a Range Error
76 > > is the fix or at least not the fix for the NaN and +-Inf cases. ISO C
77 > > 99 describes the range error case if the magnitude of x is too large as a
78 > > may fail. I'll ask Fred T for his thoughts on this one...
79 > > regards
80 > > Andrew
81 > >
82 > > On Nov 12, 9:37am in "Defect in XBD lround", [email protected] wrote:
83 > > > Defect report from : Erwin Unruh , Fujitsu Siemens Computers
84 > > >
85 > > > (Please direct followup comments direct to [email protected])
86 > > >
87 > > > @ page 0 line 0 section lround objection {0}
88 > > >
89 > > > Problem:
90 > > >
91 > > > Defect code : 1. Error
92 > > >
93 > > > The function lround is described in http://www.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/007904975/functions/lround.html
94 > > > On Error it is specified that errno has to be set to EDOM. However, the C99 standard ISO/IEC 9899:1999 (E) specifies this as a range error, which would result in a value of ERANGE. So an implementation could not be conformant to both these standards.
95 > > >
96 > > > Action:
97 > > >
98 > > > Change the value of errno to ERANGE, if the result is not represantable. More specific: In the description of the function, replace all occurences of "domain error" with "range error" and replace "EDOM" with "ERANGE"
99 > > >-- End of excerpt from [email protected]
100 > >
101
102 -----
103 Andrew Josey The Open Group
104 Austin Group Chair Apex Plaza,Forbury Road,
105 Email: [email protected] Reading,Berks.RG1 1AX,England
106 Tel: +44 118 9508311 ext 2250 Fax: +44 118 9500110