| 1 |
[[!comment format=mdwn |
| 2 |
username="fr33domlover" |
| 3 |
ip="46.117.109.179" |
| 4 |
subject="comment 4" |
| 5 |
date="2014-09-17T11:22:57Z" |
| 6 |
content=""" |
| 7 |
> Could you test whether your tip works with \<div dir=\"rtl\"> or something, please? |
| 8 |
|
| 9 |
Sure, I will check that soon. I think it does, I just tried here in ikiwiki. Just curious, why is |
| 10 |
div preferred? IIRC I use \"class\" there after looking at some existing templates. But |
| 11 |
I'm not an expert, especially not in CSS. Would that be used as an HTML4 parallel of the dir attribute? |
| 12 |
|
| 13 |
As to that website with the patch, the problem is that the text is aligned to the left. When |
| 14 |
I type Hebrew in an LTR page, it already shows more or less correctly - English words are |
| 15 |
shown in correct letter order thanks to the bidi algorithm. The issue seems to be aligning |
| 16 |
to the right - that is what my tip does. Maybe the direction setting in the CSS also has other |
| 17 |
effects - I just know it works :-) |
| 18 |
|
| 19 |
I'll happily help with the tests. I also have a test page on my wiki which uses many ikiwiki |
| 20 |
features, to demonstrate how they all look in RTL. Test case ideas: |
| 21 |
|
| 22 |
- Page in RTL (e.g. Arabic) with an LTR paragraph (e.g. English) |
| 23 |
- Page in RTL with LTR paragraph in the same language (e.g. fancy way to write a poem) |
| 24 |
- Page in LTR (e.g. English) with an RTL paragraph (e.g. Hebrew) |
| 25 |
- Page in LTR with RTL paragraph in the same language (poem again) |
| 26 |
- Translated page - master language is LTR, slave is RTL |
| 27 |
- Translated page - master language is RTL, slave is LTR |
| 28 |
- Master LTR page has RTL paragraph, all slaves have it RTL too regardless of their global direction |
| 29 |
- Master RTL page has LTR paragraph, all slaves have it LTR too regardless of their global direction |
| 30 |
|
| 31 |
An example for the last 2 tests is an English master page about linguistics which has a paragraph in some |
| 32 |
RTL language that is being studied, and all slave pages must keep that paragraph intact - both the |
| 33 |
text itself and its RTL direction. But the rest of the page can be translated and correctly made RTL when |
| 34 |
translated to RTL languages. |
| 35 |
|
| 36 |
This gives me another idea - most of the time what you actually mean is to reverse the direction: RTL |
| 37 |
becomes LTR and vice versa. When writing some fancy poem, that's what you probably want. But in the |
| 38 |
previous example, the direction should not be reversed - so there should maybe be two kinds of direction |
| 39 |
modifiers: |
| 40 |
|
| 41 |
1. Dynamic (the default) - You write e.g. a master page in LTR and some RTL paragraphs. an RTL translation |
| 42 |
automatically reverses directions, RTL <=> LTR. |
| 43 |
2. Fixed - this is like my tip, e.g. An RTL paragraph in an LTR page has a fixed direction set, which is kept even in |
| 44 |
translations for RTL languages - the page in general is reversed, but that paragraph is not. |
| 45 |
|
| 46 |
Another very useful thing (at least to me) would be an option to have different wiki pages/section with |
| 47 |
different master languages. I have sections in English and sections in Hebrew, which makes the PO |
| 48 |
plugin a problem to use, unless I keep one of these sections untranslated. |
| 49 |
"""]] |