| 1 |
An attempt has been made to restructure the fortune database. This has |
| 2 |
included, of necessity, a concatenation and redivision of the offensive |
| 3 |
and inoffensive fortunes. In the process, some fortunes may have gotten |
| 4 |
lost, and others may have moved from one category to another (or from |
| 5 |
both categories to one or the other, more commonly). |
| 6 |
|
| 7 |
The following were the criteria I used to make the division: |
| 8 |
Anything about sex is offensive. Welcome to America. *sigh* |
| 9 |
Insults based on religion or ethnicity are offensive. |
| 10 |
Generally, any criticism of anybody's religion is offensive. |
| 11 |
"He really said that?" quotes from politicians are offensive. |
| 12 |
Political bias is offensive. |
| 13 |
Limericks are offensive even if they aren't. |
| 14 |
Tastelessness is offensive (q.v. "The Snack"). |
| 15 |
Misogyny and misandry for the sake of themselves are offensive. |
| 16 |
Vulgarity is offensive. |
| 17 |
Violence for the sake of humor is offensive. |
| 18 |
|
| 19 |
Surprisingly, given this rather broad definition, there are still more |
| 20 |
inoffensive quotations, quips, and quozzits than offensive ones. A |
| 21 |
peculiar, back-handed compliment to human nature (it surprised me). |
| 22 |
|
| 23 |
In another file in this directory (Notes), the original author(s) of the |
| 24 |
fortune distribution state that "racist, mysogynist [sic] (sexist), or |
| 25 |
homophobic ideas" should never be included in the fortune database. |
| 26 |
|
| 27 |
This was not the case when the database came into my possession, and I |
| 28 |
began attempting to divide it thematically. Misogyny and homophobia are |
| 29 |
both pretty well-represented; it is thus only a minor relief that racism |
| 30 |
isn't (nonetheless, it *is* a relief). Faced with two unpalatable |
| 31 |
alternatives, of including material that really deserves no wider |
| 32 |
publication or of acting the censor, I choose to pass on the |
| 33 |
responsibility, though I have attempted to make maintenance easier. |
| 34 |
Misogyny is sequestered in the file "misogyny," homophobia in "hphobia," |
| 35 |
and racism in "racism" (see the file 'cookie-files' in this directory for |
| 36 |
a discussion of the contents of the various files), all in the offensive |
| 37 |
directory. Those who respect women, gays, and people of color may prefer |
| 38 |
to either remove the .dat file (which keeps the strings, but makes them |
| 39 |
inaccessible via the fortune program), or to delete these files altogether. |
| 40 |
|
| 41 |
I admit that I was strongly tempted to simply remove these fortunes, an |
| 42 |
action that I might have justified by pointing to the Notes of the |
| 43 |
original authors. However, it appears that over the course of time there |
| 44 |
have been those who find these sorts of prejudice amusing, and in |
| 45 |
America, at least, even Nazi rhetoric is a protected form of speech. So |
| 46 |
I include them, and leave the decision to individual system administrators. |
| 47 |
|
| 48 |
I will add, as a final note, that reading through the offensive fortunes |
| 49 |
(I have been forced to read and reread every fortune in the database |
| 50 |
several times, in order to assign things to their proper places) has left |
| 51 |
me far less amused by fortune -o than previously. It is easy to overdose |
| 52 |
on insult. |
| 53 |
|
| 54 |
Amy Lewis [email protected] September-October 1995. |