Debian Codegraph @

tasks/README

raw
1
2 NOTE: In these lists, package names should be on one line by itself.
3 No spaces/tabs/comments on the same line.
4
5 cpp does not remove spaces/tabs, and perl apparently considers literally
6 everything between \n and \n as package name. So, it's best to have no
7 spaces/tabs at all outside the comment delimiters.
8
9 The exclude/unexclude lists are NOT preprocessed, so comments there are
10 not supported.
11
12 -----
13
14 THE "USEFUL CD 1 PROJECT" RATIONALE J.A. Bezemer, Jan-Apr 2001
15 [email protected]
16
17 Quite many Debian users do not have the Complete Official CD set, but only
18 one (or sometimes two) CDs. They expect that CD to be as useful as
19 possibe, that is, to contain as much useful packages as possible.
20
21 We have four means to determine the usefulness of a (set of) package(s):
22 the Popularity Contest (see above), the task-* packages, packages included
23 on the official CDs of other distributions, and our own experience.
24
25 We can distinguish two main groups of people that will use a single Debian CD:
26 1. People paying nothing
27 2. People wanting to pay as little as possible
28
29 ad 1. This happens mostly at tradeshows/expos/conferences. We can further
30 subdivide this group into two opposites:
31 a. Complete Linux newbies that want to use Debian as their first
32 distribution.
33 b. Well-experienced Linux users that want to compare Debian to other
34 distributions, mostly with the pre-determined intent to either switch
35 to the "best" distribution for their own personal use, or employ the
36 "best" distribution for some specific project in their company.
37
38 ad 2. This occurs mostly by people ordering CDs from regular vendors.
39 While groups a. and b. are also present here, there is another group that
40 deserves attention:
41 c. Relatively experienced Debian users with a reasonably fast and cheap
42 Internet connection that order CD1 to get the bulk of the upgrades, and
43 fetch the rest from online repositories.
44
45 The mentioned groups each have specific expectations from their single CD.
46
47 ad a. Newbies often start using a Linux system guided by some manual or
48 other piece of literature that may, or may not, be Debian-specific. Many
49 introductory Linux books describe/demonstrate the same utilities and
50 programs; however several of these examples don't have much to do with the
51 daily routine of a more experienced user.
52
53 What they do use:
54 - install tools
55 - "easy" packages, like task-newbie-help, task-dialup(-isdn), X, Gnome
56
57 What they don't use:
58 - "difficult to learn" packages, like task-sgml, task-fortran
59 - development packages (well, they may want to compile a new kernel)
60
61 ad b. When comparing Linux distributions, quite often either a simple
62 install without much packages is tried, to see "what it looks like", or a
63 more elaborate install that mimics one's currently working system, to find
64 out "what it feels like." Once Debian is recognized as the truly best
65 distribution, a complete CD set will be bought which will be used to
66 set-up the production system(s).
67
68 What they do use:
69 - install tools
70 - "easy" packages
71 - to compare distributions: packages found in their current distribution /
72 other distributions from which they have collected CDs
73
74 What they don't use:
75 - packages that require much setup/tuning, or just "a long time to get
76 functional", like task-database-*, task-news-server,
77 task-parallel-computing-node
78 - "heavy development" packages, like task-sgml-dev, task-objc-dev
79 (maybe they are interested in these packages, but they will recognize
80 them as being "advanced", and not expect them on the "most popular" CD)
81
82 ad c. Upgrading as much packages as possible from a single CD means that
83 the most-used packages on Debian systems should be present on that CD.
84
85 What they do use:
86 - packages used on at least 5% of all Debian systems (which happens to be
87 the top 5% of the Popularity Contest results)
88
89 What they don't use:
90 - the rest
91
92 Keeping all this in mind, a solution was developed that (implicitly) uses
93 all mentioned "rating methods" to create a CD 1 that should answer the
94 stated demands as well as possible. The lists were entered, tested, verified,
95 cross-checked and adjusted, until an acceptable result was reached.
96
97
98 Further work/Recommendations:
99
100 The described procedure has resulted in a drastically reduced number of
101 task-* packages that are forced to go on the first CD. But since the
102 Popularity Contest can't handle task-* packages very well, most of them
103 will be moved to the last CD in the set, while in many cases all of their
104 "contents" are available on "more popular" CDs. It would make more sense
105 if a task package is included as soon as, say, 50-70% of it's dependencies
106 are included. Since all APT tools are available during CD image creation,
107 this can probably be automated entirely.