DesaturateColorsDesaturateDesaturateDesaturate
By using the Desaturate command, you can convert
all of the colors on the active layer to corresponding shades of gray. This
differs from converting the image to grayscale in two respects. First, it
only operates on the active layer and second, the colors on the layer are
still RGB values with three components, with R=G=B, which makes gray.
This means that you then can paint on the layer, or individual parts of it,
using non-gray colors.
This command only works on layers of
RGB images. If the image is in
Grayscale or Indexed mode, it can do nothing.
Activating the Command
You can access this command from the main menu through
ColorsDesaturateDesaturate….
OptionsThe Desaturate option dialogMode: Five options are available for converting
from color to black and white:PresetsBlending OptionsPreviewMerge filterSplit viewLuminance
The shades of gray will be calculated using
linearized sRGB as
Luminance =
(0.22 × R) +
(0.72 × G) +
(0.06 × B)
LumaThe shades of gray will be calculated using non-linearized sRGB
Luma = (0.22 × R) + (0.72 × G) + (0.06 × B)
Lightness (HSL)The shades of gray will be calculated as
Lightness (HSL) = ½ × (max(R,G,B) + min(R,G,B))
Average (HSI Intensity)The shades of gray will be calculated asAverage (HSI Intensity) = (R + G + B) ÷ 3
Value (HSV)The shades of gray will be calculated as
Value (HSV) = max(R,G,B)
Using the five modes to convert two very different color images
to black and white
Original image
Original image
Luminance applied
Luminance applied
Luma applied.
Luma applied.
Lightness (HSL) applied.
Lightness (HSL) applied.
Average (HSI Intensity) applied.
Average (HSI Intensity) applied.
Value (HSV) applied.
Value (HSV) applied.
Comparing results from using different options for
converting from color to black and white:
The degree and direction from which the various ways to convert
an image to black and white diverge from a straight Luminance conversion
to black and white depends on:
The conversion method you choose.
The RGB color space in which the conversion is done.
How saturated the colors in the original image happen to
be, with more saturated starting colors (such as the red globe and the
bright yellow sunflower) producing greater amounts of deviation from a
straight Luminance conversion.
The hues (for example yellows vs reds) of the various
saturated colors in an image also make a difference.
Being the maximum of the RGB channel values for each
pixel, an HSV Value conversion to black and white is always lighter than
the original color image, and also lighter than all the other ways to
convert to black and white.
Comparing the red globe to the yellow sunflower:
For the red globe Lightness (HSL) produces a result very
similar to Luminance, and Luma produces a conversion that is much darker.
For the sunflower, Luma produces a result very similar to
Luminance, and Lightness (HSL) produces a conversion that is much darker.
Notice that the less saturated parts of each image look
more or less the same, regardless of which method is chosen for converting
from color to black and white.
More information about the five options for
converting from color to black and white:More information about Luminance:
"Luminance" is the only physically meaningful way to
convert a color image to black and white, as the resulting black and
white image has the same relative luminance (reflects the same
percentage of light from the various shades of gray) as the colors in
the original color image.
Luminance must be calculated using linearized RGB values.
For convenience we say "Luminance", but what we really
mean is "Relative Luminance". For more information, see
Relative
Luminance and
CIE 1931 [XYZ] color space.
GIMP uses hard-coded sRGB values to do Luminance
conversions to black and white. "Future GIMP" will support correct
conversions for images in other color spaces.
More information about Luma:
"Luma" is what you get if you use the formula for
Luminance on RGB values that haven't been properly linearized.
The multipliers have been properly Bradford-adapted to
D50, which is required for use in an ICC profile color-managed editing
application (at least until the next version of the ICC specs is
released and people figure out how to deal with the new freedom to use
non-D50 reference white points).
GIMP uses hard-coded sRGB values to do Luma
conversions to black and white. "Future GIMP" will support correct
conversions for images in other color spaces.
More information about Lightness, Average, and Value:
The "Lightness (HSL)", "Average (HSI Intensity)", and "Value (HSV)"
ways to convert a color image to black and white use color space models
that were invented for fast processing on consumer-grade computers from the
1990s. For details see
HSL and HSV,
paying particular attention to the section on
Disadvantages.
In case you are wondering why LAB Lightness is
not among the options
for converting an RGB image to black and white, a properly calculated
conversion from RGB to LAB Lightness, and then back to RGB, produces exactly
the same result as the Luminance conversion to black and white. Here is why:
In the XYZ color space, Y is Luminance. So if you
convert a color RGB image to XYZ, the "Y" of XYZ is the same number as
the R=G=B values that you get when you calculate RGB Luminance.
LAB is a perceptually uniform transform of XYZ. If you
convert from RGB to XYZ and then to LAB, and set A=B=0.0 (or 0.5 for
image editors that put the midpoint of the A and B axes as 0.5 instead
of at 0.0), and then convert back to XYZ, the X and Z values will
change, but Y will not change.
Tutorials that produce anything other than Relative Luminance when
converting an RGB image to black and white using LAB Lightness, very sadly
are trading on various mathematical mistakes in the conversion routines.