\begin{table}[!htbp] \centering \begin{tabular}{lrrrr|rrr} \sisetup{detect-weight=true,detect-inline-weight=math} \hfill{} & \multicolumn{4}{C{8.2cm}}{Reads} & \multicolumn{3}{C{4cm}}{Bases} \\ \cmidrule{2-8} Program & \multicolumn{1}{C{2cm}}{Wrongly Trimmed} & \multicolumn{1}{C{1cm}}{Over-trimmed} & \multicolumn{1}{C{2.2cm}}{Under-trimmed} & \multicolumn{1}{C{1cm}}{Total Error} & \multicolumn{1}{C{1cm}}{Over-trimmed} & \multicolumn{1}{C{1cm}}{Under-trimmed} & \multicolumn{1}{C{1cm}}{Total Error} \\ \midrule Error rate 0.2\% \\ AdapterRemoval & 664 (0.09\%) & 29 (0.00\%) & 65 (0.01\%) & 0.10\% & 6,043 & 2,511 & 0.005\% \\ Atropos (adapter) & 51 (0.01\%) & \hlcell{1 (0.00\%)} & 28,991 (3.77\%) & 3.78\% & 490 & 102,133 & 0.057\% \\ Atropos (insert) & 60 (0.01\%) & 24 (0.00\%) & \hlcell{31 (0.00\%)} & \hlcell{0.01\%} & 186 & \hlcell{94} & \hlcell{0.000\%} \\ SeqPurge & 94 (0.01\%) & 24 (0.00\%) & \hlcell{31 (0.00\%)} & 0.02\% & 1,574 & \hlcell{94} & 0.001\% \\ Skewer & \hlcell{18 (0.00\%)} & 13 (0.00\%) & 146 (0.02\%) & 0.02\% & \hlcell{39} & 8,309 & 0.005\% \\ \midrule Error rate 0.6\% \\ AdapterRemoval & 666 (0.09\%) & 19 (0.00\%) & 69 (0.01\%) & 0.10\% & 5,547 & 2,032 & 0.004\% \\ Atropos (adapter) & 72 (0.01\%) & \hlcell{6 (0.00\%)} & 28,843 (3.76\%) & 3.77\% & 733 & 101,839 & 0.057\% \\ Atropos (insert) & 52 (0.01\%) & 15 (0.00\%) & 42 (0.01\%) & \hlcell{0.01\%} & 151 & 146 & \hlcell{0.000\%} \\ SeqPurge & 78 (0.01\%) & 16 (0.00\%) & \hlcell{41 (0.01\%)} & 0.02\% & 822 & \hlcell{145} & 0.001\% \\ Skewer & \hlcell{8 (0.00\%)} & 8 (0.00\%) & 180 (0.02\%) & 0.03\% & \hlcell{16} & 11,732 & 0.007\% \\ \midrule Error rate 1.2\% \\ AdapterRemoval & 680 (0.09\%) & 16 (0.00\%) & 65 (0.01\%) & 0.10\% & 5,795 & 2,667 & 0.005\% \\ Atropos (adapter) & 76 (0.01\%) & \hlcell{5 (0.00\%)} & 30,152 (3.92\%) & 3.94\% & 721 & 117,027 & 0.065\% \\ Atropos (insert) & 49 (0.01\%) & 13 (0.00\%) & \hlcell{35 (0.00\%)} & \hlcell{0.01\%} & 111 & \hlcell{85} & \hlcell{0.000\%} \\ SeqPurge & 71 (0.01\%) & 13 (0.00\%) & \hlcell{35 (0.00\%)} & 0.02\% & 1,524 & \hlcell{85} & 0.001\% \\ Skewer & \hlcell{11 (0.00\%)} & 8 (0.00\%) & 182 (0.02\%) & 0.03\% & \hlcell{19} & 14,261 & 0.008\% \\ \end{tabular} \caption{Trimming accuracy on simulated data with three different base-call error rates. Wrongly trimmed: reads that do not contain adapters but were trimmed anyway; Over-trimmed: reads that contain adapters but from which too many bases were removed; Under-trimmed: reads that contain adapters but from which too few bases were removed. Both read-level and base-level error rates are shown. Fractions of total reads/bases are in parentheses. The best tool(s) in each category is highlighted.\label{simulated-accuracy}} \end{table}